6 ms·
If you don't have insurance you can negotiate your bill. The problem is that people don't understand that, that Americans hate negotiating, and that negotiating
by gowld 8y ago
If you don't have insurance you can negotiate your bill. The problem is that people don't understand that, that Americans hate negotiating, and that negotiating the price of something after you bought it (or even after you need it) stinks.
- maxxxxx 8y agoPeople also don't know how far they can negotiate. For a lot of people these numbers are close to financial ruin so it's hard to negotiate with clear head. Add to that being sick. It's a perverse, heartless system.
- mruts 8y agoI mean, the closer the number is to financial ruin, don't you think it's more likely that someone will negotiate? What you're saying, essentially, is: the higher the price of something, the less likely someone will negotiate. Clearly, that is not the case. And in regards to your last point, what has made the system so perverse is the insurance companies in the first place. If most people were actually responsible for paying all of their healthcare costs themselves, the prices would be pretty cheap. For example, I live in Tanzania, and I can get medication that is over $500/month without insurance in the US, or like $75 with insurance, for around $1-$2. Also, I can get a tooth pulled for under $5. No one has health insurance here, I don't think it even exists, and therefore, hospitals are forced to charge an amount that the people can pay for. The system actually works, and if for some reason you can't pay, you can volunteer at the hospital until your bill is paid off. Consequentially, even though there aren't laws about accepting all patients (hospitals are allowed to turn away whoever they like), they don't, because they know they will be paid at the very least in labor. Though, honestly, at this point in the US the system is so fucked up that I'm not sure it's even possible to create a free-market system anymore. It pains me to say this (as a staunch libertarian), but I think maybe it would be better at this point for the government to just foot the bill for everyone.
- whatislovecraft 8y ago> I mean, the closer the number is to financial ruin, don't you think it's more likely that someone will negotiate? No. Such panic-inducing tactics are not likely to make someone a better negotiator. Learned helplessness is a real problem.
- mruts 8y agoYou’re the one being a victim shamer shamer. I’m super offended and this needs to stop I can’t believe we live in a world in which a victim shamer is shamed for being a shamer! Shame on you, clearly your parents didn’t raise you with a proper shame compass!
- dang 8y agoPlease don't do this here.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't cross into incivility, even when the topic is sensitive and you feel someone else is wrong. It just makes this place worse. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- whatislovecraft 8y agoOkay, edited, is that better? I think the incredulity of the OP was quite incivil, for what that's worth. Would be more effective to catch this stuff further up the chain. > Clearly, that is not the case. when it "clearly" is the case.
- dang 8y agoYes, that's better. Thanks!
- notafraudster 8y agoWhy should the amount you need to pay for life-saving care depend on your social/intellectual wherewithal to negotiate? Is this a good outcome for society?
- HarryHirsch 8y agoShareholder value doesn't care about society.
- ben509 8y agoExcept the vast majority (4,888 of 6,210) of hospitals have no shareholders because they are run as non-profits or by governments. https://www.aha.org/statistics/fast-facts-us-hospitals https://www.aha.org/statistics/fast-facts-us-hospitals
- maxxxxx 8y agoNon profit means profit for management and their friends. They aren’t do gooders.
- jjoonathan 8y agoI'd reckon the people downvoting you have never tried to negotiate a bill.
- HarryHirsch 8y agoYou wish a dissected aortic aneurysm in front of Zuckerberg General on the folks arguing for negotiation or a market-based solution. The pox aren't serious enough.
- maxxxxx 8y agoJust look at he ownership structure of a lot of non profit hospitals. It’s always the same well connected guys.
- 8y ago
- thisisweirdok 8y agoGet this though: if you have insurance and your insurance doesn't cover something, you often can't negotiate. I had a $10,000 procedure that insurance didn't cover (i.e., I hadn't met my high deductible yet), and I had no choice but to pay the insurance's agreed-upon rate (which I feel was higher than what I should have been paying out of pocket). So it was kind of negotiated, but through insurance and their negotiated rates not an individual's out of pocket negotiated rates. This was also a service where I wasn't informed that a second doctor was out of network, which also screwed me me (and there's literally nothing I can do about this after the fact).
- nradov 8y agoYou can always negotiate and threaten to not pay. They might send you to collections or even sue you for the debt, but often they'll agree to a smaller number to avoid the hassle.
