7 ms·
Widespread and sometimes drastic marine oxygen declines
- valtism 8y agoFrom what I have researched about conservation, it seems that our oceans are simultaneously the most important and most overlooked parts of our environment. The oceans house 80% of the world's biomass, and produce between 50% - 85% of the world's oxygen. We can't see below the waves, so it's easy for us to ignore what is going on down there. Massive overfishing and acidification is having huge impacts, not to mention the falling levels of oxygen in the water.
- dgzl 8y agoYou might be right, but damn does this world have a lot to worry about.
- eanzenberg 8y agoWe’re always 10 years from total annihilation and destruction. You can worry your whole life (tons of people do) or go on with your life. The earth has dealt with far far far worse outcomes in the past and there’s no evidence that it’ll reach that in the newr future.
- skh 8y agoWe’re always 10 years from total annihilation and destruction. I know people talk in hyperbole to make a point but can you point to any credible source in the last 30 years stating we are close to total annilhilation within the next 50 years? No one doubts the Earth will be fine. The doubt is whether or not human civilization will be fine.
- XorNot 8y agoI think an even better way is not even human civilization, of some sort is in doubt. It's civilization where you get to walk to the store and buy a week's supply of food in exchange for money, and expect to do so the next week just as easily, which is in doubt.
- thomasahle 8y agoProblems were fixed because we did stuff about them. The abandonment of cfc gasses was huge. Treaties on fishing and hunting has saved tons of species. Any single person can probably get away with not doing anything, and the problems will seem to magically go away, but they only do so because some people act. (And usually it takes a lot of people.)
- taneq 8y agoWe're always 3 missed meals away from anarchy too.
- swinglock 8y agoYou're right, the earth has had worse and will be just fine. After all the earth is just a rock, it's not concerned about emissions or life. It's not the earth anyone needs to worry about, it's the humans. We've not been through worse and our smaller challenges often have catastrophic outcomes.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago"Total annihilation" may be a bit far-fetched, but what we are much closer to is global war, death and suffering for you, me, and everyone we know. Just to cover one angle (IMO most likely one): reduced living space (sea rise) and food shortages will cause massive migrations. Think how the whole EU went basically insane over a bunch of refugees from Syria (and the aftershocks still threaten to shake it apart). Climate-change induced migrations will be much larger, and this time around actually backed by countries people are fleeing. Wars are likely. Proxy wars are likely too. And nukes won't be off the table either. Even if you live so far inland that waters can't get to you, people will. And if you survive that, then lack of people will get to you as the global supply chain stretches to a breaking point and suddenly no one can make anything as all the components came from China. The lifestyle we're all used to depends on global-scale systems with single points of failure.
- ckastner 8y ago> We’re always 10 years from total annihilation and destruction. You can worry your whole life (tons of people do) or go on with your life. The earth has dealt with far far far worse outcomes in the past and there’s no evidence that it’ll reach that in the newr future. This got down-voted to hell, which is odd, because it rings true. The "total annihilation" isn't even that hyperbolic. I've seen comments here on HN that depict our world as under imminent threat of global nuclear war, or that depict our world as suffering from a mass extinction (caused by humans) that will end all life as we know it. I believe those statements are the hyperbolic ones, and one should be allowed to call them out for that.
- usrusr 8y agoThe history-repeating argument, when applied to drunk driving: "so far I've always made it home without killing anyone". I read a lot about history and the one common thread that appears over and over again is that history is only repeating until it stops doing so. So many cycles that must have seemed eternal to those inside have eventually come to an end. One day, every Cassandra will be right.
- ckastner 8y agoThe history-repeating argument, when applied to astronomy: "so far, the Earth has revolved around the Sun". Just to show that the history-repeating argument can be made ad absurdum both ways. We have ample empirical evidence that drunk driving poses a significant risk of killing someone, hence there should be a non-trival level of expectation of this outcome. We have absolutely zero empirical evidence as to what actions may trigger a nuclear holocaust, and we're currently not seeing any of the popularly accepted causes for the 5 mass extinctions of the past.
- acqq 8y agohttps://www.mymoneyblog.com/talebs-thanksgiving-turkey.html https://www.mymoneyblog.com/talebs-thanksgiving-turkey.html "I have the story of a turkey that is fed for 1,000 days by a butcher, and every day confirms to the turkey and the turkey’s economics department and the turkey’s risk management department and the turkey’s analytical department that the butcher loves turkeys, and every day brings more confidence to the statement. So it’s fed for 1,000 days… " Every day somebody was able (even accidentally) to start the nuclear annihilation of the whole world (hint: it's not "just a president" who can do that, but many, many more): the complex systems and the war plans are actually maintained in which everything happens in just a few hours. Our statistics that it didn't happen yet is not a proof that an "accident" (oh, sorry, it was an error!) can't very easily happen any moment now.
