4 ms·
> I always come prepared, with custom-made ear plugs that filter highs and lows equally. Protective preparation be damned, they played for 75 minutes and my ear
by kazinator 8y ago
> I always come prepared, with custom-made ear plugs that filter highs and lows equally. Protective preparation be damned, they played for 75 minutes and my ears rang for days.
That's what you get for using boutique plugs instead of the good old cheap foam ones that do -30 dB.
Flat frequency attenuation ... for a rock concert?
Okay, first of all, due to the Fletcher Munson curves, the perception of bass versus treble is affected by volume. If you want to hear the proper amount of bass that you're supposed to hear at concert volume, but at a lower volume, you in fact need to attenuate the highs more; certainly not flat attenuation.
Why not use wine corks for ear plugs; then you can literally do cork sniffing before putting them in.
- aunty_helen 8y agoThese are what I use, https://www.etymotic.com/consumer/hearing-protection/er20.html https://www.etymotic.com/consumer/hearing-protection/er20.ht... They're pretty good, not perfect. They remove the screechy it's too loud feeling I get at concerts but there is a little degradation in sound quality.
- ilamont 8y agoI saw Motorhead about 10 years ago with the cheap foam ones and my ears were still ringing the next day. And Lemmy warned us it would be loud. The volume some bands play at is astounding, and foam plugs, full-ear headphones (like the kind Roger Miller used to use when playing for Mission of Burma back in the 80s) and other devices may only be of limited use. I read somewhere that The Who played an outdoor concert in London in the 70s that was so loud fish in a nearby park went belly-up in the ponds they inhabited. I wonder how the kids at that show are faring now, hearing-wise.
- kalleboo 8y ago> I wonder how the kids at that show are faring now, hearing-wise. My dad is suffering terribly from tinitus he attributes to a Rolling Stones concert where he was right up next to the speakers. He says the frequency loss lines right up with a howling guitar solo. I would say they are not faring very well.
- Arbalest 8y ago> Okay, first of all, due to the Fletcher Munson curves, the perception of bass versus treble is affected by volume. This is one reason using dBA for everything is silly. They work at about 60dB SPL. They used to have a dB(B) for about 80dB, and then you use dBC for levels above 100dB. Even worse, dBA as a measure for sound limits for heavy machinery, which is a complete abuse, as this hides the power of lower and higher frequencies, and hearing damage is not interested in hearing sensitivity.
- ubercow13 8y agoI have worn all types of earplugs at concerts, playing music etc. and the flat attenuation 'botique' moulded ones sound so much better for any situation, it's not even close. If the concert really is loud enough that 25dB isn't enough attenuation maybe it's not worth going. If something is loud enough, no earplugs will make it safe.
- circlefavshape 8y agoI belatedly (47 years old, been playing bands all my life) got the moulded ones last year and they're amazing for shows. I suspect it's because all the sound engineers are wearing them too
- kazinator 8y agoYou're not even sitting in the box where the sound engineers are tweaking the mixing board. Every location in the hall sounds a bit different. Boutique plugs sound better because they attenuate less. Louder sounds better. A fair A/B comparison of two audio signals requires them to be level-matched. When two samples are being compared, where one is louder, listeners will tend to be biased toward preferring the louder one.
- kazinator 8y agoYou're not making a level-matched A/B comparison. That's like mistake #1 of audio engineering. Louder sounds better; plugs that attenuate -25 dB will sound better than -32 dB.
- ubercow13 8y agoNo, I am comparing cheaper types of plugs with the more expensive ones, with similar levels of attenuation. You are thinking of a quite subtle effect which can lead you to think louder sounds are better, when they are actually the same apart from the volume. The difference between the sound of different types of earplugs is _massive_. There is no mistaking the difference.