7 ms·
TI Claims Breakthrough in BAW On-Die-Oscillators
- bgorman 8y agoWill this technology slowly replace external crystals for generic microcontrollers? Or just for high-accuracy applications.
- zeroping 8y agoFor many low-accuracy applications, just an RC oscillator is used. This sounds like a good way to reduce part count for systems that need the accuracy of a crystal - if the main IC is made by TI.
- PaulHoule 8y agoOr somebody that licenses the patent(s) from TI.
- dbcurtis 8y agoIf it is as good as the article claims, I would say more like “instantly”. Bringing the resonator on die eliminates the crystal from the BOM, one of the pricier passive components. Also probably two capacitors are now gone, again for xtal circuits you need better caps, cheapies are not good for oscillator circuits. Plus the PCB area for the oscillator is eliminated, and that is an area of PCB that requires careful layout to meet the constraints on paracitic capacitance, etc.
- baybal2 8y agoProcess people will take their sweet time to turn this into a marketable fab product. I'd say that it can come to market quicker as a packaging house product: they grow resonator dies with BAW separately, dice them, and put into existing RF SoC packages.
- janekm 8y agoOf course currently only TI can make these (though no doubt everyone else is going to make a real effort to replicate). The chip in question is rather pricey though, $11.44 in thousand quantities vs. $3.54 for the very similar NRF52840 + about $1 for the crystal and other components needed.
- TrueDuality 8y agoThe increase in power draw is significant for a lot of applications which will make these unfeasible. That being said there are a lot more applications that could fit that within their power budget. I suspect in the cases where the power isn't an issue it will come down to the designers choosing between the cost and space trade off where a crystal is necessary (it isn't always).
- w0mbat 8y agoI assume this is the technology Apple is already using in their custom silicon, and why there was that fairly recent story of a hospital where Apple devices failed in the presence of helium leaked from their MRI installation.
- ohazi 8y agoApple is/was using silicon mems resonators, which is basically a fancy tuning fork on flexures cut out of silicon. This technology ("bulk acoustic wave") sounds like surface acoustic wave, but perhaps with the vibration mode being through the bulk material rather than just the surface.
- makomk 8y agoIt also seems to fill a different niche from the MEMS resonators Apple are using. Those are ultra-low-power 32KHz oscillators for keeping time in standby mode, but the CC2652RB still relies on an external quartz crystal for that, perhaps because this tech is even more power-hungry than the already too power-hungry high frequency quartz oscillator it replaces.
- abainbridge 8y agoSounds like it is slightly higher power. From the article: > Asked if there is any tradeoff by integrating a BAW resonator in the wireless MCU package, Wong noted a potential power delta at about 2% — “a couple of hundred microamps.” He called it “a reasonable tradeoff, [considering] its benefits outweigh [it].” But, I guess if you can invest the money and area you saved by not having an external crystal and buy a 2% bigger battery, which is probably a net win.
- ohazi 8y agoHow does it fare in a slightly-helium-rich environment? That story about every iPhone in a hospital shutting down for a week after an MRI shutdown turned out to be due to not-quite-hermetically sealed packaging of the silicon mems resonators.
- baybal2 8y agoCeramic piezo oscillators and silicon mems oscillators are a very different technology based on different physics. What matters here is the speed of sound in that ceramic piezo material. Can helium change that by much? I don't know.
- ohazi 8y ago...Yes? That's why I asked.
- vanderZwan 8y agoTechnically, you are not answering GP's question.
- pkaye 8y agoFrom this old paper, I think quartz crystal oscillators are still vulnerable. It all depends on the packaging. https://tf.nist.gov/general/pdf/906.pdf https://tf.nist.gov/general/pdf/906.pdf
- tzs 8y agoBased on the video here [1] and some of the links on that page, plus assorted diagrams of other bulk acoustic wave resonators, I don't think there will be any problem. Helium can interfere with devices that either depend having a vacuum in a volume or depend on having that volume contain a gas mixture with specific properties. Helium getting in messes that up. The BAW on-die-oscillators do not appear to have any places that are supposed to be vacuum or supposed to contain gas. The have two piezoelectric thin films, with acoustic reflectors behind them. The gap between them appears to be solidly filled. All the relevant acoustic waves are carried in that solid stuff, not in air. (This also means, I think, that these things should be OK in vacuum). [1] https://training.ti.com/tis-bulk-acoustic-wave-clocking-technology-0 https://training.ti.com/tis-bulk-acoustic-wave-clocking-tech...
- gugagore 8y agoI think it's so interesting that the best oscillators we can use in electronic circuits, atomic clocks excluded, all operate in the mechanical domain. If I knew nothing, I would assume we could build good RC oscillators, which are purely electrical.
- jakeinspace 8y agoI suppose once you're in the domain of crystal oscillators, the line between "mechanical" versus "purely electrical" is a bit fuzzy. The mechanical/thermal effects of passing a high-frequency signal through passive components (or a transmission line) might be comparable to the mechanical vibrations of a quartz clock, though somebody better at physics could probably correct me.
