15 ms·
Kdenlive: an open-source video editor
- noodlesUK 8y agoOne of the things the Linux desktop sorely needs is a good video editor. I’ve heard of kdenlive before but never tried it. How is it (both for experienced users doing complex editing and for newbies just wanting to trim some footage)? I’ve also seen that black magic’s editor is available for Linux, but it is an enormous package...
- scoutt 8y agoI tried to used Kdenlive to make some very simple videos (a couple of fade-in, fade-out, some overlays here and there). Even with the latest versions (and me being a very patient person) it suffered from stability problems: random crashes, file saving problems, file corruption, horrible preview mode. I don't know on Linux, but for Windows I also had to search around and manually install some codecs because otherwise it wouldn't render to a given format (I believe it was mp4). Then I've found OpenShot, that was enough for my requirements (https://www.openshot.org/ https://www.openshot.org/). It has a Linux version. Source code here: https://github.com/OpenShot/openshot-qt https://github.com/OpenShot/openshot-qt
- camtarn 8y agoAmusingly, I had exactly the opposite experience on Windows - OpenShot crashed constantly, and Kdenlive was completely solid. I wonder whether we had different system setups, or were just using different builds?
- tofflos 8y agoI had the same experience running OpenShot on Windows and could barely get it to run for five minutes straight without crashing on very basic video editing. :(
- wired-voyager 8y agoI probably fit under the 'newbie just wanting to trim some footage' category. I had to put a presentation together using Kdenlive. Nothing special or fancy, just put together a bunch of 'day-out' clips into something nice. Not once did I have to resort to Google or documentation for help -- it was all fairly intuitive. I want to reiterate that I wasn't doing anything fancy, just trimming bits and pieces off clips here and there.
- schrijver 8y agoI‘ve used it a few years ago to edit a video* and it was great. It uses the same UI paradigm as most non-linear video editing software, a timeline with tracks on which you can place, drag and trim clips. I used Final Cut Pro 7 before and had no problems to get up to speed. It was also stable. The only reason I don‘t use it at the moment is because I‘m on OS X for now. * https://vimeo.com/107907361 https://vimeo.com/107907361
- nkkollaw 8y agoIt's the only non-commercial, non-toy video editor for Linux. I'm actually not aware of another one that uses proxy files on Linux, and with even cell phones shooting at 4K any video editor that doesn't is unusable in most cases. DaVinci Resolve is also extremely good (probably even better than Kdenlive), but it's a commercial software although they do have a free unlimited version.
- cjjl 8y ago> I'm actually not aware of another one that uses proxy files on Linux.. FYI, Blender can user proxy files, although I don't think there is an option to automatically create the proxies when you add a video clip.
- mseidl 8y agoprobably even better than Kdenlive >>> They aren't in the same league. Resolve is used in Hollywood productions. The license is cheap, 300$, If you wanted to buy it, the free version works great. The big hardware console for Resolve is 30k.
- mikekchar 8y agoI've used Kdenlive pretty extensively (as a hobbyist). It has an impressive collections of features. Different releases tend to vary greatly in terms of stability. I've had it eat my project (and even corrupt save files). Back up frequently if you use it. The last time I used it, it was pretty stable, so possibly they are improving in that area. My biggest complaint is that the workflow is tedious. There are absolutely not enough keyboard short cuts. If you apply the same transformations over and over again with slight changes, you're going to be hugging that mouse pretty tightly. My next biggest gripe is that the sound editing was really flaky when I was using it. I eventually gave up and did all my sound editing in Audacity. I often liked to do transformations with sound and video at the same time and it was really hit or miss if you could preview it, or if it would bug out, or if it might crash things. The thing is, I really want to like Kdenlive because it is really close to being able to do what I want, but I just felt that every step of the way I had to be very creative just to figure out a workflow that would work well. I eventually moved to the video editor in Blender which has a lot fewer features, but the workflow is really exceptional. I figured that what time I saved struggling with Kdenlive I could spend using other tools for features that aren't in Blender. I don't do any video editing any more (I decided video isn't really a medium that I enjoy being expressive in), so take my comments with a grain of salt.
