11 ms·
It's articles like this that make me wonder how much of our middle class burden comes from hidden rent seeking parasites like this. I honestly don't know. I'm
by jerf 8y ago
It's articles like this that make me wonder how much of our middle class burden comes from hidden rent seeking parasites like this.
I honestly don't know. I'm not trying to imply any particular thing. I honestly wonder. These sorts of things can stack up through the layers of companies that make things.
And where does this money go? What does it end up doing?
- mbell 8y agoI worked at a sunglass hut part time during college. The _vast_ majority of sunglasses I sold were for fashion, not function. People weren't paying $250 for the lens, they are paying $240 for the style and 'real' D&G logo and $10 for the lens. In my time there I would say the only brands you should buy for performance are Maui-Jim (great lens / polarization) or Oakley (impact safety), everything else is junk lens put into fashion frames, including Ray-Ban, though their glass lens were at least passable. EDIT - I mean amongst the brands they carried, I'm sure there are other good lens manufacturers out there. What I'm mostly saying is that I don't see this as rent seeking, it's just people willing to spend large amounts of money for fashion.
- perfmode 8y agoare prescription lenses not priced along the lines of the fashion lines?
- dustindiamond 8y agoIt is just the frames, the lenses cost additional.
- mbell 8y agoI don't know as much about that side of things but as I recall Luxottica didn't make the prescription lens, they were ordered to spec from a third party. They sold and manufactured the frames and did the fitting work (which does some times require significant work on the lens like reshaping or drilling holes). This was ~10 years ago though so that may have changed.
- acct1771 8y agoIf you're not ignorant, no.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y agoAt the same time if I walk into a sunglass hut thinking that it is a neutral marketplace where many brands compete for my purchase across the dimensions of fashion AND price I am being deceived. sunglass hut and most of the brands inside of a sunglass hut are owned by the same company which is not competing with itself but instead acting as a dominant firm using it's price-setting power to increase how much I'm going to be shelling out when looking for a pair of sunglasses.
- sampo 8y ago> the only brands you should buy for performance are Maui-Jim (great lens / polarization) or Oakley (impact safety) Sunglass Hut doesn't sell them, but Serengeti makes some great lenses. Maui Jim might even not make lenses that are both photochromic and polarized, but Serengeti does.
- RandomTisk 8y agoSerengeti with amber lenses are my goto sunglasses for driving since about 2 years ago. I used to wear nothing but Ray Bans but the dark tint inhibits overall visibility slightly where the Serengeti's seem to augment it, while both cut out glare like they should.
- standerman 8y agoSunglass Hut is owned by Luxottica and sells their products: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxottica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luxottica Yes they do really produce that many different brands.
- eberkund 8y ago> And where does this money go? What does it end up doing? Some of it goes to providing jobs to those same middle class people.
- bigdubs 8y agoThe share of incomes from private businesses (especially luxury businesses) isn't flat and benefits mostly the executives and directors and shareholders.
- wbracken 8y agoHow can you say that? Luxottica employs 85,000 people. Do those people obtain no benefit from employment?
- cazum 8y agoWhat? Nobody is claiming that they don't. What is being claimed is that the majority of those employees are not seeing an increased benefit (wages) proportional to the increased profits of the company they work for, whereas shareholders and executives do.
- wbracken 8y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/esop-essilor-employee-shareholders-2018-11 https://www.businessinsider.com/esop-essilor-employee-shareh...
- Someone1234 8y agoIf there was healthy competition that same number of jobs may be split over multiple companies, but it would still have to exist since the market for the product itself wouldn't change. That isn't an argument for not breaking up a monopoly. Only an argument that the market may be big enough to support actual competition.
- volkl48 8y ago
- bdamm 8y agoRight, it's almost a collective statement on our health and priorities that allows parasites like this to thrive. What I mean is that obviously, in general, we can afford $800 glasses even though we may hate it. But it isn't, for most people, coming at the expense of food, cars, rent, etc. It is not good free market operating, though, and should be forcibly interrupted.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wbracken 8y agoEmploying people at each step in the eyewear industry. Plus, employing people at companies who support the eyewear industry. Plus, employing people at companies that support the companies that support the eyewear industry...etc. etc.
