6 ms·
I hate Tock, and my wife and I will not eat at any restaurant that requires that we use them. Eating out is not just about acquiring food. It's a social ritua
by lisper 8y ago
I hate Tock, and my wife and I will not eat at any restaurant that requires that we use them. Eating out is not just about acquiring food. It's a social ritual, and paying for the meal at the end is an essential part of that ritual, the culmination of mutual trust between a diner and a restaurateur. Tock's pay-up-front business model destroys that trust. The not-so-subtle message to the customer is, "We don't trust you to pay." But that knife cuts both ways: if you get my money up front, why should I trust you not to cut corners on the meal that you provide?
I get that restaurants have to protect themselves against no-shows, and I have no problem handing over a credit card number so that they can charge a no-show fee. But paying the entire cost of the meal up front is a line that I won't cross. There are too many excellent alternatives out there still doing business the old fashioned way, thank God.
- DannyBee 8y agoTock's business model is about people who make reservations and don't show up (or try to resell the reservations, etc), which is a huge issue for restaurants. It's also about who the relationship is with. OpenTable, as you can see, believes the relationship is between you and OpenTable. Tock generally believes it is between you and the restaurant. It's not at all about whether you can pay or not.
- lisper 8y agoYou must not have read my comment all the way through, because I explicitly said: "I get that restaurants have to protect themselves against no-shows, and I have no problem handing over a credit card number so that they can charge a no-show fee." > It's not at all about whether you can pay or not. I never said it was.
- DannyBee 8y agoI did read your comment. I just found it mostly not worth responding to your suggestion, honestly. But let's do it anyway. ""I get that restaurants have to protect themselves against no-shows, and I have no problem handing over a credit card number so that they can charge a no-show fee." " Did you ever consider this may not be at all a viable product model, given it's been tried and failed miserably? IE your solution may not be a solution that works. If your level of trust is that you expect restaurants to cut corners if you pay up front, i guess i'd suggest not letting other human beings prepare food for you, since they already paid in advance for the ingredients, and so they already have an incentive to cut corners in your model regardless of Tock or not. Put another way, before you eat, you have already cost them money whether you eat there or not, and whether you use Tock or not. Additionally, basically all menus are fixed price and the tips don't got to the restaurant. So there is no reason people will cut corners more due to tock.
- lisper 8y ago> it's been tried and failed miserably That's news to me. Restaurants that I eat at do this all the time. Reference? (I have a very hard time believing that now-show fees fail while pay-up-front succeeds. It makes no sense that consumers would accept the latter but not the former.)
- tptacek 8y agoYou are probably not eating at the kinds of restaurants that are Tock's mainstay. In San Francisco, that's places like Atelier Crenn and Saison. A no-show at Alinea or Crenn is not the same thing as a no-show at The Publican or Zuni Cafe. They're all great restaurants, but The Publican and Zuni will chug along just fine with no-shows, while Alinea has every single 4-top in the place intricately planned out a week in advance. Not all the restaurants on Tock are pre-paid, for whatever that's worth to you.
- lisper 8y agoLOL. We've eaten at every 3-star Michelin restaurant in the Bay Area (we did Meadowood before they signed on to Tock) and four of the 3-stars in NYC (one of them lost a star since we were there). We're regulars at Manresa. We've eaten at four of the six two-stars in the BA (we won't do Atelier Crenn because Tock). (BTW, one of the two-stars was absolutely horrible. We didn't walk out, but we would never go back.) We ate at and fell in love with Gabriel Kreuther just before they received their second star, and at Meadowood just after they got their third one. We've been doing this for a long time. Michelin doesn't give stars to LA restaurants any more, but when we lived there we were regulars at Patina, Spago and Providence (and the Water Grill before the chef quit to go to Providence). So yeah, I'm pretty sure we are solidly in Tock's target audience. > Not all the restaurants on Tock are pre-paid, for whatever that's worth to you. Not even FaceBook is 100% evil.
- tptacek 8y agoI deliberately chose the restaurant comparisons I did to avoid this bogus response. It's not my contention that you're unfamiliar with fine dining. I'm saying something different, and if you reread my comment, I think you may find it. A good clue that your response is out of line is that you started it with "LOL". I do that too, all the time (more often, the single-word sentence "What."), and have learned to notice it as a tell that I'm writing something I'm not going to be happy having said later. The edits I make when that happens always improve my writing.
