4 ms·
Why isn't the explanation that the reporting function is slow? Your "free will" -which we won't explain- decides to fire the motor neurons, and then does the re
by lordnacho 8y ago
Why isn't the explanation that the reporting function is slow? Your "free will" -which we won't explain- decides to fire the motor neurons, and then does the reporting, which is pretty unnatural compared to moving a muscle, to do the thinking about where the dot was.
Or maybe you overcompensate when calculating where you thought the dot was.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe video addresses that. The experiments were constructed not so that you report "I decided to press the button", but rather by reporting "The state of the world [as measured by this rotating dot on the screen] was this at the time I decided to press the button." And he found that the state of the world that people reported when they pressed the button was consistently 200 ms before actually pressing the button (which is in accord with other experiments measuring human reaction time), but the EEG spike in the motor context were 350 ms before the subject's perception of reality at the time they made their decision, and 550ms before pressing the button. Most people think of their consciousness as "That part of my mind which integrates all my sensory information into a coherent experience of reality at this moment, and then decides what to do within that reality." You could redefine free will as the EEG potentials themselves operating within your brain - but that's not how most people, subjectively, experience it, particularly because they are not generally aware of most of these EEG potentials directly.