13 ms·
Black Hole Propulsion as Technosignature
- eckmLJE 8y agoFor a captivating exploration of these same ideas in contemporary fiction, try Liu Cixin's The Three Body Problem. As a tip, I enjoyed it much better having not even read the blurb on the back of the book. It spoils events that don't truly unfold until far into the story.
- arethuza 8y agoI was going to say something similar about the Xeelee stories (I also love the The Three Body Problem) but remembered that humanity in those stories only manages to have weaponized neutron stars in a feeble attempt to fight the Xeelee.
- littlestymaar 8y agoHow funny, a friend recommended it to me last week and I just started reading it yesterday. I'm only in the beginning, but I must say I really like it so far.
- shrimp_emoji 8y agoIt starts with a horrifying dive into '60s Revolutionary China, then veers off into an extremely surreal and nerdy anime plot, and proceeds on a very cool and foreboding sci-fi arc (I think; I don't remember how much of the sci-fi it has vs. how much of it is in the two sequels).
- pradn 8y agoThat's a good way to put it. The novel series manages to have 1) brilliant and highly imaginative set-piece sci-fi events 2) ruminations on the possibly dark nature of humanity in space 3) amateurish characters - save two or three 4) universal-scale scope 5) awareness of just 6 countries in the world : all at the same time.
- elorant 8y agoAnd a lame ending compared to the rest of the trilogy. It's like in the last 50 pages he run out of ideas.
- eximius 8y agoIn his defense, he explored quite a bit. I really had kind of hoped to get a glimpse into what he'd have come up with for if the universe restarted.
- littlestymaar 8y agoEnding is hard, and when it comes to sci-fi series it empirically looks impossible: I can't remember a single one whose end wasn't disappointing.
- Florin_Andrei 8y ago> Liu Cixin's The Three Body Problem His vision of the future is bleak in the extreme. His characters are naively constructed and occasionally make incomprehensible choices. The worst sin is he's unsure whether he wants to write hard sci-fi or just mostly "fi" with a thin veneer of "sci". Occasionally he seems like he wants to stick to solid science with a few extra assumptions (in the best tradition of hard sci-fi); but then he veers off into some cartoonish "science" that's quite jarring. In the end, you get the impression he just tries to brag about how much science he "understands". In the end I was reading it the way some folks watch a bad movie - to make fun of it. If you want cosmic scale hard sci-fi, try Stephen Baxter. He can be a bit dry at times, but that's his only fault.
- pasabagi 8y agoI'm completely with you. It baffles me how many people loved Liu Cixin's book. It's written like a 70's era 'ideas, no execution' sci-fi novel, but the ideas are terrible. I mean, the central 'xeno-anthropology' thing, that's treated as like a deeply profound maths proof, is kinda a brain fart. If you read a writer like Peter Tchaikovsky, you get actually interesting ideas, and really good execution. And I'd say PT is pretty mid-range for contemporary sci-fi authors. People like Yoon Ha Lee or China Mieville are really pushing the genre forward. Lui Cixin's work on the other hand reads like one of those 70's books about uplifted dolphins and sexy spacewomen, all robotic characterization and uninspired writing.
- Florin_Andrei 8y ago> It baffles me how many people loved Liu Cixin's book. If this is the first sci-fi book you read, and especially if this happens at an early-ish age, I imagine it may seem impressive.
- natosaichek 8y agoI think you mean Adrian Tchaikovsky, right? Peter was a great composer of music, but not SF. Where would you recommend someone start with Adrian Tchaikovsky?
- ohaideredevs 8y agoThe Three Body Problem is officially the most overrated book on Hacker News. I am trying to understand why. It has no soul, the "science" is garbage, not a single character is memorable, it's way, way too long for what it is.
- colordrops 8y agoI would mostly agree, but having lived in China and studied Chinese for several years the element of Chinese culture and history intermingled with sci-fi made it a lot more intriguing to me. Also, it was a great way to practice reading Chinese.
- otabdeveloper2 8y agoEh? It reads like a book translated into Chinese. It's probably one of the most not-Chinese Chinese books you can read.