- Gibbon1 8y agoThe big advantage of mechanical oscillators vs RC occilators is mechanical ones have very high Q. Q is related to the ratio of resonant energy vs the amount lost per cycle. High Q oscillators allow you to produce spectacularly pure and or accurate signals. That's important for RF applications. On the other hand RC oscillators can start up very fast. In uS vs milliseconds. Lot of microcontrollers have an internal RC oscillators for that reason. Go to sleep and wake up instantly. TI's announcement is interesting since external crystals for RF transceivers is a pain point in design and manufacturing. You can have inexplicable variation from one batch of crystals to another. Batch's of IC's. Variations in the PCB material, etc.
- ajross 8y agoWhat does "purely electrical" mean at this scale? Quartz resonators are piezoelectric devices, after all. The same field of solid state physics that explains a MOSFET is required to explain a oscillator.
- SamReidHughes 8y agoQuartz resonators still move and are affected by the direction of gravity
- cedivad 8y agoThis is so funny to me. I instantly thought of the CC26xx series (FSK transceivers) from TI when I first read the title, "Surely the next version of their chips will use this amazing new tech and destroy the need for that external epson oscillator!". Sure enough, that's the first chip quoted in the article. That explains how the newest CC2652 has been available in sampling quantities only for what, a year now? GG, TI.
- kingDreux 8y agoI thought the Atlanta rapper was branching out, but was disappointed when I read the article. I GUESS it's still cool.
- retSava 8y agoAt a "couple of hundred microamps" penalty, this more or less kills a wide range of potential products, ie battery-operated products like smart sensors or remote controls and the like. One of the most important factors for a long lifetime is to minimize the static power draw, and running at 0.1--10 uA is quite common. A common CR2032 has about 225mAh. If you can get 80% out of it, you have about 225 * 1000 * 0,80 / 24 = 7500,0 uA-days. At 10uA, you have roughly 2 years (depending on usage etc). At "a couple hundred uA", you'll have two months.
- cushychicken 8y agoNot necessarily. The application in question is for the baseband reference frequency in a radio. If the oscillator can be powered down with the radio, and powered on during transmit, it would be a great savings. A good callout re: low power applications, however.
- pplonbaw 8y agoI, too, chuckled at the "couple of hundred microamps" quote. However he refers to the high-speed clock, which is turned on only during transmit/receive, and is indeed negligible compared to the total power consumption during RF communication. That being said, their low-frequency on-chip oscillator specs are horrendous (50ppm PER DEGREE). You can't maintain a BTLE connection or mesh node with that kind of clock, you still need a 32kHz crystal oscillator, so TI haven't "solved" the crystal oscillator problem just yet...
- zbrozek 8y agoIndeed; they clearly haven't solved accuracy. But they've done a remarkable job of cleanliness. In particular, the close-in phase noise (e.g., at offsets from carrier < 1 KHz) these BAW-endowed parts are amazing.
- SwaraLink 8y agoWith the CC26xx parts you can use a 32kHz RCOSC and get accurate enough timing for BTLE connections, so with the CC2652RB you should be able to have true "crystal-less" Bluetooth LE.
- dildo_fingers 8y agoAnd he can rap too!
- m3kw9 8y agoThe thing preventing this to be a home run is the power usage increase. +2% vs
- femto 8y agoWeird, the LMK05318 datasheet shows an external crystal oscillator on pins 31 and 32. Is this an older part and the integrated oscillator is not yet released? I went looking for phase noise specifications, as the article and CC2652RB data doesn't have much to say about how the phase noise of the integrated oscillator compares to an external oscillator. http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/lmk05318.pdf http://www.ti.com/lit/ds/symlink/lmk05318.pdf http://www.ti.com/product/LMK05318 http://www.ti.com/product/LMK05318
- zbrozek 8y agoIn that particular part the BAW is part of a secondary, faster oscillator. It's leveraged for its spectral purity - its phase noise - rather than its accuracy. The datasheet you linked is for a clock chip that's designed to take in a reference clock and transform it into multiple end-use clocks. A really neat thing you can do with that part is use a GPS receiver's pulse-per-second output as a high-accuracy, high-noise reference to generate high-accuracy, low-noise, high-frequency clocks. It's something you would see in datacenters or cell sites or distributed sensing systems.
- ChuckMcM 8y agoThis is a pretty big change for digital design. With high accuracy 48MHz clocks on chip, parts that do USB become that much cheaper and more reliable. Single chip USB-3.1 chips become possible as well. The low phase noise is something that makes them very useful for wireless systems that are all software radios these days anyway. Phase noise, or clock jitter, results in difficulty in receiving closely spaced signals. And since many (if not most) of the modern wireless protocols today are multi-channel, it means you can make wireless protocols that support more clients in the same spectrum, or more data to clients in the same spectrum. I am hoping that as a minimum TI releases a series of 4 pin oscillators to replace the ones like from Vectron that can be very finicky to keep working precisely. The only thing I didn't see was what is their vibration resistance standard? The small 'can' oscillators can be pushed of their center frequency by yelling at them ;-) It is a really hard problem to both secure a quartz crystal from outside vibration influences and still allow it to vibrate at its intended frequency!