7 ms·
I worked at a place that had many customers who used a major free email provider that also ran an ad network (but was not Google or Microsoft) that kept decidin
by tzs 8y ago
I worked at a place that had many customers who used a major free email provider that also ran an ad network (but was not Google or Microsoft) that kept deciding that most mail we sent to our customers was spam: receipts, installation instructions, responses from support, and notices that subscriptions were going to re-bill were all blocked.
We'd contact them, they would fix things, and it would work for a while...but invariably it would go back to classifying it all as spam, and we'd get customers calling to complain about not getting instructions or support responses.
Finally, our guy who managed our ad spending called up our rep in ad sales at the email company, and asked in rather forceful terms just why we should continue spending $large_number/month on ads there to acquire new customers, when we were then going to be blocked from emailing those customers?
The ad rep conference called in their head of IT, who conference called in their engineer in charge of spam filtering, and had him right there add us to a whitelist that would prevent anything from us being classified as spam no matter what the rest of their spam system decided. As far as I know we never had another email go into the spam filter.
If we hadn't been spending a large amount on ads with them, I doubt the problem would ever have been resolved.
If you sell a software product to end users, and have non-marketing messages that you need users to see such as responses to support requests or reminders that subscriptions are going to automatically re-bill, I'd recommend including some kind of messaging system specifically for this in the product itself. Still send them as email, but also send them via this in-product channel, or at least send notices that there is a message with links to a way to view it on the web. Email only is simply not reliable enough.
- pmlnr 8y ago> Email only is simply not reliable enough. That is because implementations, especially gmail, ignore the specifications: (EDIT) there are specific error codes and messages should be sent back to the originator. The reasons to ignore it is, in theory, not to give spammers ideas how to avoid it. Email is incredibly reliable, it can tolerate outages, configuration errors, delays, etc, by specification, but ever since "modern" spam filtering, gmail (and those who follow their practices) it became a nightmare, because everyone ignores how it _should_ work. It was done in a time when connections were slow and prone to errors; it had to be flexible. Yes, I know spam was bad I was there. But I'd rather have spam, than actually important mails getting dropped because of false positive, paranoid spamfilters.
- lostlogin 8y agoYou’ve just explained why it’s become unreliable. It might have been great once, but fixing it when it’s broken is a complete nightmare now.
- mikeash 8y agoWhen there’s too much spam, your important mails are effectively dropped as they’re buried in the noise. Modern spam filtering is what saved email. Without it, you’d never see those important messages, because new spam would come in faster than you could delete it.
- jstanley 8y agoI don't have any content-based spam filtering (but I do use the spamhaus sbl-xbl list). It doesn't take very long to manually delete spam from the inbox. And if your spam filter is putting legitimate emails in your spam folder, you need to manually filter them anyway.
- mikeash 8y agoAt the peak of my spam experience, I was getting hundreds a day. That was ages ago when the internet was much slower and more expensive than it is today, and bad people online were much less sophisticated. I wouldn’t be surprised if a totally open email system today generated enough spam that even deleting one message per second you’d fall behind. I haven’t checked my spam folder on a routine basis in many years.
- jstanley 8y agoWhat I'm saying is that "modern spam filtering" (by which I assume we mean GMail-style highly-aggressive spam filtering that puts lots of legitimate email in the spam folder) is not what saved email. Rudimentary spam filtering saved email. There's no need to ever have a legitimate email go to the spam folder.
- 8y ago
- EGreg 8y agoEmail SMS Notifications They all go through some provider who can block you. It’s a rare product that people check on their own without notifications! Any ideas how to reach people without gatekeepers? I have just one way: a desktop app or mobile app that is allowed to periodically wake up and poll a server.
- ams6110 8y agoA printed invoice in an envelope and sent via Post mail usually still works.
- daveFNbuck 8y agoThen we have the problem of a service that doesn't sort out spam. I often get enough junk mail that it's hard to fit everything in my mailbox. Important mail ends up shoved between pages of catalogs I'm about to throw out or mixed in with an ever-growing stack of junk that I'll sort through later when I find the time.
- imglorp 8y agoIt's a DOS attack on your mailbox. The SNR is approaching 0.
- EGreg 8y agoYou’re kidding, right? The Postal Service is the ultimate gatekeeper. You have only a companies that would make the last mile delivery.
- cr0sh 8y ago> Any ideas how to reach people without gatekeepers? I have just one way: a desktop app or mobile app that is allowed to periodically wake up and poll a server. If you're asking "anybody today" then yes, that's probably one of the only ways. But maybe tomorrow might be better. On the horizon (where it may stay - it's been slow in coming) is the idea of "distributed and serverless" internet. Also known as "peer-to-peer". You can think of it as everyone (well, their device) being their own server - kinda like the internet was originally meant to be (before vast sums of money got involved). Through "magic" - each person that is on the network can browse, send, receive, post, etc - to others without needing much of anything else - just the pipe (not really any way around that kind of "gatekeeper" unless you have a mesh network of some sort - and even there, long-haul can be tough or impossible). A well known example: https://ipfs.io/ https://ipfs.io/ ...there are others out there as well; just google around for "peer-to-peer web" and similar terms.