4 ms·
You can say the same about Twitter and Facebook. In fact, the guy had a Twitter where he posted guns and ammunition with slogans on it, days earlier. Had it rec
by gamblor956 8y ago
You can say the same about Twitter and Facebook. In fact, the guy had a Twitter where he posted guns and ammunition with slogans on it, days earlier. Had it received more attention, this could've possibly been prevented.
That's not true, and it's notable that you had to create a new account just to make this FUD claim. Those murderers may all have used Twitter and Facebook to try to disseminate their idea vomit, but they were radicalized and incited by 4chan and/or 8chan. Also, Twitter and Facebook make the effort to remove those posts once they are made aware of them. 4chan and 8chan revel in keeping up those promote, and even promote them to show just how "free speech" they are.
It's a bunch of anonymous people posting crap, often for shock value. Sure, there's incitement on there, but nobody takes anybody serious.
More than a dozen mass murderers in the past few years took 4chan and 8chan seriously enough to murder hundreds of people. Mass murder might be an abstract concept to basement dwellers, but I know people who were shot at in the Santa Barbara, Vegas, and Thousand Oaks shooting, and it sure as fuck isn't an abstract concept to me or the thousands of other people who knew the victims of those shootings.
- setquk 8y agoI've heard the same horrific shit in casual conversation in numerous pubs in the UK in the last 30 years and the people in there certainly don't know what 4chan or 8chan are. In fact the horrible things pre-dated the proliferation of internet connectivity. This isn't a specific platform problem but a problem with a subset of humanity.
- gamblor956 8y agoThat's true. But people engaging in "casual" conversation over beer aren't inciting each other to commit violent acts of hate. But in those rare instances where a bar crosses over into openly supporting that type of speech, the police start taking an interest and monitoring that bar and its customers. And if a line gets crossed with respect to incitement, conspiracy, etc., the local municipality will usually pull the bar's liquor license and get it shut down to prevent future such crimes from being organized or incited at that bar. So, really, you're actually quite spot on with the bar analogy. 4chan/8chan are exactly like a skinhead bar that's getting shutdown because the customers kept inciting each other to kill people and actually followed through.
- setquk 8y agoActually sometimes they are inciting it. There was a “paki patrol” (their term not mine) that originated in a local pub in a town I lived in. They did do things about it. We pulled one guy out of the river and helped him after they had chucked him in and threw bricks at his head and ambled off when they got bored. Incidentally the police did nothing. Edit: this was early 90s.
- gamblor956 8y agoI'm not sure why a single incident of the police failing to enforce the laws over 2 decades ago during the notoriously racist Thatcher era is relevant to a discussion of incitement as it is enforced today?
- lostlogin 8y agoA pub audience is probably a handful of people, some platforms have a reach many magnitudes larger and this changes the dynamic.
- gridlockd 8y ago> That's not true... What exactly isn't true? The guy did have that Twitter. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/resizer/4vW9tadY1zUt-CwkgRo6DWG7NuY=/620x478/smart/filters:quality(70)/arc-anglerfish-syd-prod-nzme.s3.amazonaws.com/public/HYN7KWCY7ZEMBDO6BG6BVHTZLQ.jpg https://www.nzherald.co.nz/resizer/4vW9tadY1zUt-CwkgRo6DWG7N... > ...and it's notable that you had to create a new account just to make this FUD claim. I created this account three days ago to comment on an entirely unrelated matter. > Those murderers may all have used Twitter and Facebook to try to disseminate their idea vomit... So you agree that Twitter and Facebook are linked to the murderers? > ...but they were radicalized and incited by 4chan and/or 8chan. That's a pretty questionable claim. The guy had a manifesto similar to Breivik. Would you say Breivik was radicalized by 4chan? He holds specific political beliefs, whereas on places like 4chan, no belief is taken serious at all. There are real Neo-Nazi forums where there is serious discussion on Neo-Nazi ideals, but 4chan isn't one of them. > More than a dozen mass murderers in the past few years took 4chan and 8chan seriously enough to murder hundreds of people. Again, these forums are made up of pure shitposting. Nobody knows anybody. Nothing on there is taken serious, even things that should be taken serious. It's a brain dump.