- jdreyfuss 8y agoTicketing systems like Tock are speaking to that mutual trust. Reservations are another form of mutual trust in the restaurant interaction. You're making a promise to show up and they're promising to hold a table for you. But that's a very uneven trust. You can bail with no consequence to you, while the restaurant gets screwed. I see no problem in leveling the playing field. Besides restaurants are the outlier. Most experience-based services have a pay-up-front model: concerts, sports games, transportation, conferences, movies, etc. The reason restaurants generally don't is because the cost isn't usually predictable up front for each person. For fine prix fixe dining, it is.
- lisper 8y ago> But that's a very uneven trust. You can bail with no consequence to you, while the restaurant gets screwed. Yes, that's true. > I see no problem in leveling the playing field. Neither do I. That's why I wrote: "I get that restaurants have to protect themselves against no-shows, and I have no problem handing over a credit card number so that they can charge a no-show fee." You are the second person I've had to point this out to. Good grief, doesn't anyone actually read the comments they are responding to (or downvoting)?
- jdreyfuss 8y agoPeople are calling out that your argument is pointing to the wrong step in the trust interplay. A ticketing system is not at all about a restaurant not trusting you to pay at the end of the meal and 100% about guaranteeing that you'll show up in the first place. As you say, you're fine with restaurants addressing the reservation trust imbalance, but you apparently don't like the way a ticketing system accomplishes that. Why? Because you don't like the way it feels as an experience?
- lisper 8y ago> Why? Because you don't like the way it feels as an experience? Yes. Exactly. Imagine if you took the menu of the French Laundry and served it in a McDonalds. The exact same food. Would you still pay $300 a plate?
- pmart123 8y agoI believe they have restaurants that don’t require upfront payments, or “ticket” resales? I get it for some of the destination restaurants. If a three star Michelin restaurant is in the countryside of Spain, they have to protect against last minute cancellations, and even no show fees would probably be less revenue than the full meal price. We could argue on the merits of whether that type of restaurant should be seen as a similar experience as theatre, but since people seem to, the model makes logical sense to me at the high end.
- lisper 8y agoThe difference between restaurant and theatre is that in the theatre everyone is getting the exact same product at the exact same time (with the only variant being seating location). Restaurants are more personalized. Even high-end restaurants that only offer tasting menus will make adjustments based on individual tastes, preferences, allergies, etc. At least most of the time. Here's a data point: My wife and I are frequent patrons of high-end restaurants. 99% of the time we have a great meal, but very occasionally we have an experience that is an absolute nightmare. On one occasion we went to a very well known (two Michelin star) restaurant in the Bay Area. They offered both a tasting menu and a la carte options. When we made the reservation (by phone) we told them that 1) we wanted to do the tasting menu but 2) my wife doesn't eat red meat. They said no problem. Well, it was a problem. When we asked if they would substitute the red meat courses on the tasting menu they refused. We even offered to pay the price of a fish course from the a la carte menu. They still refused. (It was the chef who refused. The rest of the staff were as mortified as we were.) So we walked out, which we have not done before or since. So I know for a fact from first hand experience that even a high end restaurant will occasionally treat their customers like shit. When that happens, I want to retain my leverage.
- pmart123 8y agoFair point. Shows and concerts are a one-to-many versus a many-to-many experiences. Everyone hears the same sound versus your steak is perfect and mine is overdone. Although, Broadway shows can have alternative actors perform though in case the main actor gets sick, Lebron James gets hurt, etc. I've never walked out of a restaurant after the food was served. I've had poor experiences at nice restaurants where little was done to remedy the situation, and I've had times where simply moving tables resulted in a free meal. I realize Yelp and Tripadvisor have been known to hide or remove bad reviews, but this often is the best recourse of action along with contacting the manager or owner, or potentially disputing the charge with your cc company. I'm not sure if Tock has any policy specifically in this instance? My guess would be that they leave it to the you and the restaurant to figure out? Interestingly enough, the co-founder of Tock and Alinea just had a public dispute with Cat Cora of "Iron Chef." I've been to Alinea and Next, and had incredible service, but things happen.
- notyourday 8y agoThey will be out of business. It only works in extremely high end ( think $400/per person ) kind of places with super limited seating. Or in a fast casual place that competes with the likes of Chipotle.
- stephencanon 8y ago> The not-so-subtle message to the customer is, "We don't trust you to pay." But that knife cuts both ways: if you get my money up front, why should I trust you not to cut corners on the meal that you provide? Because the mostly-anonymous diner has effectively no reputation to lose by not showing up. The restaurant has everything to lose by not continuing to produce good meals that satisfy their customers.
