4 ms·
The difference between avoidance and evasion is only relevant if you have tax law interpreted to the letter only. Tax law should be interpreted by the lawmaker
by alkonaut 8y ago
The difference between avoidance and evasion is only relevant if you have tax law interpreted to the letter only.
Tax law should be interpreted by the lawmakers intention and companies should be ready to be fined or uptaxed if authorities find they pay less taxes than is reasonable given global profits and relative turnover within their jurisdiction.
Constructs such as paying “royalties” to parent companies, or taking very expensive internal loans to effectively move all profits to tax havens (using Dutch BV’s etc) should simply be outlawed. Countries simply shouldn’t recognize these as acceptable practices.
This obviously leads to what companies like to call a “hostile business climate” - so a country will need to be pretty attractive in other aspects to not scare off international business.
- nradov 8y agoIt's unreasonable to expect judges to divine lawmakers' intent on subtle issues of tax policy. If lawmakers want a tax to work a certain way then they need to just write that down so that it's clear to everyone.
- Marazan 8y agoYou liter ally put it in a preamble. Like, if you say "this tax break is intended solely for people who sell second hand cars" then you don't have to spend 100 pages exactly specifying every nuance to 100% prevent people not selling second hand cars from taking advantage of it. Ots called principles based tax code and it works. I was initially high sceptical of the idea but, based on outcomes, it is a vastly superior system to rules based tax codes. It makes it far simpler and clearer to everyone.
- gizmo686 8y agoIf it is that simple, you can add a clause to the law that makes selling second hand cars a requirement. Then you have to clarify how much of your expanses are eligable. Just those directly involved in the sale? Upkeep of your main facility? Upkeep of your satalite corporate offices? Your finance division? What if you sell new and used cars? What if you are actually a battery manufacturer that makes and sells cars and also buys back and resales used cars? What if you are a software engineer who sells your current car every 6 months?
- Marazan 8y agoBut what if the people 'engaged' in the selling of the cars are only tenuously engaged in the activity and are simply trying to game the law and rack up paper losses? All the car buying and selling is racked up by agents working on their behalf and they pay absolutely no heed to buying a selling cars? http://www.mynewsdesk.com/uk/hm-revenue-customs-hmrc/pressreleases/second-hand-car-dealer-tax-scheme-scrapped-964268 http://www.mynewsdesk.com/uk/hm-revenue-customs-hmrc/pressre... https://www.theguardian.com/media/2014/feb/21/chris-moyles-used-car-dealer-tax-avoidance https://www.theguardian.com/media/2014/feb/21/chris-moyles-u...
- RHSeeger 8y agoI disagree. Tax laws should be simple and explicit. The people in charge change over time. I don't trust that the people later will interpret the laws the same way as the people today, or that either will interpret the laws the same way they were intended, or that the group of people that wrote the laws all had the same intent.
- Fnoord 8y ago> I disagree. Tax laws should be simple and explicit. The people in charge change over time. I don't trust that the people later will interpret the laws the same way as the people today [...] You can say the same about law in general, yet law isn't "simple and explicit". It is very complex, hard to grok, therefore only a small amount of people are able to, leading to expensive lawyers and a law system which the poor cannot afford (ie. class justice). Yes, ideally I also want laws to be simple and explicit. I'd even argue that worked quite well before globalization. Now it doesn't anymore. We need to adapt.
- duado 8y agoCrimes much more serious than tax evasion have grey areas specifically to create room for judicial discretion. Words like “with malice aforethought” or “forcibly” are used in statutes because the law can’t preconceive of every possible way to commit a murder or rape.
- RHSeeger 8y agoAnd crimes much less serious, too. There's a LOT of US laws that are intentionally vague and/or grant far too much leeway for the justice system. The grants extraordinary power because of edge cases they want the law to be able to handle ("think of the children"). Yet time and time again, it's the average Joe that has the law abused against him. These overly vague laws are used incorrectly, and yet we keep creating them because we don't learn that the people in power cannot be trusted; most of them are good, but it only takes one bad apple to ruin the lives of many people.
- crazygringo 8y agoThat would be a nightmare. First, tax laws don't have clear intentions to begin with -- if a tax law passes with 51 out of 100 votes in the legislature, all 51 representatives could be supporting the "letter" of the law for 51 different actual intentions, many of which might not be noble in the first place (e.g. give a particular local factory a tax break to win more votes next election). Second, because of this, "intention" would be left open to completely different interpretation by different judges and result in completely arbitrary, non-predictable outcomes in different cases, which would be a nightmare for companies to even attempt to comply with. There's a reason that laws are interpreted by their letter -- it's the only fair way to do it. Third, the tax laws are passed by different countries and are not harmonized, so even if they had clear intentions, their intentions can completely conflict, and there's no reason why they should be harmonized -- different countries are allowed to have legitimately different philosophies on taxation, there's no "right" answer. The things you say should "simply be outlawed" -- how? How are you going to determine which internal loan is merely "expensive" (OK) versus "very expensive" (not OK)? How are you going to differentiate between legitimate payments and the "royalties" you put in quotes that you call a construct?
- pjc50 8y agoThe usual solution is a "General anti-avoidance rule" (GAAR). This doesn't get into the intent of the tax law, only into the intent of the business action. If there would be a simpler, more natural, and otherwise cheaper way to do it, but it's been done a particular way to avoid tax, then it's unlawful.
- ethbro 8y agoThis seems kind of like the "What is / isn't gerrymandering?" problem. I am not an accountant, but couldn't most corporate structures be reimagined by taxing authorities as an idealized "single company"? Then calculate the difference between taxes that would be owed by that company vs the actual structure? If there's a statistically significant discrepancy, require the company to provide a rationale. Or pay some penalty.
- Nasrudith 8y ago
- gamblor956 8y agoEnforcement of tax law is based on the spirit of the law, not just the text. Things which are legal for a few years could become illegal the best without any change in the tax laws themselves, though this is only a real risk if you structure your activities within the letter of the law but not the intent of the law. (I'm a tax lawyer.)