8 ms·
Dublin has been having a bit of a boom (of which tech is a major driver) in the last decade, but this just feels like another symptom of the city which is not a
by Macha 8y ago
Dublin has been having a bit of a boom (of which tech is a major driver) in the last decade, but this just feels like another symptom of the city which is not allowed to build denser or to sprawl with the result being anything less profitable in terms of land value is getting pushed out of the city (including many families who have lived their behind) while rents reach some of the highest levels in Europe
- CydeWeys 8y agoSeriously. And when space is at such a premium, and it's possible to build up as much as demand warrants, why exactly should nightclubs be prioritized over, say, people's housing? Perhaps the fact that they're diminishing in number reflects the simple fact that housing is a better (and more economic) use of limited space? It sounds like they're not allowing enough construction to meet demand, and then being shocked when the obvious outcome (prioritization of some uses) occurs.
- jwagenet 8y agoWhy can't a nightclub be included as part of "first floor" commercial/retail space that can be found in many cities? You have the best of both worlds, a mid/high rise with housing and close proximity to retail and entertainment spaces. Sure, clubs have noise and people issues, but these can be designed around for noise abatement and traffic control or put them underground. Bars have these issues too. Just because land owners can make more from developing housing in the modern urbanization doesn't mean commercial retail/art/dining/entertainment spaces should be pushed out, otherwise the declining proximity benefits of urbanization lose their appeal.
- jakecopp 8y agoNightclubs are pretty loud though, and that bass travels a long way and is hard to isolate. Maybe if the club was in the basement it might work, but I'd love to get some insight from someone who deals with acoustics!
- lapnitnelav 8y agoMy ex-flatmate left our flat to live above one. He didn't stay long in that new place. So yeah, good luck with blocking out low frequencies.
- imgabe 8y agoIf it were a high rise, I don't think it would be a problem. You could do a nightclub on the ground floor, 10 floors of office (which would would be empty when the nightclub is open) and 10 floors of apartments above that.
- jakecopp 8y agoTrue, that does seem like it would work.
- fredophile 8y agoHave you ever lived near a night club? I used to live in an apartment with a nightclub down the street on the next block. I couldn't hear noise from the club itself but I could always tell when it closed by the loud people on the street. I was 20 floors up. People can decide they're willing to live with the noise for the convenient location but there will always be some amount of noticeable noise if you live on the same block as a night club.
- sshagent 8y agoOh crap, i had forgotten about that. I lived on a corner of two streets filled with clubs, several floors up. 23:00 onwards it was like someone was shouting constantly and directly outside each of my windows. Granted after a few weeks this became "normal" and every place I've lived in since as seemed strangely quiet.
- _wmd 8y agoWho in their right mind wants to invest in a new build with the knowledge a late license was issued to the floor below?
- jen729w 8y agoAny nightclub in a new residential build is going to be a terrible place full of shiny teenagers. The sorts of venues mentioned in this article remind me of the old warehouse parties I used to go to here in Melbourne ~10 years ago, when I was well in to my 30s. They just wouldn’t have worked in a new place.
- volkl48 8y agoSure, but eventually places age and develop their own character and audience. In the same vein and more my crowd, you can't just open a (good) dive bar, it takes years to develop the community atmosphere they wind up becoming.
- Symbiote 8y agoThis can exist, for example the Islington Academy in North London. The exit is into the shopping centre, so noise and chatter from people leaving isn't a big problem. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O2_Academy_Islington https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/O2_Academy_Islington
- imgabe 8y agoThe existence of things like nightclubs is a reason there is demand for the housing. A city with only housing is not one that anyone would want to live in.
- jhbadger 8y agoThat's really a good point. The whole reason city living became popular again is that the supposed "utopia" of suburbia was really boring.
- dgellow 8y agoAt what point was city life not popular?
- hnhg 8y agoIn the UK, anytime before the late 90s. I can't find the statistic, but I remember reading that in the 80s, less than 1000 people lived in the city centre. Contrast that with the numbers now: https://www.centreforcities.org/blog/the-return-of-city-centre-living-in-manchester/ https://www.centreforcities.org/blog/the-return-of-city-cent...
