8 ms·
> While waiting, there was a guy with a guitar in the observation car, and we had a nice sing-along. That bit sounds like hell to me but I'm glad you had fun!
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> While waiting, there was a guy with a guitar in the observation car, and we had a nice sing-along.
That bit sounds like hell to me but I'm glad you had fun! In the UK we have special carriages where you're not allowed to make a noise so you can avoid that kind of thing.
- truncj 8y agoAfter 14 hours of silence you might think twice!
- dagw 8y agoSpending 14 hours alone in silence is the sort of day I fantasize about.
- galago 8y agoAmtrak has quiet cars, at least in the Northeast. I often take Boston-NYC and there seem to be a lot of business travelers. People who are riding in a train across Utah are probably in it for the experience.
- shereadsthenews 8y agoCapitol Corridor also has a quiet car but all it means is you are assured of having to inform some bozo of that fact because the fraction of riders on their first train ride ever is very high.
- a_e_k 8y agoThe line in the Pacific Northwest that I've been on also had quiet cars.
- ArrayList 8y ago> In the UK we have special carriages where you're not allowed to make a noise so you can avoid that kind of thing. That's _so_ ... British.
- hjdehdfhjkj 8y agoThats because there is a cultural difference between how americans and europeans see trains. For americans its something quaint and wild whereas for europeans its just a basic form of transportation.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI once saw a large party of school children going on a trip on the Caltrain. Turned out they weren't going anywhere... it was just going on the train that was the activity. A commuter train running alongside a highway through urban sprawl. They were whooping when it pulled into the station.
- war1025 8y agoI've taken the train in Minneapolis from the mall to downtown several times, purely for the novelty of it. We have a lot of freight trains in Iowa. Passenger, not so much.
- beat 8y agoI live a few blocks from that train, so I wind up taking it all the time to get to the mall or downtown. The novelty wears off, and you wind up mostly worried about having to share your ride with packs of unruly teenagers, or sports fans heading downtown who can't resist saying racist things about our various African immigrant neighbors. It's a pleasure or a drag, depending on the manners of those who share the ride.
- NoNameHaveI 8y agoOne Iowan to another: you didn't ride a train in Minneapolis. You rode a streetcar (tram in British). And yes, only the southeast corner of Iowa is served at all by passenger rail. Would be nice if they extended the Hawkeye Express to CR, or better yet, Amtrak service from Davenport to IC to DSM. Alas, not enough $$$ to make it worth doing.
- strictnein 8y ago
- CalRobert 8y agoFortunately, that should suggest that it's OK in the other carriages.
- mikeash 8y agoThe observation car is a special car you can visit that has better visibility. Nobody is forced to go there.
- chrisseaton 8y agoBut some people might want the observe the sights and not have a lot of noise around them, right? Not really sure it's fair to pollute a public space with your music when not everyone might like it, or have the confidence to say when they don't like it. Not very nice to say to people you're going to subject them to music and if they don't like it their only option is to leave. Doesn't really sound right does it?
- CWuestefeld 8y agoMost of the ride the observation car was quiet. The sing-along was a welcome diversion from the anxiety and ennui of sitting for hours waiting to see if the train would be allowed to proceed.
- frosted-flakes 8y agoThe train was stopped, so if someone left the viewing car they weren't missing anything.
- CWuestefeld 8y agoA bit more of the story. Where we were stopped was the the side of a mountain. On the uphill side was a similarly-stopped freight train, with an oil tanker car right next to us. Below us was a raging, flooded, river (on account of the same storms that washed out the track). And up above was a cliff, with a boulder on top that seemed maybe a little precarious. So we were sitting there wondering if the same storm that eroded the tracks had maybe eroded the cliff around that boulder, allowing it to tumble down through the oil tanker to send us plunging into the flood waters below. Brooding over that was less fun than the distraction of the sing-along.
- mikeash 8y ago
- abraham 8y agoThe observation car is a specific car for socializing and community gathering. If you want less noise you just don't need to go there.
- cubano 8y agoEven if the guy was really good? I personally think a well-executed acoustic guitar singalong can add a lot of real joy to any group experience. I've played in rock bands since I was 15 (I'm north of 50 now), and I've been on stage in front of a thousand people and I've played to killer mosh pits and all that, but my best memories of all those years were the after-parties where it was just me and my bassist with acoustics and a room full of drunk people singing along to the Eagles or Sublime or maybe even Weezer... Now, it helps to have a professional level acoustic guitar and, of course, a professional lead singer to hide everyone's mistakes, but it can be a magical, cathartic experience when the room all sings at the top of their lungs... Great memories.
- chrisseaton 8y agoI guess I’m just a grump who doesn’t like being subjected to music no matter how good they think they are.
- 72deluxe 8y agoI think Brits find public singing embarrassing, and even more so if the person doing it is right next to you, and a complete stranger. It gets worse if it involves a guitar. Of course, this changes if alcohol is involved. I get the feeling that showcasing some skill in a public fashion is loved in the USA, not so much in the UK. We typically want to sit and not disturb others, and find any other kind of disturbance awkward; we try to sit quietly and pretend it isn't even happening, eg. not even looking at the person making the disturbance. eg. some people arguing at the back of the bus probably won't make people at the front of the bus turn around or tell them to shut up.
- munk-a 8y agoIn the US observing someone showcasing a skill in public is usually not enjoyable but there is less of an emphasis on decorum and politeness and more of that good ol'libretarian individualism so going out into public and demonstrating how heart stoppingly amazing you are is a pretty common occurrence. I think this is a bit different than busking which tends to be relegated to locations where people aren't required to hang around for long periods of time (like outside a metro station where someone enjoying your music can stay and chill for a while or just continue into the relative quiet of the station platform.
- balabaster 8y ago> That bit sounds like hell to me Yeah, us Brits don't like to do anything that sounds like it might be fun when we're under stress. We want to sit there and bitch and complain about the fact nobody is fixing the track and who is going to get fired for it. We definitely don't want to have anyone distract us from that with anything that looks like it might be fun. /satire
- stuaxo 8y agoHey, the moaning bit IS the fun.
- balabaster 8y agoThis is why all our greatest comedy is people moaning... Life of Brian, Holy Grail, Fawlty Towers, Little Britain, the list goes on...
- ovao 8y agoI’ll quote Jerry Seinfeld here: “I can’t watch a man sing a song.” Jerry and I share sentiments on this.
- luckydata 8y agoAre you Carl?
- CWuestefeld 8y agoI am not now nor have I ever been Carl.
- nraynaud 8y agoI think the USA doesn't do silence.
- moron4hire 8y agoThe regular passenger cars do have noise restrictions. It's only in the meal and observation cars.
- aidenn0 8y agoAt least in the northeast corridor (basically the only place in the US where trains are usable as transportation), there are "quiet cars" as well.
- joejerryronnie 8y ago>That bit sounds like hell to me John Belushi concurs: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqpNQ9AJYgU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqpNQ9AJYgU