6 ms·
I think this CLOUD Act will basically force internationally operating US companies to split up into a US part and an EU part. This law makes it impossible for a
by mcv 8y ago
I think this CLOUD Act will basically force internationally operating US companies to split up into a US part and an EU part. This law makes it impossible for any company with access to personal data of EU citizens, to obey both US and EU law. The only solution seems to be to ensure that they are two different companies. The other option is to abandon the EU market.
What still surprises me is that nearly all of the major cloud companies are based in the US. Microsoft, Amazon, Netflix, Google, Apple, all of them US companies. If ever a law is going to create some EU competitors, it's the Cloud Act.
The other option is that either the US or the EU is going to water down their law. I'd be really sad if it's the EU, because that would legitimise and strengthen other countries' extraterritorial grasp over non-citizens' data. Like China with Huawei.
- nolok 8y agoOf course it will, they were already bordering on it before that (see specifically Microsoft USA arguing it could not access Microsoft Ireland data when the US court told them to, which directly leads to the new situation)
- guitarbill 8y ago> The only solution seems to be to ensure that they are two different companies. The other option is to abandon the EU market. > What still surprises me is that nearly all of the major cloud companies are based in the US. Microsoft, Amazon, Netflix, Google, Apple, all of them US companies. If ever a law is going to create some EU competitors, it's the Cloud Act. Given that e.g. AWS alone "owns"/operates two regions in China and several GovCloud regions, at worst it'll have a slight impact on these cloud provider's business via mainly legal and not technical changes. What it will do is show the Privacy Shield agreement is a farce, and the US cannot be trusted in these matters - well, hardly new insights, with things like ICANN et al, but these things were largely left unsaid. I suspect US foreign politics and their image will be harmed more than any of these cloud companies.
- 420codebro 8y agoAWS China is ran by a in-country 3rd party Chinese entity. Similar structure to what the above describes - a separate, but related entity.
- bradknowles 8y agoThe AWS Chinese regions were handed over to a Chinese operator. They're "AWS Regions" in name only.
- guitarbill 8y agoPrecisely. But the code deployed there seems to offer the same functionality as other regions, right? So this is a legal/business trick, not a technical challenge.
- CannisterFlux 8y agoThe Microsoft response was to have a separate German trustee be the ones that held the data, and MS have access to the data as needed (but I guess MS could not just hand it all over to the US government when demanded to) https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/global-infrastructure/germany/ https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/global-infrastructure/germ... "All customer data and related systems reside in Germany Controlled by a German data trustee"
- icebraining 8y agoMicrosoft Cloud Germany with its trustee model isn't accepting new customers, you'll have to wait for their new regions that are only coming at the end of the year: https://news.microsoft.com/europe/2018/08/31/microsoft-to-deliver-cloud-services-from-new-datacentres-in-germany-in-2019-to-meet-evolving-customer-needs/ https://news.microsoft.com/europe/2018/08/31/microsoft-to-de...
- skrause 8y agoBut those new German regions will be controlled by Microsoft, so they fall under the Cloud Act.
- wvh 8y agoI don't think it will necessarily create a lot more competition inside the EU. All of those companies already have European data centers; surely it would complicate some technical deployments, but definitely not more so than the effort their legal, HR, accounting and other divisions already have to go through to comply with local regulations. I assume those companies already have multiple legal entities for all sorts of reasons. I guess all companies ought to start tagging data with a jurisdiction tag of sorts now, if that data doesn't already come with a clear location indicator.
- pergadad 8y agoWouldn't the cloud act also apply to subsidiaries? It's be surprised if the giants can at the same time split (for the purposes of the cloud act) and stay one coherent entity with central steering.
- mcv 8y agoI suppose that's going to be the big challenge. You'd want a structure where neither company controls the other, yet they still have every incentive to cooperate closely. Maybe they should each own 49% of the other's stock?
- cabalamat 8y ago> The only solution seems to be to ensure that they are two different companies. If the EU comany is a subsiduary of the US company, then it will have to follow its orders and won't really be separate. Furthermore if people based in the USA have physical access to the servers located in the EU, then if the US government wants that data, it will probably be exfiltrated to the USA, regardless of what EU governments want. The solution is for EU governments to have control over their own computing infrastructure. This obviously includes cloud computing and datacenters. But it also needs to include operating systems and chips, because otherwise the risk of a foreign power putting a backdoor in them is too great. Ditto for all countries, of course.
- hellisothers 8y agoHere lies humanity, they tried to do the same things 15 different ways and squandered their resources doing so. (Not saying you’re advocating for this, just that it is the current plan it seems)
- gumby 8y agoHere stands humanity, they tried to do the same things 15 different ways as a way of figuring out what was best for various situations.
- bradknowles 8y agoAnd then there were 16: https://xkcd.com/927/ https://xkcd.com/927/
- d-sc 8y agoHumans are good at building houses and have many standard plans detailing how to do so. Yet we still hire architects to design custom homes. I’m ok with that. Efficiency doesn’t always need to be the end all goal.
- hopler 8y agoHumanity built the tower of Babel, all speaking one language, and was struck down and fragmented for their hubris.
- olau 8y agoI talked to a lawyer specializing in data protection a couple of years ago, and according to her, the problem is already there - you cannot satisfy both the GDPR and US law that requires that the US government can snoop whenever they want to. Currently, the companies are getting away with it, but with people like Max Schrems, they might not be able to in the long run.
- james_in_the_uk 8y agoThe European Commission's own view on this is here https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/17/17-2/23655/20171213123137791_17-2%20ac%20European%20Commission%20for%20filing.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/17/17-2/23655/2017121...
- krageon 8y agoThe situation you describe (companies "splitting") already exists, and it's also already not a good guarantee of actual privacy. I'm not convinced that this is any kind of solution.