4 ms·
> Also, take home challenges are probably very discriminatory towards older candidates with families. So maybe just as subtle way of age discrimination? I see
by hn_throwaway_99 8y ago
> Also, take home challenges are probably very discriminatory towards older candidates with families. So maybe just as subtle way of age discrimination?
I see this sentiment fairly frequently, and TBH, it completely baffles me. I am in my mid 40s. Yes, I don't have nearly as much energy nor desire to spend all weekend doing take-home programming assignments as I did 20 years ago. But if one candidate is willing to do more work and preparation for an interview, that's not 'discrimination' - that's one person showing they are willing to put more effort into a job than another.
True, your family obligations may mean you don't have as much time to spend on that preparation. If that's the case, that's a fine, very reasonable trade-off you've made to prioritize your family over your work. But then it strikes me as entirely UNreasonable to accuse businesses of discrimination because they choose employees who have decided not to make that same trade-off.
- ppod 8y agoI agree with what you say as-is, but the other side of it is that the company might not be making optimal hiring decisions by doing this discrimination. A 22 year-old can choose to spend a full weekend on an interview task and do a great job, but once hired that doesn't mean they will actually work more hours (though they might). If we assume that once hired both the 20yo and the 40yo will work 40 hour weeks (i'm in europe), then it wouldn't be optimal to compare their take-homes evenly if the 20yo had spent way more time on it. Anyway its complicated. Seems like on-site open-book 90 minute real-world problems would be a nice solution.
- gav 8y ago> Seems like on-site open-book 90 minute real-world problems would be a nice solution. It is. And it's superior to a take-home test because you know the candidate wrote the code, you know how long it took them, and you can turn it into a pair-programming exercise.
- jboy55 8y agoThe whole bent against white board questions is that they are unrealistic as to actual working conditions and thus are artificial. So if you are a successful engineer, using your work time efficiently, and yet, you have family obligations that prevent you from spending enough time as someone else on a take home challenge, is the take home challenge showing realistic 'working conditions'? Or is it a measure of freetime? >If that's the case, that's a fine, very reasonable trade-off you've made to prioritize your family over your work. I'd advise that if you are ever involved in a hiring situation you never write that down. "I'm sorry my project wasn't done so well, [my baby, pregnancy, illness, religious service] took most of my weekend". That is a prime example of age/gender/disability discrimination. You should never assume someone's out side of work life presumes an inability to do the job during work hours.
- hn_throwaway_99 8y agoThe vast majority of jobs I've worked at have required some flexibility in working off hours. Whether it was something that went down at off hours that needed to be addressed, or an unforeseen (and unforseeable) change in a business that required a last minute scramble, these things happen. True, there may be some jobs that are truly 9-5, and if that's the case, so be it. But frankly, as someone who is willing to put more dedication into my work, it feels like complete discrimination against me if someone willing to do less work then demands the same level of compensation and advancement opportunities.
- akiselev 8y agoHow does someone know that their coworker with family isn't just a better negotiator than them or that they didn't come at an opportune time when their employer was more desperate for the coworker's skillset? There's a reason there's so much room for plausible deniability in these matters.
- LanceH 8y agoTraditionally, having a family is viewed as a positive because you are more likely to get a more stable, longer term worker.
- jboy55 8y agoIf 'Work Hours' require someone to be oncall 24/7, you can ask that as part of your interview, but you can't infer that from other factors. Yes: "Our job requires you to be on-call 24/7, one week a month, can you commit to that?". No: "You said you didn't have time for the take home test because you have a family. The family will get in the way of 24/7 support" Also yes: "you will be traveling 5 days a week for your sales job, can you do this?" No. "We don't hire people with families for this job." And, there's no discrimination towards you putting more time into your work. That's quite a stretch, if all you have going for you is your ability to put in more that 60 hours a week, that's not saying much.
- 8y ago
- alaithea 8y agoPeople whose kids are older may have forgotten how hard it is to get even five minutes to one's self at home, when there are infants or toddlers in the house, let alone an hour or two. Without an adequate support network in place, a parent might have to pay a babysitter to get the time to do the take-home. So yes, take-homes which are expected to be done in one's "free time" are discriminatory against those with families.
- bradleyjg 8y agoWho says that they are expected to be done in one’s “free time”? What responsibility or business is it of an employer to know how candidates are making time for the job interview process? If any non-zero time required to obtain a particular job is descriminatory then every existent hiring process is discriminatory. What do you suggest, drawing lots?
- quakenul 8y agoIt's not a trade-off! We as a species absolutely require people to have kids. Discriminating against those who do is the most fundamantally wrong thing I can think of. It is what we are here for, if nothing else.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- moonlet 8y agoYou’re cis male and probably don’t do the majority of the housework or childcare, no? I highly doubt you’d hold this opinion if you were/did.
- mevile 8y ago> I am in my mid 40s. Yes, I don't have nearly as much energy... Do people in their mid 40's have less energy for some reason? Do you exercise regularly? Do you get enough sleep? Do you eat healthily? You don't mention anything about a family obligation taking up your time. I am 41 and I don't have any lack of energy issues. I don't think it's a 40's thing, more of decades of bad lifestyle decisions catching up. Which I don't think should be out of bounds for a company to consider when hiring as long as it isn't due to health issues beyond the candidate's control. I guess this distinction can get fuzzy, but I stress that there shouldn't be any reason why in your 40s you should have dramatically lower levels of energy than in your 20s. Honestly depicting people in their 40s as having less energy does more harm than good. It's just feeding into the perception of older people as less capable when it's not true across the board. It's not OK. I don't have less energy, I have tons of energy and I'm sure many people older than me do as well.
- humanrebar 8y agoIt's more that family demands tend to be less friendly to time shifting. You can't just put off feeding your kids, grounding them for getting into trouble, or changing their wet sheets at 2 a.m. Single people (and empty nesters to be fair) can more often skip some happy hours or some intramural games. And to be even more fair, once employed, it seems parental excuses (my kids blah blah) get more understanding than single excuses (I need to actually date, my boyfriend blah blah). But I'll wager the interview process is more complicated for people with families.
- mevile 8y agoFamily obligations taking up time I can understand, but the person I am replying to just seemed to equate 40s as being in a state of having less energy without mentioning family obligations. I am taking issue with 40's being a state where you have less energy. I don't believe it is true, unless there's an underlying health condition that has little to do with age.
- mvyo 8y ago> if one candidate is willing to do more work ... that's one person showing they are willing to put more effort into a job than another I'm not happy with this logic. It's harmful. If you extend it further, it motivates everybody to work more hours too. "If a person is willing to put more effort into a job than another let him do that! Oh and by the way, let's fire those who are not and hire those who are". And we're back to 12+ hour work day and a lot of great specialists are out of their jobs or forced to sacrifice their time with families, friends, hobbies, physical activities, etc. There are ways to conduct interviews without whiteboarding AND without take home assignments.
- JustSomeNobody 8y agoIt is interesting that you use, “... willing to put more effort...”. It isn’t about will, it’s about time. But hey, if we’re going to generalize, I bet a dev with a family is more “willing” to do hard work for a company than some single dev.