4 ms·
> In reality, your conjecture turns out to be largely untrue. Visual design quality does have an impact. Did you read the article? The author specifically says
by naasking 8y ago
> In reality, your conjecture turns out to be largely untrue. Visual design quality does have an impact.
Did you read the article? The author specifically says, "Before all of the UI designers that read this go out and riot and champion against me for saying UI redesigns are a waste of time, let me say that I do value design. I think at the bare minimum, a product or website needs to be usable, and if you possess a good eye and steady hand, you should feel compelled to create something that looks pleasing."
He then goes on to say, "Just stop redesigning the UI all the time. UI redesigns, in my opinion, are a waste of time 95% of the time. Let me explain further."
That's not so contentious IMO. Redesigns can be too frequent and the purported purpose of redesigns is typically nebulous, and can be driven more by politics than any of the objective metrics that you describe.
> People aren't idiots. They don't do this work for no reason. Try to understand and respect the work outside your own department and specialty.
Of course they have reasons. That doesn't make those reasons objectively correct. Maybe you should try to understand and respect the point the article is trying to convey, that perhaps the pendulum on UI redesign has swung a little too far one way.
- mgkimsal 8y ago> That doesn't make those reasons objectively correct. You don't even need to appeal to some 'objective correct' standard. You can just look more basically at "what is the purpose?" Usually, it's "increase sales". So... determine baseline metrics, perhaps implement some testing to see what changes have what effect, and then push forward a larger redesign effort if the tests moved towards the goal/purpose. Perhaps the goal is 'reduce number of clicks'. Is that really important? Or is it 'reduce user frustration'? How will you measure that? "Reduce page load time" - should be pretty easy to measure, but will it have an impact on other things (sales, support, etc)? People may have 'good reasons' for a redesign. Without a measurable goal, they're a waste of time, imo, and I've often seen them do more harm than good (measurable harm, like reduced sales, customer drop off, etc). But hey - those front page pictures looked really nice in the photoshop mockups sent over...
- js2 8y ago> Did you read the article? Please don’t do this. > Maybe you should try to understand Or this. Reminder: be civil, don’t be snarky. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- naasking 8y agoCome on, literally the second paragraph of the article addresses exactly the OP's point. I also wasn't being snarky, I was applying the OP's exact argument to his own critique of the article. I'm fine with sensible moderation, but holding up a mirror on a bad comment isn't an uncivil or snarky reply.
- js2 8y agoHN guidelines specifically say: > Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." Your first paragraph is just as strong with its opening sentence (“Did you read the article?”) removed. The guidelines also say: > Don't say things you wouldn't say face-to-face. The final sentence of your last paragraph could have been phrased: “The point the article is trying to convey is that perhaps the pendulum on UI redesign has swung a little too far one way.” I get that you were mocking the “try to understand” from the parent comment, but your comment would have been stronger by not doing so. > holding up a mirror on a bad comment isn't an uncivil or snarky reply. The bulk of your comment is polite and civil, but the opening and concluding sentences are attacking the the commenter, not the comment. ($0.02. Just trying to keep things polite around here.)
- naasking 8y agoEdit: I've erased this because I'm not going to debate rhetorical methods since this is all pointless. HN's guidelines also suggest avoiding unrelated tangents, so this will be my last post debating rhetoric and HN guidelines.
- sekh60 8y agoI really wish Gmail would stop changing so frequently. It probably objectively isn't that bad, but having to teach older, not so tech competent relatives where things moved to is a real pain.
- pembrook 8y agoYou don’t think Google is running tests on the effects of every little UI change? Remember, their goals aren’t the same as your goals. Your goal is to get the best email tool possible. Google’s goal is to extract as much money as possible from you and your data...while still being the best alternative to competitors. Those goals are very very different. Most of these comments are so naive. It’s almost as if most people have never seen the amount of actionable data the average digital product throws off. A smart default assumption, especially when it comes to the big guys like google/Facebook; the UI changed because it makes the company more money.
- Fins 8y agoBut that assumes that the new design does make more money. I, honestly, fail to see how, e.g., moving the account switch button in the new Gmail app from left to right increases ad views. On the other hand, from all we hear about Google's promotion process, it seems quite likely that the redesign happened "just because" and somebody gets to add a checkbox to the promotion list.