3 ms·
Consider: it might be cheaper in total long-term ROI to dispose of things in landfill now, and then let people a hundred years from now dig them back up if they
by derefr 8y ago
Consider: it might be cheaper in total long-term ROI to dispose of things in landfill now, and then let people a hundred years from now dig them back up if they have need for the materials then, than to recycle those things right now. And by “cheaper”, I mean for the entire economy that includes both us and the hypothetical future people digging those things up! Our recycling now might have lower ROI (higher costs, less reclamation efficiency) than their digging-up + recycling would! (This is actually a thing in archaeology: frequently sites that are hard to dig up will be left to future archaeologists who—it is assumed—will be able to reclaim them more cheaply and effectively than we can today.)
It’s sort of like the “bargain” of cryptocurrencies: what promotes long-term GDP growth more, bank fees or massive electricity use? Crypto miners are hurting the environment right now; but they pay for their own externalities. Banks impose fees that lower net productivity in a way that might mean that the companies/technologies that we need to reach sustainability take longer to come into existence. So will we be in a better place with 100 years of crypto mining + 100 years of an economy [including green industry] that was spurred on no bank fees; or vice versa? The question doesn’t have an immediate, intuitive answer.
A stupid but weirdly-precise analogy: when playing an RTS like Starcraft, anything that slows down your “economy” (mineral mining) prevents you from “teching up” as quickly as your opponent. In humanity’s case, our opponent is Malthusian resource starvation (in the small—of individual resources) and habitat loss from climate change. Anything that slows down our economy from “teching up” to face these problems, for a reward of merely moving around in time our ability to use our resources (rather than decreasing permanent losses/increasing permanent gains of resources), isn’t really worth it, if we’re “racing the clock.” (That’s a big, hotly-debated “if”, of course.)
- marcosdumay 8y ago> what promotes long-term GDP growth more, bank fees or massive electricity use? Assuming they have the same cost, bank fees promote more GDP growth, hands down, at any time horizon. Money simply changing hands will always beat money changing hands with added useless usage of resources and labor. And that's not even considering the reality, that average electricity costs of a BTC transaction are orders of magnitude expensive than the average bank fees on money transactions.
- derefr 8y agoOh, no, I meant that the other way around. As in, "what promotes GDP growth more—companies and individuals having more money from a [lack of] bank fees, or power grids having more spare capacity from a lack of miners consuming electricity"?