10 ms·
College Cheating Scandal: An Admissions Officer Speaks Out
- wycs 8y agoMake the SAT so difficult that on average 1 person gets a perfect score each year. Then do not allow any other criteria for admission. To prevent bribery randomly sample 1% for a retest under much stricter security. If you must, lower standards for protected classes to even out demographics. Rich people can afford to burn their children’s childhood on the enrichment activities and “volunteer” work Harvard requires. Standardized testing is by far the most fair way to do this. SAT prep is not that effective and besides SAT prep is now available online for free.
- apengwin 8y agoThat biases admissions for people who can afford extra tutoring and preparation for the test.
- sam0x17 8y agoYes. Case in point, the daughter of the lady in my town who ran the SAT and SSAT prep courses got all 800s. ALL 800s. She was smart, but not that smart. It is possible to be completely prepared for the SATs.
- wycs 8y agoA perfect score on the modern SAT is not very impressive. The bar has been lowered considerably in the last 40 years. [edit: seems I was very clearly wrong about this]
- Pfhreak 8y agoAh, there it is. The "this generation has it so much easier" mentality. Got any citations to back this up? Or just feel like grousing about millennials?
- wycs 8y agoNope. Seems I was wrong.
- throwawaymath 8y agoWith respect, what in the world are you talking about? A casual search on the topic shows that 2 million people took the SAT last year. Of those 2 million, fewer than 500 achieved a perfect score. Being part of the 0.025% isn't impressive to you?
- wycs 8y agoYes. False memory on my part it seems. I was very clearly wrong. The current SAT is clearly selective enough for my very popular scheme.
- krackers 8y agoIsn't the difficulty tuned to produce a histogram close to that of a normal distribution? Yes it's true that the contents of the test have changed (removing analogies, and then recently circa 2016 revamping the writing/reading sections to be more like the ACT) but fundamentally it doesn't really look that different to me. In fact if anything now the reading section relies more on understanding and analysis of passages rather than just memorizing words and definitions which if anything seems like slightly raising the bar.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoGoodhart's law: "Once a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure."
- barry-cotter 8y agoFar from universally true. IQ tests like the SAT, GRE, GMAT etc. are all designed to be as close to ungameable as possible. There’s a limited amount they can do but the limit is very high indeed. The major, and unavoidable defect is the practice effect. The more you do something the better you get at it. But IQ tests are like running or weightlifting, there are beginner gains, there are tough gains that are ground out with a great deal of effort and there’s a limit you’re not going to surpass no matter how hard you try. O matter how many steroids I take or how hard I train I’m not going to beat Usain Bolt in the 100m. I’m probably not going to beat the average NHL player. Goodhart’s Law is the opposite of true in quality control. What gets measured gets managed. Manufacturing defects in semiconductors, automobiles and I presume, most everything else have been trending down for decades. Businesses have KPIs for employees for a reason. Monomaniacal focus over a long period on one measure may not be the best idea, but it’s a great tool to have.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoThis is a great example of Goodhart's Law, though. If nobody studied for the SAT, it might (arguably) work fine as a measurement of collegiate potential. But because it became the metric for collegiate success, and because the "practice effect" means that practicing makes you do better on the test, many people study hard for it and greatly increase their likely score. The folks who don't study as much or as effectively for it for whatever reason will not do as well, as so you're left with a measurement of whether people studied for the SAT and not whether the test taker would be likely to succeed at college. So a good metric becomes a bad metric because it's chosen as the metric.
- Nasrudith 8y agoNot saying it isn't a problem but those better off have the resources to be educated better before in addition to factors like nutrition. Essentially the advantages aren't bias but a byproduct. The way to fix it of course is to raise the floor.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- enriquto 8y ago> If you must, lower standards for protected classes to even out demographics. As a member of a "protected class" that is able to get very high SAT scores, I would be extremely pissed if that criterion was applied.
- NavyNuke 8y ago> I would be extremely pissed if that criterion was applied. It isn't a matter of "if"...that is the standard now, lower scores for certain demographics...that is why I don't put Asian on anything...as a mixed-race Filipino, I can pass as some kind of Latino which is what I now "identify" with since it helps me in nearly every case imaginable...it kind of sucks, but that is the world we now live in.
