4 ms·
There are a few difficult aspects to the reality of war. One is that wars are fought for strategic reasons, such as continuing campaigns against enemies, contr
by ilaksh 8y ago
There are a few difficult aspects to the reality of war. One is that wars are fought for strategic reasons, such as continuing campaigns against enemies, controlling resources, or maintaining the "petrodollar" status, etc. The other is that since war involves risking one's life or killing other people, only moral justifications are adequate.
This is problematic because the real motivations for war are practical and strategic and not actually moral. But since military personnel require moral justifications, there is no choice but to fabricate them. For this reason, information control is a key aspect of warfare.
The reason people are blind is because they have been inundated with propaganda. US intelligence must require large outlets like NBC, NY Times and Wall Street Journal, etc. to toe the line when it comes to certain key war propaganda. If they do not do this, then soldiers will not fight. Soldiers are not going to go to battle if the president gives a speech saying "well, the oil executives say that if we can't maintain the status quo for pipeline protection then we can expect 8% higher oil prices next year". They are not going to risk their lives for something like that. They _will_ happily go kill an "evil dictator" and his "evil minions".
But the bottom line for control in our world is deadly force. If we want to get away from that then we need everyone to start following an entirely new paradigm.
- chrischen 8y agoIf a war is fought for strategic non-moral reasons, then a war has to be fought to stop it. So somewhere, someone can be fighting for moral reasons. Doing nothing and letting someone die is just as immoral as potentially killing someone.
- ilaksh 8y agoThat's the justification the other side always uses. But when it comes down to it, the other side is still just trying to control more resources.
- chrischen 8y agoSure, they may provide that justification, but that doesn't change the fact that the counter-party to an immoral fighter is always a moral one. After all, even Hitler hated his enemies, so no one can be free of being hated by at least someone unless they are a passive rock.
- colordrops 8y agoIf I try to snatch your phone out of your hand, are you "just trying to control more resources" by preventing me from doing this? Are you saying there is no such thing as theft?
- TheOtherHobbes 8y agoWar is theft. Nation states currently operate like violent criminal gangs. In the same way that street gangs indoctrinate their members into loyalty, nation states indoctrinate their populations. And in the same way that most of the benefits of gang crime go to the leaders, most of the benefits of war go to a country's upper class, while everyone else bears the risks.
- eeZah7Ux 8y agoOften the strongest gang claims to be "maintaining order" and "protecting" others.
- chrischen 8y agoThe difficulty is in finding out which side is moral, not in determining if one is. Also it's non-binary. Each side can have moral and immoral reasons to varying degrees. This is the common phrase "lesser of two evils" at work.