16 ms·
> Certainly, using such categories for job and housing advertisements should not be allowed. But if I'm reading Facebook's announcement correctly targeting on r
by ajross 8y ago
> Certainly, using such categories for job and housing advertisements should not be allowed. But if I'm reading Facebook's announcement correctly targeting on race and gender is being completely removed
The problem is "such categories" is squishy. What about elective medical treatments? What about vacation deals (often partially sponsored by real estate interests)?
There is a broad, broad spectrum between "elective frivolity" and "hidden opportunity" in advertising, and who are you to make that decision? Step out of the obvious counterexamples and scary edge cases abound.
I mean, yeah, advertising "soda for women" or whatever isn't going to harm anyone who doesn't see the ad. But would you say it's OK if I pitch my startup camp to asians only?
- manfredo 8y ago> What about elective medical treatments? Should companies have to advertise mammograms to men? Or vasectomies to women?I would object to this - not because of targeting certain populations but on the grounds that ads for medical treatment should not be run at all. > What about vacation deals (often partially sponsored by real estate interests)? Why not? I don't see how people would be negai impacted by not being exposed to vacation deals. Jobs, credit, and housing are necessities and if a group has lessened exposure to those opportunities they are at a disadvantage. Trips to Vegas are not necessities and not being exposed to deals to go to Vegas are not harmed (one could even argue that the ones being advertised to are the ones harmed here).
- ajross 8y ago> Should companies have to advertise mammograms to men? That's the same strawman though! There are an endless list of products that are clearly targetted in some kind of inherent way. My point is that there is an equally large list of ones that are gray areas, and that if your policy is "advertise whatever to whoever you want" you're going to be engaging in an awful lot of accidental discrimination. So sure, make your exceptions for tampons and birth control. Just let them be exceptions. > Why not? I don't see how people would be negai impacted by not being exposed to vacation deals. You say that now, until, oops, it turns out you've been running ads for condos in a de facto whites-only resort community. Who could have known, amirite?
- googlemike 8y agoWhats wrong with running ads for condos in a whites-only resort community? If their internal numbers show that this community has a really high chance of conversion, why should they target something else on a finite ad budget? Can't a company decide who it wants to sell to?
- HappySweeney 8y agoAre there de jure whites-only resort communities in the US? To answer your questions: > Whats wrong with running ads for condos in a whites-only resort community? - profiting from racists - ghetto creation - perpetuating harmful discrimination - assisting in the longevity of a community which exacerbates the prior 3 issues > If their internal numbers show that this community has a really high chance of conversion, why should they target something else on a finite ad budget? They shouldn't. But also it shouldn't be available to them, by law. > Can't a company decide who it wants to sell to? In the general case, yes, but since the civil rights movement, you cannot refuse goods or services to someone based on race. That includes housing. I was under the impression this was widely known.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- cwkoss 8y agoAll ads for medical treatments should be illegal
- WalterBright 8y agoSo ignorant consumers become totally reliant on getting medical information only from doctors?
- cyborgx7 8y agoOr independent reporting. Or public information offers. Ads are not a good way of distributing good information. And people who argue otherwise are naive, or doing so in bad faith.
- WalterBright 8y agoThere's no way to distinguish an ad from those things. It's analogous to distinguishing between porn and art.
- quotemstr 8y agoPaying for placement is a clear boundary between one and the other, isn't it?
- SamReidHughes 8y agoWhat if somebody slanders your product?
- Dylan16807 8y agoFiguring out astroturfing isn't a perfect system, but kicking out TV/radio/magazine/banner/streaming ads is straightforward and beneficial.
- okmokmz 8y agoYou think people are getting better medical information from ads than from doctors? I don't know about you, but if I started taking a new medication every time I saw an ad saying I needed to I would be on a lot of boner pills