6 ms·
In Amsterdam, any property that has been empty for over a year can be legally squatted, and once in, legal squatters may be hard to get out. For this reason, la
by mcv 8y ago
In Amsterdam, any property that has been empty for over a year can be legally squatted, and once in, legal squatters may be hard to get out. For this reason, landlords tend to rent out their empty properties cheaply as "anti-kraak" (anti-squat), on the condition that the tenant moves out when the landlord needs the property again. This is quite popular for students because you often get a ridiculous amount of space for very little money, though it may come with excessive restrictions.
Amsterdam has (or used to have, perhaps) a pretty healthy squatting culture. Many squatters are ideologically driven and improve the neighbourhoods they're squatting in.
- cf141q5325 8y agoIts "had" isnt it? Squatting was made illegal in 2010 if i recall correctly.
- cies 8y agoMunicipalities can still kind of "allow" it on case by case basis. Nation wide legal basis (loop hole) is gone now indeed.
- cf141q5325 8y agoThats likely with buildings owned by the municipalities? We have something similarly with a few decade old squats in Germany.
- cies 8y agoNot exactly, but that's often the case.
- mcv 8y agoThat's possible. I admit I haven't been keeping up, and my knowledge of squatting stems mostly from the 1990s, when I was a student. I still think it's a very pragmatic way to fight real estate speculation. But my impression is that Amsterdam doesn't have a big problem with buildings sitting empty, so if squatting is illegal again, I guess they've found a different way to prevent it? I have no idea what that is, though.
- emptyfile 8y agoWow, so every word of your post is probably wrong. Do you not see the problem with the most upvoted and seemingly informative comment on the thread being, at the very least, 20-30 years out of date?
- cf141q5325 8y agoNot wrong and not 30 years but 9 years out of date. I still think its noteworthy, that Amsterdam had such a rule for a long time until very recently. It shows that there are precedents for how to deal with empty buildings.
- narcindin 8y agoI think its noteworthy, but in the opposite manner. Amsterdam tried such a rule and then got rid of it. What do the Dutch know about the costs of this rule that isn't in this conversation?
- winterismute 8y agoWell, this is not always how it works: many factors can lead to a reverse of legislation, such as stonger lobbying, backfire from a government held together by strong opposite ideas, or simply the measure might have solved the problem and a different rule might have been adopted (btw, assuming you are from the US, I think the idea of undoing medicare is a good example). I have lived in the NL just when the change in squatting legislation was happening (2009-2015). My impression was that more and more parties that were ideologically against it got popular and this changed the agenda of policymakers, given also the pressure estate investors that were hunting for a treasure. But existing squats were definitely well integrated with the cities I lived in (Utrecht, Amsterdam), sign that this law somehow became part of the city identity.
- mcv 8y agoIt was mostly the right-wing parties (CDA and VVD) that wanted to ban squatting. No idea why they didn't succeed in banning it during the 1980s. From what I read about the history, I can't find anything about a law that explicitly allowed it; it seems it was simply the high court that didn't consider it breaking and entering when it was in a building that wasn't being used, presumably considered a building unused when it hadn't been in use for a year, and anyone living in a house for some time got the same legal protection as a legal tenant. Conservative parties considered this a loophole in the law, progressive parties probably thought this worked quite well to prevent housing speculation. But it appears it may have originated from a legal accident rather than explicit legislation. Still, during the 1990s it was explicit policy at least in Amsterdam to tolerate squatting within these conditions.
- clydethefrog 8y agoThere are manuals out there called "It's still possible" in the Dutch squatting community. Houses still get squated, but less often and the squatters have to leave much quicker. A quick translation of a Dutch article explaining how squatting is still possible: >Today, squatting is illegal. This means that if a building is squatted and the owner makes a declaration, a procedure is started by the Public Prosecution Service that can result in evacuation. The squatters must be informed in time, so that they have the opportunity to institute summary proceedings. That does not mean that the squatters can just be removed from a building once they live there. That is only possible if they seriously misbehave, break house peace, get in the way of the activities of a company, or are at risk because the building is in poor condition.
- blablablerg 8y agonot anymore, squatting has been prohibited in the Netherlands for a couple of years now.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- StreamBright 8y ago>> Many squatters are ideologically driven and improve the neighbourhoods they're squatting in. How did you quantify the improvement?
