3 ms·
which would be very interesting, as youtube is 100% dependent on Google infrastructure to work (everything from machine learning to data delivery).
by dekhn 8y ago
which would be very interesting, as youtube is 100% dependent on Google infrastructure to work (everything from machine learning to data delivery).
- wernercd 8y agoAnd Windows was dependent in Internet Explorer to operate. And that dependence was both created artificially and then abused. Why can't YouTube switch to, say, Azure? Or Oracle Cloud? or whatever other magic exists? Infrastructure exists outside of Google - as did the ability to decouple Internet Explorer from Windows.
- dekhn 8y agowindows was never dependent on internet explorer to operate. MS put a simple DLL with HTML and other web tech in the OS, making it easier to serve up help and other content. What they did (IMHO) was completely reasonable in terms of OS integration. Look at ChromeOS today- it's the same idea, taken to its logical conclusion. People often misrepresent the MS trial.
- donatj 8y ago> And Windows was dependent in Internet Explorer to operate. I mean it was and still is dependent on MSHTML for rendering things like the help system as well as rich text in many pre-XAML apps. You don’t want the icon on your desktop, fine, but it certainly is a core part of the OSs rendering system.
- tobr 8y agoBy definition, since it's owned by Google. You can apply the same logic to any proposed split.
- gipp 8y agoNot really; chrome and Android are far more independent. YT is integrated at every level from infrastructure on up. It depends on Google-internal libraries which are in turn integrated with other parts of the infrastructure... It would pretty much amount to a full from-scratch rewrite of almost the entire product. Moreover, I'd question whether other providers even have the available public resource capacity to support YT.
- vlangber 8y agoOr give both Youtube and Google ownership of the affected code, and let them develop separately from the split.
- vlangber 8y agoSure, but those issues can be solved, both short-term and long-term.
- dekhn 8y agoI can't really see how. It would literally cost billions of dollars, be extremely wasteful in terms of duplicated efforts, consume millions of SRE and SWE hours, and the result would be slower and worse in many ways. Then people would complain that youtube sucked even more.