8 ms·
The failure of Google Fiber paints a very bleak picture of the future of internet infrastructure, or even all communication in this country. If Google cannot co
by paxys 8y ago
The failure of Google Fiber paints a very bleak picture of the future of internet infrastructure, or even all communication in this country. If Google cannot compete with the status quo, who can?
- bovermyer 8y agoThat's not the lesson I'd learn here. This seems like Google has not yet learned how civil engineering works, which is a crucial component in internet infrastructure. It's unfortunate that Louisville is getting bit hard here.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- smueller1234 8y agoI would also point to the engineering required to build and operate some of the world's largest datacenter and wan infrastructure.
- halbritt 8y agoThey don't build the WAN infrastructure, nor is building data centers an exercise in civil engineering. Typically, data centers are located where the least amount of civil engineering is required.
- smueller1234 8y agoGoogle don't? Not exclusively, but well: https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/google-builds-its-own-subsea-cable-from-the-us-to-france/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/07/17/google-builds-its-own-subs...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoThe lesson is never trust in the longevity of Google products, a lesson they keep teaching us over and over.
- otachack 8y agoThe government, if it wasn't being run by puppets.
- nikofeyn 8y agothat is very worrying, but i also wonder how hard google tried. they don't have a very good track record for building and maintaining products outside of their main product space (ads and selling data).
- geodel 8y agoMunicipalities. They are world class experts in running broadband infrastructure if only evil ISPs let them.
- wincy 8y agoCertainly. It took TWO YEARS of negotiating with Louisville before Google could start construction. If the municipalities do it themselves, there’s no small time politicians hands to grease, and the city can start construction immediately.
- ryanhuff 8y agoIf the municipalities build the infrastructure and bid out the service in renewable contracts, seems like the politicians would get theirs every 3-5 years.
- vb6lives 8y agoThey tried to lay fiber in 2in trenches instead of typical 6in trenches. Then left when it didn't work. This isn't Goliath beating David. This is David throwing a rock, missing, and going home.
- wincy 8y agoI’m not sure David and Goliath is an apt metaphor when Google has a market cap 4x that of a broadband competitor Comcast.
- Someone1234 8y agoMarket cap is only relevant if both companies had a singular focus. Google isn't investing heavily into Google Fiber, and certainly not compared to Comcast.
- sodosopa 8y agoDavid vs Satan is more apt
- quest88 8y agoIs there any particular two inch trenches were dug? Was it too expensive? Extra permits?
- teachrdan 8y agoIf I understand your question correctly, they used 2" trenches because shallower === faster. However, they were so shallow--and the surfacing material so brittle--that the fibers ended up getting damaged too often. So they corrected with slightly deeper trenches afterwards.
- vb6lives 8y agoShallower === cheaper
- 8y ago
- duxup 8y agoAny chance some form of wireless can increase competition?
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoThe "wireless competing with broadband" thing is mostly ISPs trying to claim that the two services compete with each other in order to claim that they have more competitors than they do. Wireless is slower, has higher latency, is less reliable (interference/obstructions), etc. But you can put in one tower and service every customer for miles under those conditions, which is much cheaper than wiring every building. It's possible to address those problems with wireless, but the way to do it makes the wireless network look like the wired one. Instead of one tower serving many people, you have very many towers each serving a small number of people. But then the cost benefit evaporates. You need a tower on every street corner which has to be wired with fiber. At that point you might as well just hook the existing phone or cable wires already going into everyone's houses into that box on the end of the street in order to get the last few meters, and save yourself a few billion dollars in wireless spectrum.
- subway 8y agoWireless is slower, has higher latency, is less reliable This all varies based on the wireless tech used. My apartment in Seattle is serviced via point to point wireless with another building across the neighborhood. Currently I see under 2ms RTT to google.com, and can max out the 100mbit port on my router both up and down. (Gigabit is available, but requires an account with WaveG. 100mbit is free with my rent, and on the landlord's account). Aside from a misconfiguration on my building's switch that allowed a neighbor to act as a rogue dhcp server, I've yet to see an outage in the two years of living here. Wireless doesn't have to suck.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoYou're describing the thing that requires you to have many towers each serving a small number of users. Moreover, the reliability you get has a lot to do with what happens in your neighborhood. Point to point wireless is great until somebody builds a new building in the path between you and the other wireless device.
- DanHulton 8y agoI mean, this is almost exactly the kind of massive public project that the government is there for.
- notJim 8y agoI agree with this, and I think the general slogan of "broadband for all" could be a winning one for a politician (though they have to actually deliver.) My parents live in a rural area and the fastest internet they can get can barely stream Netflix on a good day, and only as long as no one else is using it. Many people have it much worse. Access to high-quality broadband seems like an issue that could span the rural/urban divide.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoThis isn't likely to span the divide, when you consider that urban folks probably won't like having to pay drastically higher taxes to cover not their cheap connection, but to cover the hundred thousand dollar project to trench fiber out to one dude's cabin fifty miles from civilization. And then to do that over and over for every isolated place in the country. There's a reason rural Internet sucks: It's expensive to build and unprofitable to operate. That's why ISPs don't want to build them out.
- linuxftw 8y agoWhat about roads? What about electricity? Why should rural people have those when it adds extra tax burden to those in the city? What about the postal service?
- dodobirdlord 8y agoIn all seriousness, why should they? There are obvious diminishing returns and there's a point where the distances get large enough and the number of people gets small enough that it's unjustifiable. Opportunity costs exist, and it follows that advocating for money to be spent inefficiently is bad.
