3 ms·
It's not just bad press; engineers (of any stripe) are often frighteningly socially incompetent. In my experience, this is true far more often than for lawyer
by timr 19y ago
It's not just bad press; engineers (of any stripe) are often frighteningly socially incompetent. In my experience, this is true far more often than for lawyers or medical doctors.
It's also a kind of stereotype to say that programming is about creation and empowerment; the existence of this forum (and most of what pg writes) seems to me a reaction to the utterly dismal, uncreative state of most programming jobs. So it's not really fair to say that people flock to other fields based on misinformation. Most computer-related jobs really do suck.
- DaniFong 19y agoPerhaps I was insufficiently specific. The problem isn't that the conception of the median programming job is wrong. The problem is that technical people of both genders are often completely unaware of the existence of better jobs. Sometimes, when people talk of career prospects of becoming a programmer, they say it with such disdain that they might as well be talking about becoming a drone.
- aswanson 19y agothey say it with such disdain that they might as well be talking about becoming a drone Not without good cause. Startups aside, the vast majority of programmers and engineers spend their careers implementing other people's ideas. Outliers that start their own companies are very rare. In law and medicine, it seems that running a startup (your own pratice) is the expected progression of a successful career. They are groomed to expect it. The typical tech/science track seems to be tailored to produce....drones. Judge them by their fruits.
- timr 19y agoWell said. Even in academic science, the presumption is that you will one day lead your own research group (however unlikely that may be)...and academia is not known for progressive organizational thinking. Closer to your example: my dentist is in his mid-20s, and already owns a half share in two established practices. How many programmers own a half share in their own business at 25?
- aswanson 19y agoHow many programmers own a half share in their own business at 25? None. I swear if none of my startups work out I will count my engineering degrees a complete waste of time. I found only 2 or three classes moderately interesting, and from a moneymaking standpoint, the brainpower required to make it through the curriculum versus the salary is a joke. I studied EE and use next to none of it. I could have learned to code on my own, and even studied electronics in my own time like I did as a kid, and still ended up in cubicle land, or earned a professional degree to fall back on (medicine, law) probably having a better time in the process. Sometimes you have to separate business and pleasure.
- reynolds 19y agoHow many programmers own a half share in their own business at 25? None. I must be the only one then. We also haven't taken any funding and are profitable.
- aswanson 19y agoI answered that question wrong. I should have stated "none that I know." But at any rate, I can rattle off far more lawyers, doctors, dentists, and for that matter CPA's that own businesses than programmers.
- ComputerGuru 19y agoHow many programmers own a half share in their own business at 25? How about the whole thing at 19?
- aswanson 19y agoCongrats, and that is a great forum design on your site. What did you use to build it?
- Tamerlin 19y agoIt's worse, actually; the vast majority of the programmers out there today aren't implementing squat, they're providing life support for the bad programmers who came before them. (This has come very close to driving me entirely out of the field; the only thing that has kept me in it for so long is the paychecks.)
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]
- helveticaman 19y agoIt's not just bad press; engineers (of any stripe) are often frighteningly socially incompetent. It's not always their fault. A lot of these engineers have ADD.