4 ms·
AFAIK this is a draft for a new police law in North-Rhein Westfalia (NRW), so it would affect “only” that province. NRW was also the province that made the draf
by atoav 8y ago
AFAIK this is a draft for a new police law in North-Rhein Westfalia (NRW), so it would affect “only” that province. NRW was also the province that made the draft for the infamous new police law.
The article says the draft is beeing discussed in the Bundesrat. The draft is mainly targeted on dark net market places, but its formulation is broad enough that one could argue TOR exit nodes could be affected by it (its forbids platforms that enable criminal behaviour, which is arguably nearly everything if you squint your eyes the right way).
German privacy activists are mainly suspicous here because there is no real reason for the draft to exist. Running illegal black market sites is already illegal under german law, because the stuff you sell there is illegal — it doesn’t matter if you do it online.
Why such a law then?
- e12e 8y ago> Why such a law then? Fight "herd anonymity" provided by a large tor network? Ironically(?) that'd make the original purpose for Tor (covert channel for covert operatives) less viable too. Broad, redundant overreaching legislation with ample room for "discretionary" enforcement seems a prime way to enable tyranny in a country otherwise democratic/ruled by a normal three-way powersplit (executive, legislative and judicial branches).
- tgragnato 8y agoNational powers want to filter the contents circulating on the net, but the application of the rules is subject to the limitations of enforcement capabilities. And I'm not only thinking to espionage, terrorism, money laundering and child porn, but to article 13 and copyright violations too. The government would like to push for overly broad regulations, but they realise that the application of such creates incentives to adopt and democratise radical technologies. Platform operators who do not want to comply with the regulations can move them beyond national / European borders, or use darknets and decentralization to resist the capacity of police forces. Response: "Let's ban the darknet"
- kbwt 8y agoNo, this law was proposed by NRW and Hessen, but if passed it would affect all of Germany.