- enriquto 8y ago> that is the standard now, lower scores for certain demographics I was talking about the opposite case: belonging to a class whose scores are artificially raised. If I can get excellent scores and get admitted by myself, but then everybody thinks that I got admitted due to my ethnic background, not due to my merits. Infuriating! > it kind of sucks, but that is the world we now live in. That certainly does not seem to be the case in Europe.
- NavyNuke 8y ago> I was talking about the opposite case: belonging to a class whose scores are artificially raised. If I can get excellent scores and get admitted by myself, but then everybody thinks that I got admitted due to my ethnic background, not due to my merits. Infuriating! I think I follow you...that must not be fun...having everyone think you didn't deserve the spot you earned because of other undeserving "diversity applicants" > That certainly does not seem to be the case in Europe I was talking about the U.S. because the author of the article was talking about the U.S...I should have been more specific
- Pfhreak 8y agoWhat a terrible idea. Ignoring the fact that not everyone can take the test for economic or mental health reasons, and the fact that being able to prep for this test effectively skews in favor of wealthier folks, there are so many experiences that shape us. How does learning to overcome adversity because you had to survive homelessness show up in the SAT? How does being raised in a multicultural background? How does music? The arts? Your ability to engage people around you and spark imaginations? Or your inventiveness or compassion? There are so many types of people I would want to be around in college who might not do great in a standardized test. I'd rather have a rich set of people around with different ideas and experiences than filter down to a single test result.
- pmart123 8y agoI still agree with his main point. I got an 800 in Math SAT I & II, and I am far from a Math genius. I don't think you need to implement the Putnam exam, but the SAT is structured to make it very difficult to discern a college player from a pro basically. More than 25% of MIT has an 800 SAT and 75% has at least 780 Math SAT.
- mLuby 8y agoWhich would be fine IF the SAT were a useful predictor of future academic or life success. Since it's not, we could either 1) pick something that is a better predictor, or 2) give up and use a lottery.
- barry-cotter 8y ago> Predicting Success in College: SAT® Studies of Classes Graduating Since 1980 > Studies predicting success in college for students graduating since 1980 are reviewed. SAT® scores and high school records were the most common predictors, but a few studies of other predictors are included. The review establishes that SAT scores and high school records predict academic performance, nonacademic accomplishments, leadership in college, and postcollege income. The combination of high school records and SAT scores is consistently the best predictor. Academic preadmission measures contribute substantially to predicting academic success (grades, honors, acceptance and graduation from graduate or professional school); contribute moderately to predicting outcomes with both academic and nonacademic components (persistence and graduation); and make a small but significant contribution to predicting college leadership, college accomplishments (artistic, athletic, business), and post-college income. A small number of studies of nonacademic predictors (high school accomplishments, attitudes, interests) establish their importance, particularly for predicting nonacademic success. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED562836.pdf https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED562836.pdf > SAT and ACT scores as predictors of undergraduate GPA scores of construction science and management students > The result showed relatively strong positive correlation and predictive indices for both ACT and SAT. Thus, the hypothesis of higher UGPAs being related to higher ACT or SAT scores was supported. It was concluded that the admission committees might need to reexamine their admission requirements and/or look at ACT score more than SAT during admission. https://scholar.google.de/scholar?as_ylo=2015&q=sat+predicts+college+success&hl=en&as_sdt=0,5#d=gs_qabs&u=%23p%3D6xC4R70kbtIJ https://scholar.google.de/scholar?as_ylo=2015&q=sat+predicts...
- MagnumOpus 8y agoThere is no better predictor for future academic success than the SAT (or an equivalent IQ test - ACT/LSAT/GRE/GMAT). The only other predictors that are good at predicting success are either undesirable (socioeconomic status of parents, for instance), or hard to standardize between applicants (school GPA).