- newnewpdro 8y ago> damn does this world have a lot to worry about. Around 7.55 billion with something like three more every second. [1] [1] https://www.census.gov/popclock/ https://www.census.gov/popclock/
- taneq 8y agoNot to imply that population isn't going to be an issue (especially since we're likely going to flood a bunch of arable land in the next few decades) but if the graph "Yearly Population Growth Rate (%)" here (http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/ http://www.worldometers.info/world-population/) is to be believed, there's been a pretty significant drop-off in world population growth in the last ~50 years and we're certainly nowhere near the exponentially exploding population crisis that people were fearing in the mid 20th century.
- henryw 8y agoThere's a good animated video that explains this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsBT5EQt348 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QsBT5EQt348
- yesenadam 8y agoI learnt from that that there are more non-religious people than there are catholics! I had no idea. (Most of my friends are catholics, I'm atheist)
- saiya-jin 8y agoNot non-religious, but other religions - the fact that only -+28% are christians might give some humbleness to those feeling righteous and above all in religious aspects (ie us vs those poor lost pagans mindset). Since muslims believe in basically the same god it gives you 54% (jews are rather insignificant portion of population). It still means 3.5 billions currently (and historically over 100 billion) are breaking 10 core amendments and should burn in hell eternally (grossly oversimplified obviously). You can't just bring rationality, common sense or critical thinking into most current religions, they fall apart like house of cards. I wish there would be some new major religion that would only preach a single thing - be a nice, good person to yourself and every sentient living creature out there. Nothing more required.
- smallgovt 8y agoMy thoughts exactly. I feel like a day doesn't go by where I learn about another potential problem that could lead to the end of civilization. What's a good way to stack rank / prioritize these issues to know what's most urgent?
- krageon 8y agoI suspect you are seeing the result of a few generations of humans doing exactly what you are proposing and subsequently maybe (with effort) fixing the number one demand. All the other "future huge problems" have become the now huge problems and it doesn't really make sense to rank all the definitely going to destroy our way of life issues because they will all result in the same thing with a similar time frame (way too soon).
- m_mueller 8y agoI have the same intuition. It’s not all that different from an old codebase that runs on even older (and disintegrating) hardware. You may keep fixing things, adapt to mildly new requirements, change a tape deck here, a consensator there, but eventually the whole system is going to come down and has to be replaced - there’s nothing we know that lasts forever in a self-repairing way, and that’s what’s going to happen to our civilization. Telling by the worms and the beetles my guess is it’s a matter of decades, not centuries, hopefully not years. The only hope is that we’ve wisened up sufficiently till then to renew without completely getting annihilated or being back at cave-and-sticks level.
- bryanrasmussen 8y agomaybe although I got to think that a lot of these environmental issues destroying our way of life way too soon are interconnected, and it perhaps isn't as difficult to rank them as it might seem when viewed as singular unconnected problems. on edit: typo, changed out to our.
- collyw 8y agoClimate change has been talked about for decades now, and very little actually seem to be done. What is something you would consider a number 1 that was fixed? (I guess the ozone layer hole was a relative success).
- CarelessSmirch 8y agoOn the upside, the dying process of oxygen deprivation seems to be quick and painless. https://jme.bmj.com/content/36/3/174 https://jme.bmj.com/content/36/3/174
- std_throwawayay 8y agoDoesn't the extraction of fish have a positive impact on the O2 balance? I thought that overfishing the kinds of big fish we like to eat will just lead to a growing population of smaller fish and other marine life.
- zappo2938 8y agoTop level predators plays a key role in balance and sustainability of ecosystems. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysa5OBhXz-Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysa5OBhXz-Q
- std_throwawayay 8y agoI agree that taking one specific animal out of a complex system that had a long time to adjust will produce big changes. Killing the wolves allowed the deer to thrive. We wanted lots of deer, so that was good for some time. Now we don't hunt enough of them, so we need wolves again. I agree that the oceans change - a lot - due to human influence. Some species will dwindle in numbers and disappear. It takes a long time for new species to emerge. But what I'm not so sure is that the overall change necessarily would have to be so negative in the long run.
