8 ms·
Formula 1: The secret aerodynamicist reveals design concepts
- JakDrako 8y agoSome say that he can make a brick fly using only a banana and a pair of socks and that he's been known to reverse the wind; all we know is he's called the Secret Aerodynamicist.
- shriphani 8y agoI really miss the Stig segments in the (now) old top gear with clarkson, may and hammond. Really unfortunate what happened to that show - it kept me going through some ugly periods in life.
- lozaning 8y agoThe Grand Tour is 95% the same show. In many ways I actually prefer it to Top Gear.
- usaphp 8y agoI honestly don’t like it, they are trying too hard to make it funny and while in top gear I sometimes wondered if the joke is scripted or a natural one, in grand tour I feel like every joke is scripted, and most of them are quite poor. Also they don’t spend as much time reviewing cars as they did in top gear, which I liked
- dnbgfher 8y agoI felt that the second season greatly improved from the first. I'd say the studio segments were still pretty subpar compared to the Top Gear days, but they seemed to get a better handle on the rest of it. I haven't watched the latest season yet, but hopefully they managed to improve again. If you gave up after the first season, you might want to give the later ones a shot. Though I have to admit I never cared too much about the reviews, so that's worth keeping in mind.
- shriphani 8y agos3 is really good - the car reviews are back, the panoramic views and cinematic genius of top gear is back.
- black-tea 8y agoReally? I honestly can't remember the last time I didn't think every single utterance in Top Gear was scripted. I can't remember the last time they reviewed a car either. Are you not thinking of Top Gear of 20 years ago?
- mhh__ 8y agoThe classic series of top gear (mid 2000s) are brilliant, organic and only scripted in terms of set pieces (No dialogue)
- TylerE 8y agoIt’s so not. It’s conpletely missing what made the early seasons of new Top Gear so magical at times. Now it is just typical 100% staged reality TV bullshit.
- kayoone 8y agoIt is not really all that different from the later Top Gear Seasons though.
- chrisan 8y ago> Now it is just typical 100% staged reality TV bullshit. Don't you feel they are mocking staged reality?
- ablation 8y agoHaving worked briefly on a unit attached to the show, huge amounts of Top Gear during the Clarkson era were also "staged". (I'm assuming by that you mean scripted).
- TylerE 8y agoOh, I'm not saying that it wasn't, but in the early Clarkson years it was....less flagrant.. and the show was mostly (obviously scripted) studio segments. I have nothing against scripted television, I just don't like it when they pretend they're on some grand adventure when in reality everything was probably planned shot for shot in advance. Everything became "oh, look how witty and clever and snarky we are" rather than humor developing organically.
- ablation 8y ago> Everything became "oh, look how witty and clever and snarky we are" rather than humor developing organically. Yes, agreed.
- mhh__ 8y agoThe script sounds like it was written by an AI trained on a combination of old top gear and an American dictionary (i.e. why is Clarkson giving temperatures in Fahrenheit when he used to shun all things American etc.)
- ggm 8y agoThe dynamic between the three of them is good but (and the ev supporters and musk drive me crazy too) what Clarkson did with Tesla was fundamentally dishonest. As was the Argentina thing. So.. clever and funny but also a bit suss. The cool wall is every pub conversation ever.
- flurdy 8y agoDespite popular opinion, I like the new Top Gear (once they got rid of Chris Evans). The last two series with Matt LeBlanc was really good. Will reserve judgement on the new-new line up with McGuinness and Flintoff [1]. McGuinness used to be funny, and Flintoff's podcast [2] is/was brilliant. * [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-45937945 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-45937945 * [2] https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08fr7t1/episodes/downloads https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b08fr7t1/episodes/downloads | https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/flintoff-savage-and-the-ping-pong-guy/id1201798262 https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/flintoff-savage-and-the-...
- mhh__ 8y agoChris Harris is a legend. The segments of him racing would've been impossible with the old lot
- ablation 8y agoI've worked a lot with Chris Harris on various projects with car manufacturers. He is indeed a very nice man, with a great sense of humour, and hasn't let his slightly bumpy road to televisual semi-stardom change him.
- na85 8y agoThe article makes it seem like all teams add more rear downforce as the season progresses. I don't follow F1 - is this true about the increasing downforce and if so, why is that so? Is it simply that the drivers get more comfortable pushing the limits?
- clouddrover 8y ago> is this true about the increasing downforce and if so, why is that so? The regulations have changed this year so the teams can't use the same aerodynamic designs they had last year. The idea of the new aero regulations is that they will promote overtaking, but it also means the cars will lose downforce: https://www.formula1.com/en/latest/article.aero-changes-to-promote-overtaking-approved-for-2019.153os6PCPsI0SaQSsE0cQ6.html https://www.formula1.com/en/latest/article.aero-changes-to-p... https://www.motorsportweek.com/news/id/20555 https://www.motorsportweek.com/news/id/20555 They'll regain some (and maybe even all) of the lost downforce through new aero approaches that are allowed under the new regulations. The designs will be developed and refined as the season progresses.
