5 ms·
> A warning light that would’ve alerted the crew to the disagreement wasn’t part of the added-cost optional package of equipment on Lion Air’s 737 Max aircraft.
by kccqzy 8y ago
> A warning light that would’ve alerted the crew to the disagreement wasn’t part of the added-cost optional package of equipment on Lion Air’s 737 Max aircraft.
I'm not an aviation expert, but why should something that seems as important as an indicator of system malfunction be an optional package instead of builtin?
- dangwu 8y agoI agree with you, but cars have optional packages for warning lights for lane changes and automatic braking. It’s not that hard to imagine.
- TheSpiceIsLife 8y agoThe first thing I noticed about planes is they are not cars. Seems an analogy that’d rapidly break down.
- Joe-Z 8y agoWell, you want to be witty, but that‘s exactly the point of an analogy: Make things that are different comparable, so you can come to conclusions about thing A even though you only have knowledge of thing B. You might want to try to strengthen your argument by explaining why an analogy between cars and planes can‘t hold (one moves only in „2D“ vs. the other one moves in „3D“ for example)
- zaphirplane 8y agothat 737 costs 100,000,000 a plane crash kills a lot of people The training to drive a car vs a 737 is Hugh
- lozenge 8y agoThey both have alternatives (ie looking around you). What's the procedure for figuring out whether AOA sensors disagree when there's no indicator light? The sensors are probably used in numerous ways by the flight control software.
- Thimothy 8y agoThose are compulsory... At least in Europe. Are there many cars in the US that don't have warning lights when braking? Jesus.
- copperx 8y agoAutomatic braking is optional. Braking lights aren't.
- ilkkao 8y agoI'm not an expert at all either but wondering too why this can't be a notification on one of the screens, a SW feature I mean.
- ulfw 8y agoIt’s when you keep warming up a 1967 architecture with as few as Possible changes so you don’t have to recertify. The whole 737 is preposterous and wouldn’t be legally certified if presented as a new airplane today.
- tobinfricke 8y ago> The whole 737 is preposterous and wouldn’t be legally certified if presented as a new airplane today. In what way is it preposterous?
- iliketosleep 8y agoTo cut a long story short, they put massive engines on an airframe not designed for it, causing "unusual flight characteristics" (the huge engines could generate their own lift, pitching the nose up) which they compensated for with MCAS. MCAS took input from an AoA sensor, and if this sensor provided incorrect input the nose of the plane could be pitched down aggressively during normal flight - a very dangerous occurrence especially soon after takeoff. To make matters worse, it overrides pilot input (i.e. pulling up on the yoke doesn't help - the system has to be switched off). An AoA disagreement indicator, which may provide timely alert in such situations, was an optional paid extra (should have been a mandatory safety feature). Without this indicator and in an emergency situation, it might be too late to save the plane before the pilot figures out what is wrong and disconnects MCAS. Additionally, information about the MCAS was initially left out of the plane's manual. One could ask, in what way is it not preposterous? There's no way it should have been certified in that state.
- BrentOzar 8y agoThat’s the 737 Max, but the grandparent was referring to “The whole 737 was preposterous” - not just the Max model.
- iliketosleep 8y agoYes, you're right. I can't say that I misread it, nor did I consciously make that assumption. Oh well, faulty heuristics.
- pauljurczak 8y agoIt's all about the Benjamins baby! Yes, there should have been a warning shown on one of many LCD displays in the cockpit, but Boeing decided that it has to be displayed by HUD system, which is an expensive upgrade.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoI agree that the AoA disagree alert (and AoA gauges) should be standard. If you've watched any of Capt. Vanderburgh's videos on youtube you'll know he's got a fair amount of disdain for the lack of AoA indicators on most Boeings. But, in all fairness, even without the "AoA disagree" indicator there were telltale symptoms on the Lion Air bird that something was wrong with the alpha vane (the sensor in question). The most obvious was that only one stick shaker was going off (each control column has a shaker which only takes input from the alpha vane on its side). That's a pretty obvious symptom. However on the previous Lion Air flight there were two other symptoms written up in the maintenance log[1]: "IAS (indicated air speed) + ALT disagree shown" and "(elevator) FEEL DIFF PRESS light illuminated". On the MAX, both of those systems take angle-of-attack into account (which is new for the MAX, IIRC). As an aside, American Airlines 191 had a similar situation. Their DC-10 had only a stick shaker on the captain's control column, a second stick shaker was a paid extra. Boeing, of course, bought McDonnell Douglas years later. 1: http://www.jacdec.de/WP/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/2018-10-29_PK-LQP_B737MAX8_LionAir@Jakarta-area_MX-DOC.jpg http://www.jacdec.de/WP/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/2018-10-2...
- sexyflanders 8y agoOut of curiosity how is one of two stick shakers activated obvious when each is connected to a different person? Is it common to ask “hey, is your stick shaker going too?” it seems possible that each pilot would assume the other was feelig the same feedback from the stick and go on troubleshooting elsewhere, but I have no experience with this.
- inferiorhuman 8y agoOut of curiosity how is one of two stick shakers activated obvious when each is connected to a different person? Stick shakers are noisy, but I suppose you would also ask and cross check the instruments. If only one stick shaker goes off you'll probably get various "something disagrees" lights going off, which should prompt you to check. Take this for instance: https://aviationweek.com/awin/boeing-addresses-pitot-tube-anomaly-its-737s https://aviationweek.com/awin/boeing-addresses-pitot-tube-an...