- MiddleEndian 8y agoI live in Boston, where Google had a service called WebPass which was fiber with radio dishes for the last mile. They eventually gave up on our market, but two other radio fiber ISPs exist$. So Google isn't the necessarily the best competitor in that market. $ Due to a wacky series of misunderstandings, both of these ISPs service my building now that Webpass is gone. They periodically send out sales reps who bring snacks and wine.
- OldHand2018 8y agoThere was an existing company called WebPass that Google bought. As far as I can tell, they got rid of all the local sales and support in the dozens of cities they operated in (presumably to fold all that into their existing Google Fiber org). It was a total failure.
- MiddleEndian 8y agoAah that is a shame. They're clearly not equipped to handle anything that requires human support.
- newnewpdro 8y agoAt this point it's more noteworthy for Google to not abandon any project. This is indicative of nothing more than Google behaving consistently.
- tptacek 8y agoThe current telecom providers, who compete with each other? If you compare similarly dense areas in the US and Europe, we're doing pretty well on high-speed Internet access. I have multiple gigabit options in Chicago, and only got them in the last couple years. What's not working?
- kasey_junk 8y agoIt’s rare in Chicago to have multiple fiber options and lots of the city has none. I don’t necessarily disagree with your point but your experience may be on the rare side.
- OldHand2018 8y agoYou may not have multiple fiber options all over the city, but its really common to have at least 2 high speed options. Chicago doesn't have a cable or telephone monopoly, so you've always had the option of Comcast or RCN and AT&T or Verizon. They all offer internet these days. All the railroad right of ways are loaded with fiber, the freight tunnels are loaded with fiber, etc. If you are downtown, you can add the half dozen or so fully competent local ISPs. These companies sell internet to condo associations; every unit gets a dedicated connection and the common areas get shared wifi. The cost gets added to the monthly assessment. Where I live it's $25 per month for 500 meg symmetrical. I work in a 1920s skyscraper in the Loop. Cogent stops by at least once a year and puts coffee and (expensive) donuts in the lobby. They'll run fiber directly from their backbone to a server rack on whatever floor your office is on.
- kasey_junk 8y agoI can get gig speed from xfinity. That’s it. When I lived 10 blocks south I had zero options. At that location 16mb dsl was the best choice. Railroad right of ways are largely immaterial to last mile home seevice.
- jcims 8y agoI don't know that Google is well positioned to offer this type of service. Operationally their customers are homogenized through the interfaces that their bread-and-butter services offer. This is not possible with a last-mile ISP. There is, relatively speaking, a lot of overhead per-customer and they simply have very little experience operating in that way.
- jrockway 8y agoGoogle gave up on fiber and this is the version that is running on fumes. I worked on Google Fiber until early 2017. I was informed that it was cancelled and that I had to find another team. I did, and didn't like the new team, so I quit. Many of my coworkers on Fiber did the same. Of the people I've remained in contact with, exactly zero of them currently work on Fiber. I now work at a different fiber ISP. The industry is fine, it's just that Google sort of gave up. Even if they went full-on "we changed our mind" after I left, it's not the original team anymore. A lot of knowledge has disappeared into the void. You hear "invest in teams, not in products," around here a lot. That's not what Google did.
- walrus01 8y agoIndustry perspective here. I work for an ISP that does gigabit class last mile residential access. Google gave up because they couldn't make the ROI numbers work. I doubt whether it was ever intended to be economically viable. It was a PR stunt. You simply can't promise gigabit class last mile service to every residence in a city, and actually build it with a reasonable dollar-per-house cost, and make a return on investment on it. Not unless you have an incredibly low cost to deploy it, basically a city and local electrical utility that has handed you ROW (right-of-way) on a silver platter. Or unless you are already the incumbent telecom operator, and have ROW literally everywhere, and can overbuild your POTS network with modern GPON stuff, as Centurylink is doing in parts of Seattle. Or unless you bring the dollars-per-unit cost way down, by focusing on MDU (multiple dwelling unit) such as WaveG and Webpass have done. It costs a lot less to light up an 85 suite condo building with 1000BaseT to each suite, than it does to build last mile GPON or active ethernet fiber to 85 individual houses.
- jrockway 8y agoIf you have to borrow money, it's expensive. If you just have the money sitting in your treasury, it's a lot more viable. I never saw the Google Fiber cancellation as a cost issue. It felt to me like more of a scale issue. You have to live in Kansas City to pay Google for fiber, but you can buy an Android device from anywhere in the world. Thus, one of those things is going to make more money than the other, and it makes sense to focus on that. The economics of ISPs, the way I see it, depend on: 1) Cost of money. (Free if you're Google, 18% a year if you're some guy using your credit card.) 2) Expected lifetime of wireline Internet. Wireless internet isn't getting _worse_ every year. While a lot of us here won't be giving up our wired connections any time soon, many people already have. Their phone is their computer. They can't even plug an Ethernet cable into it if they want to. If your fiber is going to be good for 50 years... after you've paid off the loan, it costs basically nothing to provide Internet service over. And yet, people will pay more than $0/month to have Internet service. So economically it works out... if fiber continues to be relevant. That is the if that scares people. (The other issue is that it's hard to find free money unless you are, say, Google.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kortilla 8y agoI have fiber that’s not from google at 1 gig/sec for $85/mo in Austin and had it in Phoenix as well. Is it possible google is just an incompetent ISP?