5 ms·
It depends on what is meant by "define". If we are allowed to use existing words in a language, L, to create a new language, L', then use expressions in L' to d
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
It depends on what is meant by "define". If we are allowed to use existing words in a language, L, to create a new language, L', then use expressions in L' to define each word in L, a single word w, originally in L, suffices.
The idea is to first index each word v in the lexicon of L (including w), starting at 1 and ending at n, whatever is the number of distinct words in the language. Alternatively, you can index _meanings_. Then (should be obvious where I'm going with this by this point) you map a sequence S_k of repetitions of w of length k in [1,n] to each k'th word, v_k, in L. So now L' is the language of n sequences S_1,...,S_n of w each of which maps to a word (or meaning) in L. And you have "defined" L in terms of a single word, the word w.
But that's probably not at all what the reddit poster had in mind.
However, it should be noted that natural language is such that there's really no reason that we have many words- it's just convenient and helps us create new utterances without having to create long sequences of one word, as above. The important ability in human language is that we can combine words to create new utterances, forever- which we can do with one word just as well as with a few thousand.
Finally, I suspect that if there was a minimal set of (more than one!) words sufficient to define all other words (meanings) in a language, all natural languages would converge to about that number of words- which I really don't think is the case.
- sandworm101 8y ago>> words sufficient to define all other words. Often the reason we have a word for a concept is precisely because no other combination of words would do. I'd suggest that the article's attempt to "define" one word with another is an oversimplification. It is not enough to sufficiently define a word, to convey its most common understanding. To declare a word superfluous, replaceable, one must define it absolutely. For many words I'd expect such a definition to fill an entire volume, not a short sentence. The author also forgets that words have layers beyond literal meanings. Their tone, their length, and even their spelling can convey different meanings depending on context.
- antiterra 8y agoAssuming they exist, words that require an entire volume to functionally define must be rare and specialized. Plus, the question still stands: what’s the smallest number of unique words needed to write all those volumes? You don’t have to have felt schadenfreude for someone to explain to you what it is.
- adrianmonk 8y ago> probably not at all what the reddit poster had in mind I'm pretty confident the goal is to choose a smallest subset of English so that, if you know this subset of English and are given a dictionary written in it, you can learn the entire vocabulary of full English. That means you're not allowed to create any new words, so you can't create the magic uber-word w. > if there was a minimal set of (more than one!) words sufficient to define all other words (meanings) in a language, all natural languages would converge to about that number of words- which I really don't think is the case. This amounts to saying there is little to no redundancy in language. I'm not convinced. For example, once you've got "one" and "plus", the words "two", "three", "four", etc. are just convenience. Another example might be opposites: if you have "down", you don't absolutely have to have "up". But the thing is, people really like convenient ways of saying things. In fact, the economics probably drive you toward doing this. It makes for shorter sentences think of it like data compression: if a concept occurs often, you want a dedicated word for it so you can just say that word instead of saying the definition.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> That means you're not allowed to create any new words, so you can't create the magic uber-word w. Oh- w can be an English word. And the reddit post didn't say anything about not inventing a new language, with only English words (it would be a new language since it would have completely different grammar and semantics). But I think you're right that what I propose above is totally cheating :)
- Dylan16807 8y agoI'd argue that even if you take the same letters as an existing word, adding completely unrelated definitions makes a new word.
- rijoja 8y agoOf course there are redundancy a lot comes from historical facts where due to conquests and other form of migrations one language has become influenced by several. As such you could say that English is not one but rather consists of 3 or four different languages. So for English it would be rather easy to find this by looking up synonyms originating from France, Germany and even Scandinavia and of course latin.