- Someone1234 8y agoWhy would any of these jobs be lost in a more competitive eyewear industry? People keep repeating this talking point, but I don't understand what they mean. Nobody is asking for the eyewear industry to stop existing. We're talking about a single monopoly controlling the majority and driving up prices. How does an artificially high price and artificially low competition generate more jobs?
- wbracken 8y agoI never said there shouldn't be competition. The parent asked where money goes...
- fouc 8y agoI don't believe the previous poster actually included any value judgement in their comment. Basically the administrative overhead of all the layers is what is taking the bulk of that money. I agree that those jobs can be redistributed elsewhere instead.
- mhb 8y agoIf you're suggesting that all these jobs are good, for their own sake, then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window
- aj7 8y agoOnly if there’s no learning. The Apollo 1 fire, countless air disasters etc. led to much greater safety.
- 8y ago
- sampo 8y ago> how much of our middle class burden comes from hidden rent seeking parasites like this. If you include the unwillingness to respond to demand by building enough new homes in the popular urban areas, probably a lot. A 1000 sq.ft. home (house or condo) should not cost more than $200,000 to build. Anything above that, someone is making profit.
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoIt doesn't even seem like anyone has interest in building $200,000 houses anymore, but they will sell you a poorly made condo for $400,000 and $600/mo HOA fees. I am a single person trying to find a house that is not four or five bedrooms (I only need one or two) and doesn't cost 1/2 mil minimum and it's difficult. This used to be called "the starter house" but it doesn't seem to exist anymore with new construction.
- TheLoneAdmin 8y agoThe biggest cost in any metro area is land. There are few empty lots left to build on, and those go for a premium. Not going to give any specific listing publicity, but "$350,000 USD for 0.047 acres empty lot" is common in the residential parts of Atlanta. We recently paid $25M for 8 acres with abandoned warehouses on them, to build condos on. We're still looking at $100k land costs per condo. Go out two counties and a 1.5 hour commute, and land is only $5k/acre. Plenty of $200k starter homes in that area. No one wants to move out there though. Disclaimer - I work in the residential construction business
- dustindiamond 8y agoIt pays for leasing storefronts.
- munk-a 8y agoOh absolutely... the concept of a thing I'd call a "restaurant" that would need four times the footprint, something like 5% of the ratio of sale price / cost per unit and would take about 90 minutes to finish servicing a customer must be an entirely ludicrous fantasy I dreamed up last night.
- commandlinefan 8y agoWell, my first thought was - if eyewear can be produced for less, why doesn't somebody take advantage of the opportunity and do so? Capitalism at its finest and all that. But the answer immediately struck me: if somebody was offering a product at half the cost everybody else was, I wouldn't trust it - and I suspect most other people wouldn't, either. Considering the size of the initial investment, this upstart wouldn't be able to get enough traction to stay afloat.
- onychomys 8y agoMore importantly, when you have a giant company with a monopoly on something, they don't have to compete with you, they can instead just buy you up.
- mrguyorama 8y agoWhich is what the company behind lenscrafters did. IIRC, Oakley tried to compete fairly, and not play their monopoly/collusion game, so Luxottica threatened to pull from any stores that carried Oakley. When Oakley inevitably lost a huge amount of sales and the companies value tanked, Luxottica bought them. Nintendo did the same thing, minus the buyout, in the eighties when video game manufacturers tried to subvert Nintendo's control in that market. You don't need a full fledged monopoly to upset market forces. Even the existence of a single large entity that can make unified decisions destroy a healthy market
- ams6110 8y agoThat's not how the market works. You may think that way, but most people shop on price above all else.
- munchbunny 8y agoCompanies can and do, e.g. Costco, for prescription glasses anyway. I bet what often happens instead is that the higher margin company just buys out the cheaper guy, and... it's back to the higher prices!
- 8y ago
- guelo 8y agoRent seeking is a large part of the pharmaceutical industry, which is 4% of the economy. And also a good chunk of the rest of the health care industry, which is 18% of the economy.
- barry-cotter 8y agoIt doesn’t show up in their profit margins. If they’re rent seekers Roche, Novartis, Pfizer and GlaxoSmithKline are really bad at it.
- jopsen 8y agoIsn't this just as much another fashion trap? Many things from underwear, glasses, clothes to paper tissues are branded fashion items. None of these items are expensive to make, we just don't buy the cheapest.. probably you can find cheap glasses somewhere online, if not there's probably a business opportunity in that :) Question: do people want to buy cheap glasses, clothes, underwear? Or do they want to buy branded Kleenex tissues?
