5 ms·
Compared to what ? Is it safe to eat 3 times a day + snacks, mostly over processed, calorie dense, low micro nutrients food ? Food is like most things, modera
by lm28469 8y ago
Compared to what ?
Is it safe to eat 3 times a day + snacks, mostly over processed, calorie dense, low micro nutrients food ?
Food is like most things, moderation/balance is key.
I have no doubt fasting can be beneficial in some cases just as I have no doubt that the typical western diet is universally bad.
This new fasting trend is just the blowback of the over abundance / over consumption of low quality food we experience pretty much everywhere in US / Europe.
- rfreytag 8y agoIt is an NIH study which to me implies rigor; including controls.
- glastra 8y agoYou cannot assume this is an NIH study just because the website hosting the PDF is from the NIH. The NCBI is somewhat of an online repository of papers and citations, nothing more. The study was published in the journal BMC Complementary and Alternative Medicine, and none of its authors are affiliated with the NIH, judging from their affiliation statement in the paper itself: Author details 1 AOMA Graduate School of Integrative Medicine, Austin, TX 78745, USA. 2 NoviSci, Durham, NC, USA. 3 TrueNorth Health Center, Santa Rosa, CA 95404, USA. 4 TrueNorth Health Foundation, 1501 Pacific Avenue, Santa Rosa, CA 95404, USA.
- leemailll 8y agoBmc on the nih website nowadays basically hosting nih-founded research papers. Not just papers published from nih
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThe report appears rigorous, but it notes in several places that the data is not acquired in a rigorous way as it was not intended to be used to make such assessments. As to controls: >"the relative safety of water-only fasting is necessarily descriptive in nature as we did not identify a comparison group(s)" It's a good paper. I was left wondering why people attended the facility. A 9 day water only fast, with limited activity, sounds pretty extreme for a 70+ yo.
- shiven 8y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sallekhana https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sallekhana
- Legogris 8y agoIf you read the article you will see that the results and conclusion might be in line with what you expect. Academic papers don't necessarily follow Poe's Law in their titles ;)
- arkades 8y agoIt is bad form to criticize posters on HN for not reading the article they’re criticizing. Oddly, it seems to be less accepted than not reading the article one’s criticizing.
- vanderZwan 8y agoI don't know what gave you that impression, but it doesn't match my experience on HN at all. Discussions based on headlines alone tend to be accepted (especially if the poster mentions they haven't read the article), but "the article addresses your questions <here> and <here>" is usually the top reply.
- arkades 8y agoIn fairness, I tend to see two types of responses: One of the kind you mention - “the article actually says ...”, in which the respondent goes to the effort of basically summarizing the article OP didn’t bother to read. Those generally catch moderate upvotes. Then there’s the more blunt variety, along the lines of RTFM. Those catch solid downvotes. Frankly, I’d rather neither existed, and posts that clearly didn’t bother looking at anything but the headline were just flagged and deleted.
- andreareina 8y agoThere's a line between criticizing someone for not reading the article (or insinuating that they didn't read it, per the guidelines[1]) and stating that such-and-such claim is found in the article. Please don't insinuate that someone hasn't read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that." [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- DeusExMachina 8y ago> the typical western diet is universally bad As if there is a "western" diet. Even just remaining in Europe, the typical diet in Italy has nothing to do with the typical diet in Germany. And while southern countries and northern countries tend to have more similar diets, even between them they have big differences. Same goes for "eastern diets". China and India, to pick just two, have completely different diets. Criticize overcompsuntion of low quality food all you want when it occurs, but I think that broad-stroke generalizations like "western diet bad" are not useful.
- dagw 8y agotypical diet in Italy has nothing to do with the typical diet in Germany. That's not really true. Both build a lot of their meals around a boiled starch, a grilled or fried protein and a vegetable dish, often prepared separately. It is not uncommon that this dish is primarily made up of raw vegetables. The starch and protein component almost always makes up the bulk of the meal. Both use a lot of dairy based sauces and/or a sauce made by thickening a meat stock (either pre-made or by de-glazing the pan they fired their protein in). Bread and other baked goods are a common component in many meals in both counties, often served with vegetable or dairy fat.