- throwawaymath 8y ago> Allow people to challenge students on their score forcing them to retake the test, or randomly sample 1% for a retest. You want to implement a challenge round for the SAT? Over 2 million kids took the SAT last year[1], many of them for the second or third time. Your proposal forces a kid to be required to retest if they're arbitrarily challenged by someone else. Or it uses a lottery to select tributes who will have to retake the exam again. The SAT is an incredibly stressful part of an incredible stressful stage of life. Kids already take it several times to improve their scores. Your proposal adds even more elements which are out of parents' and kids' control that can potentially wreak havoc on their time and mental health. It's basically the nuclear option of attempts to improve the SAT. ____________________ 1. https://reports.collegeboard.org/sat-suite-program-results/class-2018-results https://reports.collegeboard.org/sat-suite-program-results/c...
- wycs 8y agoMy point was just there are obvious ways to prevent bribery. And considering the amount we burn on higher education, spending much more on tests and verification does seem like a much much better use of money.
- grecy 8y agoIn Australia the final year 12 exams, which are used as University entrance ranks are standardized. It works exceptionally well. https://www.uac.edu.au/future-applicants/atar https://www.uac.edu.au/future-applicants/atar
- lysp 8y agoAnd the cut off for course admissions are adjusted up and down based on supply and demand.
- vore 8y agoThat seems unfair to the students who apply for admission: if supply was high the previous year and low the current year, a student in the current year may not be admitted even if they demonstrated identical academic performance (assuming "academic performance" just means standardized test score here) as an admitted student from the previous year.
- joppy 8y agoSure, but this is just life isn’t it? A university decides to change the courses it offers, or the number of places offered within a course, just because things change. There also might be a new course offered this year which the student would not have had the opportunity to apply for last year.
- drawnwren 8y agoIn Korea and Japan, they use the one test system and have the highest suicide rate among high school students. It also makes their high school lives hell and their education system lackluster at best. I would advise caution.
- ndnxhs 8y agoThe test also means next to nothing. I know people who failed badly at the test and still got in to uni.
- 8y ago
- sgustard 8y agoHalf of the bribery scandal was cheating on SATs, so the more you emphasize test scores the more you elicit that kind of behavior. The College Board and its executives make millions selling test prep materials and running a monopoly over US higher education. There's a good chance we're only beginning to discover the inherent corruption here.
- yumraj 8y agoI disagree. In India the IIT-JEE, for admissions into the IITs, are super hard, so hard that I can bet no one can repeat performance between years, thereby removing almost any chance that someone else taking the test would be able to provide any kind of performance guarantee. In fact the problem with the US college admission system is that it's not at all objective, rather is completely subjective, thereby giving the admission committee a lot of leeway. Students, who are good in academics, are unnecessarily (biased opinion) forced to spend time on extra curricular activities, volunteering, sports etc. Not that they are not important, but I'm not convinced that they should be part of the admission criteria. By making admissions dependent on some standardized test you will remove all, or at least most, of human involvement which leads to corruption.
- kkarakk 8y agoThere are people offering IIT jee scores(usually at really expensive coaching institutes). hell the best IITJEE instructors take the test every year(to see the difficulty changes) and manage to get roughly the same high score everytime
- wpasc 8y agoI selfishly love standardized testing because I have mostly done well on it. but SAT prep is ABSOLUTELY effective. I have my own personal anecdotal experience as well of that of my peers, but there are countless prep courses that boast impressive scores (unless they are lying through false advertising, but I believe it). The price of private tutoring and multiple rounds of simulated live exams is prohibitive and an absolute difference maker.
- headsoup 8y agoEffective for passing a test, maybe, but in my view 'passing tests' (that can be prepared for especially) is well down the list of 'important life skills.'
- majewsky 8y agoIf a good SAT score is required to get you into a good college, and a good college is required to land a well-paying job, then passing the SAT with a high score is definitely an important life skill.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoIt pushes the burden to the people that have to teach these all these little box-checkes
- dpweb 8y agoHere’s a solution. Make college free for all. Anyone with a HS diploma can get in. But, you MUST attend the classes and do the work or you’re kicked out end of semester. Totally based on merit. No biases on income or anything else.
