22 ms·
Graying Out
- smacktoward 8y agoI feel this myself. I used to run an ejabberd server on the same domain as my email address; that, along with a multi-network client like Pidgin, let me chat seamlessly with just about anyone. The number of people I could contact through those two tools eventually became so small that I turned them both off. Nowadays the first conversation I get to have upon meeting a new person is a long negotiation about what baroque, proprietary messaging app I will have to use to reach them. Sigh. At least we still have email...
- cydonian_monk 8y agoI wish we still had email, but an increasing number of folks in my circles are refusing to use it too. And you can forget trying to call anybody - nobody answers because every phone call is a robocall or a scam. The balkanization of communications is real. I've become some sort of middleman/organizer in one of my hobby circles because I'm the only one who uses all of these disparate services; many of which I only use to connect to two or three folks.
- jethro_tell 8y ago>And you can forget trying to call anybody - nobody answers because every phone call is a robocall or a scam. Same for email, as soon as every site required signup, then felt the need to send a daily marketing email people just gave up on email. Now it's just for getting signup links and password resets and anything unexpected is just drowned out in the mess of advertising.
- asdff 8y agoSet up a rule to find "unsubscribe" in the body and push the email out of your inbox and into a folder or your junk/spam. Advertisers hate this one weird trick!
- asdff 8y agoWho are you in contact with? Tech workers with enough autonomy to fall off the map without consequence? I can't think of anyone I know who doesn't get critical emails that require a reply. You'd fail college without checking emails. You won't get hired if you don't check your emails. You'd get fired from my job without checking emails. You'd fall out of touch with collaborators in the field without checking emails. Who are these people who refuse to check emails, and what do they possibly do that gives them this privilege of avoiding the most basic and fundamental electronic communication? It seems just absurd to me.
- neurotrace 8y agoI had a roommate like that. The man missed out on a number of important opportunities because he just plain never checked his email. These people exist and it bothers me
- tatersolid 8y agoWhy would you expect investing a few seconds of your time to push your words unsolicited at someone to create a sense of obligation in the recipient? The problem with email is it’s too easy to send, and I get 100+ non-spam per day between work and personal. I do not have time to read, let alone respond to 100+ emails per day. So I triage them as best I can, and a lot get binned based on sender or subject alone. The walled gardens improve on email and XMPP because they’re walled.
- neurotrace 8y agoOh sure, I was never arguing for that. I'm just saying that you need to at least attempt to triage your emails. You can at least make the conscious decision of "I'm not going to deal with this email." However, I will say that walled gardens do not necessarily improve on this problem. If everyone is within the same walls then it's the same situation all over again.
- asdff 8y agoYou can't control those walls though. With email, you can craft the most convoluted rules and sure it's not always clear how to get a rule to do what you want, but you have total power in building up your own walled garden to your personal preferences, not whatever preferences are studied to get the most ad revenue and waste the most amount of your time without wasting so much that you get frustrated and leave the platform.
- JohnFen 8y ago> I get to have upon meeting a new person is a long negotiation about what baroque, proprietary messaging app I will have to use to reach them. I skip that negotiation entirely by letting them know that if they want to talk to me, the options are SMS and email.
- massivecali 8y agoTrillian used to be my goto for combining everyone's communication preferences. Worked great for the time. Sad none of those things work like they used to.
- golemotron 8y ago> once you get past Global Warming and deranged chiefs of state, the atomization of the social fabric is high, high on the list. I haven’t fought hard enough to stay connected (not alone in that). And time grows short. Predicted in 'Atomised', by Michel Houellebecq
- icebraining 8y agoThe increasing atomization of society has been discussed since at least The Lonely Crowd (1950).
- hprotagonist 8y agoThe day AIM died, I logged in one last time. A friend of mine was actually online! So i IM'd him. I got a frantic phone call about 30 seconds later. "how did you DO that?!" "do what?" "you made my PHONE play the AIM BING noise!" "..." He'd long ago wired SMS notifications into AIM, forgotten that he had done it a decade or more ago, and was deeply confused until we walked through the possibilities.
- donatj 8y agoI was on AIM the day it went offline. Ran into a person who was very important to me and my development. Reminisced for a couple hours. They added me on Facebook. I was hopeful to keep in touch, but they've since disappeared off Facebook like a lot of my friends in the recent trend.
- hprotagonist 8y agoI was genuinely a little scared that i'd log in and see my high school girlfriend online.
- war1025 8y agoI've found that it's difficult to keep in touch with a lot of people that I'd like to because Facebook chat is really the only widely used chat service at this point, and many of the people I'd like to talk with have decided that they don't want anything to do with Facebook. Lost touch with quite a few past friends from that
- keerthiko 8y agofacebook is in the uncanny valley of achieving its goal of universally connecting people but disconnecting people even more because it was so close to universally connecting people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- buboard 8y agoHey, there is twitter (at least many of the ppl in the least have accounts there)
- smacktoward 8y agoOh good, just what I wanted, all my private conversations made public so that dumb things I say to my friends can come back to haunt me years later and hordes of howling idiots can shower me with death threats because I don't agree with their deeply held opinions about the latest McMarvel movie. Progress!
- buboard 8y agoYeah but did you hear , it s asynchronous , and you never have to worry that the conversation will get too long
- 5874-4b22-a4e0 8y agoJust have everyone make a new account everyday. Help boost up the subscription count to help existing shareholders. Two birds with one stone.
