15 ms·
CowToilet, a Toilet for Cows
- therein 8y agoI thought it was going to turn out to be a new copy-on-write zero-day given the name.
- grenoire 8y agoThe vulgar cousin of Heartbleed and Meltdown.
- uhtred 8y ago"cow friendly" whilst showing a picture of a cow in a cage. Fuck dairy.
- openbasic 8y agoNot just a cage, but one that barely fits them. Fuck dairy.
- nostromo 8y agoWatch the video. The cow enters the cage voluntarily when it wants to eat. When it's done it leaves the cage. The cage is just there to position the cow correctly over the toilet.
- soperj 8y agoWow. See what you want to see. There's no cage. It's a voluntary system for cows.
- hirundo 8y agoI control all of your food, and only give you access to it at 3pm. When you come to eat at 3pm I also remove your bodily fluids for resale. You can deny me your bodily fluids only by not eating. Would you describe that as a voluntary arrangement?
- oh_sigh 8y agoThe cow voluntarily goes into the cage to get fed. Then it goes back out into the field. It's not like this cow lives it's life in that cage
- grenoire 8y agoHow else do you suggest you align the cow onto the toilet itself? Cows are not potty-trained.
- ct0 8y agoPersonally I don't do dairy products, but this is going to be great news for fertilizers containing manure.
- skrebbel 8y agoPicture any human on a toilet and it'll effectively also be a "human in a cage". What's the difference?
- floatingatoll 8y agoTo an outsider, the metal bars remind of both human jails and stacked chicken cages. It’s not easy to realize that they have to look like jail cell bars in order to avoid being damaged by the cow, and it’s not well-known that cows are taught to enter metal frames for food and such to let human work on and around them occur more safely. Humans don’t as often need metal bars to avoid knocking the bathroom walls down, but when we need metal bars for support (ADA bathrooms), they look a lot like the cow bars.
- lwb 8y agoWait why is this here?
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoIt's a new invention/technology, it has potential impact on our environment, and it's interesting.
- t3rabytes 8y agoThis is such a shitty product. (/s) Edit: okay, clearly someone didn't get the pun.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- PunksATawnyFill 8y agoThey’re just being pissy.
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agourinit to deep
- benj111 8y agoNow now, don't be cowed. We should really steer this conversation somewhere else, before your karma goes down the toilet.
- hsnewman 8y agoIs there a bull toilet?
- gatherhunterer 8y ago“Cow” includes bulls, heifers and steer.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- bunderbunder 8y agoThat might be something that varies regionally. In the usage I'm familiar with, "cow" specifically means a female who has given birth. As opposed to heifers, who haven't. The general term for any member of the species would be cattle (both singular and plural). You might use "cows" to more generally mean any female cattle, but using it to include males of the species, too, would be understood as humorous.
- gatherhunterer 8y agoWhat is your source for this information? I have worked with meat for years and have never heard anyone react with humor to steers or bulls being referred to as cows. Go into a butcher shop and ask where their cows are raised and they will answer you without hesitation. Ask them without using the word and they will readily refer to beef as having come from a cow. EDIT: Even googling "beef cows" provides a wealth of contradictions to your statement.
- bunderbunder 8y agoMy source for this information is how the language is spoken among members of my social circle. Which admittedly doesn't include any butchers, just dairy farmers. Maybe our social circles are different. That's regional variation for you.
- fbelzile 8y agoI really like the design of the product logo: https://www.hanskamp.nl/uploads/webshop/products/2019/jan/hanskampcowtoiletlogodef_25.png https://www.hanskamp.nl/uploads/webshop/products/2019/jan/ha... For some reason, it's oddly satisfying to see two concepts merge into one cohesive logo.
- mbel 8y agoI have the exact opposite feeling. Connecting head with toilet feels somehow wrong and I don't really feel comfortable looking at the logo. Also the "recycling-ears" feels like unnecessary addition to main concept of unholy merge of cow with toilet.