- wangchungtonite 8y agoWho pays the utility bills? Professor and administrative salaries? Is anyone allowed in just due to having a diploma? What keeps rampant cronyism and end of year cost splurges to keep high budget levels for the next year? Who sets the budget? How does enforcement work, government employees doing enforcing? In short how do you pay for it given the already spiraling out of control costs of higher education?
- ndnxhs 8y agoAll fairly simple issues that many countries have solved.
- dodobirdlord 8y agoI suppose so, but it's worth noting that no other nation's tertiary education system holds a candle to the United States.
- cf498 8y agoBecause of a few flagship institutions who are valued quite a lot in comparison to the average institution.
- titanomachy 8y agoSwitzerland and England both have schools in the top 10.
- em500 8y agoThose schools don't admit everyone, and certainly not everyone for free.
- burfog 8y agoThe SAT/ACT is no longer standardized testing. All the determined parents abuse this. They find a sympathetic doctor to diagnose their kid with a nonsense learning disability, then that gets them double the time for the test or more. The test vendor isn't even allowed to disclose this inequality to the colleges; there was a lawsuit over that. So you may play by the rules, but other students are getting twice the time to complete the test. Some students are more equal than other students. This pretty much invalidates the whole concept of the test. Unless sanity prevails, the only way for test vendors to fix the problem would be to give an absurd amount of time to everybody.
- iliketosleep 8y agoStudents have slowly been reframed as customers - it's no surprise that admissions may turn into form of customer screening.
- Nasrudith 8y agoIt is the Ivy League - there is no "turning" about it. Many practices were goal-post moving to keep model minorities out including ridiculously biased vocabulary in test questions like yaucht sailing vocabulary which is covered nowhere in even the most in depth historical or literaty sources.
- eanzenberg 8y ago“75% in-state acceptance, 25% out-of-state” yet out-of-state usually pays double? Are 75% of applicants “affluent”? I’m sorry but a lot of these recent biased articles smell a bit of BS lately...
- headsoup 8y agoAlready accepted students on first pass are likely not then questioned, so make up majority. The Deny/Check students that are affluent are subsequently 'reviewed' and allowed would be a percentage of the 75%
- cbsks 8y agoNothing about this surprises me. Just another thing in the long list of ways that wealthy people are able to keep their wealth, and pass it on to their children. I had college paid for in full by my parents, and they also were able to provide a good portion of the down payment on my house. My parents aren’t exceptionally wealthy, but they have been able to give my siblings and I a very good head start on life. And if they were wealthier, they would have been able to provide even more advantages to us. The whole system is rigged, and has been for a very long time.
- lwhalen 8y agoWhat's stopping you from going full Siddhartha, selling your house/earthly possessions, and giving the wad to the first homeless person you see on your way out of town to live your best ascetic life? Caring for and providing as much of an advantage to your kids as one is able is a basic human (one could even argue 'mammalian') behavior. I'm disappointed that the narrative is trying to label such hard-coded behavior as everything from 'evil' to 'frowned upon'.
- cf498 8y agoIts only reasonable that individuals do it but it isnt healthy for society as a whole, as it leads to an entrenched class system.
- FranzFerdiNaN 8y agoSomething that is good for the individual is not necessarily good for society. Such as wealth-based admission to college, which is good for the wealthy but terrible for society.
- Err_Eek 8y agoIt is normal behavior, everyone does it. But as that passed down wealth becomes more and more essential for a good life, society at large should stop pushing the myth that it is largely meritocratic, especially as lines between social classes become more rigid by the day.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
- raincom 8y agoI would rather hear from an admissions offer from HYP and Stanford, where average admit rate is 5 to 6%. This guy worked for schools whose admit rate ranges from 60 to 75%; so, the target for such schools is different from that for HYP.
- ashelmire 8y agoI heard exactly the same from a friend who worked in admissions at an ivy league university. Applying for financial aid materially damages your application. Ability to pay is factored in just like test scores. The rich continue to get opportunities poor kids will never have.