- ktpsns 8y ago> Different releases tend to vary greatly in terms of stability. Second that. Had great and worse times with Kdenlive. My general feeling: KDE software tends to be more unstable (i.e. crash or freeze more frequently) then GNOME software. But they have in general more features. Just compare the KDE office suite, Calligra, against OpenOffice (which is however not related to GNOME). It is amazing at what speed KDE software moves, in general.
- dotancohen 8y agoWhat features does Calligra have that are lacking in LibreOffice? LibreOffice's word processor is actually one of the most feature-rich Linux software that I can think of. The presentation and spreadsheet do need some work, though.
- phosphophyllite 8y agoLinux desktop needs consistency and freedom (yes, open source desktop needs freedom). Freedom of updating and installing newer versions of software without waiting for maintainer/distro half of year to build new package (outdated next week because it's STABLE package). This is main problem of any linux desktop initiative - linux users get newer gimp after windows users. Hope snaps/flatpack/appimage solve this problem in future (snap versions of apps look ugly now).
- jcastro 8y agoThe flatpak on flathub is 18.12.2, which appears to be the latest version.
- beojan 8y ago> Freedom of updating and installing newer versions of software without waiting for maintainer Then use Arch, or some other rolling release distro. > Hope snaps/flatpack/appimage solve this problem in future These are terrible solutions, not least due to the theming issue. Rolling release is the real solution.
- phosphophyllite 8y agoMacOS model is real solution. Like really. Windows + chocolatey or macos + brew (cask) is better than any repository with dependencies on linux. Also, do not want Arch or any <distro-name> - I just want LINUX (or Desktop Linux). One predictable system, instead of many kinds/variants of basically the same programs - one system to hate, one system to deal with. (Arch wiki is good though)
- bibyte 8y ago> Also, do not want Arch or any <distro-name> - I just want LINUX (or Desktop Linux). What do you mean ? How can you have Linux without using a distro ? Are you saying there should be one official distro instead of many ?
- 8y ago
- darkpuma 8y agoI prefer blender as an NLE (in fact I know jack shit about 3d modeling, so blender is just a video editor to me.)
- snazz 8y agoSo do I. You’ll need the manual or some YouTube videos, since it isn’t the traditional UI paradigm, but if you take the time to learn Blender you’ll find that it is a very capable video editor.
- IshKebab 8y agoIt doesn't even let you do frame rate conversion though.
- snazz 8y agoI haven’t needed to do this (it’s an ffmpeg task IMO), but apparently it is possible: https://blender.stackexchange.com/questions/14999/how-to-change-the-frame-rate-of-video https://blender.stackexchange.com/questions/14999/how-to-cha...
- darkpuma 8y agoTo my knowledge it doesn't let you go in the other direction with motion interpolation though. Maybe there is a way to get blender to run a video through ffmpeg's minterpolate filter, but I haven't looked into that.
- darkpuma 8y agolate edit: if any Blender developers are by chance reading this, my greatest gripe with Blender is that it doesn't use ffmpeg for encoding, making it infeasible to leverage ffmpeg's many desirable features and supported output codecs and formats (at least not without the inefficiency of going through a lossless format. ick!)
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- maeln 8y agoI use it a bit for small things and more in-depth for a 30 minutes montage. For a free (as in free beer) software, it is really good. It support a wide variety of feature that can be extended through plug-ins, has a decent UX (even though some stuff required me to look in the documentation) and has a decent documentation (although some of it is outdated). Overall, if you are looking for a free video editor, my experience is that KDenLive is the best you will get (as of 2019). It has some obvious drawback (last time I used it, it was crashing fairly frequently, but a lot has been fixed), but if you are looking to do some amateur/semi-pro video-editing, KDenLive should do it for you.
- boudin 8y agoWhen I had the need for a video editor a few years ago, i was quite happy with OpenShot. I have nod idea how it evolved though, but back then I found it was the best balance between being easy/efficient and not crashing with the hours and hours of raw videos I had.