- sxates 8y agoa "golden cow" so to speak?
- lainga 8y agoIt looks a bit like the robot from The Day the Earth Stood Still.
- mc32 8y agoI think they used the wrong graphic. They don’t poo, they pee in this thing so they should have converged a urinal and cow head. Also called it a cow urinal.
- londons_explore 8y agoIf the urine goes on the field, then the farmer gets to dispose of it for free. If the urine gets collected in tanks, suddenly it's hazardous liquid waste and very expensive to dispose of. The farmer couldn't just dump it in a river! Unless a commercial use for cow urine can be found, or laws changed, I can't imagine this product going anywhere.
- gadders 8y agoMaybe they use it to make DEF/BlueTec, the diesel emissions additive. That is 30+% urea. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust_fluid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diesel_exhaust_fluid
- harpastum 8y agoIf there is a clear benefit of collecting and disposing the urine somewhere else, this seems like a good use of regulation/taxation/credits. Have a credit/tax that captures the value of not having the cow urine in the fields.
- ddebernardy 8y agoWatch the video. Besides it being interesting, towards the end he explicitly invites startups to come up with an idea on how to put the cow urine to good use.
- loceng 8y agoYup, finding efficiencies to create a market for the urine will make the economies of collecting it work better. I've never had interest in cow waste products until now..
- joering2 8y agoGates found a way to filter pee into water. He drank some on the record :) Wonder if the same could be done with cow urine. After all, it all started as a drinkable water as well. Still would be hard to find market but in some rural areas or deserts where water is harder to find or more expensive...
- bloudermilk 8y ago> Noteworthy is that cows visit the CowToilet voluntarily. The visit to the toilet is combined with the receival of their daily portion of feed. "Voluntarily"... right
- bluedino 8y agoIs it much difference than milking them? It's just another liquid.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoI guess it is roughly true, in the same way that employment is voluntary.
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoWell, incentivized, it gets them to pee while the cow eats.
- chris_va 8y ago> "Once located, the nerve, which triggers the urinary reflex, is stimulated and the cow starts urinating. ... The visit to the toilet is combined with the receival[sic] of their daily portion of feed." May be stretching the definition of voluntary.
- loceng 8y agoYeah, using the word voluntary is disingenuous. I'd be interested to see third-party research to determine if there's a developed preference, where both options are provided to cows - two different physical locations that they are both introduced to, and see if they're indifferent or if a percentage prefers one or the other.
- jessriedel 8y agoIn fact, you could even roughly quantify the degree to which cows like/dislike this experience by looking at the quality of food (or treats) that have to be paired with this versus a non-toilet feeder for the cows to be indifferent between the two options.
- mft_ 8y agoCows have learned to voluntarily (genuinely) use automatic milking machines. (Now, apparently they like it because of the relief it provides to their swollen udders, which are swollen thanks to the hormonal state they are kept in, but still...)
- anonymfus 8y agoJudging by the video, the cow is free to touch or not to touch the toilet.
- fenwick67 8y agoYes the cow is perfectly free to starve
- munificent 8y agoVery disappointed they didn't call this a "moo loo".
- wesammikhail 8y agoyou should consider a career in marketing!
- xrd 8y agoCows don't have much purchasing power, so you are wrong.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gabbygab 8y agoOr a career as a cow whisperer.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- inopinatus 8y agoMarketing and bovine scat. What a match.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dkarl 8y agoThe product video shows the device working... after it shows a guy doing the same thing manually.
- morningmoon 8y agoSo now we’re going to force them to pee by stimulating their urinary nerves!? Another reason to stop our inhumane practice of enslaving, raping, and slaughtering cows to serve our tastes. We don’t need to do this to have nutritious healthy lives.
- nkkollaw 8y ago> Another reason to stop our inhumane practice of enslaving, raping, and slaughtering cows to serve our tastes. Do a lot of people really rape cows..?
