6 ms·
They make a big deal about IBM using images published under a Creative Commons license without asking for permission, when the whole point of CC is to give perm
by yorwba 8y ago
They make a big deal about IBM using images published under a Creative Commons license without asking for permission, when the whole point of CC is to give permission to anyone, without having to ask. The people who are now surprised that their images are being used for purposes they disagree with should probably have used a different license, but I guess the messaging around CC (which tends to emphasize reuse by artists) makes it difficult.
Using images with a restriction to non-commercial purposes is a bit more of a gray area, depending on how you separate commercial from non-commercial activity. Since they share the data set with researchers at other organizations (presumably including competitors), I'd consider it non-commercial enough, because they don't gain a competitive advantage, but the details might have to be fought out in court.
- jasonhansel 8y agoBut the CC license requires attribution (and, in some variants, prohibits commerical use). It's not clear to me that IBM followed these requirements--presumably a trained neural network counts as a derived work, so far as the CC license is concerned.
- EpicEng 8y ago>presumably a trained neural network counts as a derived work I just spent about 15 minutes trying to confirm that and... I have no idea. I suppose it's not surprising that a software engineer would not be able to suss that out in 15 minutes. Every definition I find tends to focus on on art, visual and auditory creations. Disregarding a legal interpretation (you know, the thing that actually matters), I can see it either way. Certainly the model is based off of data derived from the characteristics of these images. On the other hand, if I saw e.g. a shade of blue in one of these images that I liked, would I need to provide attribution if I measured it and used it in my own work? I have no idea, I suppose I'm just thinking out loud here. I do understand the taking something to a logical extreme (the color example) is not the end all be all of legal arguments.
- nitrogen 8y agoIsn't the purpose of a ML model to describe actual facts, derived mechanically and not creatively, and thus might not be subject to US copyright in the first place?
- penagwin 8y agoBut you could argue that the weights of the model wouldn't be what they are without the copyrighted work. Since their model does use the work, apart of it was "derived" from that piece.
- sls 8y agoThis isn't about the various senses the English word "derived" can have, it's about the specific meaning of the legal term "derivative work." That would start with including major elements of another work and those elements being subject to copyright (e.g. in the US, book titles are not). There's no point in talking about how one could argue that something wouldn't be what it is without something else, that's not the legal basis at all. In no legal sense are the Indiana Jones movies derivative works of the old 1930's serials just because they were sources of inspiration.
- pgeorgi 8y agoIt may not constitute a new copyright (like a database copyright on a new collection of stuff copyrighted by others), but that doesn't invalidate existing copyrights and the license requirements under which the copyrighted material was used. But I'm not a lawyer, so no idea how the interactions are in that situation. The closest analogy I could think of are sampling in music: how much must the original works be atomized before they don't count anymore?
- gnopgnip 8y agoBeing subject/able to copyright, complying with the license, and not infringing on the original work are separate issues
- alasdair_ 8y ago
- yorwba 8y agoTFA mentions contacting the Flickr users who uploaded the images, so for all we know, they were attributed appropriately. (Not all CC licenses are CC-BY anyway.) The problem of treating a neural network as derived work is exactly why IBM said they wouldn't use the dataset in their products. Instead, they'll likely train various different networks, note which ones performed best, write a paper about it and throw the trained networks away. So long as they do that, they're not infringing on anyone's copyright.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoThe CC licenses where created before using this kind of content for machine learning was a widely known possibility, probably should be rewritten to create a new type of license where you can disallow this kind of usage.
- nmstoker 8y agoAre you sure on that timing? The CC non-profit was set up in 2001 according to Wikipedia, yet people were going things like face detection in the 80s which would have required using images of faces
- Mediterraneo10 8y ago2001 was before mobile phones with cameras. It was years before big social networks. Years before the selfie became common. There simply weren’t that many images of faces on the web, comparatively speaking. As Creative Commons arose, the idea of harvesting an enormous amount of ordinary people’s faces was not something people were thinking about.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agoyeah I'm pretty sure of that timing hence my usage of the phrase 'widely known'. Sure, there were face detection projects before 2001, with much lower quality results, and maybe not even familiar to the creators of CC. Controlling a fetus' DNA is just getting ramped up, but of course there has been a good deal of academic knowledge of the possibilities before hand. Do you think there may be some laws or contractual formats worked out in the last few years that might apply in the area, yet have not adequately taken the implications into consideration? Time's arrow being what it is I expect there are.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agohuh, I just noticed I wrote where instead of were.