- colordrops 8y agoWhich makes it an easy first book for a beginner.
- flukus 8y agoI mostly agree but I still enjoyed the story, at least until book 2, the ending of book 3 was horrendous. For the "soul" I gave it the benefit of the doubt, maybe Chinese writing different from western writing or something get lost in translation. For the characters I don't know if it's them or me dealing with Chinese names, I get lost playing games like shogun total war because of this.
- wazoox 8y agoI'm reading Shuǐ hǔ Zhuàn right now, there are 108 heroes along the ~2000 pages but somehow the most important remain memorable enough: Gao Chai, Song Jiang, Li Kui, Wu Gong... See, I can even remember some names :)
- kristianp 8y agoI really enjoyed the trilogy, some clever and original stuff there. I didn't enjoy the third book so much, but don't want to spoil anything.
- ethbro 8y ago> events that don't truly unfold until far into the story Aka "the last 100 pages, where something actually happens."
- JohnJamesRambo 8y ago>Remember the methodology: A spacecraft emits a beam of energy at a black hole that is moving towards it, choosing the angles so that the beam returns to the spacecraft (along the so-called ‘boomerang geodesic’). With the beam making the gravitational flyby rather than the spacecraft, the vehicle can nonetheless exploit the kinetic energy of the black hole for acceleration. > Light acts the same way, but light cannot return faster than the speed of light. Instead, in gaining momentum from the black hole, the light blueshifts. How do you get propulsion from blueshifted light?
- dmitrygr 8y agoEmit low energy photons, expend energy X, receive higher energy photos with energy Y (Y> X) Maybe this way?
- extropy 8y agoYes I want my free energy device too.
- thatcherc 8y agoThis isn't a free energy device because you're extracting energy from the rotation of a black hole (this process only works on rotating black holes). After a long enough time, you could extract all of the angular momentum from the black hole using this method.
- mrfusion 8y agoI can see how you gain energy but you’re also putting yourself deeper into a gravitational well that you’d have to expend energy to get out of. Wouldn’t it be a wash?
- ceejayoz 8y agoWe do this fairly regularly with space probes already. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_assist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gravity_assist You steal energy from the object you're slingshotting off. The black holes are slowing (infinitesimally) down every time you do it, gifting their energy to the accelerated object. Hence the article talking about potentially detecting this sort of behavior by monitoring for prematurely merging and overly eccentric binary black holes.
- simonh 8y agoThe problem with firing lasers at a black hole light years away is beam spread. Using the biggest best telescopes we currently have, at our admittedly miserable technology level, the tightest beams we can project on as close a target as the moon are kilometres across. Even if we were to create a mirror as wide as a planet to create a beam, it would be many, many times that wide by the time it reached the binary system. It would be further diverged by the slingshot round the black hole (or neutron star), and diverge further again on it’s way back to the spacecraft. I don't see any way such a system could be made practical.
- _Microft 8y agoIf you have the technology to reach the nearest binary blackhole ("you just have to pay the one-time fee of the cost to reach the nearest binary black hole system", at 16:12 min in this video: https://youtu.be/rFqL9CkNxXw?t=972 https://youtu.be/rFqL9CkNxXw?t=972 ), you can most likely deal with the mirror/energy harvesting problem as well.
- 781 8y agoA civilization using this method might not use optical systems to focus the beam like we do, but might individually fire precisely aimed photons.
- thatcherc 8y agoYou'll have a similar problem due to the Uncertainty Principle. Even a single photons will experience the same kind of diffraction as a beam of photons, limiting the degree to which you can aim it.
