5 ms·
> Let's be clear about all this, and where the problem arises from. Yes, let's. It arises from parents letting kids not only watch but outright discover conten
by airstrike 8y ago
> Let's be clear about all this, and where the problem arises from.
Yes, let's. It arises from parents letting kids not only watch but outright discover content unsupervised.
If it weren't YouTube, it would be [insert name of threat to kids].
With both parents working, supervising kids is easier said than done – I'm not saying it's their fault for having to go to work to support their families, but the responsibility of policing their own kids is certainly theirs and nobody else's.
- rickycook 8y agowell, yes and no; what are parents going to do? sit with the kid and watch the whole thing after they (parent) picked out the content? i agree the parent should pick out the content, but the whole auto play at the end of a video situation makes it difficult: is make a good wager that (like when i was a kid) “TV time” is when the parents get things like laundry done, so they have to come back right at the end of a video to pick a new one. if it couldn’t play without the parents consent, the kid would at least yell out. it’s not about parents being lazy (or hell even if it is, parents need a break too) it’s about creating a user experience that caters to the highly stressful life of being a parent. that’s what youtube kids should be!
- sbov 8y agoWe're dealing with this right now. Please, tell me how I can whitelist channels and/or individual videos on youtube for my kids. I'm not being sarcastic - I've done a lot of looking and can't seem to find out how. There are settings for "keep it kid friendly" but that isn't enough. Some kid friendly videos are terrible for kids. We've resorted to only letting the kids watch videos on a fire tablet, because we can control exactly what they can see on it.
- airstrike 8y agoBlock YouTube and have them do something else instead. What did you do for fun as a kid?
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoIf you really wanted it you could download the videos for the channels and host them locally. Even then I wouldn't trust most channels; a channel could sell out and have elsa&spidey 'porn' on it tomorrow. As a parent I carefully curate YouTube and won't let the kids watch it on their own. Netflix "kids" channel is quite good IMO, some of the content - like Story Bots - I really quite like. Could do with more shows with people in though, most of it's animation.
- orbifold 8y agoWhen I grew up I wasn't allowed to watch TV arbitrarily. I see no reason why I would allow my kids to watch Youtube regularly and without supervision.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ilovetux 8y agoThe problem really is that a multi-billion dollar company decided to release an app targeting children (youtube kids) and through sheer negligence choose to allow access to the worst kind of content through said app. Google easily has the resources to release a responsible product, but simply chooses to deny responsibility for any negative side effects of their products.
- airstrike 8y agoI'm not saying we can't address that from a policy perspective, but as a parent you shouldn't wait until the government regulates everything your child comes in contact with – you need to be a bit more proactive than that.
- ilovetux 8y agoOK, I agree with this, but Google could've easily curated the content to be kid-safe but instead relied on immature algorithms instead of hiring a few people to manage curation. At some point you need to hold corporations responsible for their negligence.