- morningmoon 8y agoOnly cows that have been pregnant produce milk. Cows are made pregnant to increase the duration of milk production, and to produce more cows for dairy or meat. (Edited for clarity) The process of artificial insemination involves sticking a rod/hand with bull semen into their vaginas. Just do a quick search for this and you can see videos of how artificial insemination works. There’s also a process of hormone injections to ensure cows sync up for more efficient AI. Usually most farmers justify this by talking about how it’s safer than letting a bull fuck the cow while it’s confined to a pen (how it was done in a bygone era). Oh, and if you’re wondering about how they get the bull semen they have them fuck artificial vaginas, or masturbate them if that’s not working out.
- nkkollaw 8y agoSeem more of a burden for the vet masturbating the bull and sticking his hand in the cow's vagina, to be honest :-D
- simion314 8y ago>Only pregnant cows produce milk. Not true, a cow will produce milk many months after she gives birth. Cows naturally get into heat, the behavior of the cow changes, she will start jumping on other cows and it is dangerous to be around it, you have to bring a bull or have it inseminated. I know this because I was raised at a low tech farm, I am not aware of procedures or reasons to make a cow get pregnant more often but maybe this exists somewhere, if this was true probably it would be used for getting more meat not more milk, Anyway there is no rape involved, if is artificial inseminated then it is a medical procedure, similar how fixing cows birth problems that involved doctors pushing their full arms in the cow is a medical procedure to save the cow.
- markstos 8y agoEating less meat and dairy also helps solve the ammonia problem. Plant-rich diets have been identified as a top solution to climate change. https://www.drawdown.org/solutions-summary-by-rank https://www.drawdown.org/solutions-summary-by-rank Harvard research found switching away from dairy products to be a necessary contribution to meeting climate change goals: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14693062.2018.1528965?af=R& https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14693062.2018.1...
- SeriousM 8y agoOr no meat at all! I can't say how much wrong it is to rape cows, steal their kids and after many births kill it. And now someone wants to take them the pleasure to pee whenever they want? WTF is wrong with this guys? Diary farms are a very bad place already...
- toper-centage 8y agoKilling this cows is probably the best thing farmer's do to them, considering the helish life they live.
- zerop 8y agoPeople in India drink cow urine. It's considered holy and healthy.. Google "why indians drink cow urine".
- miguelmota 8y agoIt's considered a medicinal drink in some religions.
- muthuraj57 8y ago*Some people in India
- elbrian 8y agoOP didn't say "all people in India" so your correction isn't at all necessary or helpful.
- joemi 8y agoIt's an understandable correction though. For instance, if one were to say "People in the US are are Nazis" you can be certain many people would argue that a correction is both necessary and helpful.
- djsumdog 8y agoI remember hearing about this from family members and seeing it online. I understand it happens, but is it really healthy or just urban legend/religious BS?
- 3into10power5 8y agoReligious BS
- Derek_MK 8y agoNo thanks, I'm good
- peterwwillis 8y agoThis just makes me want to consume dairy/meat less, and I'm an omnivore.
- fnovd 8y agoTechnically vegans are omnivores, too: being an omnivore means you are able to consume both plants and animals. Humans as a species are omnivores. Choosing to consume animal products is something else. I had always considered being an omnivore exclusive from being a vegan but I didn't have a good answer for lack of symmetry between a diet I am capable of eating and the diet I do eat. The "vegan" word for it is Carnism [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnism
- aviv 8y agoHumans are frugivores, you got your whole history/life concepts wrong.
- Noxmiles 8y agoI understood the concept, after he made the cow pee with his hand within 10 seconds of stroking her slowly and tenderly.
