3 ms·
> To blackmail is to threaten to do something otherwise legal (usually divulge information) unless you are paid. So, doing research on a politician, and discov
by vkou 8y ago
> To blackmail is to threaten to do something otherwise legal (usually divulge information) unless you are paid.
So, doing research on a politician, and discovering that they were a member of the KKK, and offering to keep mum for $50,000 (Because you hate them, and want to damage their career, but you have a price) is blackmail.
But doing research on a politician, and discovering that they were a member of the KKK, and going public with it (Because you hate them, and you want to damage their career), is not blackmail.
Why is one illegal, but the other one isn't? The personal harm (To the politician) is the same. Is there a social harm that I'm missing?
Or, suppose you're a customer at a restaurant. You saw the waiter spit in your food. You ask the manager to comp you your meal, or you're going to post a nasty Yelp review. (Scale this up to any sort of business transaction that you want, including multi-million dollar disputes.) Is this blackmail?
Or, suppose you're working in unsafe conditions, and you tell your boss that unless conditions improve, you're going to call OSHA. Is this blackmail? What if you'll not call OSHA if he fixes the unsafe conditions, and also gives you next Monday off? Is that now blackmail?
Or, suppose you're doing research on a company you want to invest in. You discover that their prospects are crap, and you short them, and make money. That's not blackmail. But, apparently, threatening to tell the public that their prospects are crap, and that everyone should short them, is.
There are no straight answers to the problem... Which is why I think people only view blackmail poorly when they feel something unfair happens because of it.
Getting a promotion because you blackmailed your boss? People find this incredibly offensive. Promotions should be fair!
Getting money, because you're blackmailing a politician? People also find this incredibly offensive. Why are you getting money for 'nothing'.
Getting a safe working environment, because you threatened to report your boss to a regulator? Oh, that's perfectly fine!
The reaction people have to blackmail has little to do with the act of blackmail itself - and everything to do with the 'unfair' nature of the payoff.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The personal harm (To the politician) is the same. Strictly less in the case of blackmail, since otherwise they'd turn down the blackmail. > Is there a social harm that I'm missing? Yes, concealing adverse information about public figures, particularly public officials, is a social harm promoted by legalized blackmail. (For non-public figures and non-public-interest adverse facts, the tort of invasion of privacy or publication of private information applies even with blackmail being illegal, and provides a stronger backstop against the individual harms than the privilege of having to pay off those who would otherwise drag your name through the mud.)
- nybble41 8y ago> Yes, concealing adverse information about public figures, particularly public officials, is a social harm promoted by legalized blackmail. I'd say that argument only holds water if you're going beyond simply criminalizing blackmail and actually saying that there is a legal obligation to report any such information, such that agreeing not to reveal the information for a price means failing in that duty (assuming you keep to the agreement). In that case blackmail is just a special case of soliciting a bribe. However, the idea that arbitrary private citizens are obligated to publish any and all damaging information they might obtain about a public figure seems like a rather hard sell.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThe incentive structure works without a mandate, because there is a market for public interest information (both via news media and interested parties). Criminalizing blackmail negated a countervailing incentive, but that doesn't make it necessary to criminalize non-reporting generally to create an incentive to report.
- vkou 8y agoThe news media won't reward me anything but a pat on the head for revealing a politician's unsavory history, and as for interested parties paying for it... The politician in question is 100% an interested party.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The news media won't reward me anything but a pat on the head for revealing a politician's unsavory history The news media rewards people for that all the time; now, mostly, those are people who've become media employees first, but they definitely exist. > as for interested parties paying for it... The politician in question is 100% an interested party. Yes, but so are their (actual and potential) opponents.
- nybble41 8y ago
- jldugger 8y ago> Why is one illegal, but the other one isn't? The personal harm (To the politician) is the same. Is there a social harm that I'm missing? I'd say yea, this two party model of 'victim' and blackmailer leaves out a third party, the person or entity that would be otherwise informed. I put victim in scare quotes here because the party being harmed is really others. Yelp: is blackmail, because other customers are denied information you'd otherwise provide. osha: blackmail for the Monday off, because other employees aren't getting Monday off; and maaaybe because osha would like to fine your employer? shorting: other shareholders would like that information, and are harmed without their knowledge by the spend. profiting by telling everyone that truth, however, falls in line The profit motive of the blackmailer is offensive, but there is also societal harm.
- vkou 8y agoIf we're going to blame blackmailers on creating societal harm, by virtue of not revealing information (relevant to third parties), why don't we mandate this sort of information disclosure in other contexts? Learn a secret? You're harming society, by not shouting it from the rooftops, to anyone who will hear. > shorting: other shareholders would like that information, and are harmed without their knowledge by the spend. profiting by telling everyone that truth, however, falls in line What about profiting by telling the highest bidder the truth? If there's a social harm from not releasing financial research on a company, why do we even allow it to be sold for profit? > osha: blackmail for the Monday off, because other employees aren't getting Monday off? So it does seem to come down to the 'fairness' litmus test? I wish that life were fair, but it doesn't seem to be a metric that our economy, or the law cares much about.
- marcosdumay 8y agoThere is an heuristic, in that do all the people harmed by the problem benefit from the exchange? If they do, than it's not blackmail.