- lisper 8y agoBut that's not true. When I reserve on OpenTable, if I don't show up, that goes on my OT record, or at least I presume it does. And I'm perfectly fine with that. I'm proud of the fact that I don't screw restaurants (even though I easily could), and I want them to know that. Also, we've had a few absolutely horrible experiences at some very high end restaurants. One case was so egregious that we actually walked out. Maybe our experience was unusual, but if a restaurant consistently treats its customers badly it's going to fail whether or not it collects the money up front. And if a restaurant does treat me like shit, I want to have some recourse other than just bitching and moaning about it.
- stephencanon 8y ago> if I don't show up, that goes on my OT record ... but, who cares? If I somehow behaved badly enough to get banned, I could just reserve a table with a new OT account, or just call the restaurant; it's not like they ask for references and do a background check before taking the reservation. A "bad OT table record", if such a thing even exists, costs you nothing.
- lisper 8y ago> ... but, who cares? Well, I presume the restaurants care. If I'm a chronic no-show, a restaurant may not accept a reservation from me, or maybe limit me to off-peak times. I can think of a lot of ways that information could be effectively leveraged.
- reverend_gonzo 8y agoOn the other hand, by having customers pre-pay, the restaurant is making sure that there are not reserved seats left empty due to no-shows, which means they are more likely to serve a full restaurant, they have a better idea ahead of time how much food will get eaten, and the end result mean less waste and they can provide better service and prices.
- reaperducer 8y agoby having customers pre-pay, the restaurant is making sure that there are not reserved seats left empty due to no-shows, which means they are more likely to serve a full restaurant When the restaurant charges a no-show fee, and then still fills the table with walk-ins, then the restaurant actually makes more money on people not showing up. It's not like if someone misses their reservation the restaurant leave the table empty for 90 minutes.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoOn the other hand, reservations are an added value on top of the services provided by a restaurant, so it makes sense to charge extra. A restaurant is under no obligation to give reservations, and if they're always busy (e.g. if a reservation is helpful to you) then reservations don't confer any benefit to the restaurant.
- lisper 8y agoAbsolutely. If a restaurant wants to charge me for a reservation on top of the cost of the meal, and make me pay up front for that, I would have no problem with it at all. I like that a lot better than asking me to pay for the entire meal up front. But that's a very different model, with very different price-discovery dynamics, than what Tock does.
- enobrev 8y agoIf I'm gathering your perspective correctly from this thread you're saying that you expect a place that charges $350 minimum per seat and is in competition with the finest culinary establishments in the world with the highest tier of service will take shortcuts with your meal, and when you notice and complain, their likely response is "too bad, sucker, we already have your money". Is that right?
- lisper 8y agoYes. The way you phrase it makes it sound unreasonable but I have actually had a few very bad experiences at high end restaurants.
- enobrev 8y agoFair enough. I have as well, but it's never gone uncorrected once I speak up. Even in cheap places that I've ordered delivery from leaning more towards the speed and convenience than quality, they tend to fix their mistakes when pointed out in my overall experience.
- lisper 8y agoYes, that's been my experience in 99% of the cases too. But it's precisely because high-end places are so expensive that this matters. If I go to Chipotle and pay $5 for a burrito that turns out to be sub-par, it just doesn't matter that much. If I'm paying $400 a plate, it matters. There's risk on both sides of this transaction.
- kbos87 8y agoInteresting, I see it from exactly the opposite perspective. By paying up front I’m putting forth trust and an expectation that the restaurant will do right by me or make it right through a refund at the end if I’m dissatisfied. I can’t say I’ve ever been in a position where I’ve been so dissatisfied with a meal that I’d use the fact that I haven’t yet paid to assert control over the situation. The friction reduction gained by being able to depart without worrying about the overhead of paying at the end is a win 99 times where paying at the end is a win maybe one time. I guess it depends what you consider to be an essential part of the ritual.
- lisper 8y agoYou only get to leave without the friction if you don't order any drinks or wine, but I can definitely see the appeal. We go on a lot of cruises, and being able to get up and go without waiting for the check is nice.
- m463 8y agoI'm wondering if this is how the world is going. Compromise on something or you won't get service. (my peeve is compromise on privacy to participate) On one hand, a friend of mine runs a contracting business has told me that the people who put down a substantial deposit are good customers. The ones who want to pay nothing up front are the ones who cause trouble at payment time. I kind of thought the price of the meal was what kept things exclusive, but not actually excluding people via tactics like this.