- thisisweirdok 8y agoreally? I've been told by different hospital billing departments that they will put me on a payment plan, but will absolutely not negotiate beyond an insurance provider's agreed upon rate. Of course, that stance is in their best interest and not mine... so maybe I wasn't being forward enough? This all feels quite ridiculous.
- uberduber 8y agoIt is all ridiculous. It honestly depends on the individual hospital. They almost always have a contract with insurance that they can't accept less, but nobody's checking and it's common for them to do so. Some hospitals are reasonable and especially if they see if you have low income/assets, will settle with you. Others don't care at all and will not accept any less and just send you to collections or sue.
- nradov 8y agoWell of course the hospital billing department is going to tell you that you have to pay the entire bill. What did you expect? Ask to speak to a manager, make a specific counter offer, and threaten to pay $0 if they don't accept. It only takes a few minutes and even if they refuse you won't be any worse off than before. (I agree this is a ridiculous system.)
- howard941 8y agoIt's difficult and painful to negotiate anything better than than a payment plan if you don't have a lump sum to offer. Patients have very little leverage.
- ummonk 8y agoActually it is a lot easier to negotiate the price after you’ve already gotten the service. They can’t take back the service if you don’t agree to their price.
- lotsofpulp 8y agoIt depends if the courts find you liable for the service regardless of having agreed upon a price beforehand or not. With medical care, I would guess the court would side with the medical care provider, and negotiating beforehand would help you, whereas not negotiating beforehand would give a blank check to the seller (as the system is now).
- jjoonathan 8y agoDebt & collections exist.
- metamet 8y agoHow does one actually go about negotiating the ER bill after you've received one?
- ben509 8y agoFirst hit on Google for that exact question: https://www.forbes.com/sites/financialfinesse/2017/03/30/what-to-do-when-you-receive-a-surprise-medical-bill/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/financialfinesse/2017/03/30/wha...
- RandallBrown 8y agoHospitals have a billing department. You go talk to them and say "I am unable to pay this amount." There is probably a number on your bill to call.
- jjoonathan 8y agoAnd then they look up your income on one of a dozen information gathering platforms and decide that you qualify for a 2% discount, because privacy doesn't matter and hospital price gouging isn't a problem. Enjoy!
- tome 8y agoWhy aren't there services that negotiate people's medical bills, for a fee?
- drak0n1c 8y agoLike the parent comment said, there are. Insurance companies play that role. Hiring a negotiator without having to buy insurance would be valuable, though.
- uberduber 8y agoThey exist but many have actually gone out of business in the last few years, perhaps due to hospitals refusing negotiation. Most of mine were referrals from health insurance brokers. They're usually commission based so they only charge if you they save you money.
- jjoonathan 8y agoBecause "negotiating" the blank check that you already signed does't work. Yes, it works if they have actually stuck you with a bill that exceeds your net worth and expected income, but in that case you can't afford and/or don't need a negotiator -- you just default. It also works if you've stirred up a media frenzy, but you can't turn that into a business model for obvious reasons. The only place it does reliably work is in the imagination of those looking to downplay the severity of the current state of affairs.
- geebee 8y agoThat’s interesting. The friends I talked to did mention this, but it sounded more like you could knock the bill down a bit, perhaps in the 10-25% range (10% being a lot more likely). The er physician I spoke with seemed skeptical That you could negotiate it down anything like and hmo with massive negotiating power could, but that is just one conversation, and ER docs may actually not be the most knowledgeable people about this. A hospital admin or financial person would probably be a better source.
- uberduber 8y agoThis used to be true but is no longer so. Almost every hospital would negotiate with you if they could see that you had no money or were willing to pay a lump sum. You could end up paying 4-10x medicare rate. However, starting about 5 years ago some hospital got the idea they could refuse to negotiate with everyone and it seems to have spread. Now there are a bunch of these unreasonable hospitals. You can open up all your finances and show that you have no money and that their bill is 100x medicare rate and they would rather get $0 and you declare bankruptcy. I guess they end up getting more revenue overall this way?
- jjoonathan 8y agoOf course they do! "Rely on the mercy of a for-profit (or faux not-for-profit) organization to whom you have already handed a blank check" is a terrible plan, nobody should be surprised that it doesn't work very well, and the people who propose it as anything other than a desperate hail-mary should be ashamed of themselves. gowld, I'm looking at you.