7 ms·
Interesting to point out that the $35k is the full price, which goes down when additional discounts are applied. If you get the short range model with no optio
by CydeWeys 8y ago
Interesting to point out that the $35k is the full price, which goes down when additional discounts are applied. If you get the short range model with no options, it starts out at $35k, then goes down all the way to $24,950 after including the $3,750 Federal tax credit, $2,000 New York EV rebate (clearly it's geolocating by IP address here), and "$4,300 estimated 6 year gas savings".
OK, so that last bit is BS, and it looks like there's a hidden $1,200 destination and doc fee, so the actual real price including tax breaks is $30,450 in NYC. Still not bad at all!
- kevindong 8y agoThe gas savings is definitely shady. But including the federal tax credits and destination fee is fair I think. As far as I'm aware, no auto maker includes the destination/docs/handling fee in the MSRP. The Tesla fee amount is comparable to other automakers also (it's on the high side at $1,200; but it's not too different from Toyota's $930 and Honda's $920). Presuming your location due to geolocation is a bit too far (but that's debatable) since they didn't disclose that immediately up front.
- CydeWeys 8y agoI still think that $30,450 overall is a good deal, and I'd go for that if a car made sense for me at all (it doesn't though, being in NYC). It's just purposely confusing the way the price is manipulated downwards using questionable-at-best pricing practices.
- thebluehawk 8y agoIt's annoying that they don't make it more clear that's what they are doing, but the gas saving is a real thing. I used to spent $120 a month on gas, that went to $45 a month of electricity, then I got on a Time of Use plan where electricity is cheaper at night and now my monthly "fuel" cost is $15.
- vvanders 8y agoYup, I was spending $400/mo on gas which is now close to $50/mo before you figure in oil change costs. Quite a few cars/trucks run synthetic these days which can really start adding up.
- mrfusion 8y agoBut how much are you going to pay to replace the battery?
- steelframe 8y agoThere's tons of data on EV batteries from the past 5+ years. At least for Tesla, battery degradation is not a problem.
- toomuchtodo 8y agohttps://cleantechnica.com/2018/04/16/tesla-batteries-have-90-capacity-after-160000-miles-may-last-for-500000-miles/ https://cleantechnica.com/2018/04/16/tesla-batteries-have-90... "Actual Tesla owners report about a 5% drop in battery capacity by the 50,000 mile mark but after than, the rate of degradation drops considerably. On average, cars with 160,000 miles on them still have 90% of their battery capacity remaining. Projecting forward from the real world data available, a Tesla battery should still have 80% battery capacity after 500,000 miles of driving, the group claims. The vast majority of internal combustion engines would have stopped functioning long before then." Assuming a conservative usage of 20k miles/year, it will take you 25 years to reach 500k miles.
- vvanders 8y agoI'm at 85k miles and still going strong so I'm not worried.
- eMSF 8y agoNot really. Oil changes (in a car comparable in size to Model 3) cost me about 50 USD per 25000 km, or 15000 mi, indeed because the oil is synthetic and fulfills certain criteria. In any case it's a rather insignificant amount compared to fuel costs, especially with fuel taxes as they are. If oil change costs start to add up, there's a significant possibility of you doing something wrong (including the choice of vehicle).
- pkaye 8y agoIs there a destination charge if you pick it up from the factory?
- ksherlock 8y agoYes. Federal regulations require the destination fee be separate but equal -- listed separately, but the same regardless of where it's bought (and the actual shipping cost for that particular car). So if you buy from the factory, you subsidize a buyer in Hawaii or Alaska, etc.
- gowld 8y agoAlso, non other automaker sells their cars for MSRP.
- api 8y agoGas savings will vary by where you live and whether you have cheap gas and/or cheap electricity or expensive gas and/or expensive electricity. Even with expensive electricity though it's still cheaper than gas. I agree that quoting a single figure here is misleading.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gniv 8y ago> after including the $2,750 Federal tax credit, Small typo: $3,750
- CydeWeys 8y agoThanks, fixed.
- Someone1234 8y ago[Deleted]
- plexicle 8y agoYou just described a deduction. A credit is literally cash (assuming you have enough liability to cover it).