- draw_down 8y agoYou're right, there should be a way to make twitter accounts private.
- JimDabell 8y agoTwitter only defaults to public; you can use it in private mode if you prefer. In the Privacy & Safety section of Twitter's settings, you'll see "Protect your Tweets": > If selected, only those you approve will receive your Tweets. Your future Tweets will not be available publicly. Tweets posted previously may still be publicly visible in some places. Learn more: https://help.twitter.com/en/safety-and-security/public-and-protected-tweets https://help.twitter.com/en/safety-and-security/public-and-p...
- drankula3 8y agoIt's funny this post is being created now. Google Hangouts was the primary method that my wife and I used to chat. I could talk to my wife while she was at work, even if I had no idea where my phone was. Its shutdown prompted me to look for an alternative. We ended up switching to an XMPP client, and we plan on creating an XMPP server for ourselves on a cloud instance so we know the conversation won't be intercepted by non-state actors. I don't know if it will ever reach the popularity it once had, but XMPP is useful to us at least.
- PaulHoule 8y agoFor all of the despair that people are expressing I think quite a few people are going back to Gopher, XMPP and other open and efficient (e.g. not "blockchain") protocols.
- jethro_tell 8y agoI run a gopher site/hole. but like, the users for that would be a small percentage even on a site like HN. In the wild, I'm going to guess it hasn't cracked a point. Not exactly a renascence.
- newaccoutnas 8y agoWasn't Gopher fairly un-open model (initially) one of the reasons HTTP/HTML became so much of a thing in the first place?
- Leace 8y ago> We ended up switching to an XMPP client Could you say what clients do you use? > we plan on creating an XMPP server for ourselves This surprisingly took less effort than I anticipated when I set up mine (from this [0] list) and I can see most of this modules were incorporated into "core". There is also ejabberd. [0]: https://serverfault.com/questions/835635/what-prosody-modules-do-i-need-to-support-conversations/835636 https://serverfault.com/questions/835635/what-prosody-module...
- drankula3 8y ago
- ravenstine 8y agoThe internet was way more social before "social media" came along.
- pcurve 8y agoI think anonymity was a big plus, including getting to know them part. It took work, but it was a lot of fun. Just like making friends in real life.
- buboard 8y agoOtherwise known as "unblock lists"
- lucb1e 8y agoI don't understand what you mean and can't find the term literally on Google. Do you have a link to something explaining it?
- c0nsumer 8y agoThe idea is that you didn't hear everyone, or even a significant amount of people, by default. You effectively had to find what you wanted and make efforts (joining chats, RSS feeds, etc) to tune-in. Or... make lists of things to... unblock.
- baddox 8y agoI assume the commenter means that, with modern social networks, you specify a list of people with whom you socialize, instead of previous networks (perhaps like IRC) where you stopped by and could socialize with whoever happened to be there. Of course, this is not really the case. Twitter is a great example where the default is that anyone can stumble upon your profile and tweets.
- buboard 8y agoyep , this. and even twitter is somewhere-in-between
- lqet 8y agoICQ recently disabled the OSCAR protocol, which means I am not able to use it with Pidgin anymore (well, at least until someone writes a working plugin). I really have to completely switch back to IRC, which is sort of protected against this sort of thing because it is an RFC standard.
- yxhuvud 8y ago> ICQ recently disabled the OSCAR protocol, which means I am not able to use it with Pidgin anymore Which is a strange claim, as it seems to work for me. Got the message they were turning it off, and then it just continued to work. shrug
- vthriller 8y agoNot only mail.ru, current owner of ICQ, officially dropped support for OSCAR because of new WhatsApp-esque features [0], they also tricked a lot of users into linking phone numbers to ICQ accounts [1], presumably in preparation for Russian laws about identification of IM account owners [2]. (All links are in Russian.) [0] https://habr.com/ru/post/433900/ https://habr.com/ru/post/433900/ [1] https://habr.com/ru/post/434286/ https://habr.com/ru/post/434286/ [2] https://habr.com/ru/post/428874/ https://habr.com/ru/post/428874/
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoFrom what I heard, you can still log in, but now if you try to send a message, it'll tell you that it's no longer supported. I imagine this behavior will eventually change.
- yxhuvud 8y agoMessage sending also works.
- orliesaurus 8y agoI remember using Adium with Growl on Mac for MSN, IRC and AIM all in one - good ol' days :-) I think in the online gaming industry XMPP is still quite adopted - sadly it's not easy/straightforward to find out what server and port and auth to use, because game companies don't want to have another "bot" problem to deal with. AFAIK Twitch.tv uses a slightly customized IRC for their sidebar chat while Blizzard (WoW, Overwatch, Diablo etc) XMPP.
- Macha 8y agoTwitch uses IRC (which you can connect to with a regular IRC client, but you have to authenticate with a code somewhere from their website), which is nice as a occasional small streamer as it's the only way to see chat and the user list active in chat at the same time.
- mfkp 8y agoCheck out Chatty: https://chatty.github.io https://chatty.github.io
- dmitriid 8y agoI'm surprised he could keep the list for so long. I remember every time I changed my computer or reinstalled the OS, only ICQ would diligently repopulate the contacts list. Everyone else would have to be re-added manually.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoI thought this was going to be another article about ageism in tech. It may still be, but in another way, I suppose. Good article. I liked it.
