7 ms·
When my daughter was born during the recession, my wife and I went through a stretch where money was pretty tight. One obvious expense to cut was eating out for
by munificent 8y ago
When my daughter was born during the recession, my wife and I went through a stretch where money was pretty tight. One obvious expense to cut was eating out for lunch every weekday. So I switched to bringing in lunch.
For several months, I brought the same thing: granola, yogurt, and chopped melon. I love food and love variety, so I was really surprised to discover that I simply didn't get tired of it or resentful. Every day, I looked forward to having it.
Every now and then I would have a bowl of canned soup instead, but that was literally the only variety I had. Like others in the article, I found the peacefulness and simplicity of not having to stress out about where to go for lunch more than made up for the monotony. In fact, knowing all day what I was going to have for lunch led to a greater anticipation of it.
I think this worked for me because I was only doing this for lunch and not for every meal of the day. So this actually increased the meta-variety of my eating: dinner meals were varied and lunch meals were not. So I got to experience both repetition and novelty.
It was a really interesting experience that I'd encourage others to try. In general, I think repetition and ritual tends to be undervalued in Western culture, but has always been an important part of the human experience.
- maccard 8y agoI used to do this and I did grow resentful of it, after about 6 months. I've switched to having the same thing for a week and cycling between 4 options. It's hit that sweet spot of variety and familiarity for me.
- YinglingLight 8y agoRepetition is the only thing that creates change. No one on r/fitness or /fit/ is going to call you crazy for eating the same thing each day.
- oids98d98s 8y agoI have a ton of variety in my diet. But when you're a vegetarian (as I was), to maintain a reasonably nutritious diet requires some repetition. For example, getting certain protein and nutrients in one meal so you don't have to think about it in the others. I'm no longer a strict vegetarian (just mostly), but the diet habits I learned mean that my overall diet is better, lower calorie. I now think it's important for EVERYONE to do strict vegetarianism. Not for ethical or environmental concerns, but simply because it forces you to think about what you're eating and to read labels (and thus learn that the "vegetarian" tacos you're eating have gelatin (meat product) in the sour cream). In addition, being a strict vegetarian in a sustainable way requires learning about what your body requires. After a few months (or however long it requires to build a stable, nutritious diet), you'll be extremely well informed. Of course, you could also just read all this stuff on various articles, but trial by fire is an excellent way to learn.
- akgerber 8y agoI'm vegetarian and have been since I was 12. There isn't all that much repetition in my diet. I don't eat that much 'American' food, though, because 'American' vegetarian options can be pretty limited. I just eat a ton of Indian and Mexican and Thai and Chinese and Mediterranean and other foods.
- YinglingLight 8y agoGelatin is godlike http://raypeat.com/articles/articles/gelatin.shtml http://raypeat.com/articles/articles/gelatin.shtml
- swah 8y agoI've had that thought about a simple brazilian meal as well: I don't get tired of rice, beans and a steak.
- kinow 8y agoDitto here. Been overseas for a while, but foun a rice and beans that taste like ours, plus steak/chicken/mistura. I wish I could have pingado (espresso with milk) and pão francês na chapa (a grilled bread with margarine or cream cheese). Dinner would be the left overs of lunch, of just some salad, bread, turkey... never get tired of it.
- clairity 8y agothe worst part of my experience in costa rica was eating the same meal of rice, beans, plantains, salad, and a mild and sometimes dry protein, none of which i dislike on occasion. eating the same meal twice in a row makes me not want it again for weeks. there are also very few foods that i won't eat, so maybe that's correlated with the love of variety. (variety in) food is such a simple pleasure for me that i guess i will never understand this behavior.
- jjtheblunt 8y agoI'm so glad as I read what you wrote. I also long have hated the tedium of choosing where to go, actually going, not squandering finite time fucking around with ordering when coworkers want to chat up the alternatives, when I'm lucky enough, or persistent enough, to have a job I like which I'd prefer to be doing.
- rconti 8y agoI quit eating out for lunch because I got tired of spending 20 minutes hungry, trying to decide where to go, then half the time paying money for food I didn't really want to eat in the first place.
- mixmastamyk 8y agoYou might like soylent.
- 0xbadcafebee 8y agoAs an aside, I save ~$1300 a year by bringing in lunch, and ~$550 per year in breakfast, in addition to controlling portions and nutrition. If I had been doing that for the past 10 years I could buy a new car by now, or put a pretty decent chunk into retirement. I now find it absolutely bizarre how many people at work go out for lunch.
- lambda_lover 8y agoAs an aside, I could save $XXXX a year by having a roommate/living in a worse house/having a crappier car/never going out for drinks/etc. The list goes on. There is an incredible number of things your average first world worker could give up to save money per year. The reason people spend money on these things is that they spend 40+ hours a week working so they CAN afford to spend those unnecessary dollars a year on things they enjoy, that enrich their lives. Otherwise we would all have plenty of money in the bank while we live in a 5x5 concrete cell and literally only go to work/sleep. Some things are not about maximizing profit.
