7 ms·
Is it an unpopular opinion that USB is already fast enough and has enough features and USB implementers should instead work on cost reduction and compatibility
by modeless 8y ago
Is it an unpopular opinion that USB is already fast enough and has enough features and USB implementers should instead work on cost reduction and compatibility so that we can all move away from USB 2 and pre-type-C connectors?
- p1esk 8y agoIs it fast enough for 4K120 or 8k displays?
- izacus 8y agoUSB or the alternate modes over USB-C connector?
- p1esk 8y agoThe modes don't matter if bandwidth is not there. Ultimately, I just want every monitor and TV to support a single universal interface, fast enough for the highest resolution/refresh rate. I don't care how it's called or how it works. If "USB 4.0" can be it, great.
- StreamBright 8y agoDo we need 8K displays at all? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehvz3iN8pp4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ehvz3iN8pp4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VxNBiAV4UnM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VxNBiAV4UnM
- p1esk 8y agoI haven't actually seen an 8k monitor yet, but a couple weeks ago I was at an Apple store and checked out 5k monitor. PDF text was noticeably sharper and at the same time smoother than on my 4k monitor at home. Both are relatively recent 27" IPS panels made by LG. So I don't know if I will be able to tell the difference between 5k and 8k in 27" size, but I know that 4k is not enough.
- dwringer 8y agoI probably can't see even 320x240, but that doesn't mean I don't like having the extra pixels since I don't stare at one spot the whole time. Upgrading to 4k felt extremely liberating compared with 1080, IMO - productivity is so subjective I'm not sure it can be said scientifically that more screen real estate is necessarily pointless. Plus, imagine a screen the size of a whole wall - if you want to project a life size image of a desktop computer onto it, you can only ever render some small subset of your pixels as its screen, so if you want to render it with a 1080 display you'll need a lot more than 4k. The number of pixels one needs is highly dependent on what one is doing with those pixels.
- Dylan16807 8y agoSo the first video is that framerate is better than resolution for gaming. Not relevant to this discussion. The second is mostly about how screens and eyes work, I'm not sure why you linked it at all. 8K is useful for crisp lines and text on a big close monitor.
- dcbadacd 8y agoThat's approaching the visual acuity of humans. I think 8K is going to be what we're going to end up with everything.
- pault 8y agoMy favorite monitor is my 42.5" Dell ultrasharp. The screen real estate is amazing, but it has old school 100% scaling. I would absolutely love the same panel dimensions with twice the number of pixels.
- woolvalley 8y agoWell you can already get cheap usb-c cables that only have usb 2 speeds and power delivery capacity, if that is what your hinting at.
- snazz 8y agoI am of the extremely unpopular opinion that USB 2.0 is plenty fast for my needs. For those who do need more than 450Mb/s, however, it seems logical to standardize on a single type-C connector. But with so many competing and superseding protocols implemented over the type-C cable, I feel like labeling should be mandatory so that users know what they can and can’t use a cable for (and don’t fry a power supply or run into incompatibilities).
- koala_man 8y agoUSB is already fast enough for all the things we've traditionally used USB for: wifi, mice, audio, smartphones, printers, thumb drives, HDDs, etc. It's not fast enough for next generation use cases: external displays, eGPUs, or modern SSDs.
- notJim 8y agoIt's not fast enough. USB cannot drive a 4k monitor at 60hz. You can use the physical interface to do it, but this uses Thunderbolt. This means that the dream of a one-cable-for-everything setup is not here yet, unless you use a Thunderbolt dock, which multiplexes the USB stuff in with the monitor signal. A thunderbolt dock costs around 10x more than a simple USB dock.
- stordoff 8y agoTo be honest, I'm not really sure why this is necessary. I don't see why couldn't have two interfaces - one simple/moderate-speed one for most use cases, and a fast one (which could incorporate the slower one) for when it's needed. Trying to cram everything into one interface seems to introduce too many compromises (I no longer know what the port does) and a lot of complexity.
- kkarakk 8y agothe point is you shouldn't have to know what the port does, it should seamlessly interconnect. you shouldn't have to be thinking about wires etc. it's like how bluetooth somewhat seamlessly interconnects across generations of bluetooth. that's how all standards should be
- Mirioron 8y agoOne cable for everything will mean that the cables cost an insane amount though. Oh, and they will either be short or require power to run the cable itself.