8 ms·
That anybody'd even think to block a website on such grounds is worrying. That it actually happened is alarming.
by snvzz 8y ago
That anybody'd even think to block a website on such grounds is worrying.
That it actually happened is alarming.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 8y ago4chan and 8chan have been linked to almost all of the white nationalist and incel shooters of the past decade. At some point, you need to recognize that what's happening on those boards isn't "free speech", it's "incitement" to commit violent acts, and that has never been protected by any of the free speech regimes, even in the U.S. New Zealand's free speech rights are not as broad or strong as they are in the US. I wouldn't be surprised if 4chan and 8chan find themselves blocked across most of the globe by the end of the year.
- gridlockd 8y ago> 4chan and 8chan have been linked to almost all of the white nationalist and incel shooters of the past decade. You can say the same about Twitter and Facebook. In fact, the guy had a Twitter where he posted guns and ammunition with slogans on it, days earlier. Had it received more attention, this could've possibly been prevented. > At some point, you need to recognize that what's happening on those boards isn't "free speech", it's "incitement" to commit violent acts, and that has never been protected by any of the free speech regimes, even in the U.S. New Zealand's free speech rights are not as broad or strong as they are in the US. It's a bunch of anonymous people posting crap, often for shock value. Sure, there's incitement on there, but nobody takes anybody serious. Having said that, I was pretty shocked about the reaction on 8chan. I haven't been there before. It's pretty sad to see.
- growlist 8y ago> I was pretty shocked about the reaction on 8chan. I haven't been there before. It's pretty sad to see. You have no idea who is posting there, or why, and yet you take the posts at face value? Interesting.
- gridlockd 8y agoWho says I take it at face value? Even if it was 100% non-serious shitposting, it would be sad. I guess you're implying though that there's some sort of elaborate false-flag operation going on there?
- faissaloo 8y ago>It's a bunch of anonymous people posting crap, often for shock value. Sure, there's incitement on there, but nobody takes anybody serious. As someone who frequents 8chan, I can tell you this categorically is not the case and /pol/acks are very serious.
- gridlockd 8y ago"Being serious" about their own beliefs is different from taking another anonymous poster serious. On there you have literal Nazis, MAGA people and white identitarians all disagreeing and trolling each other. They can't even agree on everything being a Jewish conspiracy.
- faissaloo 8y agoThey don't have to agree on every point to be a danger.
- gridlockd 8y agoThat's besides the point. Individually, they don't have to agree on anything and still pose a danger. What you can't say is that this is some sort of organization that poses a threat as such. It is a bunch of random people on the internet that do not know each other and that vaguely share certain beliefs.
- faissaloo 8y agoThey share those beliefs because they gave each other those beliefs, they didn't come out of nowhere. People go into /pol/ having some unconventional views on immigration and come out full blown fascists. There's no need for some 'evil organisation' like you're imagining.
- snvzz 8y agoIt's more like, fascists and such come to /pol/ to post their garbage, and meet well-spoken anons that oppose their views and expose the flaws of their arguments. This is an obvious advantage to all of this happening in the open, over it happening in some members-only curated hate forum where any voice of reason is just removed and banned. I'm baffled with how irrational some people can get, irresponsibly calling for the suppression of public, anonymous image boards.
- gamblor956 8y agoYou can say the same about Twitter and Facebook. In fact, the guy had a Twitter where he posted guns and ammunition with slogans on it, days earlier. Had it received more attention, this could've possibly been prevented. That's not true, and it's notable that you had to create a new account just to make this FUD claim. Those murderers may all have used Twitter and Facebook to try to disseminate their idea vomit, but they were radicalized and incited by 4chan and/or 8chan. Also, Twitter and Facebook make the effort to remove those posts once they are made aware of them. 4chan and 8chan revel in keeping up those promote, and even promote them to show just how "free speech" they are. It's a bunch of anonymous people posting crap, often for shock value. Sure, there's incitement on there, but nobody takes anybody serious. More than a dozen mass murderers in the past few years took 4chan and 8chan seriously enough to murder hundreds of people. Mass murder might be an abstract concept to basement dwellers, but I know people who were shot at in the Santa Barbara, Vegas, and Thousand Oaks shooting, and it sure as fuck isn't an abstract concept to me or the thousands of other people who knew the victims of those shootings.