- CaliforniaKarl 8y agoI’m by no means an expert—or even an expert amateur—but I’ll try until someone with more knowledge comes in! All of the technical regulations are set in advance of the season (this year’s is https://www.fia.com/file/78015/download/26184 https://www.fia.com/file/78015/download/26184). The teams are only allowed to test their cars during a fixed number of “test days”, so they do a _ton_ of simulation pretty much all the time (https://arstechnica.com/cars/2017/04/formula-1-technology/ https://arstechnica.com/cars/2017/04/formula-1-technology/). The chassis (the tub that the driver & engine sit in) doesn’t change much over a season, so the time will be occupied by the team finding ways to move and re-shape things like front and rear wings, so as to increase downforce. Downforce is king because it allows you to make sharper turns at higher speed without understeeting (where the front refuses to turn) or oversteering (where the back refuses to stop turning). And the technical regulations are really finicky about many areas of the car. And in many ways, the three “free practice” sessions before qualifying are as much about in-season development as they are about getting used to the track. Yes, as drivers get time in the real car, they begin to understand where they can push. But also the engineers are seeing how the car is responding during real-world conditions, to feed that into the simulation.
- djpilot 8y agoWhat about the underside of the vehicle? I remember hearing it was a super big tightly guarded secret. Was that ever true? Is it still?
- JshWright 8y agoThere isn't that much teams can do on the underside of the car. A lot of effort goes into preventing air from "leaking" under the car in the first place. While you don't see the underside of the car much (for obvious reasons), the occasional roll-over crash (or crane lift after a 'regular' crash) gives us a glimpse from time to time. Check out Nico Hulkenberg's crash at Abu Dhabi pay year for a good example.
- RaceWon 8y ago>What about the underside of the vehicle? A very astute question. Yes, as much effort goes into the design of the underside as does the shiny side. The most recent article I found via a quick G search is from 2013. For sure the rules have changed since then, but it's still a fair benchmark to illustrate the complexity of overall design with regards to the aero. "https://www.roadandtrack.com/motorsports/news/a18417/the-secret-underside-of-a-modern-f1-car/" https://www.roadandtrack.com/motorsports/news/a18417/the-sec...
- mhh__ 8y agoMore effort probably, most of the downforce is from the floor AFAIK
- zandor 8y agoChain Bear F1 on YouTube has great video from an incident last season which helps explain the floor setup. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUC2gDPiHEc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rUC2gDPiHEc
- ajayh 8y agoFloors in F1 have been flat for a while with the exception of the FIA mandated plank down the middle. The rear diffuser is sometimes blocked from cameras when the car is parked. For example 2009 with the double diffuser.
- JshWright 8y agoWe're just a few hours away from qualifying at the Australian GP, so we'll know soon enough which approach is working better (at the moment they look _really_ close)
- mukwenhac 8y agoSo it turns out Mercedes were sand bagging in testing, as usual. Beat Ferrari by 7 tenths of a second! Anyways, that's the same gap as last year's race, interestingly it turned out Ferrari had a car cappable to win the championship. https://www.formula1.com/en/results.html/2018/races/979/australia/qualifying.html https://www.formula1.com/en/results.html/2018/races/979/aust... - 2018 Aus GP Quali result https://www.formula1.com/en/results.html/2019/races/1000/australia.html https://www.formula1.com/en/results.html/2019/races/1000/aus... - 2019 Aus GP Quali result
- manojlds 8y agoBut Ferrari fixed their floor for the next race which made the car much stronger. They don't seem to have any "problems" right now so may not be able to catchup like last year.
- LandR 8y agoI think it's going to be another season of Mercedes dominating. As a Ferrari fan this makes me sad.
- JshWright 8y agoI was _really_ hoping for Seb to win this year. It would have set up Lewis and Seb both going for their sixth driver's championship in the last season before the upcoming rule change...
- DVassallo 8y agoF1 is the best form of technology applied to a sport. If you like impressive machinery take a look at Lewis Hamilton hitting 5 to 6.5 Gs multiple times in an 82.188 second lap at the Australian GP in 2017: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zJRh9FG83d0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zJRh9FG83d0 That s-curve at turn 11 starting at the ~53 sec mark (video above) with 6.5 lateral G-force is taken at 300km/h, down to 250 at the apex. This is the same lap with the speedometer instead of g-force meter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mtjC9DozXs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mtjC9DozXs (turn 11 at the ~59 sec mark)
- james_s_tayler 8y agoI almost feel stupid but I never realized they take the corners THAT fast. Holy shit. Respect. That's insane.