- leroy_masochist 8y agoNot sure how this makes a lot of sense commercially. By way of background I work remotely from my family's small cattle farm (we have 225ish head of grass-only fed cattle). In simple terms, cow piss has a bunch of nitrogen in it which makes the grass grow faster (especially when you have a well developed soil biome). I watched the video and appreciate that quality engineering went into this product, I just don't get why it would make sense for any farmer who has cows in pasture to invest in this technology, even if it were available at mass-produced-in-Asia prices. More specifically, it's hard to imagine a use case for cow piss that makes it valuable enough that I'm going to spend tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars on machinery to harvest it, at an opportunity cost of less nitrogen going into my fields. Maybe it makes more sense for feedlots? They get a bunch of nasty health issues going on with their animals living in mucky high-density conditions, so reducing the ammonia in the muck might lower the amount of sores their animals have, or something like that. But taking a step back, I guess I don't get the general wisdom of inventing technology that makes bad practices marginally better on the animals and/or environment.
- fjfaase 8y agoHere in the Netherlands, cows only go into the fields half of the year, simply because during winter time it is too cold for them to be outside with no protection against wind and rain.
- leroy_masochist 8y agoFWIW, for a climate like the Netherlands most breeds of cow would be just fine living outside in the winter.
- fjfaase 8y agoIt might no longer be true for the cows that have been breed for producing lots of milk. I guess most of them might still be able to survive outside during the winter, but I suspect that their milk production will be strongly affected.
- smnplk 8y agoNow just make bottled water from cow urine and profit.
- CodeCube 8y ago> Urine as a businessmodel lol ... I think this is enough internet for today
- djsumdog 8y agoThe video was so serious, but the 7 year old deep inside of me was just laughing the whole way through. I wonder if they realized the absurdity of this as they were making the marketing materials.
- danielecook 8y agoWhat about capturing methane from cows? Isn't that arguably bigger problem? Cows emit an enormous amount of methane which is a much more potent greenhouse gas than CO2.
- mchannon 8y agoCareful with the whataboutism. Methane's largely been solved by food additives that discourage methanogenic bacteria. We're talking about urine and ammonia right now. Methane is more potent as a greenhouse gas, but it's shorter-lived, way less of a contributor to global warming than CO2, and doesn't appear to have anywhere near as much impact on the health or growth of animals or plants as heightened CO2 levels do.
- danielecook 8y agoThanks for your input. I tend to think of whataboutism in the political sphere. I suppose it goes beyond that.
- Pharmakon 8y agoSolved, but not implemented on a wide scale. I don’t know if it’s the added cost, availability or what else, but solved problems aren’t really solved if the solution is never implemented.
- rdiddly 8y agoThis partly addresses problems pointed out a few days ago in this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19368542 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19368542 It's neat when that happens on HN.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoI think it is great that people are working on solving problems like this. As a feed stock for other processes I'm guessing that the big win here would be use in a modified Haber process to produce bulk Ammonia which is used in a number of chemical plants.
- sangd 8y agoMost of cow's methane comes from his mouth, not the other side.
- reaperducer 8y agoIt's not about methane. It's about ammonia.
- sabareesh 8y agoNot sure why this is being downvoted. I am not sure even ammonia is even a problem to start according to the top comment here
- dev_dull 8y agoI love our society. Always chasing after solutions to things that aren’t really problems. Ban straws. Ban glasses of water. Ban cow pee. Forget that none of those things here make any material difference.
- Mtinie 8y agoCompletely different situations in this case. This isn’t banning cow urine, it’s solving a co-mingling problem with real economic costs and jusristictional concerns.
- markstos 8y agoSingle-use plastics is a big problem. It gets solved by chipping away it from a lot of different angles. Plastic straws are one piece of the problem. My family loves straws and brings steel straws when we go out. No big deal. No one is banning steel straws. The only hit I get when I search for "ban glasses of water" is this post. Perhaps you referring to bottled water? That's another piece of the single-use plastics problem. Shifting away animal agriculture is one the top solutions for climate change ( https://www.drawdown.org/solutions-summary-by-rank https://www.drawdown.org/solutions-summary-by-rank ). So yes, cows and all their poop and pee are a very real problem. I don't think moving the piss around differently is nearly as a good solution as breeding and killing fewer cows, though!