- setquk 8y agoI've heard the same horrific shit in casual conversation in numerous pubs in the UK in the last 30 years and the people in there certainly don't know what 4chan or 8chan are. In fact the horrible things pre-dated the proliferation of internet connectivity. This isn't a specific platform problem but a problem with a subset of humanity.
- gamblor956 8y agoThat's true. But people engaging in "casual" conversation over beer aren't inciting each other to commit violent acts of hate. But in those rare instances where a bar crosses over into openly supporting that type of speech, the police start taking an interest and monitoring that bar and its customers. And if a line gets crossed with respect to incitement, conspiracy, etc., the local municipality will usually pull the bar's liquor license and get it shut down to prevent future such crimes from being organized or incited at that bar. So, really, you're actually quite spot on with the bar analogy. 4chan/8chan are exactly like a skinhead bar that's getting shutdown because the customers kept inciting each other to kill people and actually followed through.
- tuxxy 8y ago> It's a bunch of anonymous people posting crap, often for shock value. Sure, there's incitement on there, but nobody takes anybody serious. No. It used to be like this. Maybe in the mid-2000s when 4chan was first getting popular, it could have been seen as this. It might have been seen like this during the early 2010s, does anyone remember Anonymous and how it started basically from /b/? It used to be a troll site -- it's not anymore. It's literally a cesspool of white supremacy. Seriously, go read what's on /pol/ right now. It's not shock value, it's sympathy.
- def_true_false 8y ago4chan is not just /pol/.
- Konnstann 8y ago/pol/ is literally the containment board for serious fascism/racist/etc. 99% of the rest of the boards is porn, legitimate conversation (for the sfw boards) or shitposting from both sides of the political spectrum
- krapp 8y agoThere's no such thing as a "containment board." Nothing and no one is actually being contained, and the culture from popular boards (which /pol/ is) bleeds out to the others all the time.
- snvzz 8y ago>fascism/racist/etc. Do get argued against in /pol/ all the time. It literally acts as a safeguard against these twisted beliefs. If it doesn't happen in 4chan, then I'm worried. Because these fascists/racists/etc. might end up in a members-only, non-public-viewable fascist/racist/etc echo chamber, with not a trace of voices of reason.
- kthejoker2 8y agoAdvocacy for violent action is absolutely protected in America, see Brandenberg v Ohio. It's only not protected if it's likely to cause "imminent" action eg yelling fire in a theater.
- kolbe 8y agoBlaming an entire community for individual actions is dangerous. Sometimes it is called for, but first I'd like to see a real honest analysis about why these communities are responsible for a significantly greater number of homicides that do not happen in other acceptable communities.
- odessacubbage 8y agohigher rates of serious mental illnesses among the userbase. anon sites are highly appealing to people on the autistic spectrum in particular for a variety of reasons, i think that the concept of autistic burnout that was outlined in this post >https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19311970 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19311970 could have a lot to do with that. but also the posting style itself is attractive to fringe personalities of all sorts. there is no cumulative reward to anything you post, you don't get karma or followers; you maybe get a few laughs or are called a retard but that's it. on the flipside, there's also virtually no disincentive since short of breaking the law, nothing you say really matters. i personally find it much easier to have positive interactions on anon sites and have made many good friends that way. however, possibly due to the high rates of comorbidity among asd individuals (depressive and anxiety disorders are the rule rather that the exception) you end up with a lot of people with varying degrees of instability and, anecdotally, a not insignificant number of people with more serious conditions like schizophrenia. iirc, both james harper mercer and elliot roger were asd; they were also both fucking losers but that goes without saying i believe that imageboards are highly valuable and that the problems that can be seen within them are reflective of greater societal issues that we refuse to acknowledge.