- fromthestart 8y ago>Question: do people want to buy cheap glasses Absolutely, so long as they function. What do I care if the microprint logo on the frame is a recognizable brand? Especially if I'm buying frameless glasses where there just isn't much material work with for fashionable design. Just give me good lenses and a minimalist frame that won't fall apart. I don't want to pay $200 for $5.00 worth of titanium that people can barely even see on my face.
- DanieI 8y ago> Question: do people want to buy cheap glasses? Yes, I grew up with my Mom taking me to an expensive glasses store and the salesman's sales pitch was, "My stuff is the best because it's expensive". I didn't know anything because I was age 7 or 8. I was sort of indoctrinated into shopping there, but a few years ago an online store called Googles4u had a $10.00 for glasses and frames deal. It was likely as a loss-leader, but I realized that I didn't see any better out of the expensive Elissor / Hoya glasses with all of the top-of-the-line coatings than I did the no-name cheap glasses. They also made me feel a lot more relaxed. Before I was so worried about dropping them or losing them in the water but now I had a carefree attitude.
- refurb 8y agoI think you'd be surprised just how many markets like this exist where there is a ton of slack in the system and profits are high. In terms of the impact on middle class, I think most of these markets tend to command a relatively small part of a household budget.
- dalbasal 8y agoIt's complicated, inevitably. This is not just increased cost to the middle class (and anyone who wears glasses, presumably), it's also their income. For the most part, price inflation is a result of and/or caused by increased spending. Complimentary optometry at the mall of your choice. Attentive salespeople standing at glass counters. Brand licensing galore. I would imagine there's a substantial corporate layer, social media coordinators... Profit too, of course. It sounds quite lucrative. It's interesting to note that a lot of economists predicted we'd be working way less by now. Keynes is a famous example. It's interesting because the theories haven't changed much, and the assumptions keynes and others made about growth and efficiency were about right. Modern economists generally explain this as "people had an unexpected ability to consume more." I get the impression their not entirely satisfied though.
- seem_2211 8y agoI think there are a few interesting wrinkles with regards to rent seeking in the current economy and how that works out for the middle class. • As a few people have pointed out, people often buy sunglasses for fashion and social signaling rather than on price. Wearing Tom Ford glasses means you're getting very good quality glasses, but mostly you are paying to wear Tom Ford glasses, in the same way that a Rolls Royce and a mid level BMW are functionally very similar, even though there is a 5x difference in price (if not a higher change). You're paying for the styling and the brand name. • Where the money goes: for a lot of consumer brands, huge sums go into brand advertising. B2B companies spend this money on salespeople and tradeshows. I like to give the example of a Rolex. A new Rolex is worth $10-15k (if not more) because they spend tens of millions of dollars every year telling us all that that's why they're worth so much. Compare that to a lesser advertised brand - say Tag Heuer, and you'll see there's a pretty big difference in their pricing. Traditionally this money has gone into magazines / billboards / tv commercials / sports sponsorship - so this money is subsidizing middle class entertainment. On the B2B side, if you engage with a company like SAP, you'll get a professional sales team walking you through the buying process (they'll probably even spot you a few nice dinners along the way). • "Rent seeking" is an interesting term, and while I agree with it in the context of sunglasses, it's a bit hard to nail down in a lot of the economy. Price is funny because lots of the things we produce now (particularly software, pharmaceuticals & entertainment) have revenue models that don't see much of an increase in marginal cost once you've covered the initial investment (10k people see your movie in cinemas vs 1m - provided you've got the infrastructure in place, it's not like the price of producing the movie goes up 100x). • The culprits for the "middle class burden" is often pointed at healthcare and higher education for the simple reason that they have dramatically increased administrative costs which ultimately haven't added much (if any) value to the consumer (people argue my first point with regards to higher education - perhaps a Harvard education is worth $60k a year, although it's hard to see many other colleges worth that much for the brand alone).
- troels 8y agoCurious - Where do you have the information fro that TAG have a smaller advertising budget than Rolex? I would've assumed the opposite.
- jononor 8y agoA lot of middle-class jobs come from enabling these rent-seekers. Not sure if that counts as 'burden'...