- CyberDildonics 8y agoLinux has a GREAT video editor, though it is not open source. Davinci Resolve is fantastic and my favorite video editor over Premiere, Vegas, Kdenlive etc. by a large margin.
- mtzaldo 8y agoDavinci Resolve is your answer
- imsesaok 8y agoI have a 5 years of experience in tinkering with After Effects (which doesn't mean that much but I can get around doing stuff) I tackled various realm of creative production, namely motion graphics and electronic music. This all started when I was using Windows and pirated program of famous tools like AE, but I was able to get around in Linux with FOSS tools. I use LMMS like a pro. I even used GIMP on Windows. This was NOT the case with video production. I was making a simple lyrics video on kdenlive, but I had to scrap the project because every time I tried to add a little bit of effect, it was half-baked or simply impossible. I cannot change size of the video without having a major headache on anchor points. I cannot "crop" a content right on kdenlive. The problem? Kdenlive is actually the most feature-rich video editor I ever tried on Linux. If you only do light editing it may work for you, but ONLY light editing. You can't have custom stuff going on as video creation tool is basically not there. I also use it as a subtitle tool... which basically sums up what your expectation should be.
- nickjj 8y agoUnfortunately for screencast videos where you record your desktop and maybe overlay a webcam kdenlive is really really bad compared to alternatives available on Windows and Mac such as Camtasia / Screenflow. It's one of the reasons why I continue to stick with Windows. Kdenlive feels like it's 10 years behind Camtasia in terms of UI polish and being able to accomplish simple tasks like put a little tooltip overlay on the screen and make it look reasonable. I think a lot of people who say kdenlive is good haven't tried Camtasia, or have created enough videos to really figure out kdenlive's shortcomings. I'm coming at this from the POV of creating 400 videos and have spent over 1,000 hours hardcore editing these videos. I don't want to tear it down too much because it's one of the better screencast video editing tools on Linux but if your profession involves creating screencast videos, you're going to be majorly disappointed compared to Camtasia (or Screenflow). Enough to where you'll probably abort the idea of using Linux even if you're primarily a developer. I wish I could throw money at the kdenlive devs and wake up tomorrow with a video editor that was as good as Camtasia.
- codetrotter 8y agoIf you want to record your desktop in Linux with a live webcam overlay I strongly recommend Open Broadcaster Software, aka OBS. https://obsproject.com/ https://obsproject.com/ OBS lets you combine multiple sources easily including adding static and dynamic graphical overlays and is basically the what all of the streamers are using on all of the three platforms Linux, macOS and Windows these days, and aside from being able to stream live to Twitch etc it is also perfect for offline recording. However, OBS is not a video editor, so if your use-case is to first record your screen and to then record the commentary afterwards rather than commenting while you are screenrecording then OBS is probably not what you want.
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoOBS is stable, packed with options, reliable, has intuitive UI, usually sets up hardware quickly and painlessly definitely try it.
- 8y ago
- bibyte 8y agoA really interesting thing is that unlike on other tasks (programming?) open source is not that visible in the graphics/animation space.
- meruru 8y agoBlender is widely used for 3D I believe.
- bibyte 8y agoYou are right but Blender is the exception rather then the rule.
- creyes 8y agoGIMP is an open source graphics program and Blender is an open source 3D graphics program. Both incredibly high quality products that are open source
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoPixar would like a word.
- jcelerier 8y agoKrita ? OpenColor.io ? Blender ? MyPaint ?
- meruru 8y agoKrita is awesome and getting traction, but most people are still on Photoshop.
- Brosper 8y agoWhy this project is not on for ex. GitHub?
- forgottenpass 8y agoDo you have a problem with the KDE workflow, or do you just want it to use tools you're more familier with?
- bibyte 8y agoNot all open source projects are on Github. In fact Github doesn't even host the majority of it.
- verin0x 8y agoIt's on their own git server: https://cgit.kde.org/kdenlive.git/ https://cgit.kde.org/kdenlive.git/
- detaro 8y agoBecause KDE as a major and old open-source community doesn't like to use proprietary hosting services when they have their own infrastructure (and probably had their own infrastructure before Github even existed?)