- UncleEntity 8y ago> The only hit I get when I search for "ban glasses of water" is this post. Used to be when you went to a restaurant they would automatically bring a glass of water to your table. Then "they" decided this was a bad thing so now you have to specifically ask for water if you want water.
- Pharmakon 8y agoI go out to eat at least twice a week, and I’ve never run into this. It sounds like the Daily Mail fed Grandpa Simpson LSD and wrote down whatever he mumbled.
- bensonn 8y agoFrom the inventor of the Moth Ladder.
- amarant 8y agoI'm not sure this makes any kind of sense actually. My girlfriend, who is a biologist and works at a waste water treatment plant, tells me the ammonia from (cow out any other kind of) urine isn't really that much of a problem. There are other components that might be (mostly residues from various medicines, but those are hard to separate from the water) but according to her, ammonia is essentially less of a problem than the erosion caused by the cows walking on the ground in most cases.
- Someone 8y agoThese cows typically don’t walk on ground; they walk on a floor in a stable, and ammonia is a problem in the Netherlands, if only because the EU has set sets national emission reduction commitments (https://www.eea.europa.eu/themes/air/national-emission-ceilings/national-emission-ceilings-directive https://www.eea.europa.eu/themes/air/national-emission-ceili...), and cattle farms are a major source of ammonia.
- droithomme 8y agoThat's extremely cool. It serves a need and apparently (according to their description) it actually works and the cows will use it. (And obviously not needed for free-range grass-fed cows as opposed to congested feed lot cows.)
- Magi604 8y agoOutside the box thinking!
- jv22222 8y agoFor me, it's really sad to see animals in that high density scenario as shown in the video. I'm not a plant based eater but I do feel myself getting pulled in that direction as time goes by.
- toper-centage 8y agoI want everyone to go vegan, but I'm pragmatic and can recognize it's a life changing choice. But eating vegan 2-3 days a week is already a healthy step for you and you'll be saving 100+ animals per year from this kind of treatment. (source: http://thevegancalculator.com/#calculator http://thevegancalculator.com/#calculator)
- hereiskkb 8y agoGet it to India. Huge potential market!
- garbagedisposal 8y agoOh great! Another cow rape system...
- nastypants 8y agoI got an erection around 1:10
- dang 8y agoPlease don't do this here.
- toper-centage 8y agoThey call it "voluntary" then say the creepy machine locates a nerve in the cows rear and stimulates it to induce urination. Nothing voluntary about forced urination... But these are animals routinely force-impregnated so maybe they're used to be abused.
- cw-dunn 8y agoMy husband sent this to me. We had a small Jersey house cow,years ago, with only 1 ac to graze and 1/4 ac veg garden, that one cow produced more nutrient load than the land could absorb... composted before (there by reducing volume) spreading. Friends with a real dairy herd had 150 acres to use, and even they had a problem using it all. This device is brilliant for the larger milk producers, and even a small New England Herds kept inside for the winter. Even a few hours eating in the atanchion barn leaves a lot of waste. To be able to collect and redirect this urine is solving Many problems on many levels. It makes a world of Common Sense to Me. As to the manure waste, many country’s burn dry dung, and the clever folks who designed ‘Cow Pots’, have redirected manure in a beneficial way. In Africa they still ‘pave’ the floors with cow dung and seal it with blood. It wouldn’t be a Martha Stewart approved design here, but certainly dried dung (mostly odorless cellulose) could be added to wood chips and made into bricks for fuel. I think the Cow Toilet is a practical device and hope it will be affordable to any dairy that wants to implement it. As for feed lots like the escresent ones in Coilinga CA.& elsewhere, be they Bovine or Porcine, or poultry; understand that the rules on the books need to be Enforced, and the graft/lobbyist elements removed. They’d get cleaned up or shut down darn fast without the greedy business machinery supporting them in government hallways. A restoration farmers point of view from seven decades looking at life