21 ms·
Recruit Is Japan’s Top Contender for Global Internet Domination
- ascar 8y agoI recently signed up to recruit to make a dinner reservation in Japan. They used a lot of dark patterns for their email marketing. Bombarding me with multiple different newsletters I didn't sign up for and I had to cancel every single one of them separately. And nearly a week delay after sign-off. One of the worst non-spam marketing I had to deal with in the last years.
- reustle 8y agoThis is common practice in Japan. We desperately need our own anti spam legislation.
- rtpg 8y agoYeah I just outright block the email addresses (the marketing email addresses are different from the informational ones). Recruit is particularly bad because there are soooo many services linked to the system
- Animats 8y agoSo it's a wannabe WeChat, basically.
- xrd 8y agoThe #1 largest market for GitHub is the US. The second largest group of users is from Japan. I'm surprised there aren't more startups from Japan. The people are tech savvy and the economic malaise exceeding 20 years should be pushing people towards entrepreneurship and risk taking.
- chillacy 8y agoWhy be an entrepreneur when there’s so much social glory in being a salaryman?
- ekianjo 8y agoThere is no glory in being in salaryman. I'm not sure where you heard that but salaryman has almost always been a derogatory term.
- chillacy 8y agoThis was posted awhile back, is this inaccurate? https://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan/ https://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/11/07/doing-business-in-japan...
- annodomini2019 8y agoI counter that economic malaise stifles innovation as it promotes playing it safe to protect your future.
- a_t48 8y agoFrom what I know, Japanese companies are pretty resistant to using new software technology. (Someone, please correct me if I'm wrong).
- mr_toad 8y agoAccording to Github’s own stats, Japan is eighth in both contributions and sign-ups. https://octoverse.github.com/people https://octoverse.github.com/people
- ekianjo 8y agoNote that the way Github defines contributions is very fuzzy (signing up and opening a ticket is good enough to be considered a contributor). If we were to measure the number of commits or the number of lines of codes contributed I'd wage the picture would be quite different (and probably worse for Japan, but I could be wrong).
- Simon_says 8y agoBug-finding is contributing.
- ekianjo 8y agoSure, but it's not the same as being an actual developer.
- Simon_says 8y agooof. I've hired people just to find bugs.
- astonex 8y agoJapan is definitely not savvy when it comes to software engineering. I'd say they're not really that tech savvy either. A lot of their tech is very dated.
- tgeo 8y agoThey are also the holding company which owns Indeed.com
- lykr0n 8y agoYep. They are using Indeed talent and culture to help drive their expansion.
- slurpeedog 8y agoWhile they may be held back by Japan’s insular culture, that very weakness is also a moat.
- z3t4 8y agoTheir business idea seem original: put yourself between customers and services.
- ndnxhs 8y agoJust another rent seeker
- echelon 8y agoI remember Recruit developed one of Nintendo's first online platforms, Randnet [1]. After trying to pioneer in this space on each of their early consoles, only to see it fail to gain traction with their customers, Nintendo let online gameplay and networking take a back seat. Microsoft and Sony (and Sega) jumped on board that train with the very next generation of consoles and became leaders in online console gaming. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/64DD https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/64DD
- reustle 8y agoFrom what I know about the tech/talent there, it won't be happening any time soon
- kazuki 8y agoIn my view, recruit is a sales company. They have very strong sales team covering SMBs. That allowed them to build gurunavi (similar to Yelp), airregi (similar to square), and so on. Couple of years ago they started focus more on hiring top engineering talent and I think it is absolutely right move, but frankly I don't think they can compete grobally as tech company in near future.
- ascar 8y agoConsidering they completely lack internationalization/localization (at least on signup, on Hot Pepper and their Recruit account management page), it doesn't give me the impression Recruit has the right mindset to compete on a global scale. While this is just a medium hard problem to fix technically, it's the mindset of most employees that would have to change. Good i18n/l10n requires some consideration of development (it's easy to create untranslatable text, when the technical structure of strings can't reflect foreign grammar), marketing/sales (you need different approaches for different markets) and management (giving time to do i18n right). Currently Recruit shows the typical island mentality. Their consideration ends at the borders of Japan. Not a good place to start for global domination.
- niztk 8y agoI live and run a startup out of Japan and given the engineering talent here or lack thereof, I can almost guarantee that you won’t see any Japanese tech startup going global anytime soon. If anything, they will copy another global innovative company and dominate the domestic market but with no real innovation (look no further than the very mediocre Rakuten). Gone are the days where Sony, Nintendo and others had what it takes to craft a quality product that was compelling to global audiences. Japan has lost its mojo and the sad thing is that the conservatives forces are so strong that this country won’t attract any talent needed to change the bad bad status quo for the foreseeable future.
- ascar 8y agoI moved to Japan to do research for my CS master thesis at one of the top5 universities. While I knew English is not spoken by most Japanese, I was honestly surprised that nearly all the CS students in my lab lack the English skill for daily conversations, let alone have a technical discussion. Considering how international and English dominated CS is and only Japans best students get a place at this university, that is a very bad basis to create top software engineering talent.
- ekianjo 8y agoThere's been a trend for Japan to close upon itself in the past 15 years or more already, so going overseas and learning english has become more uncommon than ever. That, and the utter lack of interest to whats happening beyond their borders, is really damaging the future outlooks for Japan.
