4 ms·
I really loved USB-C then they screwed it up so badly. Can we have 1 cable that is required to have every exact feature available, no exceptions? Works on any d
by giancarlostoro 8y ago
I really loved USB-C then they screwed it up so badly. Can we have 1 cable that is required to have every exact feature available, no exceptions? Works on any device, supports everything from storage to video transfer (Monitors) and whatever else Apple would add to it.
- mikeash 8y agoLook at Thunderbolt, where a cheap-ass cable still costs $20, for an idea of how that would turn out.
- thefounder 8y agoThat's a licensing issue/cost.
- mikeash 8y agoIs it? They’re complicated active cables.
- nakedrobot2 8y agotrue. and, with a licensing fee ;)
- gok 8y agoAnd USB-C 10 Gbps cables aren't much cheaper, especially if they do 100W power delivery. Both probably could be cheaper if there were more demand for them, but siren song of cheap slow cables seems to have made it impossible to scale production up.
- hakfoo 8y agoWell, realistically, you don't need 100 watt power delivery for a keyboard, so you might want a less robust cable. The big mistake IMO was a lack of obvious keying. Very little stops me from using that 2w-capacity keyboard cable to try to charge my laptop. If we're lucky, there's signaling at the device to tell me what's wrong, but if they had made a different plug on the 100W cable, it would eliminate a lot of cockpit errors. Having one cable for everything is a huge red herring. If you need a keyboard and a power brick and an external hard drive, you need three cables. It doesn't matter if they're different, as long as the OEM isn't pulling some Apple-style "one single port is enough" BS.
- gok 8y agoSo you'd want a low speed connector, a high speed connector, a high wattage connector and also a high speed + high wattage connector? So 4 plugs, or more if you want to add even faster speeds in the future. And then you need cables which have one of each of those connectors on each end, so we're talking about dozens of variants. No thank you. The drama around USB-C is insanely overblown; the vast majority of use cases are fine with the 60 watt + 480 mbps required minimum configuration for USB-C cables. In the few rare exceptions where you need >60 watts or higher speed, you're generally going to have purpose-built hardware anyway, so just devoting a special cable to that isn't such a big deal.
- jwr 8y agoI think the drama is mostly about the fact that there is no way to tell what a cable (or a port) "supports" by looking at it.
- Dylan16807 8y ago> Well, realistically, you don't need 100 watt power delivery for a keyboard, so you might want a less robust cable. But on the other hand doubling the power wire thickness and leaving the signals wires untouched shouldn't add more than 10-20% to the price of the cable. > The big mistake IMO was a lack of obvious keying. Very little stops me from using that 2w-capacity keyboard cable to try to charge my laptop. If we're lucky, there's signaling at the device to tell me what's wrong, but if they had made a different plug on the 100W cable, it would eliminate a lot of cockpit errors. Every cable supports at least 60 watts. It's not a big deal if you use the wrong one to charge with.
- hannasanarion 8y agoRegular USB A/B had the same problem. I have been frustrated many times plugging in a micro B cable only to find that it carried power but not data
- stefan_ 8y agoI don't think there was ever a USB spec that allowed you to skip the data lines. That is purely a chinese cost optimization. Meanwhile, the confusion with USB 3 (C?) is designed in.
- ken 8y agoYou say cost optimization, I say safety feature.
- dTal 8y agoThat "safety feature" prevents the client device from negotiating a higher current limit than 100mA. The host controller may generously provide more, but there's no guarantee of this without the data lines.
- londons_explore 8y agoThe host is required to not be damaged by a short circuit on the power lines. That means a device can ignore the signalling entirely and just keep taking more power till the supply turns off, and then scale back 10 percent. More and more Android phones do that, and it works very well. Only disadvantage is if you plug it into a hub, it can cause the whole hub to go out for a bit. Devices solve that by not using the above algorithm when they detect any active signalling.
- kylec 8y agoApple sells one: https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MQ4H2AM/A/thunderbolt-3-usb%E2%80%91c-cable-08-m https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MQ4H2AM/A/thunderbolt-3-u... It does Thunderbolt 3, USB-C 3.1 Gen 2, and up to 100W of power delivery. It's a shame it's only available in one kinda-short length, but I think that's a technical limitation (any longer would require an active cable for Thunderbolt).
- giancarlostoro 8y agoCurious how compatible it is with other non-Apple devices? The worst thing I've heard of is phones getting burnt out by overpowered USB-C chargers which I think is crazy and why the spec should enforce one and only one type of cable. I've been buying USB-C cables from Anker and from Belkyn that I've seen at Walmart cause they're brands I trust not to screw things up in a ridiculous way, thankfully my phones have survived both so far. I rather pay a little more if it means my phone wont get damaged.
- agumonkey 8y agoI remember the brain bliss of seeing the first usb-c article. Funny how the world goes