- krageon 8y agoFishing while selecting for big specimens and throwing smaller specimens back leads to the unfortunate result of us creating selective pressure for small fish. Those big fish have, when they are smaller, inefficient reproductive systems which means they have a harder time creating enough offspring in the wild. Even if what you are saying had anything to do with how things actually work (it doesn't), this selective pressure contributes to our favourite fish dying out.
- std_throwawayay 8y agoYes, the fish we catch will die out. Bad for us because we don't have any good fish left over. What I'm also saying is that I think that other fish (or lifeforms in general) will take their place.
- revscat 8y agoI fear we are approaching a time where the only means to stave off holocaust is for actions to be undertaken that would get one banned in polite forums such as this one were they to be openly suggested.
- ars 8y agoThere's not going to be a holocaust, or mass deaths, or anything like that. Even the worst case predictions do not predict that. The predict some species extinction, migration off the coast, and changes in the the weather - yes. But not "a holocaust" or anything like that.
- hsavit1 8y agoWhat are you talking about?? Mass extermination of life on Earth is genocide.
- eanzenberg 8y agoCitation?
- yakshaving_jgt 8y agoTechnically, that isn't true. Genocide: the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic group or nation. Emphasis my own.
- unimpressive 8y agoI'm worried about the tails. Recent revelations like the bug biomass loss should sober anybody up. https://www.laboratoryequipment.com/news/2017/10/insect-biomass-declines-75-percent-over-three-decades-europe https://www.laboratoryequipment.com/news/2017/10/insect-biom...
- eanzenberg 8y agoIt’s like, right there, in the actual link... >>>The changing climatic conditions, from temperature to wind speed, didn’t appear to impact the species.
- kartan 8y agoLong term viability and neoliberalism are at odds. Why do you want to invest in a company long term when you can squish it and buy another two more functional ones with the profits? We are ripping planet resources for short term gain. I hope that out there are some good planets on sale, because in the current course of action we will need one. > "As oxygen-rich regions become scarcer, current fish habitats will also shrink and force economically important species—such as tuna, which globally generate an estimated $42 billion annually—into new ranges." Most of the articles seem to cater to that line of though. Think about the economy! Will we let the planet die if it was good for the economy?
- vnorilo 8y agoI lean left and green as much as the next guy, but I believe markets and liberalism can and must be a part of the solution. The really hard part is to work out how to get the environmental externalities priced in. My personal gut feeling is that if we can't do that, we're screwed environment-wise.
- bendoernberg 8y agoMarkets and liberalism have been failing so drastically for decades that fascism is rising across the globe. What evidence do you see that this is going to change in time to prevent unimaginable catastrophe? We all need to sprint lefter and greener before it's too late.
- vnorilo 8y agoThe evidence is to the contrary as you said. I just think that the only way to get people to actually do this is to let the markets work it out. I'm not saying, at all, that the "invisible hand" will sort it out by itself. Agreed: that's ridicilously naive, or worse (bad faith). I mean that if regulators force the costs of externalities into the market, things could work out. When I'm shopping for milk, my local grocery has options like organic, and locally produced (within county). Which is the green choice? Soy milk is likely less co2 intensive, but then again it's shipped from across the globe. I do not know. And this is just milk. I'd prefer the govt to tax greenhouse gases to oblivion. Then it becomes easy for me and others.
- woogiewonka 8y agoIt feels like us humans are unable to solve the challenges ahead of us. One could argue the sort of effort and organization required to make an appropriate change would take a couple of hundred years, yet here we are with only a decade to meet the unattainable IPCC goals. Let's hope we don't see each other on the battlefield, in wars that are surely to come. I will lie down and die before I kill a fellow human being.
- fabianhjr 8y ago> unattainable IPCC goals They are quite attainable, it is just that most people don't feel the urgency of preventing an extinction event or they feel like "individual change" is more important than societal change. (Eg, Extinction Rebellion is one subgroup that does get the urgency)
- flukus 8y ago> yet here we are with only a decade to meet the unattainable IPCC goals They probably are unattainable, but that's only because we (an electorally significant subset anyway) opted to sit on our asses for 30 years. The Kyoto protocol (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kyoto_Protocol) was the largest international collective effort and ignored by certain selfish countries.
- krageon 8y agoThose goals are and have always been attainable. We've just not put in the effort required. No goal is attainable if you are unwilling to work to attain it.
