4 ms·
I'm not sure I understand the piece either, but I think it's trying to say that human memories are associative, sequential, and distributed rather than localise
by TheOtherHobbes 8y ago
I'm not sure I understand the piece either, but I think it's trying to say that human memories are associative, sequential, and distributed rather than localised.
So there isn't "a representation" in the discrete sense. It's more like the entire system changes, and it's impossible to physically scan specific elements of it to retrieve selected content.
You can trigger selective recall, but you're triggering a complex and noisy process which generates an experience that may include remembered elements - not pulling out a predictable bit pattern.
There isn't an exact equivalent in CS. Traditional binary memory is obviously nothing like human memory. Neural nets have some superficial similarities, but they lack generality.
I'm not completely convinced by the argument, but I'm glad someone is making it.
The problem with it is that we can remember specific discrete facts quite easily. If you ask me how many flats the key of F major has, I can tell you without being distracted by other memories.
What we don't know is how that fact is represented, how exactly my brain changed after I learned it, how similar those changes would be to changes in other brains learning the same fact, whether everyone has similar subjective experiences on recall, or how to scan someone's brain to check whether or not the fact is known.
- behringer 8y agoI think researchers are working on this very thing, and it seems like the brain does store "visual representations" or at least it can't be ruled out at this point. https://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/08/20/mindreading_mri_spots_letters_in_the_brain/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2013/08/20/mindreading_mri_spo... And of course, why wouldn't the brain store a visual representation of what you remembered. That would be the easiest way to store and retrieve it, which is why we do that on computers as well.
- slowmovintarget 8y ago> Why wouldn't the brain... Because it isn't how brains work. Recollection is re-experience. The article you link says researchers taught a model how to match patterns to letters, given the presumption that they are letters, for a single subject's MRIs taken while they were experiencing the sight of words and letters. Not at all the same as saying a brain stores data.
- behringer 8y agoAt some point the data must be stored physically in the material that makes up our brain. How that is stored could very well be a 1 to 1 mapping, and shouldn't be ruled out.
- slowmovintarget 8y agoAnd what if it is instead stored as I felt x, which led to y, which made me think z? It is conditioning of the pattern into neuronal potentials meaning that we can experience the same thing again. This is not the storage of data, it is the conditioning to react the same way at the start of a similar cascade. We don't record the memory, we make it easier to feel and think the memory again. Like muscles adapting to exercise, our brains adapt to experience. Keep it up long enough and we get good at it.
- behringer 8y agoIf that's the case, how can anybody recall 1000 digits of pi or whatever insane number they're up to these days? People don't recall it based on their feelings. It's memory storage. How it's done is still being worked out.
- tnzn 8y agoBecause you don't recall the digits, you recall yourself learning these digits. While doing so, you experience, you have feelings, although weak.
- jacobush 8y agoIt is very hard to introspect into what cannot be introspected... but with such things as how many flats the key of F major has (which I have a very vague understanding of what the question even means) ... I have a hunch that such data recall is incredibly crosschecked and error-corrected by correlating to many many other known facts. You may associate to maths lessons in elementary school, visual charts, piano lessons, math knowledge, that special smell of the paper and number theory (not necessarily fancy, just simple stuff) that altogether makes it impossible to corrupt upon recalling, how many flats the key of F major has. While as for the kinds of memories we easily do corrupt upon reading (was the perpetrator tall or blonde?) there may be no such data to draw from. Or worse, generalised "data" which is good for pattern matching but not for actual recall. (The stuff prejudice is made of.) If so, then there is no contradiction or problem, just a very intricate mesh of data. (Also I have an idea which is not even a hunch, but pulled out of thin air, that our "logic" and "memory" are much more intermixed in our wetware than in computers.)
- traject 8y agoThe encoding assumption in neuroscience is also nicely argued against in this preprint. https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2018/07/13/168237.full.pdf https://www.biorxiv.org/content/biorxiv/early/2018/07/13/168...
- ChrisSD 8y agoSurely retrieving an individual fact is more like a conditioned response than it is storing some bytes on a harddrive? When I say "what is 9 times 9" your brain activates all the pathways (probably trained in childhood) that lead to you thinking "81" in a similar way to Pavlov's dog.
- russdill 8y agoClosest equivalent in CS would be lossy storage, Monte Carlo algorithms, or of course, neural networks.
- marcosdumay 8y agoSo, the brain has a distributed and complex architecture. Well, did anybody not know that already? Evolution has no love for engineering beauty. If recall is possible, then there is a representation there. It's obvious that there is a representation of Beethoven's 5th Symphony on the brain of somebody that can play it. It's just a convoluted, distributed and encoded in some completely crazy signal space. Yet, if it wasn't there, the person wouldn't be able to play it.