- eitland 8y agoYou mean why they are using git as intended instead of introducing a single point of failure? ;-) Many in the free software movement shun commercial software. To make things worse, GitHub recently got aquired by one of free softwares old enemies. Personally I've used and even recommended GitHub before Gitlab became available and I don't shun them or even Microsoft, but I also see where they might be coming from.
- quadrangle 8y agoDon't use "commercial" when you mean "proprietary". The free/libre software community isn't opposed to commerce, only to restrictions on liberty.
- 8y ago
- fuball63 8y agoI'm a musician and Linux user, so I have to lean on open source for recording and production. I use Kdenlive to do basic video creation; background music to a picture. It works really well for my purposes, in fact, I've had much fewer problems with kdenlive than with Audacity or Inkscape. Inkscape locks up my entire machine (AMD card most likely to blame) and I can't get through a recording project without Audacity crashing (been using it for years with different machines/configs, never had good luck).
- bitbang 8y agoIf you're working on recording projects on linux, why the heck are you using Audacity? Seriously, save yourself a lot of headaches with Ardour.
- danilocesar 8y agoArdour++ life changing when I started using that for multitrack recordings..
- fuball63 8y agoThanks for the tip, I'll check it out.
- abaga129 8y agoReaper is also available on Linux now! It's my go to. Not free, but has an unlimited trial. If you decide to buy it, the $60 license is practically a steal.
- danilocesar 8y agokdenlive is horrible. Really. If you ever worked with professional video editing you know that for a fact. That said: Kdenlive is, by far, the best option OSS available on Linux. openshot is trying, but is pretty unstable and not reliable for big videos.
- akerro 8y agoWow, pears are horrible for making apple pie! kdenlive is replacement for windows movie maker, not professional video editing.
- f_r_d 8y agoWell I work with professional video editing and it is my go to tool. I can relate and agree that yes it needs to improve in many aspects but all in all it attends my needs. After the refactoring version is released some cool pro features will be added like advanced trimming tools and nesting.
- rhodysurf 8y agoI like openshot a lot for quick edits and stuff but yeah it would be rough to do anything production level
- danilocesar 8y agoMy disappointment with openshot started when trying some very-basic use cases. I tried the version shipt with my distro, I tried the version downloaded from the site (which is suppose to contain specific version of the most delicate dependencies) and both failed at different moments. I even tried in different computers. KDEnlive, as I said in another post, feels like 1995's software. But it works for what it's suppose to do.
- s3xham 8y agoShotcut and openshot crash less for me in general under linux, maybe I should give kdenlive a chance again after reading about the GUI fuzzing progress. My experience has been that kdenlive is prone to crashing and saving your project often is a must
- Erlich_Bachman 8y agoAlso for any user thinking of switching to or starting with Kdenlive, they should know that in addition to crashing often (as reported by many users) it also does not support a relatively common video editing feature as multiple timelines. In Kdenlive, in one project/file, you are only given a single timeline to do all your editing in. You cannot nest them, combine them, there are no timelines to combine, there is only one of them. Since this will be a dealbreaker for many users, they should know this upfront. All respect to open source software, but for many projects using Kdenlive is just not an option as of yet.
- s3xham 8y agoVery true and another advantage for shotcut. Layering and multiple timelines is the defining feature between "oh look it's Windows Movie Maker, except worse" and a quality non linear editor. I've definitely grown cynical but I will try out kdenlive and see if it has matured. Shotcut has been my Linux go-to for several years now.
- mrguyorama 8y agoAs much as I appreciate Shotcut, it is still missing many NLE features, like multiselect
- f_r_d 8y agoMake sure to try the refactoring version. It will be out for the 19.04 release schedule.
- f_r_d 8y agoFor now in the refactoring version you are able to copy-paste clips between open instances. Multiple timelines and nesting are on the roadmap but only after finishing the refactoring and then adding advanced trimming tools.