- jhbadger 8y agoIn the US (and a lesser degree in other countries), the advent of the car in the 20th century (and especially after WWII) meant that the "good life" became defined as moving out of the cities (where housing was generally in apartment blocks or row houses) to the new suburbs where detached houses with their own yards were the norm. Cities were viewed as places where one might work, but if you were middle class or above, you returned to your suburban home at night. But over the last couple of decades people (particularly people born in the 1970s or later) began to see the advantage of living somewhere where you didn't need to drive everywhere and shopping, restaurants, and bars were just a short walk away.
- CPLX 8y ago1977 comes to mind: https://youtu.be/bnVH-BE9CUo https://youtu.be/bnVH-BE9CUo
- zerogvt 8y agoIt's not housing though. It's hotels - quite different. Rents have been climbing up for the past years (it's now worse than London or Munich) and they don't seem to slow down. Tech boom (low taxation on tech firms), Brexit and AirBnB are the main drivers. People are coming in (quite often with fat paychecks) but few new apartments/houses are being build. New hotels will compete w/ AirBnB but will do little to alleviate the housing crisis(1). 1. It has been publicly recognized as such for quite long now. Crisis meaning that lower income families are unable to compete in this market (i.e. evictions and such). Also this is a hindrance to further economic development (who's going to work on all these new jobs when s/he'll have trouble making ends meet?). You get the idea.
- dajohnson89 8y agoWhy isn't the city allowed to be denser?
- scarejunba 8y agoSame as anywhere else. The locals don’t want that to happen. Unfortunately, other people want to live there too, and there’s a market for housing so it has the obvious effect.
- lapnitnelav 8y agoNIMBYers mostly. There's an awful lot of urban sprawl because of those archaic rules and you add to that a pretty terrible public transport by Western Europe standards. Dublin is pretty terrible place to live in if you're not wealthy. Any attempt to improve both situations are thwarted by aforementioned NIMBY folks which are only looking out for themselves, among them the people in power.[0] [0] https://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/editorial/the-irish-times-view-on-metrolink-back-to-the-drawing-board-1.3804044 https://www.irishtimes.com/opinion/editorial/the-irish-times...
- fbonetti 8y agoSame as any other city: zoning. People want to live in cities and local governments won't allow developers to build more housing to accommodate them. The rare scraps of land that are zoned properly for high density are developed into luxury housing.
- wheybags 8y agoPartially because people don't want it to be, too. Irish people have an obsession with land, and see any dwelling that isn't at least a semidetached house with a back garden as a "temporary space" for students and unmarried young couples. We just don't like apartments.
- purple_ducks 8y ago> We just don't like apartments. People have legitimate reasons for not liking apartments in Dublin of which noise is a major reason. Lax planning & building regs. dictated to politicians by developers ensured that apartments were small and had neighbours on pretty much every side. Most people who left apartments did so for valid reasons, not an obsession with land. Living long term in 98% of apartments in Dublin would ruin your quality of life.
- Animats 8y agoThe kind of low-end large space nightlife the author wants requires an abandoned warehouse district. SF SOMA used to be like that. Either a more productive use for the land is found, as in SF, or everybody young leaves, as in Detroit or the Cleveland Flats. Dublin isn't cramped by geography. Five miles west of downtown is farmland.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYeah. Those kinds of venues are going strong here in Williamsburg and Bushwick, in the numerous formerly industrial areas that are being re-colonized. And given the sheer noise and foot traffic of those venues, being out of the way is a good thing.
- lucideer 8y agoThere are so many commenters here repeating this mantra "just build higher, just build denser", with seemingly no grip of facts about property in Dublin. There's no restrictions on height nor density in the Docklands area of Dublin: an area within walking distance of the centre of the city, and with a good regular tram link, that is mostly vacant. Similarly, many areas on major tram routes are not so restricted, such as Sandyford and Cherrywood (these three areas, along with East Point, also happen to be where much of the tech boom is focused). So your denser/higher suggestion is being done and is having no affect—residential rents in these areas are the highest in the city, and much of the units available are left empty as a result. Meanwhile, in terms of actual supply, even outside of those areas, Dublin has an estimated 40000 vacant residential units, and plenty of vacant commercial units on top of that. The primary reason for this is that rent prices are not demand-based as much property is financialised—rent isn't a driver for owners, and there are little to no penalties for lack of tenancy, as other cities have.