- javagram 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Need-blind_admission https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Need-blind_admission It seems like there are only a few dozen U.S. colleges (43 by my count) that officially have need-blind admissions, so at any school not on this list ability to pay should be expected to be a factor.
- ashelmire 8y agoI can tell you that list cannot be trusted. The university I spoke of is on that list, but seeing as someone who was in the room making admissions decisions said they consider financial need, it’s clearly bullshit.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoI don't think it will really happen, but I can at least hope that this admissions scandal will shine a light on the scam that the "meritocracy" is, and I say this as a Harvard alum. At any of the most elite universities there are many more qualified applicants than there are spots. For example, Harvard could fill its undergrad ranks with valedictorians alone, twice over. Thus, the fair thing to do would be to either (a) drastically increase the size of the incoming classes, or (b) set a minimum level of objective criteria (e.g. test scores, class standing, etc.) and then just run a lottery from those qualified students. But instead, the admissions offices at schools run a system much worse than random. It's a system that's highly subject to pay-to-play access (and usually not the outright fraud kind, but more the endow-a-chair kind) while at the same time allowing the universities to keep up the charade that it is all merit based. Even if there weren't undo influence, the current efforts to maintain "diversity" (and not just the racial kind, but the kind where we need 5 cello players and 7 chess club champions, etc) means the admissions criteria is already completely arbitrary if you meet the basic (albeit still tough) academic requirements. The reason this won't change, though, is the primary purpose of today's elite universities is to maintain social stratification. If universities did the fair thing and had a lottery for all qualified applicants, it would mean they would have to admit that they are not the objective arbiters of "potential" they purport to be.
- ordinaryradical 8y agoA lottery will never happen as you laid out here. Not because it’s not a good idea but because it tarnishes the pedigree of the school. Being selected to attend Harvard and winning the lottery among those qualified to attend are so vastly different in the mind’s eye that there’s no way they’d take up this system. Fundamentally, it risks their brand. I think the real answer may still be the open sourcing of curriculum and teaching through online courses. Completing an education at Harvard should be inherently valuable whether or not you were selected for it. This is meritocratic but also realistic, I think.
- zamfi 8y agoThe (magnet) elementary school I attended used a lottery to select among the top X% of applicants. It did not "tarnish the pedigree of the school" or anything like that. There is already a lottery to select which students among the thousands who apply will be offered admission. It's just not uniformly random.
- sytelus 8y agoTLDR; The admissions are heavily affected if students expressed need for financial aid. The OP worked at two schools, one that had little endowment liberal arts college not requiring SATs. This one doesn't surprise me. The other one is state college with 75% acceptance rate for in-state students. This one doesn't seem like problematic. OP isn't clear which school he/she is accusing of. Overall, its well known fact that rich people's kid can chose great college as they prefer. Everything from Stanford to Harvard have seats reserved for donors.
- yardie 8y agoI have friends that worked in admissions office of a state university. Normally, admissions rate will be high for in-state students because college-prep would have started long before application time. And through local alumni, teachers, and counselors students will have a good idea which state schools they’ll be accepted into. But out of state and international admissions is completely different. When state budget cuts roll down that admission rate jumps from 10-15% to 25% and up. And if you can pay full freight that rate jumps to 100%. When I found that out I was less shocked than I thought I would be. It just confirmed thoughts that I observed but failed to see.
- forthwall 8y agoMy family was part of that "full pay" segment of the population, at least when I was in school - it makes me wonder if my skew to private college (vs public) acceptances could be part of this, since I was an average student.
- bhl 8y agoWhat is the value of a college education? This is a contentious question that I believe more and more people should be asking, and debating about. Is the value in the education that one receives, or in the the network that one gains access to? They're really both sides of the same coin: they both represent opportunity. Ideally, we could have both – just admit all the high-achieving students from upper middle-class backgrounds. When there's no more space, just simply expand: build some dorms, hire a few more professors, etc. But in reality, where resources are already scarce, schools face a tradeoff: do we admit the bright student from a poorer background, or the wealthier, albeit not as academically-inclined, student? Here, admissions basically become a zero-sum game. I guess it boils down to an argument of whether intellectual capital is to be more valued, or of social capital.