- rickycook 8y agoassuming that we got that right and didn’t just misunderstand what we are seeing (or assuming that there’s no “side channel” to know how to correct for it) we also can’t get to a black hole, so for this civilisation it’s safe to assume they have a significantly better understanding of physics than us. we don’t know what we don’t know
- Rooster61 8y agoInteresting concept. Why couldn't we do this with matter? Instead of firing light off at black holes, why not fire some material around a gravity well and allow it to strike the spacecraft in a way that it A) imparts the inertia it has gathered from whatever body you shot it around and B) is captured to be fired again at a new angle according to your new position? I know there are a ton of logistics to wade through with this, but it should be at least hypothetically possible. It's the same concept as in the article, save for the fact that we are now firing matter around objects we actually can reach in our lifetimes rather than light around black holes that would take an exceedingly long time to propagate.
- ajkjk 8y agoSo: shoot ourselves, catch the bullet, shoot again? I think the logistic issues of catching a bullet are probably the limiting factor here. Light at least _wants_ to be absorbed. Matter just wants to go through you.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lodi 8y agoYou're proposing to fire some material around a planet in such a way that it comes back to a mothership with more momentum than it started with. Now imagine that instead of going "there and back", you find a trajectory that sends it from planet A, to planet B, then back to the mothership. You're coming back even faster now! Why stop at two planets? Find a trajectory so you can do planet A, planet B, planet C, perhaps planet A again... and so on. Now just delete the mothership from this picture; the 'material' is the spacecraft itself. This is a gravity assist, and by stacking enough of them you can basically pick up as much extra delta-V as you want (at least until you reach Solar escape velocity). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Transport_Network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interplanetary_Transport_Netwo... The main drawback is that it can take decades of flying a convoluted series of gravity assists before you get to where you need to go, and that's all within one system. (The two-body idea you proposed has the same problem. The mothership has to sit there and wait while the matter flies back and forth on multi-year long orbits. Also now you have to figure out how to 'catch' a hypervelocity projectile...)
- LastZactionHero 8y agoI love Centauri Dreams. It's hopeful, makes me feel perspective, and realize how small and primitive we are. We fret every day about consumption, waste, and energy, and here are some people discussing methods of moving planet-sized objects. It's a kind of optimism that's so rare it almost feels outdated.
- theothermkn 8y ago> We fret every day about consumption, waste, and energy,... I'm afraid we have to keep fretting. In the Numberphile video about the number of particles in the Universe (https://youtu.be/lpj0E0a0mlU?t=378 https://youtu.be/lpj0E0a0mlU?t=378), they take an interesting diversion to ask "How long until every particle in the Universe is inside a human being?" In other words, when will we reach the ultimate limit to growth? Well, at the current annualized population growth, it's less than 9000 years! And that scenario involves every human being at that future time floating around naked in the vacuum of space. There is no food to eat, water to drink, nor air to breathe left over. Practically, this means a couple of things that are less than obvious. First, the best case is that we will reach a point where the growth in volume of the space we occupy will exceed the speed of light. In other words, "long" before 9000 years from now, we will either establish some sort of equilibrium, or we will run up against a hard Malthusian limit. We will absolutely be concerned about "consumption, waste, and energy" in a way that is far more focused than it is now. (The only economic models that are permitted to work are zero-growth models, practically speaking.) Second, to give you an idea of how soon this is coming, the Universe is much larger than 9000 light-years across. That is to say, even if we could manage the resource usage of our 1.011% growth rate optimally, we could never actually fill the Universe in that time frame, as it would take about 15 billion years or so if we were all flinging ourselves outward at very near the speed of light. (n retrospect, these two are restatements of the same idea.) Finally, and most dismally, the analogous calculation for the Solar System (an infinitely more reasonable calculation to perform) must be abysmally worse and monumentally more urgent. To give you an idea, the current doubling time of human population is something like 60 years. That means, for example, that if we were to anticipate that we'd run out of meaningful room on Earth in 60 years' time, we'd have to start working on our "second home" now, to have it ready. Once it was ready, we'd have to be working on two more. Then four, and so on. Good luck with that! (Note: After we have consumed the Earth and converted it to habitats, we will have to consume Jupiter in a similar way in about 500 years. This gets out of hand very quickly.) EDIT: El-oh-el at the few people who's fee-fees were hurt enough by this back-of-the-envelope analysis of growth rates and resource use to downvote it. Keep fighting the good fight, no matter how lonely!