- agent008t 8y agoWhy would the property owners rather have the units sit empty than rent them out at market rates?
- dubliner9039 8y agoIt's a very typical pattern in speculative finance
- nizmow 8y agoAlso happens a lot in Sydney, for the same reasons.
- agent008t 8y agoIt kind of makes sense if the apartment is more valuable as new than as having been rented out before. But I do not think that is the case in Dublin. Even if the apartment prices are rising rapidly and you plan to sell the apartment once the price goes up - why not also collect rental yield while you are waiting?
- CalRobert 8y agoIndeed. If you like ~60% of SF rents with ~39% of SF pay it's the city for you. I still like it here, but I have a flat that I got crazy cheap in 2013 and is rent controlled (incidentally, a horrifically stupid policy enacted _especially_ badly here, making the housing crisis even worse). I also just got a remote job and bought a house in Offaly. I used to encourage people to come to Dublin because it offered better QOL than the bay (I like not being annoyed on weekends and holidays, and that even my non-tech-worker wife gets a month off a year by law) but I really can't any more unless your housing is arranged or you have a fantastic (California-level) offer
- CalRobert 8y agoEh, I meant ~30%. 39% would be rather specific.
- dubliner9039 8y ago> is not allowed to build denser or to sprawl Don't confuse density with its opposite, sprawling. Irish and british cities often have large, low density, horrible sprawls.
- maleno 8y agoThere's nothing at all stopping Dublin from being much more dense than it is, and there's no need whatsoever to build high to do it. Huge gains could be made by bringing more 'above the shop' units into use. Vacancy and dereliction are massive issues, both in the city centre and further out - tackling that through vacant site levies or compulsory purchase orders would be huge. Regulating the abuse of AirBnB could bring a few thousand rental units in the city back into long-term use practically overnight. As far as building new stock goes, everything is too expensive because land is too expensive. Development land around the city has been stockpiled and hoarded for decades, creating artificial scarcity and driving up prices. It's basically impossible to make a profit on reasonably dense, reasonably priced, two or three bed apartment schemes in Dublin. The SCSI and PII have good reports on this if you want to look them up. It's nearly always more profitable (and easier) to just sit on the land rather than actually develop it. The reason all the nightclubs are being replaced by hotels is a result of this: hotels are a lot more commercially viable than almost any other form of development right now. (Hotel beds in Dublin had over 90% occupancy rates last summer - they're bursting and demand is massive.) The majority of new residential building happens in the outer suburbs and commuter belt, from Lucan to Navan. Just 31 (!!!) new homes were built in Dublin 1 (the very centre of the city) in 2018. Apartments made up just 13% of new builds in the state last year. The apartments we do build are, on average, smaller, darker, less well serviced, and more expensive than almost any other European city. The apartments built between 1995 and 2008 are riddled with issues, from fire safety to damp to electrics. I think that accounts for a lot of Irish people's apparent antipathy towards apartment living, much more than any nonsense about an inherent desire for a semi-d with a garden. Rents are expensive because of an increase in the numbers renting (doubled in last decade); because the rent-certainty regulation is weak or non-existent; because tenure security does not exist; because build-to-rent is expensive to develop; because REITs and larger commercial landlords are soaking up all supply and charging as much as they can. Take your pick. It's a mess. Sorry to go on, but I just finished a six-month deep dive on the reasons behind the housing crisis in Dublin and there is just so much misinformation out there, it's frustrating. P.S. In case anyone wants to hear more, I made a four-episode podcast series about this, the final episode of which just went up today: www.dublininquirer.com/2019/02/27/supply-demand-a-podcast-about-dublin-s-housing-crisis-episode-4