4 ms·
SEC filing: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664-Show-Cause.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664-Show-Cause.h...
by minimaxir 8y ago
SEC filing: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664-Show-Cause.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664-Show-Cause.h...
- shereadsthenews 8y agoWhy do people love to link to this awful PDF-rendering web page instead of the PDFs themselves? https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664/Show-Cause.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664/Show-Caus...
- berberous 8y agoThe last two pages (pp. 11 and 12) are a great example of why you shouldn't be an arrogant dumbass towards the government. The SEC quotes his 60 minutes interview with Leslie Stahl where he says he doesn't respect the SEC. While I think the SEC has a legitimate grievance here, I'm also guessing this is partly vindictive. Play stupid games... And I say all that as a big supporter of Elon generally.
- mlindner 8y agoGovernment being vindictive would count as evidence against the government, not for it.
- CPLX 8y agoIt goes to intent. Typically the law tries to at least somewhat take into account intent, like if someone omits something from a filing by accident or in a deliberate attempt to conceal, for example. Pointing out his statements demonstrates that he's aware of the rules and is choosing not to respect them. That's usually a sign that someone should be on the higher end of the typical punishment range for a given act.
- buboard 8y agoso, the intent was not to mislead investors, but to insult the fcc. snowflake committees much
- joshuamorton 8y agoNo, the intent is that he doesn't take the secs censure seriously. It helps to address the question of if this was an honest mistake or not, and the judgement will likely take that into account.
- jacques_chester 8y agoThe SEC are arguing that civil contempt doesn't require intent. But they also point out that yeah, maybe he's doing it on purpose.
- Derek_MK 8y agoEspecially in the case of contempt of court. The whole reason why you'd hold someone in contempt is if they are willfully not doing what the court says. The SEC is telling the court "Look, he's literally here talking about how he doesn't respect us. He's willingly doing this."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jakejarvis 8y agoThe video of the bolded part is even more unbelievable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cRNypdYQoWk&t=69 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cRNypdYQoWk&t=69
- Aeolun 8y agoSeems to me he was indeed repeating information that was already public.
- afastow 8y agoHe repeated it incorrectly(thus the follow up tweet). And it wouldn't matter anyway because he was required to get pre-approval again, even if repeating something verbatim, if more than two days had passed. From page 12: > According to Tesla’s Policy, any edits to a pre-approved Written Communication or even releasing a verbatim pre-approved Written Communication more than two days after it has been pre-approved requires that the pre-approval be reconfirmed. Even if the exact substance of the 7:15 tweet had been pre-approved 20 days before, Musk cannot credibly claim that he thought he was not required to obtain pre-approval again under the plain terms of the Policy. In fact, the written communication in the 7:15 tweet was not pre-approved 20 days earlier or at any time. Musk’s claim that he thought he was simply restating information from the January 30 communications is not credible.
- golfer 8y agoNo. The range originally mentioned by Tesla in the earnings call was production of 350k-500k cars. He then tweeted about making 500k cars a year -- guiding the world to the extreme top range of the estimate. This is material information, and he misled investors. It's clear cut.
- kosievdmerwe 8y agoTo further highlight this point, which of these three statements would make you the most likely to invest in Tesla: 1) 350k-500k cars a year 2) around 400k cars a year 3) around 500k cars a year The three statements communicate different information and (3) is the best, since unlike (1) and (2) it implies there's a chance that the production numbers can exceed 500k and would certainly be close to 500k in any case. Whereas, with (1) and (2) it probably won't be. Furthermore, quoting a specific number, even if you have the word "around" before it, implies new information was obtained narrowing down the range given in the earnings call. Giving investors more clarity on how they should invest in Tesla. This makes it material. If we can accept the information is material, then it's pointless to argue whether it's misleading or false, since that's not what the SEC is arguing about. Musk has to pre-approve material statements (due to his settlement with the SEC) and, according to internal Tesla policy, get that approval at most 2 days before posting them. The earnings call was on January 30, so even if pre-approval was given then (it wasn't) then it would have expired on February 19 when the tweets were made. The fact that he misled investors (proven by the fact that he issued a correction 4 hours later), just adds extra ammunition to the SECs argument that Musk should have pre-approved his tweet as pre-approval would have caught the factual errors. Seriously though, read through the court document, except for the bit at the end of page 9 (where they quote a bunch of cases) it's very simple to read and understand: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664-Show-Cause.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/5750664-Show-Cause.h...