- jimmcslim 8y agoI had the same fear myself... I thought if Tim Bray can’t find a job as an older tech worker, what chance do the rest of us have?
- fossuser 8y agoI wonder if part of what caused this was poor mobile support for the existing standards. It makes sense that the companies would be incentivized to make chat applications that were not interoperable, but I think the really bad state of existing standards allowed this door to be more open than it would have been otherwise.
- rubyn00bie 8y agoA lot of people didn’t understand it then. Text messaging, in the pre-iPhone era, is what killed IM... and then it “came back” so to speak as a contentious feature of mobile phones (iMessage, Hangouts). Text messaging won because everyone had a phone number and smart-phones/data services were seen by the masses as unnecessary or a luxury. When most people send a “text” they’re sending an IM be it over WhatsApp, iMessage, Signal, Hangouts (or whatever google’s is these days), Slack, etc so it really does suck we’ve gone full circle ended up where we started. From the sounds of it, looks like it’s time for some work on making XMPP sexy.
- chrisfinazzo 8y agoThat's true and certainly the "global protocol" for lack of a better term on iOS is iMessage. Either using a phone # or email it doesn't matter, and they managed to get 95% of the people all talking to each other. <Insert speculation about the total # of iMessage users being more than possibly either Facebook, Twitter, or LinkedIn> That said, although people might be wary of the dominant messaging platform coming from the OS vendor, I don't see how Google can really connect everyone unless they are the ones who do it. If only their messaging strategy was consistent - and not half assed, they might get somewhere.
- asdff 8y agoiMessage is only popular because it functions exactly the same as SMS on an iphone aside from the color of your chat bubble, and the software defaults to it over SMS. If Apple separated iMessage and SMS into two apps, it would have failed.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 8y ago"These days, more and more are always grayed out, because they were on some other service that’s no longer connected." More likely people just stopped using instant messaging. Ubiquitous mobile email, Facebook, and text messaging has not only replaced I stant messaging but have shoved our social circle into a much narrower geographic circle. Back in the day there might have been one person out of ten I talked to online that I knew in person. Now it's just the opposite.
- lucb1e 8y agoBut.. facebook and sms are instant messaging? I'm not sure what one you're drawing.
- Causality1 8y agoDifferent usage profile. Instant messaging was typically used for real time conversations. Facebook messenger, Twitter DMs, etc are typically used for delayed messaging, where the messages are longer and the sender may not expect a reply for hours.
- hombre_fatal 8y agoI grew up through AIM, MSN Messenger, ICQ, etc. and Facebook Messenger is used the same exact way except that it has "offline receiving" which expands its usefulness. Maybe you are over-extrapolating from the fact that you stopped instant messaging as you got older.
- lucb1e 8y agoOh I see. (I thought FB was used for IM.)
- taude 8y agoDon't a lot of these tech thought leaders/social influencers all know each other on Twitter and reply to each other's Tweets? I'm not on much anymore, but that seemed to be what I saw.... I know it's not the same as private chats. But I have to assume there's quite a bit of DMing going on in Twitter?
- jwr 8y agoI hope that as people notice that the centralized data-gathering walled-gardens that track our every move are not all they are cracked up to be, we will head back to decentralized solutions which do more of what we actually want. This applies not only to messaging, but also to blog postings and RSS. Pendulums swing back.
- fumar 8y agoI agree. How do we start the movement back to a more decentralized software daily life. This is solely a feeling: I remember my youth being filled with an ever-changing and growing amount web portals, communication tools, and methods of of sharing data (music). Today, a few big entities control all of those experiences. I don't think my life is any better for having a Google controlled cloud service (gdrive) vs another open source or vendor solution. I found it enthralling to be online and discovering new experiences as a kid. Somehow that is gone today. Could just be my age.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoFor me, part of that involves quitting the old circles (FB for example) and getting used to not being in touch with every old acquaintance. Once you’ve accepted that, you’ll try any new service. I recall how switching to Mac and getting over not having windows apps helped me ultimately switch to Linux.
- asdff 8y agoThese services never went away. I browse reddit and HN through their RSS feeds almost exclusively.
- jethro_tell 8y agoA big thing here is a huge chunk of the internet is getting content discovery from just a couple places with ulterior motives. We used to seek out people who made good content and add it to a hand managed rss feed, I used to peruse 1000 articles and posts a week from friends, people that I trusted, people that I distrusted, scientific journals, and niche hobbies. I talked to someone this week that wasy saying they wouldn't even know how to find new music without youtube. 10 years younger than me and discovery is a lost art. I'm not sure what resets this, and I fear the very idea of it will be completely lost in the near future.
- jedberg 8y agoThe only reason my Adium still has anyone at all is because a lot of people sign into Google Talk automatically when they open Gmail and don't realize it. Otherwise my list would be mostly barren.
- pvorb 8y agoI thought Google had retired GTalk sometime in their move to Google+, Hangouts, etc.? Is it still working via XMPP?
