5 ms·
But maybe it’s time to fresh it up a little? Get rid of gradients, dirty washed-out colors, unnecessary separators, add a little more air. No, no, no, NO!!!11
by userbinator 8y ago
But maybe it’s time to fresh it up a little? Get rid of gradients, dirty washed-out colors, unnecessary separators, add a little more air.
No, no, no, NO!!!11 I've had it with these "sea of floating text on an expanse of white" redesigns, seeing yet another one follow this mindless trend just disgusts me thoroughly. The lines, subtle gradients, and other affordances of the old design serve to organise and direct your eyes into the appropriate sections; without them, everything blends together into a jumbled mess and it almost looks like the stylesheet didn't load fully.
If you feel disoriented, give it a minute.
I've had to put up with such redesigns for literally years now (I don't remember when the trend started --- mid 2010s?) and I don't feel them getting any better --- and eventually get around to making a user stylesheet to make them look better than they used to.
In contrast to the article this is one of the very few redesigns of a site which I actually would like (not mine, previously discussed at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17242367 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17242367): https://pbs.twimg.com/media/De17PIKXUAE27W6.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/De17PIKXUAE27W6.jpg:large
If you know someone at Github, send them a link to this article. Maybe someone there will like my ideas and eventually get to implement them
Hopefully not. "Don't make me get out the custom stylesheet editor..."
- zanny 8y agoTheres usually some value in design trends, but the OP's github revamp where you can't tell non-interactive text from buttons is painful. The whole point of a button is to indicate interactivity, if your idea of an interactive control is text with maybe a bar under it don't be surprised when users are totally lost.
- Quiark 8y ago_If you feel disoriented, give it a minute._ The guy spends a very long article explaining how things could be laid out easier to orient yourself in and then asks you to give a minute to get used to his color scheme.
- shaki-dora 8y agoThis criticism seems somewhat unfair. I believe they were implying that familiarity with the old design will strongly bias your initial reaction, and giving it just a few more seconds will help to avoid that trap.
- pferde 8y agoNo. If the new design is better, I will immediately go "oh wow, that is good". If I have to give it time until my bias goes away, the new design is not necessarily better, merely different.
- noir_lord 8y agoI haven’t used the gui or windows as primary os for over a decade but that was instantly grokkable, they really nailed the gui in win2k been downhill ever since.
- deep-root 8y agoCan't tell if the irony is lost that both GitHub UI mocks are by the same designer, Nikita Prokopov.[1][2] [1] Windows UI satire https://twitter.com/nikitonsky/status/1003593821723267072?s=21 https://twitter.com/nikitonsky/status/1003593821723267072?s=... [2] Honest redesign http://tonsky.me/blog/github-redesign/ http://tonsky.me/blog/github-redesign/
- fxfan 8y agoCan some UI expert chime in what it is about the windows style redesign that makes everything so absolutely clear and easy to find? I can find everything literally at a glance? It's not sexy, quite the opposite but god does it run electricity through my fingers. I feel like i would use the shit out of it. Is it association and familiarity with the old windows UI or does it follow human nature better?
- yuchi 8y agoThis is most probably the result of the UI making you resurface good memories of your past. Anyway the old Win UI was extremely clear in creating visual hierarchies, when not too many layers were on the screen — modern UI tends to be optimized for a way larger amount of layers, or the opposite, a hyper reduced hierarchy complexity (not the ergonomic / perceived complexity)
- fxfan 8y agoThanks. I'd love to see a breakdown of what creates this clarity, like how the OP has for every element type. I know it might seem like an exaggeration but I was physically invigorated by it.
- pembrook 8y agoIt's called nostalgia. It's emotional, not rational. Ask any 16 year old (like my son), who came of age having no context for what the windows 95 UI even looked like. Shocker, he vastly prefers flat interfaces, ie. like the design of Notion. The problem I see in this github redesign has nothing to do with the fact that it's flat. It's tougher to use because it's just bad design. The three columns make it insanely dense in terms of information (eliminates any hierarchy) and adds in weird red underlines (which typically mean "error") for no reason. Also the button styles are all inconsistent in the final version. The first part of the article was great, the second part he started going off the reservation. I think he's strong in terms of a UX thinking but lacks the skills of visual designer who would better implement his thinking visually.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoI thought some of his suggestions were pretty decent. But then he just threw everything away by mucking around in the Code, I mean Overview tab. His last design, without the guiding lines, make it look like jumbled shit pie.
- piecu 8y agoI have the same feeling. He proposed a very good changes and then started to mess up Code…
- yxhuvud 8y agoI wouldn't mind seeing the latest commit history there, but the stats are totally out of place.
- vor0nwe 8y agoAgree; though even before the latest commit history, I’d much prefer the README to be hoisted up there, so it’s at least visible when I first visit a repo.
- jonnycomputer 8y agoAt the time of this posting I got 13 points for expressing a popular opinion. I'm not sure it deserved it. Its not that I disagree with what I wrote, but it could have been more thoughtful. This kind of thing just reinforces my feeling that HN's vote system is broken.