- mattkrause 8y agoI wouldn't be too sure. On the one hand, US Copyright is very explicitly attached to a piece of work, not the facts or ideas contained in it. Per 17 USC 102: > In no case does copyright protection for an original work > of authorship extend to any idea, procedure, process, > system, method of operation, concept, principle, or > discovery, regardless of the form in which it is described, > explained, illustrated, or embodied in such work. You are therefore free to create works of your own that analyze facts contained in others' copyrighted works, comment on their ideas, and so on. This is always true if you don't include any of their copyrighted work, and often true, via fair use, if you only include the small pieces needed for your commentary. Accordingly, it seems pretty clear that you could analyze a huge collection of copyrighted portraits and do whatever you want with the results (distribution of hair colors, eye positions relative to nose, how these vary within/across individuals, and so on). The counterargument would appear to be that derivative works include the "abridgment, condensation, or any other form in which a work may be recast, transformed, or adapted." Neural networks do seem to store their training data, at least in some form, and there's a fuzzy line between extracting some facts from data (which is fine) and omitting data to create an abridged version (which isn't). I wouldn't want to bet much either way, but I do think it would be a little odd for copyright to limit how much you can "learn" from something, either manually or via machine.
- Fei8reim 8y ago> but I guess the messaging around CC (which tends to emphasize reuse by artists) makes it difficult. Programming is often considered an artform. It's just that these particular artists are palpatine's personal carbonite sculptors. Still artists.
- JohnFen 8y agoSoftware engineering is engineering. Engineering can be accurately described as a mix of art and science. That's why in the olden days, "engineering" wasn't used outside of railroads -- the term used instead was "useful arts".
- ChuckMcM 8y agoAs someone who has done license clearance while employed by IBM I can assure you that their legal team is all about following the rules on this stuff. That said, from the article you have this: "NBC News obtained IBM’s dataset from a source after the company declined to share it, saying it could be used only by academic or corporate research groups." which tells me that IBM has restricted distribution to non-commercial activities, and this "To build its Diversity in Faces dataset, IBM says it drew upon a collection of 100 million images published with Creative Commons licenses that Flickr’s owner, Yahoo, released as a batch for researchers to download in 2014. So they started with a data set that someone else had re-licensed for this purpose already. (That would be Yahoo!) Back in the day, Yahoo!'s terms of service for Flickr were that you gave Yahoo! its own license to your work and could specify the license that others got if they downloaded your work. So I can imagine that it is entirely possible/legal for Yahoo! to exercise their rights under that ToS to relicense the photos how they saw fit (and remember Verizon/Yahoo! was trying to make the asset as valuable as possible, and this would contribute positively to that effort). I expect that somewhere someone has sold the old classmates.com archives of images and/or digitized a few thousand yearbooks for images. It is not too hard to find sources of hundreds of images where the include a head shot, are all equally lit, and have a small number of backgrounds to remove to leave just the facial features.
- 0xcde4c3db 8y ago> As someone who has done license clearance while employed by IBM I can assure you that their legal team is all about following the rules on this stuff. As a few HNers are no doubt aware, IBM allegedly obtained explicit permission to use Douglas Crockford's software for Evil rather than Good, because it couldn't guarantee that its customers aren't doing Evil.
- jrockway 8y agoThe guidance given by the lawyers at my last company was "everything we do is commercial activity, even research", thus prohibiting the use of anything tagged "not for commercial use". I expect that it's the same way at IBM.
- Vinnl 8y agoInterestingly I experienced something similar in academia. I combined several sources of open data to gather all of an author's publications and link to their respective Open Access versions, and have had objections from people who generally identify as Open Data advocates and had consciously freely licensed that data.
- JohnFen 8y agoYou are correct. This is a real problem, made worse by the fact that the internet had pretty well trained everyone to avoid reading licenses.
- codedokode 8y agoAs these are photos from Flicker, they can include random people not aware about how their photos are used and where they are published. So it doesn't matter what license does photo have. I think it should be illegal to publish other people's faces on the Internet or TV, or recognise them without getting their consent. Also, search engines like Google should not be allowed to index such photos.
- tokyodude 8y agoso all video of the president would be un-publsihable unless cropped to show just the president? those 100s of people around the president didn't give their permission. or how about all the people in that dash cam video of an accident.