- perlgod 8y agoAlthough most of my friends prefer Matrix these days, XMPP is still my favorite way of chatting. You can easily run your own Prosody instance [1] on a $5/month VPS and have a very modern chat experience - offline messages, syncing between devices, OMEMO end-to-end encryption, group chats, push notifications, HTTP file upload, etc. My wife and I use it for all our communications. There are some great clients for Android [2], iOS [3] and Linux/Windows [4] that support all the modern XEPs. Sadly, there aren't any mature, actively developed clients for OS X that I've found. Adium is pretty much abandoned. Monal is in active development though and seems promising. It's so nice to use an open protocol with native clients. Most other self-hosted chat solutions require electron apps, which can be painful to use unless you have top of the line hardware. [1] https://github.com/cullum/dank-selfhosted/blob/master/roles/prosody/templates/prosody.cfg.lua.j2 https://github.com/cullum/dank-selfhosted/blob/master/roles/... [2] https://conversations.im/ https://conversations.im/ [3] https://chatsecure.org/ https://chatsecure.org/ [4] https://gajim.org https://gajim.org
- sweden 8y ago"Easily" and "modern" chat experience with XMPP? I used to run my own Prosody server for some years before switching out to Matrix and there was nothing "easy" and "modern" with XMPP. Sure, I could get the fancy features such as end-to-end encryption, push notifications and file sharing... with Conversation for Android. But I could never properly sync my messages and conversations with a PC client. I'm glad I don't have to deal with XMPP anymore, I know that the HN crowd likes to dream with it but the reality is that it was a major pain.
- perlgod 8y agoAll those things work fine with Gajim. Probably not the case with other desktop clients though admittedly.
- pgeorgi 8y ago> it was a major pain It demonstrated that it can overcome major pain points though: Gajim (Desktop), Conversations (Android) and Monal (iOS) [edit to add: and conversejs on the web] cooperate quite well these days. Matrix? Let's see how they overcome their first major paradigm shift (such as the introduction of mobile devices with spotty ever-changing network environments, or E2E encryption both of which took a while for XMPP to handle gracefully)
- rapfaria 8y agoSo, anyone knows what happened to Mark Pilgrim after all these years?
- almost_usual 8y agoBelieve he works for Brave now https://github.com/pilgrim-brave https://github.com/pilgrim-brave
- r_klancer 8y agoInterestingly, just yesterday I was wondering what happened to Jon Udell (whom I used to read for his thoughtful perspective back in the aughts, but haven't followed in a long time.) Inspired by this post (he is listed among tbray's "grays") I checked him out. Turns out he works for Brave too. Also, TIL about Brave.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoI think he works for Hypothesis, not Brave: https://web.hypothes.is/team/ https://web.hypothes.is/team/ Hypothesis recently made their plugin compatible with Brave and Udell wrote a blog post about that, as he appears to be a Brave user -- but I don't think he works for them.
- r_klancer 8y agoOh, you're right. I was misled by the Brave post -- sad to say I'm _mostly_ unfamiliar with either project.
- dqpb 8y agoHadn't heard of Brave - installed and tried it out. I like the idea, but still see a lot of ad's.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nicoburns 8y agoIMO this is one of the key value propositions of Facebook. Almost everyone has it, it doesn't change or get lost when you lose your phone (like a phone number can), and it's likely to be around for a long time. It's excellent for remaining in touch with the long tail of friends that you might otherwise lose contact with.
- brianwawok 8y agoExcept Facebook is shrinking https://gizmodo.com/1-in-4-americans-really-have-deleted-facebooks-app-pew-1828824985 https://gizmodo.com/1-in-4-americans-really-have-deleted-fac...
- romwell 8y agoDeleting Facebook app =/= going off Facebook. I'm an active Facebook user, but no app, thank you. Mobile site will do. The app brings little additional value to me, and the easiest way to do away with the pesky notifications is removing the app.
- brianwawok 8y agoSure, but it's a step down the path. I don't do FB app and I don't do messenger. Only mobile, and only to find groups for one specific game I play. As soon as that moves on, I will delete.
- josteink 8y agoThat was true a few years ago, but definitely not anymore. Especially the teens are gone, but increasingly so is the 20-40 segment.
- lucb1e 8y agoRight, people hate it for a hundred other reasons. But I have a Facebook name that I can give to a stranger on the street and then negotiate which chat to use. That everyone has it and you see their rough location and such, is where it has some value even for a FOSS and self-host nut as I.
- gumby 8y agoI find it weird that email started as an open protocol; various companies tried to make their own private communities but those eventually dwindled and transferred to SMTP. Why did realtime chat fail to take the same path? I assumed it would.
- lainga 8y agoI would have to guess because open protocols lead to implementations which trade speed for interoperability, which is OK for e-mail, but not for realtime applications.
- gumby 8y agoI don’t think it was a technical issue. On the mail side it was a social issue — first gatewaying to the internet, then a desire to use a variety of clients. FWIW, XMPP appears to have reasonable performance.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoTechnically, it did: Internet Relay Chat (IRC) has been an RFC for over a quarter of a century. To me, at least, it's an interesting question why IRC never really broke out of "only nerds need apply" status.
- lucb1e 8y agoIRC is about as featureful as the telegraph, I'm pretty sure that's why so few people bother with it and while interfaces (bots that relay messages to other platforms and back) exist plenty, pretty much everyone would rather use something with at least scrollback without bouncer. Probably also file transfer, (video) calling, screen sharing, typing notifications, read receipts, etc.