- ewtddaxd 8y agoI find the nuance in the reporting to be quite fascinating depending on who the perpetrators are. When it was rich Chinese international students doing the cheating, most articles would almost always allude to how it was cultural and how it reflects on the general population. Now that's it's rich American students, the reporting focuses on wealth and class and how it's an isolated incident.
- atomi 8y agoWell yeah. The poor certainly don't have the means to bribe Ivy League schools.
- notfromhere 8y agoFraud is rampant in every university. If you locked a class in a room and force them to write a three page in class essay, a good portion will be unable to replicate the quality of their previous written content
- buboard 8y agoPeter Thiel has been warning about education turning to exclusive clubs since years ago. i dont know if much can change though
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 3rdgender 8y agoIs it actually a bad thing if people who pay for it can get a good education? Shouldn't we rather at the other end of the ladder, people who can't pay, and see to it that they can get a good education?
- jbarberu 8y agoIn that case you could make it more transparent and outright make it a bidding war over who gets in, rather than the whole charade of test scores and what-not.
- ausbah 8y ago>I saw these decisions flipped frequently for students from affluent backgrounds, and rarely for students who’d applied for financial aid. >Although our school advertised our “holistic” review process, our director typically used test scores to screen applicants. His rationale was that these were “riskier” students. The only time he didn’t? If the student could pay full price to attend our institution, or a “full pay” student. My main takeaway from this is a reminder on how reliant schools have become on gigantic, bloated tuitions to finance a large part of, if not all, their operations. Whee you need to keep paying for pricey administrators, new dorm buildings, and other likely-not-vital-for-education pieces but your state budgets have been slashed, endowment isn't paying out as much this year, and lower income students don't have access to as many loans - of course schools are going to put a preference for students from a wealthy background. I think if you want to keep colleges fair, you need to keep their budgets more bare bones and focused on the essentials of schools (teaching and research), OR charge those who can afford the vast tuitions out of pocket with even higher tuitions to offset the payments for more qualified, but less able to pay students.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- test6554 8y agoIt seems like there is a balance of meritocracy and capitalism which is fine, but society should have a say in where that balance lies.
- rchaud 8y agoEspecially since the top American schools are not-for-profits and aren't taxed on tuition fees received.
- strikelaserclaw 8y agoI read in an article somewhere that, American system heavily emphasis the brand of an Institution, which is markedly different from European institutions (Is this true?). This brand is valuable to people because they believe that the outcomes in their lives will become markedly different based on it. I think if we can somehow design a system which is indifferent to pedigree of an institution and rather afford opportunity based on individual merit (maybe university blind job admissions at the top companies), then the need to attend prestigious institutions will lessen.
- rchaud 8y agoEuropean schools are taxpayer-funded, so students don't have to think as much about 5-figure differences between in-state tuition at a public university and full tuition at a private school. The "pedigree" of US schools developed because the top schools have gigantic endowments from rich alumni, which allows them to build better facilities, hire top teaching talent and fund research. This is a cycle that is reinforced by alums (many at successful companies) who choose to recruit at those schools, thereby creating a new class of well-paid employees who're in a position to contribute to the endowment down the line. For some industries like investment banking and finance, it's extremely important to do your undergrad at a "target school", where banks come to campus directly to run info sessions and do preliminary interviews. Otherwise you may not have a real shot unless you do an MBA, this time at a target school.
- darawk 8y agoIn this article, we report on the fact that businesses preferentially seek out customers who pay more.
- Zigurd 8y agoIt's shocking to read justification of the bribery and fraud in this case as being just a manifestation of the drive to impart advantages to one's offspring. I have that same drive. I can't imagine living with a morality that would enable me to pay bribes and falsify athletic achievement, or disability. I can't imagine involving my children in federal crimes. There are lesser unfair practices, such as the ones the admissions officer in the article describes, and these should be fixed, too. But these lesser unfair practices are different from committing federal felonies. Especially when you are in technology entrepreneurial management, investing, or running a major law firm. It makes one wonder how deep the ethical rot goes.