- diimdeep 8y agoWhy is KDE software almost always available only as compile only for macOS ?
- moksha256 8y agoI'm a simpleton when it comes to video editing, but I was able to make a series of professional-looking videos without a whole lot of trouble in February. I only run Linux, so I'm not sure what I would've done without Kdenlive since I don't see what else I could have possibly used. Huge thanks to everyone who contributes to the project!
- msiyer 8y agowww.pitivi.org is a very good video editor. All videos on my YouTube channel (Two-wheel Therapy) are edited using Pitivi. It is simple, so am I. I use Arch Linux as my OS.
- morsch 8y agoI used the version of Pitivi available in Ubuntu 18.04 yesterday and for the life of me I could not get it to render anything but potato quality video (500 MB file for 60 minutes at 1080p). The deb from Ubuntu 18.10 had unmet dependencies, which is not a surprise given how interwoven it is with gstreamer. Finally, I installed the most recent version via flatpak and it rendered fine.
- unixhero 8y agoYour comment reminded me of the "First rule of Arch Linux."
- bradknowles 8y ago... Is you don't talk about Arch Linux? ;)
- unixhero 8y ago"Always mention that you are running Arch Linux."
- nacs 8y agoI've found the (opensource) Shotcut to be good on Linux (its also available for Mac and Windows). [1]: https://shotcut.org/ https://shotcut.org/
- arminiusreturns 8y agoSo I maintain a list of good gpl software, and I would also like to remind people about shotcut. I see constant activity on its github. In the Foss world usually it one give you problems the other will do. (not trying to steal any limelight from kdenlive, which is also doing great, I just like to show people Foss options)
- davidandgoliath 8y agoIs this list public? My biggest battle using linux is keeping a list of great software! :)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- arminiusreturns 8y agoLet me get back to you on that... I have an abandoned version on github that is so sloppy it's embarrassing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- PorterDuff 8y agoAs an old bored guy, I wonder if they need some help? This is a thing I know a little about. I wonder if they deal with closed captioning, titling, synching with a VTR, multicamera, drivers for video I/O cards, proper file parsing (depending on things like FFMPEG is not such a great idea), etc.
- f_r_d 8y agoThere is a big code refactoring going on and after that multicam is on the roadmap. There is also a project to rewrite the titler. I am sure any kind of input is most welcome. You can use the irc/telegram channels as well as mailing list to contact the team.
- meruru 8y agoI would definitely get in touch. I'm not following the project closely, but they have lots of things going on. The refactored timeline got merged just today which might have regressions that weren't caught. Sometimes they hold IRC meetups for people to chime in: https://kdenlive.org/en/category/cafe/ https://kdenlive.org/en/category/cafe/
- pmoriarty 8y agoWhat is it with kdenlive crashing? There's are so many other large, complex applications on Linux, but I've never in my life experienced or seen as many reports of crashes as I have with kdenlive. Is stability just not a priority for its developers?
- jl6 8y agoIt became much better for me after throwing tons of RAM at it.
- faissaloo 8y agoHands down the best libre video editor I've used, good enough to make some fairly dank memes
- proctor 8y agowhat about cinerella? when i researched what video editor to learn next after kdenlive it was cinerella. it seems to work fine, and i am surprised not to see any comments regarding it. seems like it is completely out of the running?