- z3t4 8y agoThere are clients that does file transfer etc, for example Mirc. IRC can be extended with just about anything, using a direct connection (P2P), although you might need to use the same client.
- rcarmo 8y agoMost of my long-time friends are in a private Slack we are all logged onto 365 days a year. Of course, Tim's connections span a wider relationship gradient, and I just don't have any equivalent to it other than LinkedIn chat (which has its own share of problems, since not everyone I worked with actually uses it - or cares about it). (I also used to work at a place which maintained its own XMPP client - we open-sourced it on GitHub, but apparently new management decided to retire the repo... here's a fork for posterity: https://github.com/yaye729125/sapo-messenger-for-mac https://github.com/yaye729125/sapo-messenger-for-mac) However, he does raise an interesting point - the Internet is less social these days, either due to baloonning growth or lack of depth, and it diminishes us somewhat. I swapped some e-mails with Tim, and Aaron, and a few other greats (a couple on Tim's list, too), but those interactions were always fundamentally different from "open" chat.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoSlack is so hard for me to follow. Some friends of mine use it and every time I open it there’s 50+ new messages and I just don’t know how to participate.
- tra3 8y agoJust jump in, whenever. I have a private whatsapp chat with a set of friends from highschool/university and sometimes I come back to hundreds of unread messages. Just skip to the end. It's like a conversation at a party, you're not supposed to follow every single thread. It's certainly better than seeing them every few months (kids, etc).
- josteink 8y agoI helped start a independent IRC network more than a decade ago, for a closed group of people/geeks. It’s still going, but we’ve been able to observe other services draw some of those original people away. Or maybe family or real life did. Either way, few of the original servers are still are around, same with the oppers. The net is still there though, and so are many of our old users. Or should I say friends? God knows how long I’ve known them now. It's all pseudonyms or handles like the internet originally was, but it certainly feels more real than Facebook despite their "real name" policy and all that nonsense.
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoMy social circle on IRC has been consistently growing for years. IRC is not trying to monetize you. It's just trying to connect people. That, more than anything else, is why my friends and I still use it. It's been around for 30 years and I'm confident that it isn't going away any time soon. What other technology has remained relevant for 30 years? IRC is older than HTTP, and only slightly younger than GNU. Only Unix has it beat by more than a year or two.
- nvr219 8y agowhere do i go to make friends on irc
- Sir_Cmpwn 8y agoYou have to be patient - I've been using IRC for almost 15 years. Finding public channels is fairly easy, just hang out there and talk to people. Eventually you might be invited to or stumble upon some social channels. It's easier if you bring your existing friends with you. Rizon is a good network for socializing, if you're looking for a place to get started.
- jackfraser 8y ago#yospos on synirc
- nvr219 8y agothat's my favorite
- agumonkey 8y agoThere's probably an inverse relationship between medium and communication quality. The less "chrome" the better the chats.
- sandov 8y agoIs it easy to set up a secure (i.e. encrypted) channel through IRC? I've been thinking of learning how to use it, but the fact that it's not encrypted by default is off-putting. It's not IRC's fault though, considering when it was designed.
- _bxg1 8y ago"...because if chatterers can just go ahead and talk to anyone anywhere, then your service probably won’t go viral and how are you going to monetize?" I've said it before and I'll say it again: I don't think the problem is engineers, but capitalists. Specifically, grow-at-all-costs venture-capitalists (and those at FAANG, of course). Engineers, for the most part, just want to improve things. Increasing openness is one way of doing that. But right now they're getting paid tons and tons of money to do the opposite.
- ken 8y ago"Engineer" and "capitalist" aren't mutually exclusive categories. You can wave money around all day but ultimately somebody with technical skills has to write these applications and maintain these servers. I don't know what RMS or Knuth are up to these days but I'm positive they're not working at Slack.
- _bxg1 8y agoThe difference is in where someone's primary goal lies. I'd bet that the majority of engineers in The Valley wish the tech industry was less monopolized, more open, and had better privacy standards. Just look at the sentiment of your average HN comment section. But those engineers also want to have jobs doing what they like and to make a living, and while they could arguably do more to put their ideals into action, they aren't the driving force behind unbounded growth and corporate conquest; they just get paid by it. Engineers can certainly become capitalists when power goes to their head - just look at Mark Zuckerberg - but I don't think most of them are in it primarily for the amassing of wealth and power.
- ge0rg 8y agoYes, large amounts of money can help rationalize working against your ideals, especially when there are always more potential engineer candidates to do the work that your conscience tells you not to do.
- ken 8y ago> But those engineers also want to have jobs doing what they like and to make a living In the US, the average software engineer's salary is more than double the average person's salary. Nobody who chooses to be a software engineer at any of these companies has any trouble making a living. They could literally work only half the year and still do just fine. The fact that they're doing this all year tells me that either they are indeed capitalists and wish to maximize their income, or building these proprietary systems is in fact what they like to spend all their time doing. > they aren't the driving force behind unbounded growth and corporate conquest; they just get paid by it There's plenty of people in this world who have the skills to get paid far more than they do, yet spend their time and energy doing something they find more worthwhile. "We just get paid" is a dangerous slope to stand on. How do you reconcile them as idealists who want less monopolization and more openness and better privacy, yet at the same time aren't doing it for amassing wealth? What other reason could there be for doing a job one doesn't want to do? > Just look at the sentiment of your average HN comment section. People are notoriously bad at accurately explaining their own behavior.