- onion2k 8y agoIt feels like us humans are unable to solve the challenges ahead of us. Every significant challenge humans have faced in history has probably felt like that. That isn't to say we'll definitely solve the challenges facing us now. We might not. It's just that how we feel about the problem isn't actually very useful besides being good motivation to actually try.
- aszantu 8y agoif it was important, govt would do something, instead germany govt just decided not to punish car industry for fraud and it's not pushing for higher taxes on cars in general... so.. it's not important enough to do something xD
- Johnny555 8y agoOn the other hand, Germany is in the top 10 for fuel taxes, so it's not like they are doing nothing to discourage fossil fuel usage. https://afdc.energy.gov/data/10327 https://afdc.energy.gov/data/10327 (The USA is quite close to the bottom of the list) Additionally, their gasoline price per gallon (converted to USD) is also in the top 10, while the USA is near the bottom (only Russia, Saudi Arabia and Iran have lower gasoline prices) https://www.statista.com/statistics/221368/gas-prices-around-the-world/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/221368/gas-prices-around...
- netsharc 8y agoThey also lobbied to keep lax testing so "dirty" cars can pass them: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/sep/24/uk-france-and-germany-lobbied-for-flawed-car-emissions-tests-documents-reveal https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/sep/24/uk-franc... The carmaker lobby has a lot of influence on the German government, and obviously "jobs!" is important to politicians (if they want to remain in power, they'd do anything to keep their voters employed, if that means keeping the car industry running while sacrificing the environment...). And there are still unrestricted speed autobahns because why would people buy BMWs or Porsches otherwise? Even though going really fast is really bad to the environment.
- skilled 8y agoI have always been 'happy go lucky' type of a person about my entire life. But, earlier today, from this thread [1], I learned that we have grown from 1 billion to 7 billion people in just 200 years. I knew we are at 7 billion right now, but holy fuck... in 200 years we went up by 6 billion? This seems a little disconcerting, and not for the reasons you might think. I feel as though society is so caught up in the rat race (literally!) that we simply don't give a damn about what is happening to the planet anymore. And I know there are a lot of strong characters on HN who love to talk their way out of any conversation, but what's needed on this planet is a massive awakening to the fact that you cannot expect to exhaust Earth's resources without paying a price for it. It's kind of funny how even the tech industry (presumably smart people..) overlook the very fundamentals of supply and demand. We all know about the story of Tibet vs. China, but does everyone know that Tibet is a lithium goldmine? [2] Let me guess... China "did not" invade Tibet for its resources... it was simply an emotional grudge! And tell me even more, how safe we are and ample supply there is for all the world's necessities... The UN can't and won't do anything. And everyone who is 'using' these resources has such strong ties in the political systems that we won't see any significant change any time soon. And you know the saddest part? This is all because of money and self-projected power. And at what expense? A planet that is supposed to be taken care of by its people? This is the fundamental human flaw, exhaust everything until there is none left and move on to the next thing... I can already hear the justified screams, "Elon will take us to the Mars!". [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19247821 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19247821 [2]: https://goodelectronics.org/mining-tibet-for-electronics-raw-materials/ https://goodelectronics.org/mining-tibet-for-electronics-raw...
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> I knew we are at 7 billion right now, but holy fuck... in 200 years we went up by 6 billion? Congratulations, you're one of the today's lucky 10000 :) [0]. That's the exponential growth. It seems shocking when you fully comprehend its shape for the first time. (Also a spoiler: "we're using more of resource X now than all our use in the past combined" is true at any point in time under exponential growth, too.) People don't notice it in case of many things because it's a natural consequence of independent agents doing the same thing. I'm reminded of the story about bacteria in a bottle: on 11:00 you have a single one, their number doubles every minute, and you know that on 12:00 they'll fill the entire bottle. Q: at which point the bacteria will notice they're running out of space? A: somewhere after 11:59. > This is the fundamental human flaw, exhaust everything until there is none left and move on to the next thing... Wouldn't go that far. This is a fundamental flaw of life itself. Humans, in fact, are probably the only living thing on this planet that is capable of self-moderation. Life in general is moderated by death. Animals reproduce until they either exceed the food supply and start starving, or their abundance causes predator populations to grow (and they grow until they eat most of the prey, and then starve, starting the cycle anew) This is nature's self-regulation, and it's present at every level - from animals to bacteria. Yes, it would be best if we could moderate ourselves a bit more, but it's worth stopping and considering sometimes how unnatural moderation is, before condemning humans as some aberrant creatures. > I can already hear the justified screams, "Elon will take us to the Mars!". Oh come on :). Elon wants to take people to Mars so that they live happily on two planets, thus mitigating some x-risks like killer asteroids, or biotech fuckups. He never endorsed the idea of giving up on Earth. Settling Mars long-term ain't easier than surviving here anyway, and there's a huge overlap in technologies needed - especially if we can't coordinate internationally to unfuck the climate in the first place. -- [0] - https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- writimov 8y agoWhat can the average person do to help the oceans that is easy to understand, everyone can do themselves and the government can sponsor with money? I'm thinking of something like planting trees: order a free tree (government paid) in the mail, pick a spot and plant it. * https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/07/pakistan-s-billion-tree-tsunami-is-astonishing/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/07/pakistan-s-billion-tr... * https://news.globallandscapesforum.org/28687/africas-great-green-wall-a-work-in-progress/ https://news.globallandscapesforum.org/28687/africas-great-g... Can we do the equivalent and plant a kelp bed or the equivalent for different ocean conditions? https://www.montereybayaquarium.org/animal-guide/plants-and-algae/giant-kelp https://www.montereybayaquarium.org/animal-guide/plants-and-...