- RankingMember 8y agoThe problem with the seemingly obvious solution of blocking sites like 4chan is that the people with these hateful sentiments don't cease to exist when their gathering place gets blocked- they just move to another outlet. Does it make sense to engage in an endless game of whack-a-mole when you could, rather, recognize the intelligence value in what is essentially a honeypot?
- ozzyman700 8y agoI have used 4chan almost every day since 7th grade, it is an anime imageposting forum with related hobby boards. Without it, I would not be nearly as interested in OSS development or RMS' contributions to GNU+LINUX. There are boards which tend towards topics you may consider "incitement to commit violent acts" but this is a function of a website allowing user content. HN or Reddit or any other popular website could have been used for this announcement just the same. Removing a website will not remove the people who use it, they will find other places.
- StanislavPetrov 8y agoIts absolutely free speech and is the bedrock of a free society.
- seem_2211 8y agoShutting down a largely toxic website that fuels the flames of extremism is an order of magnitude less alarming than 50+ people losing their lives. I don't really see much value lost in taking 4chan down, just like it's not a big deal if Stormfront or an Isis affiliated site was blocked. Freedom of speech doesn't mean you get to do whatever you want, with no threat of consequences.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- freehunter 8y agoIn addition, New Zealand does not have have a blanket freedom of speech guarantee. In fact their laws specifically say speech can be suppressed to protect public safety.
- NikkiA 8y agoIs it even freedom of speech? The users aren't being banned, they're free to go elsewhere like twitter and take their lumps with their precious hate speech.
- insickness 8y agoThat's like saying that the government can ban a newspaper because, after all, people can just read another newspaper.
- reallydude 8y agoWell, there are an infinite number of newspapers via the internet, so that's a valid comparison. It's not a slippery slope, when the infrastructure to deliver a message is not affected.
- icebraining 8y agoIf it has no effect on speech, what's the point of banning it?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 6djeks 8y agoPeople here agree with blocking 4chan (a very diverse community, full of all kinds of people), but then they think the UK blocking ISIS propaganda websites is abhorrent censorship.
- faissaloo 8y agoHave you considered that perhaps people's opinions are just changing?
- 6djeks 8y agoI don't, since there have been several acts of Islamic terrorism in Europe these last years and they weren't enough to change anybody's opinion. I don't believe this particular case is enough to make people support censorship on the Internet. To me, this is simply hypocrisy.
- faissaloo 8y agoSure, but none of them were directly related to the internal political climate in the West.
- seszett 8y ago> there have been several acts of Islamic terrorism in Europe these last years and they weren't enough to change anybody's opinion I'm not sure where you got this idea from, but it's wrong.
- mastax 8y agoHave you considered that it could be different people posting those different opinions?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- quantummkv 8y agoIt's not surprising really. In times like these the governments have to be seen do something least they get crucified on twitter by peace loving people for things beyond their control. Since the governments can't really do anything else in the real world, they take to banning sites with edgy reputations. The fact that banning 4chan won't solve anything isn't lost on anyone with a working mind, especially not the government. But hey, that's how they stop the violent peace protests and not loose the next election in advance. Everyone wins here. The terrorists win, the government gets popularity, the peace loving people get internet brownie points and moral satisfaction to overcome their insomnia till the next time, the media gets their clicks and ad revenue and the people on 4chan get their kicks.
- icebraining 8y agoOthers have pointed out that the government doesn't seem to have banned anything.
- lostlogin 8y agoSome people’s first knowledge of the attack was that link being sent to them. I’m not sure what to think of the block (I don’t seem to have been blocked) but wanting to preventing the videos spread seems reasonable. I think it’s too late now though. Edit: I am blocked from some sites.
- Razengan 8y agoYes, banning websites, instead of weapons... Snuffing the Medium will not remove the Cause nor the Means.
- icebraining 8y agoNZ does strictly regulate weapons.