- JohnFen 8y agoThe death of XMPP was what made me give up on chat applications entirely.
- terrywang 8y agoHaven't touched Pidgin or Adium for ages, although I've got them installed on Linux and/or macOS (really liked them). The way of IM has changed, so many social features added into IM making it more like a social chat profile presence... As we leap into the mobile age, also, over the last few years, services like Google Talk (XMPP). IM services used on a daily basis: Slack, WhatsApp/WeChat, Keybase chat (for serious stuff). Sometimes I still use IRC, very rare though.
- jethro_tell 8y agoWait a second, all of that social stuff can be in pidgin as well. It's been added to every proprietary client, usually as a repeat, but platforms all have the idea of sharing a photo, liking/loving/laughing at a comment, video chats. What am I missing that is creating lock in other than the creators themselves creating lock in?
- wazoox 8y agoI've made so many real-life friends on Usenet. I miss that. I meet them IRL from time to time, but we don't have any online community to match anymore.
- jethro_tell 8y agoI'm still in 3 IRC rooms, I meet up with a few of the people a couple times/year. It's nice, it's still out there, but it's not quite the same any longer.
- sampleinajar 8y agoInteresting. I haven't used any chat clients in my personal life for 7 years or so. I still have to use whatever my job prescribes, which is currently Skype.
- ken 8y agoThe first comment there: > now everybody needs to use a mix of iMessage, WhatsApp, and Slack It's funny whenever I see someone list the chat systems that "everybody needs to use" because they're always different. The top chat systems that I need to use to communicate with my friends/colleagues are Messenger, Hangouts, and Threema. I haven't used Slack in years, since I left tech. I've never seen anyone use WhatsApp in real life, or heard anyone ask that I install it. I occasionally use the Messages app but usually just for SMS. There's probably 10 or 12 different incompatible chat systems in common use today, and which 3-4 you use on a daily basis depends on your geography and culture and industry. And that's kind of awful.
- qwerty9876 8y agoWhatsApp is a non-US thing. In Europe, it has de facto replaced SMS
- josteink 8y agoOnly in parts of Europe. In some cliques.
- Kurtz79 8y agoIn Italy, Spain is used by just about everyone, not "some cliques", and the statment that has "replaced SMS" is a fair assessment. Can't say about other countries.
- noobermin 8y agoDitto in Asia. In Singapore, no one texts and hardly use fb messenger but whatsapp use is prevalent.
- cabalamat 8y ago> There was a time when commercial chat services supported XMPP because it was felt to be the right thing to do. There was also a time when services supported RSS for similar reasons. Sadly the web became dominated by a few big players who want to make everything their own walled gardens to keep competition out.
- z3t4 8y agoICQ/AIM died when Microsoft made Window come with their own default IM. Then people somehow moved over to Skype, then Microsoft bought skype, but screwed up, so people moved elsewhere. And Facebook happened. And smartphones happened. I think you can still reach most people via Facebook. IRC is also going strong! Gaming communities use VoIp services so they can talk in real time while playing games, there are a bunch of services targeting gamers exclusively. Old people still use mailing lists. Young people no longer use e-mail. XMPP is too damn complicated. We need something more simple, that use mostly direct connections (P2P) so public servers only are needed for discovery and NAT punching. The ID could be a public key hash, you just give the public key hash an alias on the client. Then the public key could also be used to encrypt messages. If you lose your private key you just make a new one, and tell your friends to add your new one. Other services can then use the universal ID and peer discovery services to build functionality like sending files, sharing photo albums only accessible by a set of public keys that has to decrypt a challenge to gain access, etc.
- agumonkey 8y agoThat's true ... I remember now how I didn't want a hotmail account at first but gradually other chat systems became silent so I migrated.
- lifeisstillgood 8y agoWow - how did he ever get in touch with so many people, let alone stay in touch and then be able to remember who they are and their potted histories That is why I am bad at networking ...
- ggm 8y agoReuben Hersh has written about something to one side of this in mathematics: if you drive your specialisation narrow enough, you wind up in a room where perhaps only 2-3 people can talk to you cogently. Maybe this is part of things? I overlapped with you on at least two people on that list, because of IETF but I maintain functional overlap with them on the margins. The rest have absolutely no contextual reason to know I exist and vice-versa. (Of course there are several everyone knows exist, but it is a highly a-symmetrical relationship because a time when I would have need to speak to TBL and he have need to reply has long since passed, back in the 1990s and it never happened at the time) So the author raises three points. One, is the death of open bus methods like XMPP. iMessage, Google Hangouts, use the underlying protocol but in a way which excludes exterior binding easily (Apple is a closed garden looking out) WhatsApp uses signal, but anchors in a keypair nobody else can use. Signal is about as open as it gets. These protocols improve on XMPP because they implement things like key exchange and Forward security in ways I believe work. I have no doubt XMPP encompasses this, but the client implementations seem a bit fuzzy. Adium's 'deniable chat' thing never really took off did it? Secondly, Adium is functionally orphanware. I use it, but it doesn't seem to get love and attention. Lastly, there is an age effect. I had a circle of 40-50 people I held close, I now hold very few people close and I don't feel a grumpy curmudgeon, its just hard to maintain tenuous links. S/W can only mediate so much. (I'm 57 btw and I used BSD 'talk' and UNIX 'write' for years in the eighties and nineties on ARPAnet and JANET to do this, before chat protocols emerged from the BBS world)
- tgsovlerkhgsel 8y agoSignal is a closed network, and doesn't permit people to build clients that run on their network. You can fork Signal, but your fork won't be able to talk with any Signal users. https://lwn.net/Articles/687294/ https://lwn.net/Articles/687294/
- theoh 8y agoThis just seems self-aggrandizing. There's always been something a bit off about Tim Bray's self-presentation online. Not sure how self-aware the guy is.