- Someone1234 8y ago[Deleted]
- plexicle 8y ago"A tax credit reduces the taxable amount of income you owe taxes on" is not the same thing as: "Tax credits reduce the amount of income tax you owe" The former is a deduction. The latter is a credit. It's really that simple.
- paxys 8y agoCertain tax credits apply even if you don't have enough liability. Like if you owe zero taxes for the year for some reason they will send you a check for the full credit amount. Not sure which category the EV one falls under though.
- 2trill2spill 8y agoYea your correct, theres refundable and non refundable tax credits, most are of the non refundable variety. It appears the ev tax credit is non refundable. [1]: https://www.libertytax.com/tax-lounge/electric-car-and-vehicle-tax-credit-what-to-know-and-how-to-claim-it/ https://www.libertytax.com/tax-lounge/electric-car-and-vehic...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- evanpw 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- trumped 8y ago> clearly it's geolocating by IP address here so you can use a vpn/vps/etc to get the rebate?
- jzl 8y agoFor the record, the federal tax credit becomes $1,875 on July 1st, and $0 on January 1st 2020.
- gamblor956 8y agoIncluding the credits in the price used to be pretty shady, since you had to have a sufficient pre-credit tax liability to actually get the full benefit of the credit. (The EV credit is non-refundable, meaning that if you don't have a tax liability, you don't get anything from the credit.) But the Trump Tax Bill lowered everyone's refunds (largely because the IRS lowered withholding during the year), so more people have a year-end tax liability, and those that did before the TTB now have a larger tax liability, ultimately meaning more people can now theoretically benefit from the credit.
- twoodfin 8y agoEligibility for tax credits is unaffected by witholding rates or how large your end-of-year refund or liability is. And anyone who can afford a Tesla is sure to be paying enough income tax to get the full value of the EV credit.
- usaar333 8y agoExactly. If it's only an edge case where your customers can't benefit (some retirees might have insufficient taxable income, but that's about it), it's fair to include it.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoIf you're retired, you'll do a Traditional->Roth IRA conversion to generate a tax liability for your EV or rooftop solar install.
- gamblor956 8y agoI love being told how taxes work by people on the internet.... I do this for a living. I have plenty of clients who saw little to no benefit from the EV credit because their tax liability was not large enough.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoShouldn’t you have shown them how to incur a liability (retirement account conversions) then so they didn’t lose out on an otherwise non refundable credit?
- GhostVII 8y agoIncluding the estimated gas savings is extremely misleading. I want to know how much the car will cost upfront, not how much I will save over some number of years. And how do they determine the savings? If I am cross-shopping with a Chevy bolt, there won't be any gas savings... Surprised they put that on their, it really negatively impact my view of Tesla.
- leesec 8y agoDid you look at the site? It lists 35k up front, and then lists estimated payment after incentive secondary.
- GhostVII 8y agoSure, and that is still very misleading because they are bundling gas savings along with government incentives that you will get upfront. I expect the cost after estimated savings to be the actual cost I pay upfront, not the savings over some car I would never buy in the first place, and I don't think you should ever mix upfront cost with long term savings when listing prices. Very misleading.
- Theodores 8y agoThey are underplaying this aspect of saving on the petrol. If we were in 1973 then it would be different, in today's world we are a Trump brain-fart away from a 1973 situation, for instance in Venezuela and what would happen if the Chinese and Russians decided 'we aren't playing any more'? Sure the U.S. is now god-blessed with the fracking miracle but the gas savings is also an option to be independent of the big oil companies. That could be worth more than $$$ to prepper-mentality Americans. The prices didn't even go up that much in 1973 but a lot of queues and rationing went on. The 55 mph speed limit came in. It was not happy times. If Tesla were a bit more frank they would mention this independence aspect, as it is they don't want to scare the children. Nobody knows what petrol prices will be next month so there is no way anyone can put a figure on savings. That said there are plenty of people who have swapped to Tesla and have the electricity bills to prove that the advertised savings are real.
- cma 8y agoIs there sales tax?