- gamblor956 8y agoIt appears that you aren't very familiar with 4chan or 8chan based on your other posts about not knowing much about them. 4chan and 8chan have numerous skinhead forums. They are two of the most popular forum sites for skinheads and white nationalists. Again, these forums are made up of pure shitposting. Nobody knows anybody. Nothing on there is taken serious, even things that should be taken serious. It's a brain dump. This is objectively not true. You can repeat it all you want, and you might even believe it because it's true for you, but plenty of people take the stuff on 4chan and 8chan at face value and take posts their seriously.
- gridlockd 8y ago> It appears that you aren't very familiar with 4chan or 8chan based on your other posts about not knowing much about them. I never said anything like that. I said I haven't been on 8chan before today. You shouldn't lump both together like that anyway, it's disingenuous. > 4chan and 8chan have numerous skinhead forums. I wouldn't qualify /pol/ or /b/ as "skinhead forums" by any reasonable standard. > They are two of the most popular forum sites for skinheads and white nationalists. 4chan has subforums for anime, lgbt, video games, porn and all kinds of other things. It's a popular site in general and there's people from all over the political spectrum.
- snvzz 8y ago>More than a dozen mass murderers in the past few years took 4chan and 8chan seriously enough to murder hundreds of people. If I understand correctly, you're making an argument that goes around this: Exposure to freedom of speech is dangerous to society. From this, you're proposing: All online discussion should be curated. I don't want to live in such a world, so I kindly disagree with your proposal. Adults should be able to talk about whatever they want, and no third party should decide what they can or cannot read. For this to be possible, communities with a very light handed approach to moderation should be allowed to continue to exist. This includes those that allow anonymous posting, as there's enough precedent in human history on perfectly fine ideas that are now generally accepted have been met with hostility. If posting safely is not an option, many will choose to not post at all. Thus ideas would get repressed.
- gamblor956 8y agoIf I understand correctly, you're making an argument that goes around this: Exposure to freedom of speech is dangerous to society. If I understand you correctly, you're making the argument that inciting someone to commit violent acts of murder is freedom of speech which is good for society. I believe in freedom of speech. I've defended it in court. What happens on 4chan and 8chan isn't free speech. It's acts of incitement that just happen to take the form of text. Adults should be able to talk about whatever they want, and no third party should decide what they can or cannot read. You don't understand that free speech relates to the words and ideas. Free speech means that the people on 4chan and 8chan can use whatever words they want, and spread whatever ideas they want. So long as they aren't committing criminal acts such as incitement. The words and ideas are protected, not the acts they represent. For this to be possible, communities with a very light handed approach to moderation should be allowed to continue to exist. This includes those that allow anonymous posting, as there's enough precedent in human history on perfectly fine ideas that are now generally accepted have been met with hostility. If posting safely is not an option, many will choose to not post at all. Thus ideas would get repressed. I agree. And if 4chan and 8chan were solely about the sharing of ideas, I would be opposed to banning them...in the US, where the law would protect such speech, however abhorrent it is. But 4chan and 8chan long ago crossed over the line into being more than just sharing ideas...they're now websites where people incite and plan violent crimes.
- dstola 8y ago> they were radicalized and incited by 4chan and/or 8chan If you can prove that statement then it certainly deserves to get shutdown, but you cant if you read something in the newspaper and it makes you angry and/or sparks an extreme reaction, should that newspaper be banned? or a TV network, or any other news source? Its a slippery slope if you go down this road IMO
- gamblor956 8y agoif you read something in the newspaper and it makes you angry and/or sparks an extreme reaction, should that newspaper be banned? or a TV network, or any other news source? Too many non-lawyers on this board think that saying "slippery slope" makes two things on the opposite ends of the spectrum one and the same, and that's not true at all. The law is perfectly capable of handling degees of difference. After all, there are no less than 5 degrees of homicide (more, depending on jurisdiction). It's quite possible to ban a newspaper that says "Kill all the X this weekend" without it having any bearing on a newspaper that opines "X people should die." If you can't see the difference between the two, then I won't bother responding further.