- dewey 8y agoAdium was / is such a fantastic piece of software. Connect to every relevant chat service from one native app. Infinite ways of customization, plugins and themes to install and all accounts under one unified contact list. The post made me feel sad—realizing what we had, and lost. Back when MSN (Was the de facto standard in Austria when the IM services got popular) a large chunk of my waking hours and nights were spend chatting with friends on Adium and later IRC. I just started Adium that I keep migrating from computer to computer to keep my custom icon even though I don't use it (Nostalgia I guess) and the apart from nobody being online the only message that greeted me was the ICQ message that it was turned off.
- ctruelson 8y agoI remember a friend of mine using Adium to send me Twitter DMs. Looks like they still have some type of support for it (https://adium.im/help/pgs/ServiceInformation-TwitterSupport.html https://adium.im/help/pgs/ServiceInformation-TwitterSupport....). Maybe we’ll see less “graying out” if we link up our twitter accounts to Adium.
- sizzle 8y agoI think my friend cohort has just grown up and stopped prioritizing online connections for starting a family. Even if AIM was still on today, I doubt I'd have an away message and be on like I was in highschool living under my parent's roof with no car or anything else to do besides homework.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 8y agoI think this is the real source of nostalgia. Kids these days are presumably still chatting to each other all day on the AIM of the era. Snapchat perhaps?
- sizzle 8y agoAgreed. I've seen Snapchat, Instagram, Facebook messenger, and WhatsApp being used regularly by younger people. I don't know how I would navigate having so many chat platform options if I was growing up today...
- pvorb 8y agoAIM, ICQ, MSN, Jabber, Skype. There were as many options when I grew up.
- icebraining 8y agoYou forgot Yahoo! Messenger :)
- sbov 8y agoIt's amazing to me how many online friends I've lost contact with due people moving on from ICQ and AIM. Back in the early 2000s, due to online gaming and hobby software development, Trillian would regularly have around 50 people online. These were not people I "collected", they were people I actively talked to for a variety of reasons: gaming, side projects, etc. But then I got a job. Got a girlfriend. Got married. I got busy. I stopped logging in for about 4-5 years. Around 2010 I was reminiscing a bit about the old times, and I reinstalled everything. There were only 3 people on AIM. Zero on ICQ. Oh well.
- kuon 8y agoI lost contact with many people since the death of ICQ, AIM, MSN and google chat. But I was able to find some of them on discord. I like discord, but it saddens me greatly that it's not an open service. I wish matrix would have taken off earlier, now that everybody is on discord, I have a hard time getting them on matrix.
- yowlingcat 8y agoI don't know exactly why, but reading this made me extremely sad and nostalgic. The very much social world of instant messenger and plain old web pages pre like-ified and follow-ified social media seems like a quaint anachronism, now. I suppose it really is, if it was 15 years ago. Some of you will correctly point out that those communities are still there on IRC and in the forums right where I left off, ready to be picked up, and you're not wrong. I suppose it is me that has changed and gotten older as well, and the world doesn't feel as magical as it did at that time. My internet, its media, and the people I shared it just seemed to electrify me so much more. Now, everything feels so dull and grey. But, perhaps nothing has changed so much as what and how I consume. What would younger me think of the mindless, lazy way I consume content on social media, and my corporate job? It would be really nice to see slow content and the digital village return again as cultural norms. Until then, I'll just have to make deliberate choices to choose them as I once did. I really wish I could make a time machine and talk to my younger self to knock some sense back into me. It's painful to look at how much fun I used to have with technology and how little I do now.
- safog 8y ago+1 - You've vocalized my thoughts much more beautifully than I ever could have. Aside from the general cultural aspect of it (better content, interesting forum discussions, Adium conversations with friends at 2AM), programming as a profession lost a bit of magic for me as well. Life just became all about getting that next refresher, the next good rating / bonus, the next promo in an almost mindless push towards higher comps. There isn't that sheer fascination / joy in discovering what you can do with technology anymore. Maybe it's because working in a generic big-co is intensely competitive and once you've given so much there, it's hard to come back home and engage in more deep thought. Maybe it's because we just got older, had families and do what normal adults do (reading some linux driver code at 2AM in the morning to get the wifi / trackpad working doesn't sound as fun anymore).
- richardw 8y agoI'd urge you to find something to tinker with. I've lost that magic a few times in my career but this last year I've started tinkering with machine learning, a side web app for finding lost pets and in the last week the ESP8266 chip for a few home experiments. Here's why. The apps are a nice distraction. You can forget about the work stresses and just play a bit. You loved this stuff for a reason, I think you can get that back. You also have more control in your own projects. No committee. 46 this month. Not super old but old enough to know what jaded feels like!
- elesbao 8y agoI felt sad...