- Footkerchief 8y agoAlthough this article doesn't make it clear, the underlying concepts (like the light slingshot / "halo drive") are explored in more detail in a previous article: https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2019/03/05/investigating-the-halo-drive/ https://www.centauri-dreams.org/2019/03/05/investigating-the...
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> No fuel is spent aboard the spacecraft which, using stored energy from the beam, continues to accelerate up to terminal velocity Wouldn't fuel need to be expended on the ship to generate the beam? Or is the beam reflected back to the black hole for re-energisation?
- jacobush 8y agoA mirror should do it.
- MuncleUscles 8y agoYou reabsorb the beam which now has even more energy because it's been blue-shifted, which means you can actually charge your batteries as well as accelerate.
- mudil 8y agoA question for a physicist from a layman. All objects in the universe are connected to each other through gravity, no matter how distant. So what happens to the energy or mass of an object (or total energy/mass) in the expanding universe? As space inflates, the distances are greater between objects, so where the excess of gravitational radiation went to? Can that account for the dark energy?
- sandworm101 8y agoGravity is not radiation. The expansion of the universe does work against gravity but there are limits. Gravity decreases with distance. So if the universe is expanding fast enough (it is) it will overcome gravity. Imagine setting a bomb off between two asteroids. Use a small bomb and they move apart but eventually drift back. Gravity wins. But use a big enough bomb and they both hit escape velocity. Gravity looses. The objects are moving away from each other fast enough that the force of gravity falls away so fast that it will never turn them around let alone bring them back together. Dark energy is the concept that while the universe is expanding, gravity wins / everything is at escape velocity, it shouldn't be expanding faster. Dark energy is the fact that the two asteroids separated by the bomb (the big bang) aren't just at escape velocity, something is causing them to accelerate.
- aeorgnoieang 8y ago> Gravity is not radiation. 'Gravitational radiation' is, apparently, a thing; gravity waves basically. It's not _electromagnetic_ radiation tho, which is what I'm guessing what you meant. I don't think it's crazy to think that gravity is propagated at the speed of light but that we can't, and likely won't ever be able to, measure any gravity waves smaller than those generated by extremely large-gravity systems.
- not_kurt_godel 8y ago> All objects in the universe are connected to each other through gravity, no matter how distant. I don't believe this is correct, as gravitational force/bending of spacetime moves at the speed of light.
- 8y ago
- ConcernedCoder 8y agoSo if I shoot a beam of, let's say, a movie or live feed of myself typing this comment around a black hole some 50 light years away precisely enough to have it land back here on earth 100 years in the future, would an observer see back into the past 100 years? ...in the same thread if I observe precisely enough a position near a black hole some N light years away could I see what was happening on the earth N*2 years in the past?
- aeorgnoieang 8y agoBased on other comments, and my own very limited knowledge of the relevant physics, there's no way to do this from Earth; all of the black holes (and binary block hole systems) are too far away for us to reliably aim a laser beam to slingshot around the black hole as is being described. But the general form of what you're describing isn't any more outlandish than a time capsule, i.e. 'transmitting information into the future'. But no, sorry, you can't see the past with the paucity of black holes near the Earth (and ignoring all of the other impediments to such a thing happening).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- saagarjha 8y agoYes, but there's an easier way: use a mirror. Depending on how far you place it, you're looking at yourself in the past.
- lutorm 8y agoYes, this is just a special case of the fact that when you look at something N light years away, you're seeing the object as it was N years ago. You're always seeing the past, never the present! Most of the time in everyday life it's infinitesimally close to the present, though.
- edem 8y agoRelated: [Black Hole Bomb](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ulCdoCfw-bY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ulCdoCfw-bY).
- dana321 8y agoIf you think the title of this is pure porn, check out those images!
- edem 8y agoWhy not have an actual black hole on the ship and use the Hawking radiation to gain energy? More [here](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzZGPCyrpSU&feature=youtu.be&t=461 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzZGPCyrpSU&feature=youtu.be...).