- coldtea 8y agoNot sure about the Netherlands, but from other places I know, if the empty building was dirty and falling apart, with broken windows and such, with junkies and other such people frequenting it, and the squatters painting it, made repairs, started doing community stuff (from soup kitchens to concerts), allowing some homeless/poor people to stay in, and so on, I'd qualify it as improvement over an idle building sitting there...
- mcv 8y agoI don't, but I can qualify it. Some squatters run neighbourhood projects or cultural projects of some sort, workshops, art-related stuff, community center, information meetings, that kind of thing.
- gadders 8y agoI've never understood the pro-squatting arguments. It's theft, no?
- Xylakant 8y agoThe German constitution mandates that (property) ownership brings obligations for the public good. Ownership is a construct secured by society, so society as a whole must at least partially benefit. As such, keeping a building empty can be considered theft, too.
- geezerjay 8y ago> As such, keeping a building empty can be considered theft, too. Your assertion makes zero sense even if we accept your thesis at face value. For example, it's absurd to leap from "society mut at least partially benefit" from private property to assert that private property not being used in compliance to your personal taste to be theft. That's just plain nuts from any angle.
- Xylakant 8y agoYou’re absolutely welcome to make an argument how a building kept deliberately empty of tenants over years benefits society. You can consider that position nuts, but given the amount of public support and legal backing for a current initiative in Berlin to enact eminent domain against entities that hold > 3000 flats, “plain nuts from any angle” seems to be slightly exaggerated.
- mcv 8y agoThere's more to life than property rights. Keeping buildings empty in an area where there's high demand for buildings is harmful, and real estate is inherently subject to regulation already. Opponents of squatting do indeed complain that it's theft of some sort and should be illegal, and that's hard to deny, but at the same time it's a very cheap and pragmatic solution to a problem: one way or another, it ensures that buildings are kept in use.
- pbhjpbhj 8y ago
- C1sc0cat 8y agoIn the uk to get round this sort of tax its common for buildings to have their roof removed.
- ASalazarMX 8y agoDoesn't that ruin the building? It rains a lot there.
- mcv 8y agoI noticed in Egypt that are a lot of inhabited unfinished buildings everywhere. From what I understand, that's for tax reasons: you don't pay tax (or pay less) if the building is still under construction, but you can still live there. Looks really ugly.
- dontbenebby 8y agoHow much notice does the landlord need to give? It would suck to get evicted mid-semester.
- mcv 8y agoI don't know. From what I understand, they don't have normal tenant rights, so can be evicted pretty quickly. Yes, that sucks. That's the downside that comes with cheap space. You've got to pay the ridiculously overpriced costs for student rooms if you want stability.
- dontbenebby 8y agoThis is why it's better to just live inside the dorm, Real Genius style ;)
- johnchristopher 8y ago> Many squatters are ideologically driven and improve the neighbourhoods they're squatting in. Says who ? Not that I don't believe you or that I believe it's false but are there more than one account of that happening ?
- mcv 8y agoYes there is, and it's fairly common as far as I can tell, but it's not universal. Roughly speaking, my impression at the time is that there are roughly three different types of squatters: * Opportunistic squatters: they simply need a place to live, would like it to be nice and cheap, but don't have the time or dedication for any sort of activism. Mostly students and young unemployed people. Artists possibly, though they can also fall in the next group. * Ideological squatters: they have political opinions about housing policy. They tend to know the law, but may also disagree with it. Likely to organise information meetings, protests, but also provide services like community centers or soup kitchens. Tend to take good care of their squats in order to show this can work, but the more militant type may organise riots. Amsterdam had a lot of "krakerrellen" (squatter riots) in the late 1970s and early 1980s, but that hasn't really happened since the situation got normalised. Though there has been the occasional evacuation where quatters had to be forced out. They usually leave of their own accord and obey court orders, though. * Criminal squatters: don't care about the law, or may be very aware that they're breaking it. Probably doesn't care about the state of the house. Possibly involved in various crimes. I'm not aware of real criminal squatters in Amsterdam; crime happens more on the real estate owners side: lots of organised crime in Amsterdam is involves in the real estate business. That said, I imagine militant anarchists may also cross over from ideological to criminal squatters. And of course this is the group most likely to keep a low profile. There's grey areas between all of them of course.