- Ultramanoid 8y agoWhile I agree wholeheartedly with the closing part, and things are much different and insular than 30 or 20 years ago, I do not necessarily think this affects Japan economically seriously. We've been hearing about the coming collapse of this or that in Japan and the aging Japanese society apocalypse consistently, but I shudder at the comparison between our living standards and the other so-called developed nations on every trip overseas or to Europe. And more so now than I did 20 years ago.
- ekianjo 8y agoRecruit is one of the worst domestic companies in Japan. Their services suck, they are badly designed, they are not integrated, they have way too much workforce for the kind of business they are in, I could go on and on. If that's the best that Japan has to offer then the rest of the world is safe.
- Ultramanoid 8y agoAgreed. Their marketing push ( not sure with what actual practical purpose ) is remarkable and frankly, annoying, in daily life. Can't take a train, walk down any random street, enter any number of shops / offices / konbini / whatever, without seeing a sticker, ad, poster, clip, from one campaign or another from them.
- dmix 8y agoMan it's so depressing looking at what a giant Japan could be in the tech industry if they got their shit together politically, economically, and culturally to bring entrepreneurship and creative risk-taking back. Their potential talent-to-output ratio has to be one of the worst in the world. Probably the worst if you look at their flashes on brilliance in the 1980s and early 1990s and what they could be today. This problem goes well beyond their central financial mismanagement with stagflation.
- VRay 8y agoHaha, it's true, man. I recently moved to Japan to live with family for a while. I interviewed at the top Japanese software companies in Japan, and even though I'm a senior engineer with 10 years' experience in FAANG in the USA, they felt like they were doing me a favor offering me 15 million JPY/year (150k USD at 100 yen per dollar, ~$130k USD at the time with the beefy US dollar). Tokyo is actually a little cheaper to live in than Seattle assuming you're OK with a tiny Tokyo apartment and a long Tokyo commute, but it isn't THAT much cheaper. I tried to politely explain how and why people like me command the kind of salaries we do in the USA, but they just didn't get it. At 15M JPY I'd rather just work in the USA for a year, then take a year off in Japan, so that's what I ended up doing, haha. All the local Japanese software giants are slowly being strangled to death on their home turf, and they're completely failing to compete internationally. It's a real shame, but oh well!
- jitl 8y agoI still find it very difficult to trust Bloomberg after “The Big Hack” was widely refuted without a retraction. Now whenever I read a Bloomberg puff peice like this, I’m wondering who’s agenda they’re serving. Who’s got all the Recruit stock that wants to see it rise? How much of the article is twisted to paint this company in a positive light? They’re not a trustworthy publication anymore.
- stevensawtelle 8y agoI was just thinking about that article the other day - do we know that a retraction was needed? I saw all the refutation but never saw Bloomberg back down, and honestly I'm not sure how these things normally work. I guess I'm just wondering why you're so confident Bloomberg was serving an agenda?
- segmondy 8y agoHey, folks thought Echelon was a joke in the 90's until Snowden showed that Echelon is child's play. The Big Hack might be true or not, but it's not far fetched. There might be more at play here. Watch this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqQhWitJ1As&feature=youtu.be https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RqQhWitJ1As&feature=youtu.be
- saagarjha 8y agoThe issue is that Bloomberg couldn’t provide any real evidence for their claims when pressed.
- jessaustin 8y agoThat's standard practice for media these days. One recalls the dozens of breathlessly reported then forgotten inside of a week "inside leaks" about "Russian collusion".
- fungi 8y agoFew are denying that the Chinese Government spys, vacuums up as much data as possible and generally should not be trusted. But the specific allegations raised in the "The Big Hack" appear to be without basis. In my mind it looks more like "Weapons of Mass Destruction" BS that once saturated the media.
- Johnwbh 8y agoThe analogy with tencent and alibaba seems instructive, but not necessarily in a good way. They are both massive bloated platforms that do lots of different disconnected things not very well. e.g. the wechat messaging app contains subprograms for games, payment, flight bookings, etc you can't turn off. They only continue to exist because of network effects, and because they play nice with the Chinese government. If Recruit works on the same model then they will have the same problem moving abroad that there is no one thing they are better at than an existing company
- Barrin92 8y ago>They are both massive bloated platforms that do lots of different disconnected things not very well. e.g. the wechat messaging app contains subprograms for games, payment, flight bookings, etc you can't turn off In an age where bringing users together and building ecosystems seems to count for more and more this isn't necessarily a downside. We're used to the startup and "move quick" mentality but conglomerates have been making somewhat of a comeback for a while now, and Google and Amazon aren't exactly 'non bloated' either, because I'm sure for many of their services there's some small company somewhere that does it better. (case in point, DeepL's translation is actually astonishingly good). So maybe being a big scary monolith with government support is a good strategy to be a dominating internet company in this day and age and in the years to come.
- ian0 8y agoI think your misunderstanding the goals of alibaba / Tencent. The derive their value precisely from their strategy of doing lots of things ok instead of one thing well. They are "platforms" not applications. And if they stuck to what they each did well in the beginning they likely wouldn't have been anywhere near as successful as they are now. Also I think it's too early to tell whether how their worldwide expansion plans will play out. It's worth noting that between them they own a slice of most major tech companies in SEA. I wouldn't be surprised if thats not the only part of the world either..