3 ms·
OK This kind of problem leads me to question the whole notion of "secure privacy" or whatever-kind-of-privacy Facebook is promising. So the idea, the selling
by joe_the_user 16y ago
OK
This kind of problem leads me to question the whole notion of "secure privacy" or whatever-kind-of-privacy Facebook is promising.
So the idea, the selling point, of Facebook and it's open source competitors really is the opportunity to share stuff with your friends but take it when you change your mind? Seriously?
If you think about that, it's just silly.
"at least with facebook I can delete a photo and cross my fingers that nobody has seen it yet"
Sure, in just about any system, will have a deletion mechanism that works "some of the time". If that's what you want, who cares? Post your photos on your personal blog, most of the time, you can remove it later and no one will care.
The thing is that those few things that people care about, the embarrassing Christmas photos or embarassing-drunken-comments or whatever, those are what you will want to delete and those are what will have legs - if your friends are gossips, if they aren't to be trusted to start with, they will save their browser cache or take iphone photos of their screens or whatever.
I mean, this idea is essentially personal DRM. And DRM is an invasive, adversial kind of framework. You want to send your friends informational and then control what they do with the information on their computer in their own home.
"You're my friend and I'm sharing stuff with you but I still don't trust you so I'm trying to control how you use the stuff I share with you..."
Do you really want that?
- michaelchisari 16y agoI mean, this idea is essentially personal DRM. And DRM is an invasive, adversial kind of framework. That's a description I've used before, and I think it's spot on. At the same time open source should be pushing for better privacy settings and security in social networks, we also need to be very careful about the promises we make. They say the weakest part of any secure system is always analog, and social networking is the digital representation of analog relationships. There will never be a social network where you can securely organize a revolution against a despotic regime, or be guaranteed that the accidental photo you uploaded won't go viral. We have to be honest about that, and do our best, otherwise we're making false promises.
- wickedchicken 16y agoI realize that 'personal DRM' is this idea taken to the extreme but I am not promoting this. I am promoting something akin to "deleting a post off my blog will probably take it off google search and out of the public eye, even if someone maybe saved it." I am always amused whenever I 'bypass' facebook privacy by hotlinking to a URL of an image and I realize that anyone who can take screenshots can archive as much data as possible. However, I think there is an important role to be had for deleting things that people haven't seen yet and (hopefully) without any explicit record of doing so. It has to do more with curbing the social spread of information rather than technical spread of information -- sure anyone can archive all posts and try to uncover deletions but that might be too tedious to do for anyone less important than a celebrity. Think of a regular website: when you delete content, it is not impossible to recover it by other means (google cache, etc) but it becomes much more inconvenient, which is often good enough. Honestly, I'm just curious if there is a socialist millionaire-esque algorithm which can protect a resource if access is revoked while retaining caching. I envision something that spreads encrypted data through a cloud but only provides specific decryption keys when requested.
- joe_the_user 16y agoWhat's the point? Sure, one might want to correct a typo or something but the main reason is you don't want information to go into the public eye is because it is information that the public will react negatively to. And that information that the public reacts negatively to is that information which the public saves locally, especially if they public gets used to revocation efforts. Sure you delete all your photos on your photo bucket and most will be gone but guess which photo your boss saved? I envision something that spreads encrypted data through a cloud but only provides specific decryption keys when requested. Uh, that is DRM, just not enough DRM but there's never enough DRM to do the job that DRM wants to do.