4 ms·
Gödel must have understood von Neumann to have been very very interested in his work? I mean of course he was, but to the degree that even if he were ill he'd b
by lordnacho 8y ago
Gödel must have understood von Neumann to have been very very interested in his work? I mean of course he was, but to the degree that even if he were ill he'd be thinking about math.
Otherwise it reads like "hey, hope you get better, now do you think P == NP?"
- gumby 8y ago> "hey, hope you get better, now do you think P == NP?" That was my read of it and I found it heartening. Having had a near-fatal illness myself I was bummed at the time by all the moaning about it. People were really talking about their issues, not mine (OK, kid freaking out about becoming an orphan was something for me to address). My own head was still full of stuff I wanted to do in the future (and what to do about my own therapeutic plan) and I would have been delighted to talk to someone who would think that way too. The great thing about the net is I could (textually) talk to friends far away who had no idea I was sick.
- djmips 8y agoIsn't your death more about the people left behind? I mean you're not going to have any problems once you're dead.
- triska 8y agoWithout context, one could indeed get this impression. However, Kurt Gödel and John von Neumann had met each other and exchanged letters long before that already, and Gödel was fully aware that von Neumann was interested in this area. For example, quoting from: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_theorems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G%C3%B6del%27s_incompleteness_... “Gödel announced his first incompleteness theorem at a roundtable discussion session on the third day of the conference. The announcement drew little attention apart from that of von Neumann, who pulled Gödel aside for conversation. Later that year, working independently with knowledge of the first incompleteness theorem, von Neumann obtained a proof of the second incompleteness theorem, which he announced to Gödel in a letter dated November 20, 1930 (Dawson 1996, p. 70).” To that letter, Gödel politely replied that he had already submitted the result for publication.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 8y agoDeath comes to everyone, but perhaps something more can be achieved before it does. Don't forget that both were refugees from the war, and von Neumann was a Hungarian Jew. Neither would be any stranger to personal loss.
- bradleyjg 8y agoI had a great uncle that was a mathematician. At his shiva (kind of like a wake) his former colleague were in a corner talking math. I think he would’ve appreciated that. His son (i.e. my cousin) told me some funny stories about Erdős staying at their house when he was growing up. I think they are just an eccentric bunch.