- linsomniac 8y agoWithin the last month I got an action cam and have started to edit videos to post on Youtube. Mostly "HOWTO" videos, because I've learned so much by watching HOWTO videos. I'm just finishing up a major remodel of my kitchen, with youtube videos being a large contributing factor to my success. Kdenlive I haven't tried yet, but is on my short list to try. I've been using LightWorks under Linux and it works pretty well. I mean, I have nothing else to compare it to, but I'm doing 4K30fps video, and a friend of mine tells me that his Macbook Pro with Adobe tools isn't up to the task. I'm running on a 5 year old PC I had in the closet (870K CPU, 16GB RAM, Radeon, SSD), and it works fairly well. The only downside of Lightworks so far has been that to export to Youtube at 4K you have to "subscribe", you can't just buy the software. You can do your editing and play with it, and export 720p video. But to export 4K, you have to either pay $25/mo or $170/year. I wasn't sure how much I'd like editing video, so I didn't want to pay $170. so I did the $25 for a month. I'm really enjoying it, but I kind of wish I could just pay $200-$300 and be done with it. Which I realize isn't rational, because that'll buy a lot of $25 months. Other ones I want to try: Kdenlive, Davinci Resolve (tried it and it segfaulted, $170/year), Cinelerra (looks kind of crappy), Flowblade. Pitivi looks to be abandoned. Maybe I should try Blender, but I don't want to do any 3D stuff, don't want to get sidetracked. There's also an online NL video editor that my daughter has used for school: wevideo. She showed it to me after seeing me running LightWorks and recognizing the workflow. I'm dealing with 75-200GB though, don't think that's going to work for online. Smaller video will probably work, my daughter uses it to voice-over a series of photos turned into video. There are a few rough edges, but Lightworks has mostly let me, as a neophyte video guy, to make great videos. Took me an hour to import an MP3 this weekend though.
- dsego 8y agoDon't forget Shotcut.
- linsomniac 8y agoThank you, I couldn't remember if shotcut was one that made my short list of ones to look at but it looks like it was.
- 8y ago
- la_fayette 8y agoI have created several screencasts and used https://www.openshot.org/ https://www.openshot.org/. I haven't used anything else yet to compare it to. But i will definitely try kdenlive!
- jonas21 8y agoMaybe this is a dumb question, but how is "Kdenlive" supposed to be pronounced?
- arawde 8y agoI've only used it a few times, but I pronounce it along the lines of "kayden-live"
- jancsika 8y agoHas there ever been an attempt to build a FLOSS video editor pinned to a single distro and a single piece of hardware (or at least single GPU)? It just seems like Linux cannot currently guarantee anything about the stability or even existence of GPU-acceleration on an arbitrary machine. So to start with that and then smear the software across multiple LTS versions of multiple distros seems like a perfect recipe for our current reality. Could maybe even build a funding model off of that. Compare a fundraiser trying to gain general stability for a buggy video editor to a fundraiser for getting "Paradise Video Editor" to extend its rock solid UX to a 2nd piece of hardware. I bet the maker of that hardware would find value in such support. :)
- shmerl 8y agoGeneral purpose GPU acceleration is accessible through standard APIs like Vulkan. If you mean specialized GPU video encoding / decoding, there is VAAPI, which is also pretty much supported on all GPUs and distros. But selection of particular codecs depends on the hardware.
- jancsika 8y agoNo, I mean limiting support to X distro on Y arch with Z GPU. Any usage outside of those constraints is completely unsupported and isn't allowed to be added to an official bug report. For example, let's say Ubuntu 18.04 LTS on x86_64 with GPU... (dunno, choose a decent one that has a respectable open source driver). Here's my question-- how much more stable would such a video editor be than the extant ones that ship with general Linux support? I'm asking because I see lots of reports that so-and-so crashes because the user installed from the ancient Debian package, or the Nvidia driver is garbage, or some library doesn't play well on some distro/arch/distro-arch-combo. I'm just curious how much of the eternal bugginess of Linux video editors can be ascribed to those problems vs. the more narrow problem of designing fast-and-stable video editing software.
- shmerl 8y agoI see no reason to support ancient drivers and ancient distros. Supporting recent enough ones is expected. But there is no point to limit architectures as long as given setup has GPU with enough functionality to provide hardware acceleration and drivers that expose that.
- marknadal 8y agoKdenlive saved us, it was the best libre/open source editor we could find, and were able to produce several professional interviews with it. You can check them out here: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-UMfJVuezk-YgNUNSgpv-fE6q5Qjokdp https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL-UMfJVuezk-YgNUNSgpv... Thanks again for such great software!
- dusted 8y agoI've done a bit of editing in kdenlive, and it's by far the best open source video editor I've come across.