3 ms·
Simple. Build molten salt reactors like Terrestrial Energy's IMSR, which have low capital costs and relatively short lifetimes for the reactor cores. This is r
by DennisP 8y ago
Simple. Build molten salt reactors like Terrestrial Energy's IMSR, which have low capital costs and relatively short lifetimes for the reactor cores.
This is really hard in the U.S. because the NRC is very unfriendly to R&D, but T.E. has already gotten through the hardest part of Canada's licensing process and expects to have the first IMSR running by 2025 or so. Moltex and Elysium also have MSR projects in Canada.
Nuclear naturally looks bad if you compare today's nuclear to the future of wind/solar/storage.
- olau 8y agoPermissioning is complicated because nuclear plants, even small ones, are complicated. There's a reason real nuclear plants are getting bigger and bigger. You're comparing vaporware to technologies with a proven track record.
- DennisP 8y agoWell let me describe what I mean. A couple years ago I got to sit in a meeting between people from a dozen GenIV reactor startups and a former head of the NRC. The reactor people said their biggest problem was that the NRC required a near-complete design before they would even take a look. At that point they either said yes or no. If no then that was the end of it, you were out of business. If yes you still had only a paper reactor. Getting to that point required several hundred million dollars. That's a very difficult sell to investors. They said just a more phased process would help a lot. The NRC person was unsympathetic, said it wasn't the NRC's job to help develop or promote nuclear technology, and was uninterested in climate change. Canada has a more rational approach to R&D, while maintaining rigorous safety. That's why MSR companies are moving there, and why the first one, Terrestrial Energy, is making solid progress. (And as a side note, molten salt reactors are a lot simpler than light water reactors, because they have safety advantages inherent to the physics of the fuel and coolant.)
- 7952 8y agoWOuldn't you expect those kind of costs? It seems fairly low compared to airline development costs, where a program may cost $25+ billion.
- gamblor956 8y agoIt sounds like we should let Canada shoulder the brunt of the research and then build commercial MSRs once Canada has mastered the tech....in 50 years or so.
- jabl 8y ago> And as a side note, molten salt reactors are a lot simpler than light water reactors, because they have safety advantages inherent to the physics of the fuel and coolant. I don't know. MSR's are certainly interesting, but they have downsides as well as upsides. Some of the PWR SMR's like NuScale also sport passive safety features, which should make it simpler and safer. Being a PWR, it's still a high pressure design, of course, which MSR's avoid. While MSR are very cool, in some ways they're pretty scary too. I mean, you're pumping around tonnes of super-radioactive goop. What if you have a leak? At least with a traditional design you have a couple of extra protective layers, with fuel being contained in solid pellets contained in tubes. And you have to be very careful with the chemistry of the fuel salt; IIRC one of the early MSR's (ARE?) had to be shutdown since they messed up their redox chemistry which lead to fissiles plating out on the heat exchangers. Eek! There's the famous Rickover quote that anybody can design a paper reactor, but real reactors tend to be complicated, over budget, and over schedule.
- DennisP 8y agoThat quote by Rickover is one reason we should fix the NRC process, so companies don't have to spend $300M and get nothing but a paper reactor. Moltex Energy agrees with you on pumping fuel salt. They keep their liquid fuel in a fuel rod, open at the top, no pumping. All the rods are immersed in a pool of liquid salt coolant, which just sits there. Secondary coolant in pipes through through that.
- jabl 8y ago> That quote by Rickover is one reason we should fix the NRC process, so companies don't have to spend $300M and get nothing but a paper reactor. (I didn't answer your previous points about the NRC process, but for the record, I completely agree with you.) > Moltex Energy agrees with you on pumping fuel salt. They keep their liquid fuel in a fuel rod, open at the top, no pumping. All the rods are immersed in a pool of liquid salt coolant, which just sits there. Secondary coolant in pipes through through that. Yes, Moltex is an interesting design. The main drawback, AFAICS, is that since the fuel concentration in the fuel salt is quite low compared to solid fuel designs, they have to use pretty enriched fuel. I think their current plans call for 40% Pu. And the breeding ratio is poor, around 0.5 according to a paper I skimmed through a while ago.
- imtringued 8y agoOnly several hundred million dollars? This is not some software startup we are talking about here. The reactors are going to cost several billion dollars so it doesn't make sense to let startups just "wing it". Even if the R&D costs are 10 billion you could quickly amortize it by simply building multiple reactors with the same design. At least that is what the pro nuclear lobby says will happen.