- LifeLiverTransp 8y agoPaying into huge pension fonds who hold whole industries- we are effectively take for a ride by the baby-boomers to a bitter end. No anti-trust laws of course, because those who benefit are the most loyal voters.
- coldtea 8y ago>It's articles like this that make me wonder how much of our middle class burden comes from hidden rent seeking parasites like this. One third of it. The other third is from advertising: a huge industry using all kinds of manipulation, psychological tricks, constant brain washing, and (nowadays) surveillance, to make us buy all kinds of crap we don't need, and didn't want until yesterday. And the last third is from jobs that make the middle class so tired and give it so little time and space, that shopping feels like therapy, and giving in to rent-seeking is the only option.
- DesiLurker 8y agoAt one point I made a list of biggest expenses a person faces in their lives and was shocked to realize that pretty much everywhere there is either a company or consortium that has captured the market and manages 'access' to it. This is not surprising. in fact I would imagine that as more and more automation takes hold & marginal cost to produce real goods falls to near zero you'll see only the players left standing will be the ones either with some kind of an "in" or monopolies. If you probe further you'll realize the companies with largest margins (basically ripoffs or to use Mr Buffets's lingo 'moats') will be (are?) the ones with most resources to spare on marketing and media. so the inevitable outcome will be massive corruption of public discourse and loss of clarity for common man. sounds familiar?
- barry-cotter 8y ago> At one point I made a list of biggest expenses a person faces in their lives and was shocked to realize that pretty much everywhere there is either a company or consortium that has captured the market and manages 'access' to it. None of healthcare, education or housing have even as high a concentration as online retail unless you’re going to count government provision of primary and secondary education. I struggle to imagine what other spending categories you could be referring to, certainly not food or clothing.
- DesiLurker 8y agoSorry I was offline for a bit so couldnt respond. But I find it surprising that you picked 3 most messed up sectors in america as basis to refute my argument. Anyways, Lets start with housing. Every housing transaction hold about 10% [of sale price] of commissions on both buyer & seller side. [If you dont know] you'll be surprised to learn that the govt taxes & fees are a minimal portion of that. its mostly realor commissions & bank fees. why can they do that, its because they have had a monopoly on MLS listing service forever. to have access to the MLS you need to be a realtor. if anything these commissions should be fixed cost rather than a percentage cost. to give you a sense of the severity of the situation, on an average people stay in a house for 7 years due to labor mobility & other reasons. so over a carries of 30+ years its likely you'd do 4 such transactions. That essentially means you've worked for realtors & bank for about 40% of your carrier (assuming shiller is right in concluding that it takes 30yrs of work to build/own a house). Now Healthcare, why do you think nothing Martin skerelli had done was illegal? recall that he wasnt indicted for price gouging on the meds. I actually think he did a service to america by exposing the flaws of pricing system. Also regarding medical professionals AMA works hard to maintain control of certification process and not flood the market with doctors. believe me they are not that hard to make. infact they have been fighting efforts to allow RMPs to practice basic healthcare in rural areas just to maintain the scarcity. there is a reason healthcare and college education sectors are the most inflation heavy sectors in america over last to decades. its by impeding price discovery and free market.
- forkLding 8y agoThis is why I haven't bought prescription glasses in stores for 10 years and probably won't in the future. I bought two pairs of frames with lenses for around $100 online after I do my prescription tests each couple years, whereas for an average pair in store or with the optometrist, they cost about $300+. The quality between the glasses is pretty similar, only difference is the brand.
- growlist 8y agoI think at least things are better now than they once were. One of the reasons I am pro-Amazon, H&M and other successful new-ish companies that attract criticism from the left for various perceived crimes is that I remember what things were like in the UK when I was growing up, when almost anything I wanted to buy in the shops was overpriced, so much so that it even led to the expression 'Rip off Britain'. I strongly believe that it was various consumer-exploitative practices from business at the time that was behind this, and my evidence is that they were comprehensively and easily swept aside by companies offering better service and lower prices. That said, spectacles are one of the few remaining examples of egregiously bad rip-off behaviour around. F* Luxottica, I'm wearing my old glasses as long as possible deliberately to deny them profits and as soon as I can find the style I like from an alternative they'll have my money. Who needs a stupid label on their glasses anyway?! As if makes a person any sexier - they still have defective eyesight!