- RaceWon 8y ago>I almost feel stupid but I never realized they take the corners THAT fast. Holy shit. Respect. That's insane. The camera angles Rarely do the cars justice in protraying their speed (though its gotten better). There's a great vid on HN with a Porsche 919 sportscar at the Nurbugring that portays the quick factor fairly realistically (you can quibble about the various diffrences between a Sportscar and an F1 car in terms of capabilities--both are other worldy quick, and fast). I like to post that vid when talk here turns to self-driving cars, but I digress; F1 pilots are simply amazing. The cars are too. "https://youtu.be/PQmSUHhP3ug" https://youtu.be/PQmSUHhP3ug"
- Ntrails 8y agoOld top gear put a formula something car on the test track, and it was insane how the car moved compared to everything else i'd seen travelling "fast" on the same camera angles.
- felipelemos 8y agoYou need to remove the leading double quotes because it's being carried when clicked on mobile, and leading to a 404 on YouTube.
- raiyu 8y agoInteresting to watch qualifying. The Mercedes was definitely more of a handful so it looks like it has more corner entry over steer which will make the car pivot around the Apex and allow for sooner throttle application. The Ferrari was more composed but on turn 14 Vettel struggled to get the car to the Apex perhaps showing signs of under steer. Less rotation, harder to get the power down, and more likely to destroy the front tires if you keep pushing too hard. The Mercedes also looked to not enjoy bumps or curbs as much but as bouncy as it was it was still planted. And though Hamilton had to do more counter steering inputs than we are used to in formula 1 he was still quickest in qualifying and the oversteer looked like it was completely manageable and just the right amount. Probably around 15%-20% which is easy to control and quite fun to drive. Reading the article it seems like the analysis is spot on. Not enough front grip because of the front wrong on the Ferrari which led to a tendency to perhaps under steer. What looked promising in testing was obviously Mercedes just not showing their full hand. Still different tracks will suit different cars so will see how the first 3-4 races play out before giving the championship to Mercedes. Last year Ferrari was leading just about till the summer break and there were a couple of costly unforced errors from vettel that really cost him dearly.
- exDM69 8y agoCurious fact about F1 aerodynamics: the regulations limit the computing power of the CFD clusters they use. The limit is about 30 teraflops but the teams can trade off less teraflops to more wind tunnel time. As someone working with semiconductors, I think the limit should be watts instead of flops to encourage competition in this aspect too.
- dest 8y agoWow, how can you enforce a limit on simulation time? Can't they use a secret cloud somewhere?
- exDM69 8y agoAfaik they need to provide logs. Of course they could cheat but the penalties of getting caught are severe. The limit isn't very high, though. A single box with a few GPUs is enough to hit the limit.
- kingkongjaffa 8y agofyi most cfd software is not using GPU, current cfd clusters are traditional cpu solving systems. also 30 teraflops of RANS simulations is a lot. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reynolds-averaged_Navier%E2%80%93Stokes_equations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reynolds-averaged_Navier%E2%80... basic cfd with turbulence modelling can get you pretty close and then refine in wind tunnels. the other techniques are LES https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_eddy_simulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_eddy_simulation genetic algorithms and iterative optimization is leading to more organic and nature inspired shapes in the latest generations.
- mhh__ 8y agoThey could, but they get audited a lot. The fines for cheating (unless you are Ferrari, usually) are catastrophic (for a non-works team): Lots of money and probable disqualification from the WCC
- syntaxing 8y ago
- lordnacho 8y agoI always wondered about the downforce. If one design is few % better than another, providing the key advantage, does that mean the drivers are able to drive so exactly that they can use the extra force without spinning out? Is there some sort of feedback when you're really close? I've only had a couple of track days, never came close to understanding it.
- yakshaving_jgt 8y agoI’ve never driven a single-seater, but to some degree it’s intuition, and to another it’s just getting to know the limits through practice. I think Gasly spinning in FP2 while trying to find the limit is an example of that. You’ll be familiar with the twitching feeling when traction starts to give. I don’t know if they have any on-board telemetry to measure this.
- ezconnect 8y agoYes it's a big advantage specially on fast corners (where you don't lift or hit the brakes to take it). You can maintain or increase your speed if you have more downforce than your competitor.
- joncrane 8y agoThere's an old saying for drivers (and it's usually trotted out when your favorite driver has had an off) that goes "In order to know where the limit is, one must occasionally cross it." Usually drivers are going to test that limit in an area with less risk, for example a corner with lots of paved runoff. But small factors such as the ambient wind changing direction, or the sun coming out or going behind a cloud, can affect grip enough that the limit changes enough to catch a driver out. In these cases there's usually warning, that the car very slightly stops responding as exactly to your inputs as it was the lap before. However the most common scenario for a single car shunt is when the driver is testing the track limits; for example riding 3 inches of his tire over the kerb instead of 2, or using up the edge of the track to where the tire is now on a painted line rather than bare asphalt. In these cases there is often no warning, the car just steps out.
- ilovepeppapig 8y ago