10 ms·
Major survey finds worms are rare or absent in 20% of fields in England
- gpm 8y ago> has shown they are rare or absent in two out of five fields The title presumably should say 40%
- stuart78 8y agoOr is it 1 out of 5 fields? Big difference!
- stuart78 8y agoAnd somehow the article has numbers to support both interpretations?
- gpm 8y agoI think the 40% number is correct, the article also contains this line which is oddly specific to be a typo. > However, 42% of fields had poor earthworm biodiversity – meaning either very few or none of the surface-dwelling and deep-burrowing categorisations of worms were seen.
- wjn0 8y ago> 42% of fields studied had poor earthworm diversity > 21% of fields lacked surface-dwelling worms Seems pretty clear to me. Some vs. none...
- pvaldes 8y agoTalking here about "earthworm diversity", is another thing that is wrong. To identify earthworms is difficult even for experienced taxonomists and you need a microscope, a disection table and a lot of training. Polychaetes are much easier by comparison and I can assure you that they aren't easy. You need months of study. Not, not everybody can do the work of a biologist. Not even the smartest children. Is complex, and hard work. Unless you want to classify the diversity of worms into "small", "medium sized" and "big worm", dig a hole and count isn't enough.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- lostlogin 8y agoIt seems so. Source: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0203909 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- pvaldes 8y agoWithout more context the study is not very useful pesticides, copper levels, phreatic level, number and species of hammerhead flatworms...
- sagartewari01 8y agoYour comment really shocked me, Then I realized that I'd misread worms as women in the title.
- losteric 8y agoThose questions are exactly why a study like this is useful - we didn't know there was a problem, now we can ask the questions to find out what's going on.
- pvaldes 8y agoWe knew there was a problem since decades in fact, the disemination of tropical hammerhead flatworms that predate earthworms and can release the same neurotoxin as fugu fishes (in our potatoes?). But we shouldn't fall in the temptation of making a mountain from a sand grain. Falling in gross extrapolation for clickbait purposes is as bad as no data. I can be wrong, but it seems that what we have here is an article done in part by volunteers and non professional ecologists (there is a variability in the observers), about a local area and in a narrow date interval. Would be like to register what I ate the 23-Jan and assume that this is what I will eat for the rest of the year. Earthworm populations can raise and fall as a normal process. And we should not mistake quantity by quality. I had analysed marine trophic chains and marine annelida appear everywhere. There is a huge biodiversity in sea worms. Huge loads of some species is bad, not good. Means that the ecosystem is in big trouble. With earthworms is the same. Not finding earthworms is not always a problem and finding a lot of them is not always good news.
- DougN7 8y agoIs this a relatively new development?
- notable_user 8y agoThe article makes it seem like this hasn’t been studied in depth before (maybe just in the UK?). Sound like they were just trying to get baselines, and the next step would be to understand the whys.
- fouc 8y agoProbably a result of tiling the soil. Disturbing the natural ecosystem of it. And pesticides too presumably. Something like permaculture could help. Chop and drop. Mulching on the spot.
- randcraw 8y agoTrue only if tilling has increased recently. The question is, what has changed since the last time the dead fields had earthworms? That's the cause. Reversing or neutralizing that change is the cure. Let's figure out how to fix this the right way, and now, before the remaining fields die off too.
- gus_massa 8y agoIt's not clear that this is a recent phenom. It's a result of voluntary samples, that cant be compared to a previous situation. It may be useful if they repeat the measurements in the same places, but currently it's more like an internet pool.
- 7952 8y agoIt is possible that population decreases gradually over many years, rather than in a short time frame.
- blubbi 8y agoI don't know the numbers for the UK but here [1] are some numbers for Bavaria with worm counts from a lot of monitoring spots starting in the 80s. (sorry, slides are in German) In the conclusion the author says a connection to the tilling method is likely. (worm numbers in Bavaria actually have increased as more and more farmers have changed away from "full" tilling). [1] https://www.lfu.bayern.de/boden/bodendauerbeobachtung/fachtagung/doc/walter.pdf https://www.lfu.bayern.de/boden/bodendauerbeobachtung/fachta...
- blubbi 8y agoSorry, I should probably add that the worm number also very heavily depends on the kind of ground you have on your fields. In case that is not apparent from the slides ;-)
- photoguy112 8y agoBack when I was a kid, after a heavy downpour the roads would be crowded with earthworms. You really had to watch where you step to avoid stepping on one of those suckers. Fast forward today and I RARELY see a single worm out on the road after a similar downpour.
- twtw 8y agoWhen were you a kid?
- photoguy112 8y agoLate 80's into 90's.
- optimuspaul 8y agoI noticed some worms this past fall after a downpour, it was just a few and it gave me pause. I do recall as well when I was a kid (30ish years ago) that there were a lot more worms. But I lived in the suburbs then, now I'm in the city, but near a large lake and large wooded area.
- markdown 8y agoWhere were you a kid?
- duxup 8y agoMy driveway gets covered with them. They love cooking on that black top.
- kakarot 8y agoHow were you a kid?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hueving 8y agoMost people start out that way.