- detaro 8y agoSure. It's worth a consideration though if that specific thing is one that's actually something that enriches your life, or just something you're doing because it's what you've always done. (personally, the best places have been those where a group cooks their own lunch every day, but that's somewhat rare)
- peterwwillis 8y agoI often hear my co-workers complain about their bland green smoothies or salads without enough walnuts. Meanwhile, for lunch I prepare moroccan lamb stew, chicken cordon bleu with pasta, szechuan tofu and green bean stir fry, ham and gruyere with tomato soup, pear and blue cheese salad with rotisserie chicken, loaded sweet potato with curried fried cauliflour, and quiche lorraine, among others. I'm not saying nobody should eat out, but to do it every day just seems wasteful. And I find cooking to be quite a bit more enriching than takeout.
- 8y ago
- pradn 8y agoMeta-variety is a novel concept. Perhaps we should look out for that more in our lives.
- MrMoenty 8y agoI believe the statisticians would call this heteroscedasticity. But meta-variety certainly easier to remember ;)
- gugagore 8y agoMeta-variety is like the variance of variances. Heteroscedasticity is like changing variance. Nice! I hadn't thought about that.
- perilunar 8y agoThat's weird. Never heard the word heteroscedasticity before and now I see it in two different HN threads within the hour. (the other being https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19337466 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19337466).
- aggerdom 8y agoSee further the Baader-Meinhof Effect. [1] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baader%E2%80%93Meinhof_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baader%E2%80%93Meinhof_effec...
- wil421 8y agoFiguring out where to eat lunch causes you stress? Much easier than figuring out where your pregnant wife wants to eat. Now that is stressful! Glad you were able to stick to bringing lunch. I always end up being too lazy and enjoy the break from the office or home office. If I don’t have variety I will become pretty cranky.
- munificent 8y ago> Figuring out where to eat lunch causes you stress? Reaching consensus on where to eat with my group of lunchmates definitely caused stress, especially after we'd all gotten mostly burned out on the nearby options.
- justsomeguy3591 8y agoThere is definitely something to this. I've been having a breakfast smoothie/shake every morning for about 4 years now- while the recipe changes a little every once in a while, I absolutely love the predictability of the macros, calories, and satiety I get from it. Perfect start to the day for me.
- jacobush 8y agoI felt kind of dizzy at first - your daughter... the 1930s?! Then I realised which recession you meant.
- thrownaway954 8y ago"I found the peacefulness and simplicity of not having to stress out about where to go for lunch" very often in life, we mistaken boredom for peacefulness. a simple and stress-free life can be just as, if not more, rewarding then the hectic one we leave behind.
- ChristianGeek 8y agoMistaking boredom for peacefulness is like mistaking a placebo for a cure; if the net effect is what you’re going for, it doesn’t matter.
- jacobush 8y agoVaguely dissonant with username but I like it. :)
- 0-_-0 8y ago> So this actually increased the meta-variety of my eating Wait... did you just take the second derivative of your lunch?
- genericone 8y agoKeep taking derivatives and you'll end up with rice krispies...
- blattimwind 8y ago"Higher order calculus over open food spaces"
- adrianmonk 8y agoI knew that food could lead to calculus, but I thought it was just a dental hygiene issue.
- fierro 8y agothat's where the nutrients are
- QuantumGood 8y agoWouldn't that be the third derivative, change in changes, heteroscedasticity?
- nzjrs 8y ago> One obvious expense to cut > was eating out for lunch > every weekday Honestly amazed this is the default position for anyone. What situation of living prompts this?
- mattkrause 8y agoWhen I was in grad school, there was a huge collection of food carts right outside the building. You could get a large meal of virtually any cuisine for $5-6. As a single person who liked variety and worked a lot, it was a slam dunk: fast, tasty, and relatively cheap.
- stevenwoo 8y agoIf you work with a bunch of people who commute a long way into work and do not cook and you want to fit in with your coworkers. Generally I would bring something in but be available for lunch because it's nice if you like your coworkers to hang out outside of work sometimes. This goes against my instincts for frugality. This was long before company provided lunches and the like, though, I've worked at places back then that were large enough to have on site cafeterias and we still went out most of the time. Also might be an age thing because we were all in our 20's and the veterans at those companies almost universally brought in their lunch.
- jrgoj 8y agoMany large companies have a cafeteria on site.
- telchar 8y agoCooking quickly becomes a bad time/value proposition when you're cooking for one, so that's part of the equation. And some of us value the enjoyment of many good meals over say, having a newer car. I planned to include daily lunches in my budget before I even left college (couldn't afford it at the time). I don't regret it one bit.
- manigandham 8y agoFood available at the office or paid enough to be able to do so. Very common in the major SV companies.
- amelius 8y agoI recently read that autistic people often eat without much variety. I wonder if that also holds for people with mildly autistic traits.
- usefulcat 8y agoNearly 9 years ago I started a job where (tldr) it wasn't practical to go out for lunch most if the time. Since then I've eaten sandwiches for lunch nearly every day at lunch. With some variations, but not a lot recently. Down sides: I do sometimes miss the chance to get out of the office for a bit. Upsides: have saved a bunch of money and lost about 30 pounds of weight without really even trying. Also I only need about 20 minutes for lunch each day (+shopping once a week, which doesn't take long since I mostly eat the same thing).