- source99 8y agoStop buying stuff. Eat less meat.
- devoply 8y agoDon't have children and join a right wing party which wishes to stop immigration. The fewer immigrants the lesser the consumption, as when immigrants move to rich countries they consume much more than if they were to stay in poorer countries... Also less immigration means a smaller economy which is good for the environment. Poe's law applies. > The average annual carbon dioxide emissions per person, they found, was 20 metric tons, compared to a world average of four tons. But the "floor" below which nobody in the U.S. can reach, no matter a person's energy choices, turned out to be 8.5 tons, the class found.
- inapis 8y agoThis is naive. Your argument is hinged on the proposition that rich countries will remain rich and poor countries will stay poor. Given the current economic activity, a shit ton of countries will become rich and their resource consumption will increase. It's not if, it's when. So stopping immigration will help,maybe, in the short term but the earth doesn't care for what happens in next 4-5 years. The earth does care if resource consumption increases exponentially over the next century.
- colechristensen 8y agoWhy don't we intentionally oxygenate the water where ag runoff meets the ocean to encourage algal blooms to either act as food for sea life or to fix carbon by algae dying and sinking to the bottom of the ocean? Ok that isn't the only issue, but it seems to be a big one.
- King-Aaron 8y agoWe'll probably enter the era of experimental geoengineering pretty soon, I would imagine.
- bamboozled 8y agoI think at some point in the very near future it would be better off face facts, avoid ag run off and tackle climate change rather than implement more hacks.
- collyw 8y agoI can't help but think all the suggested hacks around climate change are a bad option. We never expected that burning fossil fuels would have such a potentially catastrophic effect on our environment. I imagine that many of the solutions will have similar unintended consequences.
- FranciscusG 8y agoActually we did expect that. 160-odd years ago, people started to suspect trouble ahead and many decades ago, the writing was clearly on the wall, scientifically speaking.
- mdekkers 8y agoBetween the vested financial interest that are joined at the hip with political interest and the outright refusal of the majority of the population of the western world to make any kind of personal sacrifices to combat climate change, we are deeply fucked as a species. The "non western / non 1st world" segment of the population have a lot of other things to worry about, such as "how am I going to keep a roof over the head of my family and put food on the table" even though these people often live a subsistence-type living, where at the very least some part of their regular calories come directly from small-scale farming / hunting / fishing, and they experience first-hand the impact of climate change. As George Carlin astutely observed: "The planet doesn't need saving. It will adapt to the new paradigm, and continue to exist. The people need saving". I strongly believe he hit the nail on the head, and we should really change the narrative from "save the oceans / forests / animals / planet" to "save humanity". It should be abundantly clear that in practical terms, nobody gives a fuck about saving the environment. Maybe they care about saving their children. I really think that saving our species starts with eradicating poverty, ensuring that 100% of the global population doesn't need to worry about water, food, shelter, healthcare and education. I don't know what the best path would be to achieve this, but I have a feeling that if we would stop spending on warfare, significantly increase top-level corporate taxation and funnel that money instead to providing everyone with the basic needs, and combine that with a concentrated global effort on researching and implementing truly sustainable energy generation and associated heat removal we'd be off to a good start. Unfortunately, when it comes down to it, we have not evolved much past the "apes with sticks around the watering hole" stage, so the chances of that coming to pass are statistically nil.