- maxerickson 8y agoIn the US, invasive worms are converting forests from fungal decomposition regimes to bacterial decomposition regimes. Not a great development for mushroom foragers. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/invasive-earthworms-denude-forests/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/invasive-earthwor... Fun stuff.
- pilsetnieks 8y ago> Not all foreign earthworms are destructive. Of the 5,000 species around the globe, only about 16 of the European and Asian varieties do the real damage. One of them is the night crawler (Lumbricus terrestris), a popular fish bait that can measure up to 15 to 20 centimeters (six to eight inches). Another is the Alabama jumper (Amynthas agrestis)—also known as the snake worm or crazy worm—an aggressive Asian worm that lives at high densities and can literally jump off the ground or out of a bait can, according to fishing lore. So maybe we should use some of the remaining 4984 species of worms as fish bait?
- maxerickson 8y agoSure. It's pretty much too late though.
- hinkley 8y agoRed wigglers are also useful for both purposes, and because they don't burrow they have trouble overwintering. It's not perfect, but they are held to be a lesser of evils.
- hinkley 8y agoThe last glacial maximum in the US pushed all of the earthworms out of the north central US and Canada, and if memory serves the 'Northern Hardwood Forests' exist in a subset of that area? Earthworms of pretty much any kind are invasive there, and it's not just a soil microbiome problem, it also affects seed germination. Some of those tree species are adapted to germinate in a bed of leaf litter. It's a challenge. People post things online that are appropriate to their region and beginners elsewhere don't get why they might not work locally (like that some plants are useful in zone 8 but invasive in zone 5, or vice versa).
- lostlogin 8y agoI wonder what volume ‘a spadeful’ is? Presumably not a garden spade? Edit: 20x20x20 cm volume. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0203909 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- ekianjo 8y agoAny link to the actual study? Potential pitfalls of this kind of study: - is the historical data available? - is the decrease significant? - is the sample size sufficient? - is the sampling method reliable? (and conducted in the same conditions as the previous data points?) - is there a difference between cultivated fields and uncultivated fields? - is there any correlation between cultivation types and worm presence (not just usage of pesticides, but also types of cultures?) - are there differences in soil properties (minerals, etc...) etc... I'd really like to have reporters link to the actual paper, or even better, datasets, in this time and age.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- CalRobert 8y agoI was out digging in my field yesterday (in Ireland, not England) and thought it was interesting that there was a large variance in worm counts. Some areas had massive numbers of worms pushing 20cm, and others had relatively few, smaller ones. The bigger worms were in areas that hadn't been grazed by sheep, but I'm not sure how that relates, if at all (the sheep have been gone for a few years).
- bayesian_horse 8y agoThat may be about soil composition, but yes, many/most earth worms are detrivores, so the more to clean up the happier they are. Also sampling bias.
- cpursley 8y agoSpeaking of Ireland, the stereotype is true. The grass really is that green. What is in your soil that causes this? Nitrogen?
- redtexture 8y agoIt is a well watered island, for one, with climate moderated by the Gulf Stream, even though well north of the US (The Boston USA latitude 42+, Dublin 53+).
- desas 8y agoSoil compaction?
- bayesian_horse 8y agoThey took this Leave campaign too far.
- cauk 8y agoLaughed more than I care to admit
- jeffwass 8y agoI may have taken part in this study with my kids at the Barnes Wetland Center last year. They had a kids ‘science’ event held during one of the school breaks, they had fun contributing to a “real” scientific experiment/survey. We dug a hole of a specific size in a grassy field (the shovel was exactly the right dimensions) and counted how many worms we found in the soil to a set depth. We found a few worms, don’t remember the number or what should have been normal. We also did a butterfly count there as well, which was less formal (not under guidance of a Wetlands worker). What was cool was meeting an amateur lepidopterologist at the time who pointed us towards several camouflaged cocoons in another area. Fun stuff.
- interfixus 8y agoSummer 2017 we were overwhelmed by snails and worm of various species. Summer 2018 was long, hot, and dry. We hardly saw any. But of course they are there. Occasionally, the cats drag in an earthworm. Last winter, mice moved into the house in numbers. We heard them occasionally saw them, cats were constantly on edge, and the mice somehow managed to thrive on catfood. This winter, not a rodent in sight. And this winter so far has been clement. come summer, I expect we'll see snails and worms and mice up to normal - though probably not excessive levels. Not claiming there are no longer term downward trends. There may well be. I'm not qualified to judge. But often wonder why the huge year-to-year variability of small, fast-breeding species is so rarely touched upon in this kind of article. Small critters can bounce back in force within very short intervals, given anything resembling decent conditions.
- thorin 8y agoLots of worms in my garden. I did a survey yesterday...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- richjdsmith 8y agoRelated anecdote: I moved to a small town in the West Midlands in the UK from Barcelona last year. One of the things I first noticed was an absence of nature sounds (but you can always hear a motorway, no matter how far you walk :( ). This is compared to living in downtown Barcelona in El Born. I finally figured it out after going back for a visit to Barcelona that there are just substantially fewer birds here, or at least in the area I live. I wonder if that's because there is less food for them?
- drugme 8y agoDid anyone else notice that the article seems to be confused about "two fifths" versus "20 percent"?