6 ms·
I really like the Minnesota system. You fill out a paper ballot. You load the paper ballot that gets scanned and recorded and the paper ballot gets rolled in
by duxup 8y ago
I really like the Minnesota system. You fill out a paper ballot. You load the paper ballot that gets scanned and recorded and the paper ballot gets rolled into a locked box that is attached to the machine.
Recounts and etc should be relatively easy to manage and leave a very good paper trail tied to various machines and etc.
- azernik 8y agoCalifornia (or are least Alameda County) has the same system
- wahern 8y agoAFAIU, California mandates paper ballots statewide and also mandates post-election audits. It's not uncommon nationally, apparently: http://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/post-election-audits635926066.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/elections-and-campaigns/post-el...
- labster 8y agoWe're also required to have machines in the polling place for those with disabilities. These too produce paper records, that the voter can review. California went all-in on recording elections after the debacle in Florida in 2000.
- e1ven 8y agoAgreed. We use essentially a Scantron sheet in Massachusetts. Easy to fill out, computer countable, with a hand recount as an easy backup option.
- Teever 8y agoWhy is any of this necessary? Why don't paper ballots suffice?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> Why don't paper ballots suffice? Hand counting is costly, time-consuming and error-prone. Paper ballots with supervised electronic tabulation puts forward the best of both worlds. (It's how we do it in New York, too.)
- llukas 8y agoMore people involved and from more diverse backgrounds into hand counting then less likely conspiracy theories would be able to take a hold. Democracy doesn't work without trust. Sacrificing trust for some speed is dumb thing to do.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Not_a_pizza 8y agoBallot stuffing is a thing, and ballot disposal is a thing. Elections are one of the few games in town where the people that control things get to count up the vote and tell you who should control things in the future. If government was really ethical, you would expect independent auditors to be checking processes before and after.
- vkou 8y agoVote counting, in properly-ran systems, is done by paid contractors, and observed by representatives of both parties.
- hammock 8y ago"Both parties"?
- roywiggins 8y agoI'd wager there's only really two parties with enough volunteers to actually put election monitors in every precinct
- toweringgoat 8y agoThat's actually how large parts of Switzerland count their votes. (Some areas count/weigh ballots.) This e-voting system is optional, can't be used for more than 1/3rd of voters in a given district, and is only being used by a small number of regions. Given what's happened here, the moratorium on e-voting looks like it could well happen after all (funnily enough, that will also go to a vote).
- gdy 8y agoSame thing in Russia.
- bufferoverflow 8y agoExcept in Russia they burn trucks full of ballots, people who oversee the voting throw whole packs of fraudulent ballots into the vote box.
- ak47-1984 8y agoGot to win with 120% of the vote somehow
- gdy 8y agoI'm not sure what your point is. I've never heard about burning ballots. Throwing packs of fraudulent ballots into voting boxes indeed has been caught on cameras multiple times. What's more, statistical anomalies of voting results have been analyzed and they seem to indicate election fraud in favor of the Putin's party. It is still better to have paper trail than not.
- aero142 8y agoI feel like this is nearly perfect if you automatically hand count statistically interesting number of boxes before certifying an election. If you hand count 1% randomly, you should feel pretty confident that nothing strange happened.
- felipemnoa 8y agoI believe this is also how it is done in NY.
- brmgb 8y agoI don't understand why you need a machine at all. Counting ballots is trivial to parallelize. You just have each polling place count its own ballots publicly, display the result in a permanent manner, reseal the box and communicate the count to a regional center. The regional center publicly sum the counts, display the sum and communicate it to a bigger center until you have the final count. Where I am from, it takes less than two days to count a bit more than 30,000,000 ballots. You also get a very good result prediction two hours after the closing of polling places by using the official result of a set of selected small polling places known to be fairly representative of the voting population.
- gregschlom 8y agoYou still have to verify that the people counting the ballots aren't altering them somehow. I remember hearing a story in France where it was found that people doing the count had bits of pencil lead tucked under their nails. They would open each ballot, and if it was for the "wrong" candidate, they would discretely mark another name and the ballot would be counted as invalid since it had two names circled. Not sure if it's a true story or not (can't be bothered to check) - but seems like a good illustrations of the problems that are faced.
- brmgb 8y ago> They would open each ballot, and if it was for the "wrong" candidate, they would discretely mark another name That's impossible. You don't write on French ballot. We use a card of a standardized format on which the name of the candidate (or the list of names) is printed which you directly put in the envelope. Cards are both sent to you by post and available at the polling station. Anything written on a ballot makes it void. > They would open each ballot, and if it was for the "wrong" candidate, they would discretely mark another name Ballots are open in public. The person in charge of opening the envelope does so in front of the room and with two assessors watching. They remove the ballot, read it aloud and display it to the room. It would be very difficult to read and alter a ballot without anyone noticing. A different person updates the tally on a board when the name is read.
- jackhack 8y agoWhich is fine, if this were the only vector for votes. But then loads of "early voting" ballots turn up, and truckloads of "harvested" ballots with dubious provenance are delivered to be counted. This process adheres to the paper trail rule, can be recounted with certainty, and yet is completely and utterly fraudulent. Fair elections are the lynchpin of a democracy. Violate this trust, and the entire social contract is threatened.
- archi42 8y agoUhm, you know how Xerox got famous only a few years ago for messing up when scanning some characters? E.g. 9 and 6, or 8 and 0. Of course things should be good with that method. But they should also be good with some proper crypto.