5 ms·
> To blackmail is to threaten to do something otherwise legal (usually divulge information) unless you are paid. I would slightly edit that to: > To blackmail
by airstrike 8y ago
> To blackmail is to threaten to do something otherwise legal (usually divulge information) unless you are paid.
I would slightly edit that to:
> To blackmail is to threaten to do something otherwise legal (usually divulge information) with the intent of forcing someone to perform a certain action that they would otherwise not want to perform
For instance, you can threaten to spill the beans on a perfectly benign secret about your coworker unless they pass on a great promotion they were given and that you coveted
- cortic 8y agoThat muddies the water a bit; my boss threatened to fire me if i didn't do my job is blackmail under your definition.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> That muddies the water a bit; my boss threatened to fire me if i didn't do my job is blackmail under your definition. “I threatened to quit my job unless paid more,” fits either definition, so the problem isn't just with the revision.
- jerf 8y agoI think you'd need a concept of licit and illicit threats worked in to make it work, which may be unavoidable. For example, in general, obligations legal under modern contract law would be licit. (If you counter with "what if $SPECIFIC_THING?", I'd say "you missed the 'in general'". I'm going to spare us twenty paragraphs trying to nail that down, and I suggest you run with me on that, I mean, unless you're just dying to read that....) Otherwise you end up with "if you don't make your corn flakes tastier than your competition I'm going to buy theirs" and that's clearly not what we're going for here. The problem lies in the specific conditions being laid down, not the mere conditionalization of my actions on yours. I mean, if you really think about it, it's not even clear what it would mean to try to ban conditionalizing your actions on the actions of others.
- airstrike 8y agoNo, because doing their job is something they ostensibly said they wanted to do when they took the job
- cortic 8y agoJust because you wanted to do something in the past, doesn't remove your right to change you mind, that's taking woman's rights back to the 'no rape law within the holy sacrament of marriage' days.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- MR4D 8y ago"I'm going to quit unless you pay me more." Why doesn't that meet your definition? I'm threatening to do something legal (quit) unless you do something you don't want to (pay more money). I'm confused.
- airstrike 8y agoRelationships between employees and employers are uneven by definition, so threatening to quit isn't really forcing your boss to pay you more.
- cortesoft 8y agoThreatening to reveal information is not really forcing someone to pay, either.
- airstrike 8y agoIt's exploiting their vulnerable state so that they feel they have no choice but to comply. There's an element of coercion. Clearly different from an employment relationship. You can't really coerce your boss.
- ghaff 8y agoPractically, mostly true. Certainly one can construct scenarios where an employer has let too much depend on a single employee. Pay me $1m or I quit and you won’t be able to ship this product on which the company depends for survival.
- virgilp 8y agoWhat's wrong with the Wikipedia definition? > Blackmail is an act of coercion using the threat of revealing or publicizing either substantially true or false, and often damaging, information about a person, to the public, family members, or associates unless certain demands are met. It may involve using threats of physical, mental or emotional harm, or of criminal prosecution, against the victim or someone close to the victim
- gnode 8y agoI think an improved definition may be: coercing someone using the threat of the revelation of a secret to a third party, where there is no requirement the secret not be known by any fourth party. It's not relevant whether the act is otherwise illegal; someone may commit blackmail additionally to another crime. There's also no need to be paid; you could blackmail someone to not perform their job, or to not compete with you, for instance.
- SkyBelow 8y agoSo at what point is breaking up unless your SO changes something about themselves become blackmail, because it seems to fit the second definition (and perhaps the first depending upon economic philosophy).