- woodrowbarlow 8y agothey're like digital avatar tombstones with greyed-out names and touching pithy eulogies
- b3b0p 8y agoI completely forgot about Adium. If I remember, there was an iOS app too at one point? Or there was a way to have it push messages to you phone when you weren't at your computer? Slack, Discord, Messenger, ... should have made Adium clients as alternative to a full blown Electron App. That would have been pretty rad. I clicked on the source link and development tab only to be greeted by an expired security certificate error and broken Trac. I take that as it's not maintained any more. Sigh, so sad.
- idbentley 8y agoMakes me think about the stratification issues I have on my phone these days - some conversations in What'sApp, Telegram, Signal, Riot.im not to mention text messages, email etc. Becomes exhausting.
- beatpanda 8y agoI learned to write code because of a very different internet, and I feel like if I'd grown up with the internet we have today I never would have bothered. Interoperability and disintermediation were such powerful, intoxicating concepts that I turned my entire life around and started writing software for a living. These days, except for the money, it feels like a mistake.
- noobermin 8y agoAn aside to the discussion about open standards and all that: As someone who watch most of you from far away but was too young to join in, it always felt like tech was this small group of people who all knew each other. Nowadays, it seems rather crowded field, I'm surprised any of you keep track of each other.
- broabprobe 8y agoA big difference I see between the IM days and today is that there are no more away/status messages. That’s something that really prevents me from chatting with people over SMS/iMessage (the only universal ‘chat’ apps left in my life). I think even though we’re all ‘always online’ these days, I would still set my status to ‘available’ if I was online and wanted to chat. Just leave it on ‘away’ or ‘busy’ for most of the day and then when you’re online and wanting some real-time chat, open up your status and see who’s online. sigh
- jifu 8y agoThis reminds me of my time at the university. Everyone there was using IRC, and not just somehow using it, everyone had an instance of irssi running inside screen on the university's unix servers. When you were done chatting, you'd simply detach from the screen and irssi would keep on running on the background making sure you were always up to date. The first thing that freshmen learnt was how to do just that. Windows users would install PuTTy and others, like me, would learn how to install and run Linux. Every community had its own channel, private or public, and life was good. During my exchange year I was shocked to discover that this wasn't a standard practice in every university. The people at the other (non-technical) university were using a mixture of Skype and Facebook to communicate, but non of the feeling of being one big community was there.
- fierro 8y agoNot sure why, but this idea of reminiscing on the "old" internet reminds me of old Runescape. If you know, you know.
- jillesvangurp 8y agoIt's a generational thing; growing old and inflexible means that the enthusiasm that caused you to adopt tools 10-20 years ago is gone and you no longer jump onto new platforms and tools like you used to. The number of programmers doubles every 5 years. So, people (mostly techies, lets be honest) using stuff like xmpp ten years ago are outnumbered by millenials dominating the scene today that never used that. They use other stuff and are chatting more than ever. Stubbornly hanging on to IRC, Adium, or other ancient shit simply means you are not part of the conversation anymore. I uninstalled Adium half a decade ago.
- klohto 8y ago> The number of programmers doubles every 5 years. Source? This might have been true few years ago but there seems to be an opposite trend.
- jillesvangurp 8y agohttp://blog.cleancoder.com/uncle-bob/2014/06/20/MyLawn.html http://blog.cleancoder.com/uncle-bob/2014/06/20/MyLawn.html Uncle bob. This is five years ago, so if you have numbers that prove the opposite, now would be a good time to point that out.
- 3pt14159 8y agoThe reason this happened is very simple. Notifications on platforms like iOS are only possible with installed apps and a server somewhere that's capable of sending notifications. XMPP was great, it even had polling options for people behind shitty firewalls, but at the end of the day it wasn't possible to drop in a XMPP client and have it receive notifications without server support. This inherently balkanized messaging to each individual app. Further, the browser made installing applications locally a lesser-done thing, and since browsers weren't complex enough when the transition was happening (they didn't have notifications or LocalStorage at the time) an XMPP client in the browser alone (ie, sans coordinating server) wasn't possible. There will be a solution one day though. Some entity always figures out a way to aggregate the things people want aggregated. If I had to guess I'd put my money on the OS, since there is no way to hide from it. In a fight between Apple and FaceBook I know who wins. The future looks like Her (2014).
- newsgremlin 8y agoTo me it feels like many of the relationships/groups you have and people you meet in life is temporary, and the amount of effort you make to keep in touch can sometimes never be enough to keep in touch with people that just naturally drift away. I think with IM the issue is that you don't necessarily "cross paths" with people you know unless intentional. It requires some openness, sincerity and a bit of humility to make that contact, which I feel is more stigmatized, even though that kind of approach would mean people would want to talk to each other. It's the type of thing you don't get with modern internet walled gardens and I've put more appreciation and effort to the face-to-face interactions than the ones I do with a screen. But I do miss having interactions with people that had all the same interests as myself, perhaps that's the real difference, restrictions of the real world mean people with the same interests and world view are limited in number and availability by virtue of proximity. Comparing these experiences can warp your view of the world and make you question what you actually value.
- ptman 8y agoMatrix + bridges should help us technically oriented people connect with friends regardless of what they use. There are bridges for slack, IRC, facebook messenger, whatsapp, xmpp, gitter and many more.